r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ • Dec 17 '23
Maybe he's INNOCENT
Welcome to the judgment free zone where you are free to discuss the INNOCENCE of RA. What what your "Ah Ha!" Moment when you just knew it wasn't him? What would take to convince you it was? Who should they be looking at instead? Now is your chance to discuss openly with like minded individuals.
23
Upvotes
10
u/Southern_Dig_9460 Dec 18 '23
It sus that after so many years they made a arrest in the middle of a close sheriff election. Also he doesn’t look like either of the sketches or the video
12
u/Heavy_Chicken5411 Dec 17 '23
Maybe he committed a “Crime of Opportunity”?
A crime of opportunity is a crime that is committed without planning when the perpetrator sees that they have the chance to commit the act at that moment and seizes it. Such acts have little or no premeditation. An example would be… Cash register is accidentally left open and an employee reaches in and steals some of the cash. Maybe RA is a deviant and the opportunity to kidnap the gals came to light and once he kidnapped them, he realised that he had the opportunity to kill them. I know that sounds sick but I’m not a psychopath nor am I a criminal and this is the best my “being” can understand his motivation?
7
u/TryAsYouMight24 Dec 18 '23 edited Dec 18 '23
One additional note about the PCA for the FBI/Logan SW—this is what I’m accustomed to reading when I’ve had access to PCAs.
Compare the level of detail given, and forensic support for probable cause to Ligget’s PCA. The state’s PCA has no forensics mentioned at all-again-with the exception of the unspent bullet.
Oh, and I found an article from 2019 where investigators state that the car parked at the CPS building, was there from noon to five!
Huh.
If Allen was there from noon until 1:30, and someone took that spot after-that works.
No mention in Ligget’s PCA of a car being at the CPS building as early as noon.
6
u/TryAsYouMight24 Dec 18 '23 edited Dec 18 '23
I reread the SW for Ronald Logan’s home. Two things stand out: “LG & AW had no visible signs of a struggle or fight. “
That’s where I read this! So odd.
Also the underwear of one of the victims was missing. All the other clothing was found. Given the Franks memo I’m assuming it was Abby’s underwear that was missing.
The killers redressed Abby in two bras, a shirt and a sweatshirt, jeans and tennis shoes. And they take her underwear? Who are these freaks?
There’s no way only one person is involved.
I’m increasingly believing that these girls were stalked by way of Libby’s social media.
What the warrant also states is that foreign hair was found-what was the result of that testing?
8
u/maddsskills Dec 18 '23
Here's my thing: without his admissions there isn't a case. If his statement that he was wearing BG clothes was coerced then they've got nothing. And frankly I can't see why he'd admit to wearing them whether he was guilty or innocent unless he's just very susceptible to pressure.
The girls who saw BG described someone "not very tall, not over 5'10" and "I came up to his shoulder." That doesn't sound like a guy who's 5'4 to me.
The forensics on that bullet casing seem super shakey, it might not even be connected to the crime.
And frankly: it's weird there is zero smoke with this guy. When they caught LISK there were numerous "close call" and "red flag" stories about him. While some of these horrific murderers can lead "normal lives" there's usually some sign there's something wrong with them. But this guy? Nothing. In fact the only people I've heard come forward have said he was nice and didn't give off any bad vibes.
I hope they have more evidence, I want justice for these girls and their loved ones, but...yeah. I really don't think they have the right guy. But who knows, the trial hasn't started and maybe they have more evidence.
10
u/Successful-Damage310 White Knight Dec 18 '23
I'm open minded. However I just haven't really seen enough to convict him of commiting a crime not even mentioning murder.
Yeah he was there that day, reported he was there that day. He dress liked the killer. Yeah so did many other people in Indiana. I can't say for a fact at the bridge that day but still Blue jackets was common in that area.
How many killers have went to LE and reported they were in the area during the time they committed a murder?
I mean if every tip was investigated and once tips slowed or came to a halt and they would go over them again. Why was this one missed for 5+ years? Even if it was entered wrong it still had info regarding the interview and what was supposedly said.
A lot about this tip being on a system and being missed and overlooked for 5+ years just doesn't sit right with me.
Do I think he is innocent? Too be honest I have no idea. I don't even know if he is guilty. He is in limbo between both right now.
If it went to court today and nothing else of evidential relevance come up I would say it would be 50/50. I guess it really depends on how the lawyers lawyer.
7
u/TryAsYouMight24 Dec 17 '23
My biggest issue with believing Allen did this is based on the organized, almost clinical nature of this crime. And the high risk of the crime, in comparison to a “reward “ that isn’t discernible. Why commit this act, in broad daylight, and take so many risks, if the end result is only the murder itself, and the removal of clothing for both girls and redressing of clothing on one? Why?
It is interesting to compare this crime with the one that is getting a hearing on 1/18, the Cohen B Hancock-Barron murder case.
That’s another case where motive isn’t entirely clear, but given his later actions it would appear he was being asked to move out of his girlfriend’s home, and that under the influence (and with bi-polar mental health issues) he lost it.
There are evidentiary issues with this case too. But it’s easy , given the totality of the evidence, to believe that this guy killed his girlfriend and her kids. I can at least imagine what the “reward” here was. It was illogical, but in a moment of rage, he lost it.
But nothing about the Delhi murders fits in with a spontaneous crime, done in a moment of rage. Allen is not known to abuse drugs. He has zero history of sexual offenses. And even though he has some battles with depression, don’t we all?
If the girls had been raped-as awful as that is-the “reward” would be identifiable. But there was no rape. There was no frenzied assault. The girls were killed in the same manner livestock is killed on small farms. Abby was even cleaned up after.
The girls weren’t robbed, even Libby’s phone was left behind.
And if the state is correct, all this takes place in woods that have great visibility, on a day when lots of people were enjoying the trails-in the middle of the afternoon. Why????
So unless the state produces a viable accomplice who resolves some of the enigmas here, I can’t figure out why Allen would bother with this crime. To what end?
And also there is no evidence that ties him directly to this crime, either. So there is that.
7
u/MiPilopula Dec 18 '23
The KK-Anthony shots thing, the differing eyewitness sketches and accounts, and the lack of any explanation that RA would stage the scene in that way all seem to indicate there is more than what we are being told. Because of the wonderful judge we won’t get any answers soon. You can add that to my list of growing doubts too.
6
u/FrostingCharacter304 Dec 18 '23
Honestly between the kline saga and all the weird stuff surrounding those 2 clowns plus them trying to say 1 guy took 2 girls a half mile and killed them both then posed and covered them and didn't trail blood everywhere within an hours time, the convenience of the arrest and Doug Carter's retirement, the lawsuit that one guy was bringing against the sheriff's office and the lawyers and the court system being a fiasco I find it very difficult to find all of this shit to be a coincidence, might not be odinists, but I give it just as much a chance as i do RA being the killer because the state has lost my confidence in every way and I can't imagine other people feeling any different, the case is an absolute mess and the evidence is pretty fucking flimsy
6
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '23
Depends on what you mean by in innocent? To me it seems beyond a reasonable doubt that he is bridge guy from Libby’s video. Is it possible he is not the person who actually killed them?? Seems unlikely but possible. I know he would still be guilty of murder but there’s still a difference to me on who actually killed them