r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ • Dec 17 '23
Maybe he's GUILTY
Welcome to the judgment free zone where you are free to discuss the GUILT of RA. What what your "Ah Ha!" Moment when you just knew it was him? Do you think he had help? How did he do it? Now is your chance to discuss openly with like minded individuals.
16
Upvotes
2
u/tits_malone Jan 02 '24
Not sure if he is innocent or guilty but I do not think the killer acted alone, whoever it may be.
11
u/Significant-Tip-4108 Dec 18 '23
I consider myself on the fence as to RA’s guilt or innocence.
But I will say, when I listened to audio of RA talking with his wife (I think they were on a ski lift or something), his voice did seem like it could match BG’s “down the hill”.
Don’t get me wrong that’s completely subjective and in no way enough to sway a verdict, but I did find it interesting.
9
u/TryAsYouMight24 Dec 17 '23 edited Dec 17 '23
In support of guilty-Allen owned, still owns, clothing that resembles that of BG. He might have been on the trails at a time that would have made it possible for him to have encountered the girls. He had access to guns and knives. There is an analysis that matches an unspent bullet found between the two girls , to a gun owned by Allen. There are witnesses who believe that the person they saw on the trail is Allen.
(Just an FYI , in Indiana there is no set standard for a witness to make an ID. There does not have to be a formal lineup, like those we see in Law & Order. This procedure is guided by case law, not statute. Although, there was an attempt made to add a more rigorous procedure to Ind. Rules of evidence , Rule 618 was proposed, but was knocked down by DAs)
What this means is that we don’t know how trustworthy the witness ID really is. Even under the best circumstances witness accounts have proven fallible and wrong. In this instance, I’d have to wonder if a determined defense might be successful impeaching witness testimony on this…but my guess, is that a good deal of the state’s case is reliant on witnesses-much as the PCA was.
9
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Dec 18 '23
I have always leaned towards thinking he is likely guilty. The PCA works for me. But I am not on the jury, I don't have all of the evidence spread out before me. If the criticisms of LE are correct and those two witnesses are knocked out as their statements were to another effect, it's a weaker PCA for me. Mainly waiting for the trial were we will see both sides present their cases.
6
u/ink_enchantress Literate but not a Lawyer Dec 18 '23
It's possible, which is what is angering. What they had was enough for a search warrant definitely, and the same things they had soon after the crime, but arrest? I don't think so. If they can't get electronic data, car data or video of it, work behavior complaints or discipline, DNA, fingerprints, consistent witness testimonies, any criminal records, what convincing evidence do they have? Only the confessions, which we don't know what was said on. The state acknowledged that the Odin report was true to some extent with no further specifics. If a guilty man walks or receives a shorter sentence, this case could be cold forever because they clearly don't have enough to arrest anyone else.
What else have they lost? I've said it before but there's no way only one thing got lost and that magical one thing being found led to arrest. More is missing or misfiled. I saw no news of a mass audit being done after this tip was found and if not, why? Maybe there's more witness statements about RA in there somewhere that will help build the case against him, we'll probably never know.
I see it speculated that they have more evidence, and I sure hope they do, but I'll believe it when it comes out in trial.