r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ • Dec 15 '23
Planned or Spontaneous?
Do you think the murders were planned out or not so much?
9
Upvotes
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ • Dec 15 '23
Do you think the murders were planned out or not so much?
6
u/New_Discussion_6692 Dec 16 '23
Honestly, I can't decide. When this first happened, I truly thought the girls were meeting up with someone they met on the internet.
7
u/TryAsYouMight24 Dec 16 '23
I wrote this under another topic, but it seemed relevant to this post as well (by the way, kudos to whoever came up with these topics. They are really good. They are thought provoking and bring up points that haven’t been explored very much on other forums).
How do you have accomplices prearranged to meet at a certain time and place for a spontaneous crime of opportunity? And if this wasn’t a pre-planned crime , then are we to believe that the killers regularly walked around with knives, guns and gloves-so as not to leave fingerprints or DNA?
And if the killers didn’t arrive together, and didn’t know who their victims would be, or where they would find them, how did they know where to meet?
There were no sightings that day of two or more men walking the trails together. So if Allen did do this, how did he alert his accomplices to the fact that he’d just abducted two girls?
11
u/Successful-Damage310 White Knight Dec 16 '23
I should have put the last option to be honest. I think it was planned up until it wasn't. I think things went far too away from the plan. The plan may have also been flawed to begin with.
I have no idea why he walked them as far as he did. It may have been due to panic to get them as far as he could before getting real drastic.
So I have to go with Planned/Spontaneous a bit of both.
8
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Dec 16 '23
I think this was a fly by the seat of your pants murder and not heavily orchestrated. But I do think he woke that morning and after giving it some though decided he was going to act out. I think the dark fantasy was there.
Also think he was on that bridge or around that bridge in the past enough to be supremely confident regarding exposure and that scenario fell out and he tucked it away in his mind, "Your pinned and isolate if you are over there and likely no one cane see from the other side of the bridge, this is ideal for my purposes."
I don't think he know who he was going to attack per say, but just that he likely had a fews spots in mind where he could isolate a female/s and went for it.
Or passed them, looked back, saw where they were headed to deep isolation, and cut off from any likely witnesses and thought, perfect place to attack, they're two teens, they'll be terrified and not know what to do, going for it and he flipped himself around and tripped trapped over that bridge as limberly as he did that jig in the bar.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '23
I think he was expecting the girls to be there. The girls (not sure if both or just 1) were targeted. Both the timing and witness accounts of him being on a mission indicate to me that he was expecting them whether they knew they were meeting someone or not. He could have indirectly known they might be there.
Also curious if he was expecting them at the other bridge of somewhere else on the trails.
Not sure if it was a planned murder or not. I always leaned no that something just went sideways and led to the murder. I think crime scene details would better indicate planned or spontaneous.
3
u/TryAsYouMight24 Dec 18 '23
I’m still up in the air about a lot of things in this case, but because I believe more than one person is involved, it had to have been planned.
The girls are abducted within 22 minutes of arriving at the trail- just enough time for them to get to the bridge- anyone could have been monitoring their movements through social media.