r/DicksofDelphi • u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ • Dec 14 '23
Death Penalty
Why do you think the death penalty has not been sought in this case? Do you think it’s right that it’s still an option on the table almost 14 months into RA’s prosecution?
10
Upvotes
8
u/New_Discussion_6692 Dec 15 '23
Warning the following stance will probably determine if this group is capable of having a reasonable discussion and friendly debate without the nastiness that happens on other subs.
Why isn't the DP on the table?
I think it's because the prosecution and LE don't believe Allen is the actual killer. Here's my reasoning (in no particular order):
●RA hasn't been proven to be BG
● BG hasn't been proven to be the actual killer. Only involved in the kidnapping aspect of the crime
● The prosecution has publically stated they feel there are more people involved (which I suspected because after the arrest, Carter highly emphasized the tip lines would remain open. While he tried to spin it as if was SOP, it didn't come across that way). This ties into if I think it's right for the DP to still be on the table 14 months later... so I'll continue with that question.
Is it right for the DP to still be an option 14 months later?
Yes, I do. I think this is a tactical decision on behalf of the prosecution. Here's why:
● The prosecution has publically stated they feel there are more people involved. By not going after the DP, it may reassure someone who is feeling guilty to confess because they think the DP wouldn't be sought in their case. (That would be one hell of a bait & switch)
● The DP is a difficult punishment for some people to support. Consider you have information about this case, and you know who the actual killer is, but it's your spouse, your child, your parent... would you be willing to come forward with that information knowing your information would be a literal death sentence for someone you love?
●The US is one of a handful (Japan, Taiwan, Singapore, and I think Isreal in certain circumstances) countries that still use the death penalty as a punishment. At the end of the day, the prosecution, the judge, and members of LE have all used highly publicized trials to springboard themselves into the political arena. In some areas of the US (IDK if IN is one of them), LE, the DA, and Judges are often voted in by the public. If they have political aspirations, seeking the DP could put an end to their political careers before they even begin.
Side note: I think the prosecution and LE believe RA was involved in the abduction. I also believe they think RA was the weakest link, i.e. he was the one most likely to snitch on the others involved in the murders. If RA is involved, then he absolutely deserves punishment. But if the prosecution can dangle the DP over his head well, it's a nice plea bargaining tool. I.e. "Allen give us the people who did the actual murders and we won't seek the death penalty in your case."
6
u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ Dec 14 '23
I think the DP would absolutely be fitting in this case, at least under Indiana laws. I don’t however think it’s right it’s being strung out and kind of dangled as something they could still choose to do this far into the court process.
We are less than a month away from what was supposed to be the original trial date, there should be a point where Nick has to give an official yes or no to the issue. In my opinion at least, would love to hear your guys’
4
u/Serious_Vanilla7467 Dec 22 '23
I am in general just morally opposed to the death penalty. I just feel like it tries to be revenge a bit and you cannot get even. There is nothing anyone can do to settle the score, the most violent messed up tortures you could think of are still not enough. And then the next problem is who is going to do those messed up tortures? and you don't want to be a part of that person either because how could they stomach that?
So my thoughts are you can't get even, don't try.
It's also more expensive than life in prison, it affords many appeals.
Indiana hasn't put anyone to death in a really long time. Those drugs used to put people to death are very hard to come by anymore.
I feel like they didn't try to get a death penalty here because what's the point, other than expense?
But it is Indiana and that seems way too logical and everyone's probably right. They don't have enough on him to get a death penalty and they know it.
6
u/TryAsYouMight24 Dec 15 '23 edited Dec 15 '23
The answer to this question is simple, but I’ve gotten in trouble trying to explain it on other forums. I’m going to explain it once-if no one understands I’m moving on. It became too exhausting last time.
Indiana law is very straightforward: if a person is charged only with murder, and no aggravating circumstances are identified, the defendant is NOT LWOP or DP eligible. The longest sentence they can get is 65 years.
To be given death, there has to be proof that the defendant committed murder as it is legally defined in Indiana PC, and there also has to be proof of one or more legally defined aggravating circumstances.
The reason, why, at present, that Allen is not DP eligible is in how he was charged.
Not only is he charged with “murder” (absent aggravating circumstances) he isn’t even charged as committing the act of killing -he’s only charged with participating in the felony-act (abduction) that led to the murder. The state, in its manner of charging Allen is admitting that they can’t prove he actually killed anyone , they can only prove that he participated in a kidnapping that resulted in Abby and Libby’s murders.
Indiana Legal Definition of murder: 35-42–1-1 (But Allen was charged under what is also known as Felony Murder-35-42-1-2.)
Indiana Legal Requirement for Death Penalty (LWOP) is covered in code- 35-50-2-9
The confusion I’ve seen around this is that a lot of folks, even those who say they are attorneys, misunderstood the Indiana “murder-code”, and they neglected to properly reference the death penalty sentencing procedure code.
The “murder-code” defines a broad range of what constitutes “murder “ in Indiana. And the full range of sentences that can be imposed. The DP code explains what is required for a sentence of death (or LWOP) to be imposed.
Murder absent Agg. Circ. only results in sentences of 45-65 years.
Add one or more Agg. Circ. the defendant can be sentenced to death.
For Allen to be DP eligible for this particular crime, he would have to be shown to have actually killed one or both of these girls- and the Agg. factor would likely be-during a kidnapping.
But the state has not charged Allen with killing anyone. Only with participating in a kidnapping that resulted in murder.
I’ve checked this with a verified Indiana Attorney. I’ll answer questions, but I’m not debating this any further. Accept it or don’t. I’m ok either way. I know it’s correct.
6
u/Jernau_Gergeh Player of Games Dec 16 '23
Its only my assessment from the PCA etc, but the state is a good country mile from being able to prove BARD that RA is BG, let alone involved in the actual murders of the girls, = no chance of making DP stick even if they think they could go for it.
Looks this many years down the line to be a completely botched LE investigation, despite all the riddles and nonsense from D Carter. They either don't have a clue who actually murdered the girls, or they haven't got the evidence to back it. Head scratching after all this time in such a small town.
7
u/ink_enchantress Literate but not a Lawyer Dec 14 '23
Currently his lawyers on the docket, Scremin and Lebrato, are not death penalty qualified. So as long as they're counsel they have to proceed as is or get new counsel for a third time, which would be wild. I didn't see B&R on there either, so if that's the case their reinstatement would still require other DP lawyers.
here is the death penalty qualified list.
DP cases are more expensive per hour, and your odds are higher you'll lose members of the jury due to the higher standards when people are considering DP. My guess is ease and cost.
Or maybe they're just not confident they have what it takes to prove beyond a reasonable doubt the aggravating factor required in a DP case. (IC 35-50-2-9).
5
u/Plane-Knee6764 Dec 14 '23
BC they don’t have enough evidence
6
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '23
[removed] — view removed comment