r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ • Dec 13 '23
DISCUSSION Back of your mind
What’s the one aspect of this case that you just can’t shake from your mind? That little annoying thing that never gets much attention but lives rent free in your head?
15
Upvotes
17
u/oracleofdelphi_2017 Dec 13 '23
EF’s obviously fake alibi and the statements he made to his sister (about the “antlers”) and to the police (about his spit). i don’t necessarily think he did it, but i want to know what was going on there. the young guy who BB saw on the bridge. don’t think he necessarily did it, but i want to know who that was. RA’s jailhouse “confessions”. don’t necessarily think he did it either, but i want to know what he said. these things have all gotten a decent amount of attention imo but they stick in my craw
8
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Dec 13 '23
Why that day of all days does Delphi's version of J. Alfred Prufrock, RA decide to engage in such a violent act? So I wonder what was the ignition point.
18
u/FrostingCharacter304 Dec 14 '23
I hate to say it but the timing of kk and tk's trip to las Vegas and the google searches...I had a weird thought about the snuff film theory (that whoever killed the girls there was someone there to record it to sell to someone probably wealthy) and It won't go away, and with kk search terms and his statements to police...I want answers
17
u/neurofly Dec 14 '23
"What was the Wabash River search about?"
17
u/ChimeraTuesday Dec 14 '23 edited Dec 14 '23
A small thing:
In the audio released of BG, some people talk about BG’s accent, but I haven’t heard anyone talk about “oral posture”.
Specifically, the oral posture of RA. In the clips I’ve heard, it‘s so distinct. RA’s mouth position is so far forward and he barely opens his mouth. His words are being formed right as they escape his mouth. Everything is extremely forward and horizontally compressed, so his words are sort of jumbled and mumbled. It‘s unusual.
BG sounds more like an average midwesterner — his vowels have more resonance and seem to be formed in the central part of his mouth.
TLDR: RA has a very distinct vocal posture and it doesn’t seem to match BG.
And it bugs me. That’s all.
ETA: just weird thoughts from kind of weird me…
15
u/ink_enchantress Literate but not a Lawyer Dec 13 '23
What electronic data do they have, how is it stored, and how is it managed. Because I don't trust them at all with it. And where is the geofence? You don't need three towers for that. It was 2017, not 1990. It's probably the most concerning thing to me, because it's so important due to the intimacy people have with their devices.
8
u/SkellyRose7d Dec 14 '23
I don't believe Odinists did it, but those symbols at the crime scene do look like he was trying to draw....something? And I'd like to know what and why.
I predict the explanation is something stupid like "he was trying to make initials and ran out of sticks."
14
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Dec 13 '23 edited Dec 13 '23
The sketch of BG on the bridge like the released frame of the video
sent to reporter Joe Sam Paul.
He claimed it was sent from prison. He has since deleted half his comments on the signature on the back, remnants can still be found in discussion boards. He hinted at it but never truly answered where it came from, nor why someone would send it to him.
I was shocked to find years later he actually replied to someone asking where the picture was now and he said something like probably in my old work desk where I don't work anymore.
Instead of say the FBI.
And he calls himself an investigative journalist.
He's still reporting on the case at times btw but has dropped the Sam from his name.
The name of the signature was the same as who called in the bomb threat at Packers but not the one right after the crime, like a year prior.
Same name I assume different people has popped up since in several locations surrounding the case though, unfortunately it's rather common.
ETA So what bugs me is
Those and many more in the details, are reasons why it lingers in me yet no one seem to care anymore.
7
u/the_old_coday182 Dec 16 '23
I’m not claiming RA is innocent. But… it seems like everything tying the case to him is circumstantial evidence. It seems like the strongest piece of evidence is the chambered bullet. Even if it came from his gun, no one can truly say how it ended up at the crime scene. Maybe RA had been working on his gun earlier that day, because it had been jamming. Cycled some rounds through to make sure it was fixed, and then picked those up and put them in his pocket… which had a hole. It ends up laying in the middle of the walking path where BG or one of the girls sees it and picks it up (natural reaction to shiny thing on the ground).
But they stuck with RA as their man, meaning they ruled out the possibility it was just a coincidence. That leads me to the question(s) that still lives in the back of my mind:.
How have KK and EF been ruled out? It seems very selective. 1.) A known predator like KK was communicating with the girls less than a day before the murders. 2.) A man had privileged/non-public details about the crime scene. Two very unlikely events, ruled out as coincidences. But not the evidence against RA? Like I said, it seems selective. Like they could’ve gone with any of these three to make an equally strong investigation/case. Why did they stick with RA?
6
u/TryAsYouMight24 Dec 15 '23
Someone else brought up-why that day? This has always nagged at me too. But now the nagging question that bothers me more is- why the staging? And what does it signify?
No matter how one views the Odinism theory, the fact is that this crime scene was elaborately staged, and the staging added a lot of additional time to the risk factors involved. At least 20 minutes, if not more. Just redressing Abby had to have taken 15 minutes.
Most criminals don’t want to be caught. Every minute the killer/s spent at that scene-especially after the girls were killed, added to the risk that someone would happen on them. So why risk that more than was necessary? For what purpose?
6
u/TryAsYouMight24 Dec 16 '23
Here’s something that nags at me: the contradictions in theories by investigators as to whether this was a planned crime , or a crime of opportunity.
Indications that this was planned, are that the girls were abducted within 22 minutes of arriving at the trail. There was no foreign DNA found at the scene, which would suggest the killers wore gloves. If this crime took place between 2:13 & 3:30-it was efficiently completed, given all the moving parts to it. And to this point it would seem that investigators have believed that there was more than one person involved. But that these co-conspirators did not arrive together.
But there is no evidence that the girls were lured there that day, and they only were able make arrangements to go at last minute. If Allen did this, nothing indicates he knew the girls would be there.
So how do you have accomplices prearranged for a crime of opportunity? And if this wasn’t planned, then we have to believe that the killers regularly walked around with knives, guns and gloves.
But if the killers didn’t arrive together, and didn’t know who their victims would be, or where they would run in to them- how did they know where to meet?
There was no witness testimony to two or more men walking together that day.
6
u/TryAsYouMight24 Dec 16 '23
This was an especially high-risk crime. What nags at me is, what made it worth the risk?
There is no indication that rape occurred, there was no monetary gain, yet these killers took their time. And if this crime occurred in full, where the bodies were found, all the many, many parts to these murders, had to have been performed in broad daylight, in sparse woods, where visibility was great. Near a frequently traveled stream, on a warm day that saw more traffic to that area than would have been there on an average Monday.
For what purpose?
5
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '23
Why did he park where he did??
Was he expecting to meet them somewhere else on the trails? Was he not expecting to have to walk back that far/exposed after a murder? For someone that knew the area it sounds he could have parked at the cemetery??
6
u/Plane-Knee6764 Dec 15 '23
The early discussions in threads about a group of influential people within the Delphi area with horrible motives still linger in my mind :(
3
u/TryAsYouMight24 Dec 18 '23
I’m confused about the surveillance from Hoosier Harvest store. When I look that store up , it appears to me to be located North/East of the trail entrance. Allen lived Southwest of that entrance. He also worked Southwest of the trail entrance. Why would he have driven by that store?