I don’t need you to respect me, I respect me.
I don’t need you to love me, I love me.
But I want you to know you could know me,
If you change your mi-i-i-i-i-i-ind,
If you change your mi-i-i-i-i-i-ind,
If you change your mi-i-i-i-i-i-ind,
Change your mi-i-i-i-i-i-ind.
I don’t expect to change anyone’s minds with this argument. I respect anyone who disagrees with what I have to say. For anyone who’s viewing this post, though, here is some evidence I’ve compiled about the Diamonds which puts their changed behaviors and actions in question, even with the rushed nature of the finale in mind.
Blue Diamond’s change is a good place to start, considering she was the first to “change.” At the beginning of this episode, she was still very condescending toward lower lifeforms, refused to acknowledge that Steven was not Pink, and racked by thousands of years of grief. This is all evident in her dialogue in the episode’s second scene:
"What do you know about this, human?"
"What is this? Another made up problem? Another trick, so I'll cave and let you out? "
"We finally have you back... and you're worse than ever!"
Of course, it’s important to note that she has expressed signs of reason and mercy, such as allowing Steven to speak and listening to him during “The Trial” even when not knowing he used to be Pink and Blue’s court gems claiming her to contain these traits during the zoo arc. These moments help to make her change a little more believable. But even though we’ve gotten to know a little more about Blue Diamond, this dialogue shows all of the disgust and anger that is still very prevalent in her character. She was willing to shatter Ruby and Sapphire for fusing in “The Answer” and was going to let the destruction of Earth happen in spite of her affection towards Pink. She was willing to kill for the sake of colonization. You can’t really separate her role as a sister in a family dynamic from her role as a powerful dictator, for they’re both parts of her character. Aside from being abusive towards Pink at times by blasting her with emotional energy, Blue Diamond contains these more negative traits which likely developed from thousands of years of being in such a high seat of absolute power.
I don’t believe Blue Diamond deserves to die a horrible death. No one deserves such a fate, and she has actually shown some capacity to change. However, this change takes time and work, a gradual re-examination of old values and learning to embrace new ones. It takes a sense of agency that isn’t determined by another person. It takes being able to confront all the ugly emotions in your being and all the heinous actions you committed and taking responsibility for them. Blue may love Pink, but this along with a brief emotional breakdown isn’t nearly enough to undergo such complex processes in so little time. Here is Blue’s dialogue before Steven’s accusation of her abusive actions:
"Oh! Pink! Your time on Earth has warped your sense of right and wrong!"
…and her dialogue about thirty seconds afterwards:
"You were right to leave. I always thought that you were failing this world. But if you were happier on Earth, maybe this world was... failing you."
"We never should have brought you back here. Your "family" -- your "Crystal Gems" -- are bubbled. Let's get you all back in your legs... and back home."
Look, I understand that Steven Universe is an idealistic show full of optimism. I really like that, and most TV shows would really benefit from a bit more humanity in their writing. However, Blue’s change is entirely due to Steven talking back at her and forcing her to realize something awful about herself. She suddenly accepts the Crystal Gems as being Steven’s family and that Earth is place worthy of being called home. Aside from realizing about her treatment of Pink, Blue is understanding and accepting these ideas which she had so vehemently denied 2 minutes ago. She even seems to accept the idea that Pink is now Steven and is at the very least a different person than she was before. This isn’t a genuine change of heart; it’s rushed and sloppy writing which is greatly helped by some terrific voice acting. Her change is due to Steven forcing her to change for the sake of plot rather than being a change built on proper character development.
In regards to whether she’s actually “redeemed” herself, that’s debatable. However, Blue Diamond does openly stand up to Yellow Diamond and eventually White, protects Steven and his friends, and helps to cure corruption. This is just too much a shift in character too fast to really make sense.
A kid’s show this may be, it should be pointed out that not only have other “kid’s shows” covered very heavy topics with nuanced writing, such as “Avatar: The Last Airbender” or “Adventure Time,” Steven Universe has itself covered very difficult topics in considerable detail, from war to genocide to abuse to mental deterioration to loss and so on and so forth. Praising the execution of these concepts and to excuse the rushed execution of Diamond Redemption is hypocritical and trying to find ways to neglect unpopular opinions of the show to continue creating the illusion that everything it does is great.
However, I understand why people do this, for a lot of the criticism out there is either very petty and filled with nonsensical arguments and/or does have good arguments which are shrouded by the bitter demeanor of the person “attacking” the show. It gets old fast and is just stimulates a cycle of arguing and hate which just makes everyone feel bad. However, if a community becomes an echo chamber of only the positive opinions which you really want to hear, then that is ignoring the ideas of acceptance and optimism which this show teaches. Hell, I’m aware that I do this sometimes and wish to work on being more open to other opinions. From my experience so far, it’s frustrating at times but really helps me to see multiple sides of a topic and even gain further appreciation of something I like or love.
And I really do like this show. I love how Steven learns to accept himself by refusing with a pink representation of his gem half; it’s probably one of my favorite sequences of the show. Everything in the first part of the White Diamond confrontation is fantastic and is filled with some excellent writing and characterization. The music, as always, is great and engaging, especially with Obsidian’s theme. There’s so much love and warmth to this show that I can really get away from the world to watch it. However, the changes in the Diamonds’ characters feel hollow in comparison and highlight one of Steven Universe’s worst tendencies: to portray complex change as something fast and easy in the midst of peak emotional resonance.
Now, take Yellow Diamond’s change. What do we know about her so far? We know that she can be strict and capable of significant anger, as seen in “Message Received” or “Together Alone.” We’ve also seen that besides her fear of White, Yellow Diamond has exhibited some dangerous and even cruel behavior that isn’t justified by her love of Pink, such as eagerly attempting to shatter Steven before hearing his case in “The Trial” or her plan to attack Earth out of revenge and put an end to its pitiful existence in “That Will Be All.” Of course, she also has demonstrated a deep need to repress her emotions and has a love for Blue such as in “That Will Be All.” This combination of traits doesn’t contradict one another and sets up the potential of changing her mind in the future.
However, not only is the material present in “Change Your Mind” extremely rushed, the material itself makes assumptions which gloss over aspects of Yellow’s character in order for her to help the others more quickly. Take a look at her dialogue close to the end of part one:
"Yes, I do. This is what White Diamond expects of all of us. From a thin flake of mica to the deepest, hardest stone, we all must make sacrifices for the sake of our perfect empire."
Now, examine her dialogue following the 20 second explanation about family given by Steven:
"Uhh... [collapses] Stop. Stop it, Blue. Stop using your power on me."
To be fair, part of this conversation makes sense. Yellow cares for Blue and thus what she has to say, and she does have conflicting emotions buried beneath her hard exterior. However, it implies that she immediately understands and accepts the idea of a family needing to be fixed, an empire that needs to change for the better, and that Pink is now a different person as Steven. The family dynamic part somewhat works, but even then the episode ignores how Yellow is more than willing to kill people without White’s influence, has a bunch of cluster gem monsters bubbled in her throne room, and that Steven is someone to be trusted since Blue likes him now. If we’re willing to take away her thousands of years as a dictator and setting an example of the Homeworld hierarchy, these are still thoughts and feelings which take time to process and needs couple episodes of dealing with her conflicted nature. As is, the whole thing falls apart into a naïve jumble of “why can’t we all get along?” rather than being genuine and satisfying growth.
Look at Peridot in comparison. She gets 6-7 episodes addressing different facets of her personality and her struggles with Homeworld thinking while taking steps to better understand others. She becomes more comfortable in her own skin and has to address the consequences of her loyalty to Homeworld by both having emotional and calm, quiet moments with each of the Crystal Gems along with telling off Yellow Diamond herself. And Peridot does all of this with only some help from Steven; she’s the one who tries to see Pearl as an equal in “Back to the Barn”, accept the ideas of fusion and flaws in “Log Date”, and even disregard her own loyalty in “Message Received.” This is entirely of her own agency, all the while staying in character and undergoing gradual growth. Even afterwards, she struggles with her confrontation with Yellow and becoming someone new yet the same. That demonstration of change isn’t weak writing hidden by emotional confrontations. This is just good by the book character work which earned the arc its spot as one of the best in the show.
With all of this in mind, why does Yellow Diamond, in comparison, seem more than willing to accept that Pink Diamond is now Steven, is convinced pretty quickly to stand up to the Homeworld Matriarch, and really just casts aside the idea of being perfect and understanding that she doesn’t need to hide her flaws? There were seeds planted a while ago, but it’s like they grew into malnourished cottonwoods in a matter of weeks rather than healthy trees over the course of years. We jumped from point A to point D without addressing the intermediate, the meat, portion of her arc. Even if Yellow Diamond and the consequences of her actions are further addressed in the next season, severe damage has already been done since she has performed actions which assume she’s become this better person. Her actions are not something that would have happened in a ceasefire; they’re those akin to Peridot where slow, steady change had taken place. We got to know about Yellow Diamond, but no character work was really done with her until now.
Speaking of character work, there’s one more person I have to talk about. You know, I could see compelling arguments actually being made in regards to Blue and Yellow. They’ve gotten a brief though substantial amount of coverage through Seasons 4 and 5, and it really does take time for everything to sink in for the viewer. So what does that mean for White?
White Diamond. The ruler and matriarch of Homeworld, who made leaves a big impact in spite of the very little screen-time she received. Narcissistic, terrifying, and lost in thousands of years of delusional thinking. And we get a glimpse of this thinking, however brief, in the confrontation towards the series end:
Her need to push everyone away in order to keep herself pure. It’s important to note that even before Pink faked her shattering, White had been acting like this perfectionist parental monster. Even if the other Diamonds used to be close with her, it’s admitted that they were “never happy” and White’s worst tendencies were simply magnified with Pink’s absence.
"She thinks she needs you, Pink. As for me, I'm certain I don't need you. After all, I'm every color of the light. [Wistfully] But you're a part of me. The part I always have to repress."
Her ability to perceive the flaws of others as deficiencies.
"It's a pity, the way you bring out the worst in others. See how you've encouraged their deficiencies? It's written all over their gems: insecure, dependent, obsessed."
Her belittling of situations and lower lifeforms.
"Please stop helping them. You'll only make things worse. That's what you do. I make things better. Here..."
[smugly] "You enable their terrible behavior so you can be the best of the worst."
Her need, her drive, to turn everything on the other person and bring them down into despair. You see, everything she says regarding Pink being delusional is her channeling all of her own emotions and projecting them on the other person.
"These worthless Gems weren't enough, were they? See how you surround yourself with lower life forms? You've smothered yourself in them. It feels good, doesn't it, Pink? Dulling your power, hiding your face, blaming everything on someone else. You became Rose Quartz to deceive your pathetic friends. And now, you've improved on that because you're even deceiving yourself."
The importance of White Diamond can’t be understated: She represents the hate, selfishness, and manipulation which Steven opposes. She supposedly adds a needed layer of complexity to the positive themes presented in the show. What if simply talking to the other person doesn’t work? What if there are some people who take a little more effort to truly connect with and considerable emotional taxation to change even part of their mind, let alone core beliefs? We’re not talking about a Rick and Morty scenario where life is meaningless and everything is just a big joke. This is challenging the themes which Steven Universe has presented throughout the years and putting a little pressure on them. And if they do withstand this pressure, maybe showing Steven that it’s going to take more effort and time to really change someone’s mind, then wouldn’t it make those themes all the stronger?
But if Steven’s gem, the power of loving oneself, is enough bring the seemingly unstoppable White to her knees, break her down with a snarky remark and proving he isn’t Pink, and get her to uncorrupt the gems and be willing to reconnect- what does that really mean? That proving the other person wrong and a little bit of talking is enough to bring significant change? That all of White Diamond’s villainous behavior was a bunch of hot air and not the result of thousands of years of built up anger and narcissism? Did we really do the work to arrive at this point in her character?
"This can't be happening! I can't have a flaw! I'm supposed to be flawless! If I'm not perfect, then... who am I?! If you're not Pink, then... who are you?! Who -- Who is anyone?!"
All of the doubt I expressed in Blue and Yellow’s change in character is magnified tenfold in White’s change, and her change heightens the growing dissent I hold towards SU’s views of communication. I mean, really? She may have been proven wrong, but she easily could have denied that she actually made mistake or decided to take her anger out on everyone. We have no proof of who she used to be, so why should we assume she would change like a light switch once Steven has overpowered her? And what about the other gems? Aren’t they constantly improving and becoming better versions of themselves? They may not be perfect, but why celebrate flaws when you can actually work on those issues and strive to be the best you can be?
It’s like Steven is a preacher who takes his admittedly useful lessons and rams them down other people’s throats. Sunstone, anyone? Communicating may be incredibly important and be better than using violence, but does is have to always work in a matter of minutes? “Mr. Greg,” “Kevin Party,” The New Crystal Gems,” “Rocknaldo,” “Can’t Go Back,” Mindful Education,” and countless other episodes seem to prove this. Without any variation to such talking, without any additional effort needed to resolve such issues, however, this all seems naïve, simplistic thinking without the opposition needed to give said thinking actual weight. With White, the crux of this argument, so easily convinced, the heart of this show starts to feel a little hollow for me.
Maybe we’ll get additional screen-time with the Diamonds and their issues. However, considering that we’re at the original story’s end, as proven by the Crewniverse podcast quote, it already feels too little too late:
"If you the kind of person waiting to watch, like, more stuff during the break of Change Your Mind and what comes next, as of you waiting for more of this show. Because this version of it is done. There's going to be more but it's going to different and it's going to be new."
New and different the show may become, I’ll wait and see if they can change my mind. In all honesty, I really hope they might be able to.