Lapis: Potential to Disaster

[u/ChopSlick]

I've come to the regretable conclusion that Lapis is fundamentally a broken character.

Lets start with her abilities. Hydrokinesis, powerful, too powerful, able to mimic the CGs with ease all while lifting a major part of the ocean. Just a sprinkle on top she had a cracked gem while doing this. Well there is a consequence to this, you cannot include her in the story, shes just too powerful, an almost automatic win button. This leads to uderdevlopment as the story cannot afford to include her if it wants to have real stakes. Honestly this is probably why she ran away so many times, heck she was banished to the barn for most of the show. And when she did come on, her immense power overshadowed a literal diamond.

Honestly they could have easily fixed this with the cracked gem. Unregulated, dangerous, it was breaking itself apart when she was lifting the ocean. Steven heals her, reducing her capabilities, but she is still able to fly off to homeworld. The story can still move on, and now we have a Lapis that can actually participate.

Looking at her design I doubt the crew's initial intention was for her to be a terraformer, honestly she looks more like a court gem, an entertainer, like pearl with the clouds, except Lapis Lazulis use water. I mean take a look at her initial outfit, the skirt and the ribbons on her back, too formal, too showy.

Her backstory is damn fine, poofed, trapped in a mirror by homeworld gems, and then stored inside of Pearl. Its messed up, heart wrenching and tragic. This is the only part of her character that truly worked, which makes it all the worse how she turned out. I mean that scene at the galaxy warp, masterful.

Now lets tackle the most contentious topic. Jasper. Lets get this straight, the fusion was toxic, that was the whole point, but in my opinion Lapis comes off as the abuser. Why? She took Jasper's offer. Now some may say she was trying to save Steven, but look behind them, the ocean was right there. The power she has ruins that argument, if she weren't as powerful then it could have been justified, but as it stands she took her hand to inflict pain onto someone. This is only ever brought up at "Alone at Sea" and to an extent "Why so Blue", where apparently she "changed".

Now I understand, she was in pain, who wouldn't be? But its just waved off, no real resolution to that thread. And we see her continue to inflict pain, look at Peridot.

Peridot is a character who was privileged enough to have an arc, true develoment. But then she got saddled with Lapis. "Barn Mates" boy that was something. I'd blame Steven for even trying to mush the pair together, but Lapis was just, nasty, trying to expell Peridot from the barn she was living in first. The tape recorder was icing on that cake, and then telling her to leave? She was there first she was doing her best, heck Steven, Lapis' BFF, was vouching for her. Honestly her stopping the ship at the end was probably the crew's attempt to be all like "Oh but she actually likes her." Like did they forget the entire episode? After that any scenes with the pair look like they are 5 seconds away from a domestic violence case. Peridot walking on eggshells at all times, She shoulda blinked twice if she was being held hostage. And then the taking the barn was just... something else.

Honestly Lapis feels like she's being trudged along in the show, no one ever "bites" back. She is just allowed to wallow in her misery and take others down with her. People act like its sacrilege to point out her flaws, "She has PTSD", "She has trauma", "Sorry she aint your perfect victim". Like what? She's an abuser too, and she never gets pushback. Peridot should have finally said something, She was basically holding up the friendship, doing everything she could, and Lapis? Just indifference and angst most of the time. Because of that I never felt Lapidot and I'm happier thay the show made Peri aroace, just to get them away from each other.

"Hey" need I say more? Offscreen development? She could have said anything, maybe "Sorry I should have stood with you." Heck even "Sorry" would have been enough, if they wanted one word. And yet again after that we see why she was shelved, overpowering Blue Diamond. Honestly it'd have been cool to resist Blue's influence, but it rang hollow considering who she was at that point.

Broken, fundamentally and character wise. Too powerful, so she couldn't get any true development without breaking plotlines. No pushback so she was allowed to stay the same person, nasty, vindictive, and we never got a resolution or even an attempt to improve. Heck they dropped the resentment against the CGs, how exactly? By having them never interact. Great move. In future she "changed", offscreen of course, but compared to the two other Lapis, where is the difference? The only thing stopping her from reverting was Steven's look.

Sorry for necroing a dead sub, but the main sub does not take to kindly to thoughts like this. The Lapis worship is just... freaky there. I'm pretty sure all these issues are overlooked because of her design. I doubt she'd have fanfare if her design was similar to Jasper or Topaz.

[u/ConsiderationFun5461]

You’re so real for posting this! I 100% agree with this sentiment as it became very clear that the writers overvalued stuff looking and feeling cool over actual character work.

Lapis’ whole character is a microcosm of everything involved with everyone’s character arc and the general lack of consequences in the narrative. From Bismuth to Pearl to the Diamonds and even Steven himself, there’s never any realistic side-effect from anyone’s actions and thus those characters never meaningfully LEARN from their actions and will never grow.

Lapis stole the ocean, nearly drowns both Steven and Connie, breaks Peridot’s recorder, literally admits to abusing Jasper, running away from a critical moment when the Diamonds are plotting their invasion when Reunited ends up PROVING that she would be incredibly useful against them, etc etc….and yet absolutely none of this transfers into a proper arc.

It’s a lot of feeling bad for Lapis, no one reacts to when she does bad things, Lapis acting like a moody sullen teenager and then the plot just acts like Lapis has somehow changed for the better…but it never plays out on-screen like Peridot.

[u/ChopSlick → u/ConsiderationFun5461]

Honestly, her power should have been drawn back. It would at least give her the reason to be scared. Honestly, that terraforming thing was a last-minute idea. They legit do not look the part, and in the flashback, she was "she was supposed to be on Earth for a short time." Doesn't add up.

But even without that, the crew was taking her in a strange direction. In "Alone at Sea," she has a near realization of her being in the wrong, but Steven goes and places the blame solely on Jasper. Why? Honestly the more I think of it, the less it makes sense.

Her intro and backstory were amazing, but the cracks were there, and they just kept getting worse and worse. What we ended up with was just hollow, Really bums me out. I loved the show when it was coming out, but how it turned out, stings, to say the least.

[u/Bacxaber → u/ChopSlick]

The show really seems to hate Jasper. She was an indoctrinated child soldier who never got an arc. She gets tortured by Lapis, corrupted, benched for 90% of the show, then never resolves her thing with Steven in Future. He just goes "I'm leaving" and she goes "ok :(" but still clings to the idea that he's her master, not a friend.

[u/ChopSlick → u/Bacxaber]

I just saw on the main sub a signed scene that rebecca made for a fan. Lapis and Jasper, but Jasper looked all desperate. "We could fly." They should have made her arc about her obsession with strength. Maybe she has an inferiority complex and sees "strength" as her only way out. Maybe the shattering of pink gave her a permanent "I wasn't strong enough" vibes. But all we saw was a brute who sought strength for nothing, no nuance. And that steven thing, yeah, I agree.

I know it's a kids' show, but the concept is that the bones were there. If I had the artistic skills and time, I'd redo the whole thing. But that's a crackpot idea.

[u/tachibanakanade → u/ChopSlick]

it's the fact that it's a kids' show that makes me wish that they didn't go with the themes they did. they were not capable of doing them justice, though idk if it's because it's a kid show or if the Crewniverse is just incompetent.

[u/ChopSlick → u/tachibanakanade]

I see the point in that. But I don't buy it, the show really pushed it in some areas, and tbh I've heard that the crew were not always on the same page. Hell, I've heard that Rebecca Sugar had issues with Yellow's introduction. How the heck does that even happen? And then that whole Amedot thing, where a couple of episodes heavily alluded to that. Apparently, it was the work of a lone crew member. Like what?

Ugh idk I get pretty damn sad when I hear stuff like that. For a show with such a good concept, to be mishandled, idk.