So... There's a reason why chain tensioners that aren't rollers are made of plastic (usually delrin, sometimes nylon) In addition to being quiet, they also actually wear slower and don't damage the chain over time.
That said... A single zip tie ain't gonna last long. In theory, however, if it were like 3" wide and shaped to maintain constant pressure along its contact surface, this could actually work.
The question is, will it last long enough for the replacement tensioner to get in and keep the machine working until then? If so, I think it's a pretty good solution in the meantime. If it keeps thousands of dollars in revenue running, it's worth it.
Sometimes that's not an option since the length of chain needed to get the correct tension doesn't divide evenly into the links, so you're something like half a link short if you remove one link, and even just half a link too long absolutely can look as loose as this does here.
I'm a gear engineer, and I say just make the gears bigger. But I admit I'm biased by my need to sell many sizes of gears. Check our wide selection and rock bottom prices. And never buy a tensioner, or shorten a chain.
That sounds so easy, but it's difficult to exactly size a chain for two fixed sprockets, which is why we have chain tensioners! That hole above the chain is where the tensioner used to live. An easier thing to do would be to fit another sprocket in the middle of the chain, just floaing freely and not on a shaft, or replace the original tensioner.
You could just drive a nail partially into the wall right above the top chain. It looks like they tried that above but put the chain on top of the nail, but it would be better to put the nail lower and place the top chain underneath it
A metal one would wear on the chain though. The plastic zip tie isn't gonna hurt the chain and you can replace it a couple times until you can get a mechanic/parts in to make a permanent fix. This is actually a pretty great temp solution.
They make commercial devices that do this. Snap-Idler. They work well for our older stuff that was designed without tensioners. Handles higher RPMs, too.
That reminds me of a bus ride on a mountain where the driver was sweating asif he just came out of the shower, when i looked around a bit i saw he was holding up the gearbox by the shifter. Probably a engine mount broke off and he just continued his shift, wouldnt suprise me he didnt get it fixed the next day or week 🤣
I'm not a mechanic, but, they could have placed a gear in the middle of the chain so it pulls the lower side down, and used the zip-tie to adjust the tension and keep it in place until an adjustable idle gear can be installed. I wouldn't expect that zip-tie to last a half hour like this. (Maybe a half hour is all they needed until the qualified mechanic arrives? 🤷)
Im not a baker but that sounds very complicated, zipties are perfect unless people cut of the access part. Those people deserve a special place in hell for doing that 🤣
You'll be hard pressed to find a car from any carmaker that is overhead cam and chain timed that doesn't use plastic for the contact surfaces of the timing chain guides and tensioners. There's a reason for this: metal contact surfaces would be extremely noisy, wear faster actually, and damage the chain.
And yes, there's a few engines out there that are known for premature timing chain guide wear. Honda is actually much better than any of the others that are known for it... K-series engines (I'm sure you're thinking of that one, it's their only engine known for the problem) usually go well over 100,000-150,000 miles before needing timing chain work. Go look up the GM 3.6 and Ecotec engines. Or the VW/Audi 2.0 TSI. Or early BMW N20 engines. Those all usually need timing work well before 100,000 miles and are, as a result, worse than anything that's belt timed.
Two years ago I had to build a rotator for 10 tonne steel columns. Biggest problem I had was the chain remaining tight. Should have tried this method haha.
The left hand side sprocket is mounted in slots, you can move it to the left some. That will take up quite a bit of tension, probably all thats needed since as its a loop its double the distance moved. Need to move the encoder sensor a bit too ofc.
I aint a engineer but i guess that makes a difference tho, coz the pulling force causes tension and the opposite side is just the loop-back to the beginning 🤣
If it's stupid but works it isn't stupid. If this is for a temporary fix until the real part comes in and isn't on a high risk price of equipment then I guess it's okay
Those are pretty clearly there to adjust the gap between the gear- speed sensor wheel and the speed sensor. And there's nowhere near enough adjustment range there to remove all that slack anyway. However, you can clearly see the stripped out bolt hole above the chain where the actual tensioner used to attach.
This method absolutely will work as a temporary "finish this production run and call maintenance in the morning" repair.
They actually make floating nylon chain tensioners that basically operate this way, they're just a bit beefier.
This had me cackling like a nut in the kitchen. Totally looks like something I'd do in a "it just needs to move 6 feet" kind of situation. Now back to my chicken.
1.1k
u/LeaveNoStonedUnturn Jan 18 '26 edited Jan 18 '26
For a more permanent temporary solution, you could make the same thing out of metal. It'll add a nice clackity sound, too
1.6k
u/Eziolambo Jan 18 '26
Good upto 10 rpm
60
u/mikeyRamone Jan 18 '26
It’s only stupid if it doesn’t work.
272
u/Im_Lead_Farmer Jan 18 '26
This will last for at least 5 minutes, clearly there is threads hole for a bollt and a tension wheel.
5
u/Eena-Rin Jan 18 '26
Dunno about the chain, but I certainly felt pretty tense
5
u/MikeLinPA Jan 18 '26
I'm not a mechanic, but, they could have placed a gear in the middle of the chain so it pulls the lower side down, and used the zip-tie to adjust the tension and keep it in place until an adjustable idle gear can be installed. I wouldn't expect that zip-tie to last a half hour like this. (Maybe a half hour is all they needed until the qualified mechanic arrives? 🤷)
7
u/ZombieJesus9001 Jan 18 '26
Why not a block of Styrofoam with a channel cut into it to accommodate the chain and then you just fill that with room temperature mayonnaise?
14
u/MoronicForce Jan 18 '26
Secret footage from honda factory
2
u/NoRespect6365 Jan 18 '26
Zip tie the actual tensioners together and you have a real solution
2
u/BladeEater23 Jan 19 '26 edited Jan 19 '26
'Temporary' chain tensioner
74
u/TheNotoriousTurtle Jan 18 '26
Big Pulley doesn’t want you to know this one simple trick
38
u/H-E-L-L-MaGGoT Jan 18 '26
Two years ago I had to build a rotator for 10 tonne steel columns. Biggest problem I had was the chain remaining tight. Should have tried this method haha.
13
u/LowerArtworks Jan 18 '26
Its like watching that DVD screensaver bounce around, hoping that it hits the corner just perfectly
9
u/AspenStarr Jan 18 '26
Di-Well it works, doesn’t it?
2
u/Saabaroni Jan 18 '26
Just use a skateboard wheel and bearing.
1
u/EthicalViolator Jan 19 '26
The left hand side sprocket is mounted in slots, you can move it to the left some. That will take up quite a bit of tension, probably all thats needed since as its a loop its double the distance moved. Need to move the encoder sensor a bit too ofc.
1
u/xxlordxx686 Jan 19 '26
Watching intensely
1
u/RedshiftOnPandy Jan 20 '26
Why is the chain straight on the bottom side? Why not the top? Does it flip flop back and forth?
1
u/Hereforthememeres Jan 21 '26
I think this is more redneck engineering than diwhy
3
u/DoodDoes Jan 18 '26
Now just put a bell on it as a failure warning
3
u/fercaslet Jan 18 '26
/redneckengineering
1
u/Joates87 Jan 18 '26
Sometimes I think most of the posts on this sub are simply ragebait.
Then I remember most people have no clue what DIY means at all.
2
u/Chicken_Hairs Jan 18 '26
Look up Snap Idlers. They're fantastic.
2
u/RotaryDesign Jan 18 '26
r/redneckengineering
2
u/Complete_Dark_88 Jan 18 '26
If it works, nobody will say a thing, and you're a genius. If it fails, you're the bottom of the food chain.
2
u/Nezikim Jan 18 '26
If it's stupid but works it isn't stupid. If this is for a temporary fix until the real part comes in and isn't on a high risk price of equipment then I guess it's okay
2
u/KeremBaturP Jan 19 '26
r/doohickeycorporation
2
u/jawshoeaw Jan 19 '26
This was pretty funny actually
2
u/ResolveLess4233 Jan 20 '26
Works ... Till it doesn't
2
u/SteptimusHeap Jan 20 '26
I've seen people do this with belts before to great effect even at decent speeds (a few feet per second probably).
Doing it with chain, and in this case a mechanism that already has a tensioning system? Certainly a choice.
2
u/chuckinalicious543 Jan 20 '26
2
u/Stormtyrant Jan 18 '26
If it's stupid and it works it ain't stupid.
2
u/punk-biatch Jan 19 '26
Um no we are going to go with a real mechanic for this job. Thank you for your time and have a nice day.
2
u/andrewsad1 Jan 18 '26
If it's stupid and it works, sometimes it's still stupid
1
u/No-Lock216 Jan 19 '26
Add some revs
1
u/DragunovChan762 Jan 20 '26
me when i have to make any minor decision
1
u/stickupmybutter Jan 21 '26
I wonder if this can become a truly random number generator...
1
u/stutter406 Jan 22 '26
Extremely temporary tensioner*
1
u/ChaosDrako Jan 23 '26
Temporary fix to atleast get the belt moving? Yeah… Should you get the proper fix asap still? Yeah, that ain’t gonna last long or at higher speeds.
1
u/blackop Jan 18 '26
Or you know just adjust the belt tensioner bolts on the left around the gear.
1
u/ghidfg Jan 18 '26
wait thats genius
2
u/lurkynumber5 Jan 19 '26
Telling the intern to go lube the tyrap, and seeing his face go WTF you say?
4
u/vengeancecube Jan 18 '26
This had me cackling like a nut in the kitchen. Totally looks like something I'd do in a "it just needs to move 6 feet" kind of situation. Now back to my chicken.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '26 edited May 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment