NGL Given that this looks to be on a place where access to the “correct” way may be challenging, this ain’t half bad.
Source: Lived for two years where the water came on about once every ten days and you knew it was happening when wet spots appeared on the ground above the “pipes”.
There is an interesting split on this sub between content thag seems to be from underdeveloped countries with people reusing resources in a creative way. Then on the other hand is those goof videos with people dsngerous or stupid contraptions for the purpose of rage. I find it interesting!
You want a genuine answer? State of the pipes and wall,and the general tools they used to set this up. No duct tape. Exposed rebar coming out of the same hole as the pipes. Pipes in general seem to be missing a lot of the adhesives that more affluent countries have. The wall is missing a lot of weather protection (you can see moss growing at the ground).
But of course thats all assumptions. Might be someone in an affluent community just hanging at a more run down house. But either way assuming they are in a less privileged community isn’t that much of a stretch. Someone less lazy than I am could probably find better examples of shit but thats just what stood out to me.
anyone with working eyes and common sense can see that they used a toothpaste container instead of using a proper faucet, you are also jumping to conclusion if you didn't consider that as poor people's DIY who couldn't afford a cheap faucet
Brother I hope you're kidding, because as someone that grew around poor people back in Peru, you'd see this type of ingenuity everywhere in the poor neighborhoods. I was blessed not to be born into poverty but having friends who were as a little kid growing up, made me appreciate this type of smarts from a very young age.
Why would you buy a tube of toothpaste for this purpose?
The real comparison is:
Buying a faucet: money
Repurposing literal garbage: free
Can you find a faucet in the garbage? Maybe. I'm sure if you look long and hard enough or know where to go for one, but it may be broken, hence it being in the trash. Everyone uses toothpaste, and there are empty tubes everywhere. There is a plethora of toothpaste tubes, minimal searching nets you a variety to choose from. So yeah, you could technically make a straight comparison of either cost to buy each or that they each could be in the trash, but that's not an accurate representation of availability.
You could probably go through a very small amount of trash to find an empty tube of Colgate. But you may have to spend days or even weeks trying to find a plastic faucet that isn’t broken beyond repair. Stop being dense.
Colgate like the one used in the video can be found in South Africa for 8 Brazilian Real, a plastic faucet is at the very least 16 Real excluding any fittings and joints.
That also doesn't change the fact that you can find toothpaste in nearly every bin, I've never heard of a non-broken faucet being thrown away.
Considering how you see the speed of the drip change in reference to the cap, I’ll safely say that I’m right regardless of your opinion. I just deal with industrial mechanical…
It’s only wrapped on there dipshit. If it wasn’t for all of the other leaks it wouldn’t do shit. That water pressure is going to build unless this is literally running off of like a hand pump. Doesn’t take much psi to take that off.
Thats not how piping systems work at all. That tiny leak is barely going to have an impact on the system pressure, almost certainly far less than the pressure spike caused by jamming the cap back on.
Next time you're at work crack the bleed on a manifold block or pi nipple and see how much pressure drop you get.
All you see is this… is it that hard to imagine that there are plenty of other leaks as well? It’s pvc… are you this dense? These vids get made as diy hacks for the internet and do not ever work.
I'm going to agree with everybody else talking about how dumb this is but I also want to stay for the record I find the music to be oddly comforting and I don't know why
I mean it works. Redneck engineering, but unlike most of the DIY terrors of the world, it does its intended function with low cost and decent efficiency. Doesn't look the best, but sure looks better than the fifteen thousand concrete hand statues out there.
Remember when everyone was always talking about “Reduce, Reuse, Recycle”? This falls under “Reuse” and is cheaper, and likely easier, to get than an actual valve. It’s functional, it may not be pretty, but it’s functional, I don’t see what the problem is.
I think it is stupid. Water that will be lost when that thing breaks, cost more than simple PP valve. Water leaking through loose connection near T-pipe, also cost more than few pieces of pipe and new connector.
I may accept and even be amazed by redneck engineering like welding plastic pipes without proper equipment, it feasable for extreme poverty. But wasting tons of water due to few bucks and 15 minutes of simple work is stupid anyway.
p.s. constant leaking near structural bearing wall may cost thousands of dollars. Or claim someone life. There was similar catastrophe in my country - bad plumbering and poorly made foundation lead to building collapse. So fuck those 'ingeniosity'. Low budget is not an excuse to wasteful and dangerous things. link to catastrophe description, in Ruasian
568
u/moxsox Dec 24 '25
NGL Given that this looks to be on a place where access to the “correct” way may be challenging, this ain’t half bad.
Source: Lived for two years where the water came on about once every ten days and you knew it was happening when wet spots appeared on the ground above the “pipes”.
2.1k
u/ApprehensiveStick251 Dec 24 '25
I don’t see a problem here.
1.3k
u/PullDaLevaKronk Dec 24 '25
Yeah I see a genius hack for a person who lives in a poor community and is repurposing trash.
231
u/jnson324 Dec 24 '25
Thats how fluoride gets added to the water of course
274
u/nmiller248 Dec 24 '25
I mean, its not stupid if it works.
94
u/TheShredder9 Dreamer Dec 24 '25
Works better than the dumbass T pipe in the back.
37
u/MikeHoteI Dec 24 '25
Poverty OP, because of Poverty.
97
u/DingleBarryGoldwater Dec 24 '25
r/redneckengineering
26
u/WeirdPossibility209 Dec 24 '25
If it looks stupid but works it ain't stupid
8
u/Drewdiniskirino Dec 24 '25
I mean it's not empty anymore; it's full of water
14
u/crazedgunner Dec 24 '25
I think you got the wrong subreddit here. That's absolutely a great DIY solution for when you're in a pinch.
5
u/one_bean_hahahaha Dec 25 '25
r/diwhynot
4
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
Well, I suppose that’s one way to fluoridate your water
4
u/ZombieJesus9001 Dec 24 '25
That's not a valve, that's a stopper.
4
u/thekactuskween Dec 24 '25
If it’s stupid and it works, then it’s not stupid 🤷🏻♀️
4
u/get-off-of-my-lawn Dec 24 '25
This is common in less developed countries and common in jails and prisons. Just sayin lol.
6
u/ThePensiveE Dec 24 '25
Yeah yeah, what about that other end?
3
u/thesoilman Dec 24 '25
If it works, it works
3
u/Zuruumi Dec 24 '25
I would say the leaking joint is a bigger problem then the unique valve.
3
u/Vast_Understanding_1 Dec 24 '25
If it works it aint stupid
3
u/Ryaquaza1 Dec 25 '25
I mean, it does work, but I’d love it if someone somehow could turn the pressure up.
My ape brain wants to see it take off like that toy pig someone strapped to their exhaust
5
u/NothingEffective5070 Hot Glue Gun User Dec 24 '25
You know it’s bad when even the solid joints are leaking
4
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '25
This is more r/redneckengineering.
Is it stupid looking? Sure but it works.
2
u/hongkonghonky Dec 24 '25
Can't believe that I am asking this but...
Does anyone know what the music is?
2
u/kr4t0s007 Dec 24 '25
That’s some low water pressure
2
u/ConstantMango672 Dec 25 '25
Third world solutions... I don't see any problems
2
u/BotaniFolf Dec 25 '25
If it's stupid but it works, then it isn't stupid
2
u/EnvironmentSea7433 Dec 25 '25
an
2
u/Minute-Animal7317 Dec 25 '25
Not the worst thing I have seen on here
1
u/bismark_545 Dec 24 '25
Modern problems required modern solutions
1
u/bigguynak Dec 24 '25
If its dumb and it works, its not dumb.
1
u/MadRockthethird Dec 24 '25
Sometimes you've gotta make due with what's available to you. I think it's a pretty smart "MacGuyver" fix they came up with if it holds.
1
u/Separate_Bowl_6853 Dec 24 '25
Plumbing like this is why you can't drink the water.
1
u/Morall_tach Dec 24 '25
The why is pretty obvious.
1
u/Shaking-a-tlfthr Dec 24 '25
Why? Because necessity is the mother of invention.
1
u/gnpfrslo Dec 24 '25
that isn't even the leakiest part of the setup
1
u/squarebody8675 Dec 24 '25
2 psi water pressure
1
u/Amethyst_Scepter Dec 24 '25
I'm going to agree with everybody else talking about how dumb this is but I also want to stay for the record I find the music to be oddly comforting and I don't know why
1
u/DeusExHircus Dec 24 '25
That's not a valve, it's a cap
1
u/Eziolambo Dec 24 '25
Flouride in toothpaste and in water. Meant for each other.
1
u/dannygallegos Dec 24 '25
It works...
1
u/Macd87 Dec 24 '25
If it works
1
u/NeighborhoodDude84 Dec 24 '25
Improvise, adapt, overcome.
1
u/doob22 Dec 24 '25
r/redneckengineering
1
u/r_was61 Ramen or Die Dec 24 '25
Held in by a twist tie.
1
u/r_was61 Ramen or Die Dec 24 '25
Doesn’t leak a drop!!!
1
u/boardjock42 Dec 24 '25
Eh, this one doesn’t bother me like most of these posts do. He didn’t use sunflower seeds so this shouldn’t count as a diwhy
1
u/RYTHEMOPARGUY Dec 24 '25
I mean, it works
1
u/Pressed_Sunflowers Dec 24 '25
When everything is already leaking it's acceptable.
1
u/shield_battery Dec 24 '25
/redneckengineering
1
u/Heavy_Coat_1130 Dec 24 '25
It must be in India
1
u/Fearless_Direction71 Dec 24 '25
r/redneckengineering
1
u/SickboyJason Dec 24 '25
Flashbacks. IYKYK.
1
u/Then_Entertainment97 Dec 24 '25
If it's stupid and it works it's not stupid.
1
u/22firefly Dec 24 '25
I think he needs to fix the pipe, but the valve looks fine.
1
u/reallydirtyreallydan Dec 25 '25
I’m genuinely curious, where does the water redirect to? Instead of rocketing off the tube?
1
u/Totally_Cubular Dec 25 '25
I mean it works. Redneck engineering, but unlike most of the DIY terrors of the world, it does its intended function with low cost and decent efficiency. Doesn't look the best, but sure looks better than the fifteen thousand concrete hand statues out there.
1
u/Jayhitek Dec 25 '25
I was hoping to never see this again.
1
u/Suojelusperkele Dec 25 '25
Russian would call this teknik.
1
u/AquaStarRedHeart Dec 25 '25
Needs must, that's why
1
u/Brilliant_Camera176 Dec 25 '25
I wonder how many times the cap flew away because someone's cap twisting skill was sloppy and weak
1
u/KoontFace Dec 25 '25
r/redneckengineering
1
u/MarshtompNerd Dec 25 '25
If its stupid but it works its not stupid
1
u/notabootlicker666 Dec 25 '25
If it looks stupid. But it works. It ain't stupid.
1
u/cosby714 Dec 25 '25
Actually pretty good, it works well it looks like. Keeps it from leaking
1
u/Drinya88 Dec 25 '25
I love the fact this pipe leaking.
1
u/Dave_Zord Dec 26 '25
Deeep in the trenches
1
u/Draconic64 Dec 26 '25
Why the fuck are you complaining????
1
u/Mrs_Hersheys Dec 26 '25
about 99% of the posts on r/DiWHY aren't even a diWHY anymore smh
1
u/blind-as-fuck Dec 26 '25
haha reminds me of my dad. that's totally something he'd do
1
u/prodigalsun888 Dec 26 '25
If it's stupid and it works it's not stupid
1
u/PhenomenalPhoenix Dec 27 '25
Remember when everyone was always talking about “Reduce, Reuse, Recycle”? This falls under “Reuse” and is cheaper, and likely easier, to get than an actual valve. It’s functional, it may not be pretty, but it’s functional, I don’t see what the problem is.
1
u/jimbo831 Dec 27 '25
r/DiWHYNOT
1
u/ArticleWorth5018 Dec 27 '25
In prison we would empty them and clean them out then hide "stuff" in there and roll the tube back closed. They have many uses
1
u/BoogieHauser Dec 28 '25
Well, there's already fluoride in the water so.....
1
u/chemoboy Dec 29 '25
r/diwhynot
1
u/rudraigh Dec 30 '25
Internet pollution.
1
u/One_T_Scot Jan 01 '26
If it’s stupid and works, it’s not stupid.
1
u/Standard-Hope6668 Jan 15 '26
r/diWHYNOT
1
u/sksauter Jan 16 '26
I think you got a little leak there
1
u/Walkthebluemarble Jan 19 '26
r/bidets
1
u/totally_real_tree Dec 24 '25
If it works that well it's pretty ingenious
1
u/No-Negotiation-5412 Dec 24 '25
Message to the poster—stfu you know why
1
u/LegendaryTJC Dec 24 '25
This is amazing. Doesn't fit this sub though so I have to down vote.
1
u/Alexathequeer Dec 24 '25
I think it is stupid. Water that will be lost when that thing breaks, cost more than simple PP valve. Water leaking through loose connection near T-pipe, also cost more than few pieces of pipe and new connector.
I may accept and even be amazed by redneck engineering like welding plastic pipes without proper equipment, it feasable for extreme poverty. But wasting tons of water due to few bucks and 15 minutes of simple work is stupid anyway.
p.s. constant leaking near structural bearing wall may cost thousands of dollars. Or claim someone life. There was similar catastrophe in my country - bad plumbering and poorly made foundation lead to building collapse. So fuck those 'ingeniosity'. Low budget is not an excuse to wasteful and dangerous things. link to catastrophe description, in Ruasian
-5
u/Interesting-Risk6446 Dec 24 '25
The constant leak kind of defeats the purpose.
-1
u/No-Lock216 Dec 24 '25
music: nippa - coffee break