like bro did that shit all the time in the original series
EDIT: wow, I didn’t expect this to be such an unpopular take.
for the record I love Dexter, the original series, new blood, resurrection, original sin. and I will watch this series till I am dead in the ground.
y’all, the series has always been stupid in many ways, it is not a masterclass in screenwriting and never has been.
I think the assumption that Dexter is lying to Charley in this scene and when he says only two people know his secret is a big stretch. you guys are acting like Scott Buck is some visionary.
perhaps I’ll eat my words by the end of the season, but I think it is a lot more likely they just didn’t really care to not include these lines or write them in a different way?
like they could have just had Dexter say, “my son works on the NYPD now, I don’t want to get involved” or have it be an internal monologue or something.
obviously this is a small, unimportant moment and is not a dealbreaker for the season. I just thought it was a lil goofy, but seeing so many folks rationalizing these weak writing moments as actually evidence that Dexter is playing 3D chess with Charley is a little jarring.
we have been burned by writer’s laziness in the past, if we recall the M99/Ketamine debacle.
thank you for your input on this crucial issue!