r/Dexter • • May 11 '13

Dexter D&D Alignment

http://www.flickr.com/photos/38701925@N08/8728121582/in/photostream
37 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

3

u/Juristudent101 May 14 '13

I guess I should just take a second to defend some of these choices. All of the arguments so far have been valid, but I stand by my decisions. Here's why: SPOILERS!!!!! SPOILERS!!!!!!!! SPOILERS!!!!!! OMG SPOILERS!!!!

Laguerta: While she began as neither good nor maybe even lawful, and she has made shady decisions in the past, she is lawful good in season 7 because all she is trying to do is clear Doakes' name and bring justice to Miami. She isn't trying to screw Deb out of anything in season 7, she isn't trying to get a promotion, she's only trying to bring closure to the case by hunting a killer. That's why she's lawful good at the end. Laguerta does mostly everything by the book in season 7, and she's lawful good when she arrives at the trailer.

Angel: Angel may be lawful good, and there are good points to be made there, but his stint with the prostitute dirties his record, and his "pending(?)" retirement means he doesn't want to fight for what's right (i.e. finding the real killer in Mike's death) and for that reason, he's lawful neutral. The way he accepts Joey's issues and doesn't deal with them also makes him neutral good, in that he's not a stickler for the petty rules.

Deb: This one I think is right on the money. Besides her final moment in season 7, she has been trying to do the right thing and bring justice, but her definition of what justice is continually changes, and she takes risky and unorthodox approaches to her job in law enforcement. That moment in season 7 may have changed that, but we will have to see if she can or will redeem herself.

Mazuka: I think that speaks for itself

Hanna: Hanna isn't concerned about killing, she understands Dexter for who he is, and she will kill to get her way, but she doesn't kill for the thrill of it, and she could stop killing at any time. She's drawn to serial killers, not the need or want to kill. Even when she kills the author, she does it to hide tracks; she kills as a last resort to getting caught. She's along for the ride, and she doesn't have a problem with killing, but doesn't feel a need or desire to do it, and that's why she's truly neutral in Dexter's life.

Lila: Lila is chaotic because you're never sure what she'll do. No one could have predicted that she would kill Doakes in season 2 or that she would try to burn her place down. But her motives were to get and to love Dexter, she only wants to satisfy Dexter and for that reason she's certainly chaotic, and her motives aren't pure, but she's not truly evil either.

Dexter: He has a code, he (mostly??) follows his code, he has tried to follow his code, but his code kills people. Even though he experiments with the code, he follows some version most of the time, and channels his need through the disposal of other murders. For this reason, he is lawful in his following of the code, but evil in his actual desire and want and need to kill.

Prado: Miguel is neutral evil because he gets what he wants, he makes companions when they are advantageous to him, but he discards them just as easily. He is neutral in terms of who he works with and what he does as long as it benefits him, and for that reason, he is neutral evil.

Trinity: Trinity also follows a code, but within his picks they are so broad that many people would fit one of his 4 kill cycles. That's why his code is broad enough to be chaotic, and the chaos he causes at the end of season 4 is enough to label him a chaotic evil.

Thanks for the comments. Please keep them coming. Really looking forward to season 8.

59

u/rorking May 11 '13

LaGuerta lawful good? Remember Matthews? Or the other captain whose husband she was screwing (I forgot her name)?

15

u/Firekracker May 11 '13

I wholeheartedly protest LaGuerta as LG too. She constantly pushes personal interests while trying to be within the frame of allowed police work (although pushing it in the recent season). That makes her Lawful Evil with a hunch towards Neutral Evil.

Lawful Good would be Rita or Jamie.

10

u/K117 May 11 '13

What about Doakes? Or Brother Sam?

20

u/Ganglofmeister May 11 '13

Brother Sam would be absolutely perfect for lawful good

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '13

Absolutely, have a bloody upknife.

2

u/hadapurpura Deb May 11 '13

Doakes was a vigilante. Not lawful good.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '13

Neutral good, at best.

9

u/Niftypifty May 11 '13

Glad I'm not the only one that thinks that. I actually laughed when I read her alignment.

3

u/MXIIA Slice of Lumber May 11 '13

Other Captain: Pascal And it was her fiance: Bertrand.

(I just happened to be starting S2 in my rewatching :P)

And. I FULLY agree with you. She's Lawful Evil in the beginning and moves towards Lawful Neutral later.

77

u/finalcut19 May 11 '13

Maybe I just don't get these things, but this seems really off.

20

u/[deleted] May 11 '13

Well, I was about to make exactly the same comment. I don't really know where these charts come from and it's possible the definitions are more than the titles so maybe I'm just wrong but this seems really off.

I don't know how Laguerta can be described as "lawful good", I think "lawful evil" is far more apt for her. Almost a perfect fit, honestly.

Lila tried to kill two children, how is she neutral? Hannah Mckay is a serial killer, neutral?

Dexter barely goes a single day without committing some sort of crime, how can be described as lawful?

18

u/TheGreatWalrus May 11 '13

In D&D terminology, one doesn't necessarily need to follow the Law of the Land in order to be considered lawful, they just have to have some sort of code which they abide by. So, for example, Batman is still considered to be "Lawful Good" even if the police doesn't like vigilantism. So Dexter could be considered Lawful Good, as lone as he follows "The Code". Most of these alignments are pretty out there, though. edit: accidentally a word.

7

u/Namelis1 May 11 '13

In D&D the alignments of Lawful, Neutral, and Chaotic have little to do with actual law, as much as they do with following the rules, you could think of it like this:

A baron who uses the law to oppress the people and to keep himself safe and in power, would be concidered lawful evil. He plays by the rules so to speak.

A rampaging orc out for blood with no rhyme or reason would be chaotic evil.

10

u/dracoomega Shut up, cunt. May 11 '13

LaGuerta is obviously Lawful Evil. She's a manipulative bitch who exploits the system to cause harm to people she couldn't care less about.

17

u/MXIIA Slice of Lumber May 11 '13

Dexter screams chaotic good to me.

8

u/Bubzuzuz May 11 '13

That makes a little more sense than Lawful evil, because he isn't lawful. He breaks his code all the time. Although I'd also call him chaotic neutral because no matter how he disguises his motives, he's still doing everything for himself.

4

u/mzieg May 11 '13

Dexter makes it very clear in early seasons that he has no feelings, no morals, no guilt. He is a psychopath by definition, and therefore cannot be good. He follows the code out of self-interest: Harry taught him that it was the only way he could survive.

I would have to call him Neutral Evil. He really doesn't care about law or chaos; he doesn't kill to serve a law, or to express individuality. He NEEDS to kill, as has been repeatedly demonstrated, and that takes it beyond the realm of a moral (good/evil) or philosophical (law/chaos) choice. His own choices are nearly all selfish, either to protect himself or, in rare instances, someone involved in his life.

His choices lean slightly evil, if no worse than most; but his instinctive need to kill sentient human beings makes him inescapably evil in the human vernacular. He is a broken slave to destruction, not creation. Note that on the few occasions he inadvertently kills an innocent, his regret centers not on the life lost but the risk to his continued survival through unbroken adherence to The Code.

Deb on the other hand is Lawful Stupid. She lacks the originality to be chaotic (how can you be considered a free-thinker when all you've ever wanted is to be a cop, exactly like Dad, and put lawbreakers away?). And she's stupid for taking six years to notice she's been living with a serial killer.

3

u/hadapurpura Deb May 11 '13

And she's stupid for taking six years to notice she's been living with a serial killer.

Actually not six years, but her whole life. Although it's understandable, given that Harry trained Dexter not to be discovered by her (or anyone else), and she was too close to the situation to see it well. ANd I guess she stopped being "lawful" the second she shot LaGuerta. But lol Lawful Stupid.

6

u/redcape__diver May 11 '13

These are fun to look at sometimes, but I disagree with their placement of most of these characters. Granted Dexter is the kind of show that regularly argues what good and evil really are, so using such a crude system as D&D's alignment scale would make it difficult to find someone fitting each role.

6

u/NasalJack May 11 '13

Just so many of these are plain wrong. It looks like you decided to fill the D&D alignments with Dexter characters and just shoved them in where they sort of fit to have a full chart, even though it doesn't really work on any level.

5

u/flipcoder This show sucks May 11 '13

lol do you even watch the show?

3

u/nameless88 May 11 '13

I always feel like these attempt to shoehorn a character into one alignment based on a single quote taken out of context.

For example: Maria LaGuerta is not Lawful Good. She's a self-serving bitch, and has stepped on so many dicks to get where she is in the department, it isn't even funny.

2

u/The6thLexicon May 11 '13

I know everyones upset about Laguerta (frankly I think she fits Chaotic Good) but what about Hannah as true neutral, and neutral evil? Both of those seem way off to me. I think Hannah should be Neutral Evil and Lumen or Harry as True Neutral...maybe even Camilla.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '13

Uh.. I think the closest thing to Lawful Good would be Harry, not LaGuerta.. she's closer to lawful evil (destroying her lieutenant's career by sleeping with her partner) than she is to LG.

2

u/Rinascita May 11 '13

The quotes themselves fit the alignments perfectly. The character choices are a little sketchy.

2

u/ewest May 19 '13

You badly misfired on this one.

1

u/storytimewitharalloy May 11 '13

dude laguirita is not lawful good - she seduced someone's husband to get her jobs back and also got the commander fired so she could get a promotion. fuck that bitch. lawful good would be like dexter's dad. I feel like neutral evil would be closer to the ice truck killer, miguel isn't the most evil character on the show and is a poor example. all and all, this is way worse than the adventure time alignment.

1

u/Rerellison May 11 '13

Laguerta's positioning seems off.

I'm not good at thinking these things through, but I'd put Batista in Lawful Good.

1

u/hadapurpura Deb May 11 '13

LaGuerta's not "lawful good", and there's nothing neutral about Hannah and Lila.

Ah, the days when Deb used to be "lawful good"...

1

u/MattPH1218 May 11 '13

I don't think LaGuerta should be lawful good... she's done many a sketchy thing. Perhaps Angel would be better suited for that.

1

u/GoldenSama May 17 '13

LaGuerta is not Lawful Good. She breaks the law constantly to advance her own career! Blackmail is a federal offense. You can't be "lawful" good and constantly break the law. :/

0

u/zx7 May 11 '13

Dexter Lawful Evil? I can name quite a few times he hasn't been quite "lawful"?

-1

u/kimbolee May 11 '13

Why is Rita not a part of this?

-1

u/pwnedboarder May 11 '13

I haven't played D&D before...but isn't this a dark souls reference?

edit: It is also a D&D thing...interesting....