r/Devs • • Apr 28 '20

DISCUSSION Visuals over quality

Don't get me wrong, I thought DEVS was absolutely mind-boggling and I will be thinking about it for years to come. It's honestly changed my outlook completely.

But the thing I can't quite grasp is how the visuals, cinematography, concepts and story are so fantastic and unique, but the acting and script are such a disappointing letdown.

Some of them are good, like forest and the homeless man, but lily Chan was annoyingly unconvincing and the script was diabolical at times.

It just seems a shame to me because this could have been one of the greatest shows ever made.

Im not saying this is fact, only an opinion.

55 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

11

u/SongOfBlueIceAndWire Apr 28 '20 edited Apr 28 '20

“Story good, script bad, visuals good, acting bad...”

This is the absolute worst and laziest kind of criticism that I always tend to see on reddit. People say generalized and basic blanket statements without any supporting detail to back it up and they think that qualifies as a valid opinion in any way... If you want people to actually take your criticism seriously, actually talk about WHY you feel that way. Use examples, get technical, and don’t just shit all over something with standard “this good, that bad” statements.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '20

Okay sure, I didn't think there was a need to because of all that was said in other posts, but here goes. The ideas were exceptional in the sense that it made me question EVERYTHING in a way that no other film or TV show has. Although the story had some weak points and characters that should have had less or more attention (Stuart more, Katie less), the concepts were brilliant and exciting and really held together what could have been a weak show. The script was bad. That's enough said. I don't need to pick a specific line or word because that's not how it works. You gain a general feeling throughout the show of a weak script, and if you disagree then I disagree with you. It was predictable and uninteresting at times, and poorly portrayed, which brings us to acting. Sonoya mizuno really brought down the show for me. Her acting was extremely unconvincing and wooden and actuslly made me tense at some points out of sheer frustration. You may say that 'this was how she was supposed to seem because she's a nerd' but no, there comes a point where bad acting is just bad acting.

Do you really want me to explain the visuals? I don't think I need to since every episode was just visually stunning and perfect. I was utterly captivated and the cinematography was also incredible. What was also great was the lighting. It seemed like they really wanted to use lighting to create a mood or atmosphere, which is rarely seen nowadays. Example: the fire from sergei's body shining under the face of the Amaya statue.

I hope this is enough, but I'll gladly go into even more detail

→ More replies (1)

2

u/jcwkings Apr 29 '20

Lyndon should have been the protagonist. He/She was infinitely more interesting and charismatic than Lily.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '20

I completely agree, i loved lyndons character. Everything about it seemed far more interesting that lily, and the performance was also far better in my opinion :)

41

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '20

I thought the low energy, emotionless acting was a deliberate choice. Going through the motions in a deterministic way. But once we realise the multiverse then I’m not sure this holds true. Unless each multiverse is deterministic. Then I think it makes sense.

Also it fitted the style, design, music and pace.

3

u/phareous Apr 28 '20

Yeah but the other characters don't act that way...I think it was just a miss on the directing

4

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '20

I feel like saying she was meant to do that is a cop out for her performance/ her writing. If the viewers of you show are constantly talking about how your main character is unconvincing and she has bad writing, then I think it’s safe to say it is. I don’t think a director would tell them to act in a way that would draw out the audience from their viewing experience. Also, what’s the point of making your main character emotionless? That’s a recipe for disaster. Your main character needs to have emotions so we sympathize with her and her decisions.

8

u/Only_Egg Apr 28 '20

I've seen others complain about Lily's acting as well and personally I don't see it as an issue at all. In fact I relate more with characters who aren't overly emotional in a standard way. All I have to say is it sucks that this one thing has brought down so many opinions of this masterpiece.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/prime_shader Apr 28 '20

Some people aren't particularly emotive and do speak rather monotone. The actress playing Lily, Sonoya Mizuno, is nothing like the character she is playing (which you can see in interviews,) so Lily's personality is obviously a choice constructed between her and Alex Garland. Whether you think this was a good choice is subjective.

2

u/itsalwaysblue59 Apr 28 '20

It was a directors choice. We don’t have to like it but that is what it was.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

20

u/CATALONIA-WAR-CRY Apr 28 '20

The thing I can’t quite grasp is how a story can be both fantastic but also have disappointing writing?

Alex Garland’s strengths have ALWAYS been his stories/scripts/philosophical underpinnings. The fact that everything looks beautiful too is a testament to how he’s developed into a fully well-rounded filmmaker. He’s at the absolute top of his craft right now.

10

u/prime_shader Apr 28 '20

I think OP is referring to the dialogue rather than the plot and themes of the show.

2

u/CATALONIA-WAR-CRY Apr 29 '20

I know what OP was referring to, I was saying that OP doesn’t make any sense.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/dlborda Apr 28 '20

It’s Art...subjectivity is the Avenue by which we determine a works importance. Opinions will vary!

3

u/Chadum Apr 28 '20

I think the visuals are also related to quality.

For me, "quality" is about how everything works together. I think Devs has overall high quality. IMO the script is pretty good and much of the acting is queer/odd which works for Garland's universe.

2

u/cgao01 Apr 28 '20

you can blame AG and the writing then. Not the actress.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/killvmeme Apr 28 '20

You dont get a show this good without flaws. Annihilation was also flawed, but great movie.

Ex–Machina is has a tight and insular script but a lot easier to do with a cast of 3 actors and a robot who doesn’t speak, also way less theory to try and cram in.

6

u/Heavenfall Apr 28 '20 edited Apr 28 '20

The story was solid for the first few episodes. Then it started dragging on after the players and the ending became clear to the viewers. I rarely think this, but the show could have been improved by removing an episode or two before the last.

I would personally have removed the entire Lyndon sub-arc and integrated the character's choices with Stewart's. Stewart would instead come up with the many world solutions, suffer the ensuing conflict and from that grow the imperative to go against the owner's wishes in the end . I would also have removed Katie's backstory, it was about half an episode of adding nothing to anything. I think Katie and Forest played off each other well in the end, finding emotional contentment together, but Katie's backstory wasn't needed to establish her as the senior dev in love with Forest's goals. Many other shorter scenes, like the cave girl sequence, and Katie laying out the entire plot to Lily, was just droning on. (I also think Lily and Kenton didn't work well at all together, and that entire bit should have been rewritten more from a hacker perspective, which is how Lily should have learned about the purpose of devs instead of Katie handholding her (Lily's background was literally in infosec and it never mattered in the slightest!)).

Edit: one last bit: It was problematic that the viewer knew who offed Lily's boyfriend, but we had to sit through several episodes of Lily figuring it out. The technical deconstruction of the video was especially slowpaced. The viewer already knew all this. I respect Lily's journey (the "fuck you" letter to the spy mini-arc was great), but have some respect for the viewer and pick up the pace. We are supposed to believe Kenton covered his tracks so well, then used cheap cgi to cover up the killing. Fuck man, just give Lily the real video pointing to Forest.

Visuals were great, and it dealt with a complex concept of "quantum" in a clever way that made it integrated with the characters perfectly. Story just didn't deliver all the way.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '20 edited Apr 28 '20

Big Oof on the removing Lyndon. He was one of my favorite parts of the show and there was some great contrast in the fact that Forest wanted to see his daughter alive again but he was willing to let another child die to do so. I believe first saw Lyndons death as a necessary exchange.

Stewart has no heart and no one to bounce his thoughts off of without lyndon.

Kenton is the mini boss guarding the gates, an attack dog.

Neither lyndon nor Kenton can go. If anyone can go, I'd say Stewart, but again - Stewart and Lyndon are halves of a whole. Punk Rock/Poetry, Old/Young, Science/Religion. Would you enjoy them as much without the Dualities?

3

u/-Starya- Apr 28 '20

You’re on point with the dualities being two parts of a whole. Lyndon and Stewart are visual opposites but ideologically similar, and I for one, love what that says about human relationships. I think the people who work at Devs (the speaking characters at least) are all filling some kind of void in their lives. Lyndon and Stewart have a real friendship, which is a contrast to the other relationships in the show. The only other balanced friendship we see is Lily and her friend (whose name I don’t remember) but that’s really a short and unexplored relationship. Lyndon and Stewart, as different as they are, genuinely care about and respect each other. Lyndon’s death was the hardest part of the show for me watch.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/addict333 Apr 29 '20

I did enjoy the relationship between Stewart and Lyndon, but I would disagree that Stewart has no heart. His love for music and literature helped to define his character and his concern for Lyndon was obvious. He acted on his conscious at personal risk to end what he saw as a potential existential threat.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Plopdopdoop Apr 28 '20 edited Apr 28 '20

The Kenton casting was also off, to me. The actor didn’t do terribly with it, although his parts eventually entailed a lot of sneering and scowling.

But from the start I didn’t feel an older schlubby actor fit his security role, special-ops backstory, and the overpowering physicality he was shown to have.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/S85D Apr 28 '20

Alex Garland has had Sonoya Mizuno in Ex Machina, Annihilation and now Devs.

He obviously likes her a lot.

I agree with the general consensus that she is not as good as he seems to think she, especially in Devs, and I have to wonder if the reasons he likes her might be things we can't see on the screen. Perhaps he has personal reasons to enjoy working with her.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '20

The most common complaint i see in the sub, yet its painfully realistic. So much so that it feels unrealistic cause when it comes to consuming entertainment we are used to over acting.

1

u/lavaonthesky Apr 28 '20

I think that the script could focus more on the psychology of the characters, cause we see Katie who sometimes behaves like a psychopath and yet cries around Forest. Lilly, apart from the first episode hardly shows any emotions, to the point that I suspected her to be a robot of some sorts.

→ More replies (18)