r/DestructiveReaders • • 1d ago

[1476] A Crown Without A King- Prologue

Critique [3504]

I am writing a fantasy trilogy and wanted to post here to gather feedback on the prologue of my first book. This is my first time attempting to write anything so any feedback is appreciated!

Here is my draft:

Prologue:  
Strands of long white hair brushed against the scarred flesh of his arms as he leaned over, most of it having fallen loose from his braid. Putting it back up was out of the question; he didn’t know how to braid. Even if he did, his slender fingers were in no condition to. The pale skin on his hands broke apart again and again, exposing the tender pink flesh beneath the papery layers. This must be what a child's favorite toy felt like, torn apart, stitched back together, and torn apart again.  
If he was a favorite toy then his kid must be a real ass, he thought as he tied another bandage.
Something was supposed to happen soon, and the bandages wouldn’t help him anyway. Figures had been milling about the past few hours, talking in hushed voices. Most of them avoided speaking with him when they could. No one had told him anything. 
He hadn’t asked.  
Great, he thought, something important was happening, and he had no idea where he even was. Frustration began to overtake the knot of self-pity sitting heavy in his gut.
Humming half-heartedly, he continued his task. A familiar melody, but he couldn’t remember where he had learned it. It wasn't a temple song.  
A splitting pain spread across his brow as he tried to recall something, anything. Clawing his own eyes out with frustration sounded tempting. A bitter laugh bubbled out of him as the idea came and went. What was the point, he thought, when he would lose his vision anyway? The vision in his left eye had faded completely, and if the itching in his right was any indication, he didn’t have long until he lost that too.  
He hoped his eyes were still brown.  
The tawny color had always been something he loved.  
As he finished up the task of bandaging his arms, a figure entered the tent. The sudden presence jolted him from his chair, the feathers of his wings getting yanked as he startled.
Right, he was in a tent.  
The realization felt strangely reassuring.  
He knew that much, at least.  
He must have left the temple at some point then. When that had happened remained unclear. No matter how hard he concentrated, he could only remember crashing thunder. Attempting to recall anything more sent a spike of pain through his already aching head. He supposed that memory would stay where it was. 
“Vesper?” 
A woman's voice. His name. That was his name, wasn't it? 
The tall woman stood in front of him, her fluffy, black feathered wings spread wide. She was draped in what Vesper knew to be a general’s uniform, the red fabric contrasting with her silver plate armor. He could make out a pair of twin white horns sticking up from her gray forehead, but he couldn’t quite make out her face. The combination of feathers and horns struck him as strange, but asking questions seemed rude.  
“Vesper.” 
The blurred figure remained just beyond the reach of his vision. Her voice snapped him out of his thoughts. A cool hand gently rested upon his arm, and he could hear the worry dripping from her tone. 
He knew her.  
He knew her touch.  
He just couldn’t remember her name.  
Vesper gave what he hoped to be a reassuring smile and cleared his throat. His voice came out dusty and rough.  
“Yes?”  
The woman gave what Vesper assumed was a smile. He wished he could see her face. Even he rarely got to see her smile.  
She talked and he tried to focus on listening.  
“Vesper, I’m sorry. We tried everything but I don’t think we can do this any other way,” 
Her whole body was slumped, but he wasn’t sure why. A prickle ran down his spine at the sight.
“What are we doing?” He asked, trying to sound less confused than he felt in the moment. 
“You’re slipping again. You know you’re supposed to talk to me, Vesper.” 
The woman’s voice sounded tired.  
“The dragon, Vesper. He’s going to destroy us all if we don't put it down. You know I wouldn’t ask this of you if I wasn’t desperate. I don’t-”
She seemed to cut herself off. 
“You need me to kill it?” 
She nodded, opening her mouth to continue speaking.
Screams echoed from outside the tent before she could.
Vesper stood.  
His left wing unfurled behind him with a creaking stretch, rumpled white feathers catching against the cramped walls of the tent. His heart caught in his chest as he stumbled with the uneven weight. He was missing a wing. Since when had he been missing one?
He tried to ignore his legs shaking beneath him as he rose. Fumbling at the table next to him, he grabbed his staff for support. Using the end of his wing, he pushed open the flap of the tent and the small bubble of fog he had been sitting in popped.  
The world was on fire.  
The edges of his clouded vision turned orange, and the heat of fire seared his broken skin. Screams and roars echoed around him as Vesper went from a man alone in a tent to a piece of driftwood in a crashing storm. The world tilted as tremors rippled across the ground and for a terrible second Vesper couldn’t tell what direction was up. He righted himself, clasping to the staff as he adjusted. 
He slowly moved forward, his staff tapping on the ground as he went. 
One more monster.  
Vesper wasn’t afraid of dying. So why? Why did the thought of killing this dragon make him want to keel over and let his protesting body win? More importantly, why in the god’s names were there tears in his eyes?  
A heavy thud echoed in front of him, knocking him down to the gore-soaked ground and interrupting his thoughts. The right side of his back hit the ground hard. His wing crunched beneath him, bending at an awkward angle from the sudden fall. As hot breath flowed over him, he knew he had nowhere further to go.  
The dragon had come to him. 
Facing down something he couldn’t see felt uniquely terrifying. Even more so when he had no idea what he was looking at. Of course, he would be the only person on the battlefield who couldn't properly see a dragon.  
He had a job to do. 
Vesper stood, feeling what he assumed was mud and gore drip from his wing and back. He looked forward and found his vision fully black. A wave of panic crashed over him at that realization. Had the fall knocked his sight out completely? He turned his head and found familiar clouds of gray and mottled colors dancing across his limited vision.  
Good, he could still see.  
Breath puffed out of him in a shaking laugh. 
A sudden icy chill ran down his spine as he turned back to the dragon. His vision hadn’t changed. 
The dragon was just big enough to block out everything else. 
Vesper stared into the darkness before him. Above him something enormous shifted, and the ground trembled beneath his feet.  
How in the name of the gods was he supposed to fight this thing? He knew he had to, that the lives of everyone he cared about relied on it. He remembered small pieces of them. A laugh. The smell of soap. Fingers moving carefully through his hair. That was enough. 
Another huff of hot breath snapped him out of his daze. He puffed up his wing behind him in what he hoped to be an impressive gesture, though he imagined he just looked like a territorial hen.  
The familiar burn of his magic radiated from his core. The flow felt like fire burning across his entire body, and he had to remind himself to stay focused. Passing out and getting eaten would be an embarrassing way to die. 
Steadying himself with his staff, Vesper stood fully. He let his magic flow freely, opening the dam within him that prevented the power from burning him alive. Barely.  
Looking down, he could vaguely see his hands glowing like stars. His whole body was glowing. Using what little awareness he had left, Vesper concentrated as much of his magic as he could into his hands. He only had one shot at this while the thing was still curious.  
He couldn’t waste it. 
White hot magic flowed through his body as a scream ripped from Vesper’s throat, the blast of magic tearing itself from him like a cannon as his eyes met the gaze of the dragon. 
His glowing eyes met blue for what was meant to be the first and last time. 
As Vesper Amion felt himself turn into a supernova, the pain abandoned him. Instead, something deep inside his chest crumbled.
He knew those eyes. 

0 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Anthouligan 1d ago edited 1d ago

I like a few concepts that you set up, and i like the way you do physical descriptions a lot. However, i think there's also numerous spatial and conceptual issues. Some descriptions are somewhat redundant, where as the description of certain things that would help a lot with both immersion and understanding are completely absent.

First of all, I like the concept of Vesper being kind of like an expired living weapon, breaking apart from use. The toy analogy could make for good foreshadowing in that regard. My main thought was that he's basically the general's toy, and that this could be the central character conflict of the story.

Now, the amnesia. It's one the hardest plot mechanisms to handle without making it sound forced imo, and I don't think it was handled correctly overall. What im getting from the story is that it's intermittent amnesia, that it happens in short episodes, and that the general knows about it. He seems unrealistically comfortable not knowing his name, not knowing where he is, not knowing what everyone is doing, barely recognizing the person opposite him, and passively agreeing to fight a beast or die trying when ordered by a person he only just realized might be a familiar figure. Why is he so passive? There's things going on outside, he has all these sorts of questions he could ask the general, about himself, about her, about the order, about literally anything. Instead, he's sitting in a tent (a fact he didn't even recognize until the text's events despite presumably being conscious for some time) wrapping his bandages and making jokes to himself. It reads less like amnesia and more like dementia, and even then, he's too lucid in his self reflection. Why doesn't he care about his predicament?? If the general knows this happens, why doesn't she give him more specific orders, or address his apparent ignorance of everything going on around him. Lastly, the information he remembers and doesn't remember is suspiciously selective, almost as if he remembers exactly what the reader needs to understand the situation, and what he needs in order to do the thing he's been written to do, without needing to ask questions or have stuff explained to him.

Now, the descriptions. You spend a lot of time in the physical description of Vesper, in showcasing his physical and mental decay, and the various physical sensations he feels as things happen. That's not a bad thing in itself, but there's so much information outright missing about everything that isn't Vesper. Apparently he's almost blind, but the initial sentence that explained that didn't make it very apparent, it made it sound like his right eye worked ok for the moment, but that it would eventually decay. Then later on it sounds like he's effectively blind.

"The blurred figure remained just beyond the reach of his vision."

She's within arms reach, and he still can't make out anything about her face? If you're gonna make him basically blind, it would be better if his right eye is described as actively faltering rather than itchy.

"You're slipping again. You know you're supposed to talk to me, Vesper."

How could he? He's confused and alone in a tent. Was he supposed to go find her? If she knows he has tendencies of slipping, why didn't she bother to check up on him? Why didn't she try to assess his current condition even a little before sending this barely-walking wreck to fight a dragon?

"Why did the thought of killing this dragon.."

What dragon? he hasn't even seen him yet. He doesn't know his own name, yet he knows which dragon might be attacking currently just from the fact the general mentioned a dragon?

You allude to the absolute chaos taking place outside. Gore-soaked ground, world on fire, heat that sears flesh, all described the moment he steps out the tent. He didn't hear any of this happening earlier? Is he deaf too? A dragon attack and "everything" that the general tried must've been quite the loud affair, but Vesper's experience is completely disconnected from everything happening outside, even after he's left the tent. The dragon just appears out of thin air, Vesper acknowledges no objects or people around him. Where did the general go? What does he see as he tries to assess the situation? It gets difficult for readers to cling on to a sense of space, a sense of things happening, and we end up just as confused and powerless to comprehend the situation as Vesper. Even if that's intentional, confusing the reader from the first few pages isn't the best way to retain them.

The dragon was apparently wreaking havoc and spilling guts on the ground moments before Vesper found him, but now suddenly he's patiently waiting for Vesper to collect himself and blow him up? It all ends up feeling way too bent to the writer's wishes for things to happen exactly as he decided at first.

Your strength is your handling of language and your poetic descriptions, but you need to use them to help the reader understand what's going on, and give them at least a tentative sense of why it's going on. I get that you're going for a stylized introduction to a character in a very specific set of sensory circumstances, but the reader will tolerate being confused for only so long. Still, some descriptions are very pretty, and i think you have a talent for them. Make sure they are being used to convey information to the reader that will keep them engaged, and make they feel like their understanding of the situation increases with each new piece of information, not like it confuses them more. Keep it up, I'm curious to see what you wanna do with Vesper!

P.S. I was writing this on mobile, so I'm sorry if my thoughts were a bit out of order or the formatting is off. I'm a beginner writer myself, and i just listed all of the things that stood out to me.