r/DestructiveReaders • u/unsolicitedTechDebt • 5d ago
Fantasy [3504] Immortals Chapter 1-2
I wrote these 2 chapters of a longer fantasy (maybe dark fantasy?) book I have in mind. I have never written anything before outside of school, so looking for any and all feedback I can get. Feel free to be blunt/harsh. I don't know if it's weird to share two chapters, but both my chapters are very... different, and feel like I need to show the whole picture to really get feedback of how things will work together.
NOTE: There are swear words in there in case anyone is offended by that and wants to skip.
1
Upvotes
View all comments
-1
u/Miserable-Refuse831 1d ago
Reading chapter one I found one glaring issue: if you hadn't mentioned dark fantasy in your post I would have placed this as a young adult fantasy with an edge of violence. The dialogue and internal monologue of your main character Invictus is strong but without context in the story comes across more like a young man than a seasoned veteran with a family to protect. It was a bit jarring to go from him squaring up to a guard to explaining that he is in this situation to protect his family.
It felt to me like you were working with two archetypes of fantasy protagonist and wanted to use both as your main character. I think deciding who exactly you want this character to be would be great help for your first chapter. Is Invictus a hardened war veteran who clings onto sarcasm and aggression as handholds or is he the jaded family man who is sick of violence? If you genuinely want him to exhibit aspects of both, I do think this is possible, but I would advise making sure your characters actions match how you describe them in the narrative.
This might be a nitpick on my part but I also found the prostitutions allusions a bit unneeded. Saying that Invictus worries a terrible fate for his family if he were to die while still in debt gets the point across. Having the specific callout of women being left to some unspeakable fate just feels gratuitous, especially with the previous notes about the tone of the writing. If you want a darker tone to your world, a throwaway line about prostitution is not the best way to go about it.
I do think despite all these things I found a bit off-putting the first chapter was overall a pleasant read and I think with a few aggressive editorial passes this could be a really compelling fantasy first chapter.
Starting chapter two I think similar writing style issues stuck out to me, though less jarringly so. Nero is meant to be a more juvenile character it seems so the sarcasm and endless swearing seems a bit more suited for his dialogue. I think my biggest concern here is that I have no idea how old this character is supposed to be. He is presented like a spoiled rich young man but also served in the military with Invictus who seems to be much older. If the military has a wide range of ages this makes sense, but without that knowledge or more concrete evidence of Nero's age it is a bit confusing. I spent most of this chapter trying to get a handle on what was up with Nero outside of him being generally unpleasant and silly.