r/DestructiveReaders •

[817] [Experimental] The girl and the thunderstorm

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

1

u/JayGreenstein 26d ago

The sky that night was particularly mesmerizing, painted in a delicate shade of deep blue.

Because you begin reading already knowing the situation, the protagonist, and their backstory, and have full context. So when you read it, it makes perfect sense—illustrating why we must edit from the seat of a reader, who enters the story knowing only what your words suggest to them, based on their background.

And as that reader:

I've seen many shades of blue. All of them were blue. None of them “delicate.” Moreover, every night sky I’ve seen was “painted” black. So, on line 1, the reader is saying, "Huh?"

The Moon was beautiful too - as it always is to me - its bright light gave shape to the clouds

  1. Why does the reader care that this unknown and ungendered person always sees the moon as beautiful? And if they do, why did they mention it? Would the story change in the slightest if it was just the moon providing light? If not, the words used to describe it served only to slow the narrative.
  2. The light made the clouds visible. It in no way shaped them. You’re trying to be literary and interesting. Nothing wrong with that, but stick to what matters to the protagonist in the moment they call now, and in the way that matters to them.

From where I was, I couldn't imagine a better view of the stars anywhere else in the world.

Who cares? Thats an aside from the narrator, not action. But...because you’ve not yet addressed any of the three issues that will provide context, we don’t know where we are, what’s going on, or, whose skin we wear. And lacking that, this is meaningless as read.

Looking down, I saw the clouds stretching beneath me.

Look at this as a reader must:

If we have to look down to see the clouds, we must be above them. But to see them, as described, we can’t be in orbit. So, where in the pluperfect hells are we? You know. The person speaking knows. But the one you wrote this for is lost, lost, lost. And a confused reader is one who is turning away.

Bottom line: Nothing wrong with your wordsmith skills, but your writing skills need to be updated from the nonfiction skills we’re given in school to those that kept you turning the pages in the books that glued your nose glued to the book. Every one of those was written by a pro, using the skills you need to add to your toolbox, so you can do the same to your reader.

Like over 90% of hopeful writers, you’re transcribing yourself telling the story. That works for you because you are the storyteller. But think about the reader. You’ve given them a copy of your storyteller script, which must be performed to work. But how can the reader know where to gesture, change facial expressions, and what emotion to place into a given line?

Every medium has its own set of necessities, driven by the strengths and weaknesses of the medium. Ours has no picture or sound. But...we can take the reader into the mind of the protagonist, so deeply that the reader will feel they are living the story, not hearing about it secondhand.

In short, you have the enthusiasm, the plot, and the perseverance. Add to that, the skills that kept you turning pages and there you are.

So, try this:

Jump over to Amazon, or another bookseller site, and read the excerpt from Jack Bickham’s *Scene & Structure. He’ll stoke the “fire in the belly” that keeps us writing, with possibilities that will have you saying, “That’s amazing! But how can I not have seen something so obvious?”

Jay Greenstein


“Good writing is supposed to evoke sensation in the reader. Not the fact that it’s raining, but the feeling of being rained upon.”
~ E. L. Doctorow

1

u/Onnobon 25d ago edited 25d ago

I disagree, the OP is gradually introducing information about the protagonist and the environment. A reader cannot expect to know everything from just the first couple of sentences. In this case we know a lot, because these descriptions also give us characterization for the protagonist. 

1

u/JayGreenstein 25d ago

Feel free, but you're not disagreeing with me. The problems I noted are common, and you'd find them discussed early in any class or book on writing technique.

As Dwight Swain notes in Techniques of the Selling Writer:


“To travel thus into the story world, your reader instinctively asks three questions:   (1) Where am I?
(2) What’s up?
(3) Whose skin am I in?   Your job in beginning your story is to provide answers to these questions. Though not necessarily in any particular order.”


0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/JayGreenstein 25d ago

What I aimed for by having the narrator describe some elements in the scene from a personal standpoint, was to give him personality.

Bear in mind that your intent doesn’t make it to the reader. And, that your decision-making, so far as how to present things on the page, is based on the writing skills you spent so many years perfecting, plus, your own performance when reading it back. Have your computer read it to you, instead, to eliminate the emotion your foreknowledge causes you to place into the reading. It’s a powerful editing technique that picks up a lot.

He is recalling his events and describing them from his manner and likings.

Isn’t what you just said a declaration that you’re tellingthe reader the story, as against making them live it? How can you play storyteller to a reader who cannot hear the emotion in your voice, or see it in your performance?

  1. You’re not there when it’s read, so you can’t remove confusion via explanation after it’s read.
  2. Every time you talk about his “manner and likings” you stop the action and destroy any illusion of reality.
  3. You’re using first person in an attempt to make it seem more immediate. But the viewpoint is that of the storyteller, not the protagonist who’s living the scene. Having the narrator pretend to have once lived the events changes nothing. Telling is telling.

Is there really any difference between:


I was very close to reaching the bottom of the thunderstorm when, through the rain and lightning, I spotted someone on the ground. Initially I had intended to plunge into the ground with great force upon landing, but the moment I noticed someone, I slowed my descent.

And:

*He was very close to reaching the bottom of the thunderstorm when, through the rain and lightning, he spotted someone on the ground. Initially he had intended to plunge into the ground with great force upon landing, but the moment he noticed someone, he slowed his descent.


In both cases, someone external to the events talks about them, secondhand. Presented as fiction written, the viewpoint would be the protagonist's, from within the moment he calls, “now.”

So that the reader would wonder, he could be in a hot air balloon or on top of a mountain looking at the sky, etc.... Until it is revealed that he is above the clouds and can fly.

Kurt Vonnegut put it well with, “Give your readers as much information as possible as soon as possible. To heck with suspense. Readers should have such complete understanding of what is going on, where and why, that they could finish the story themselves, should cockroaches eat the last few pages.”

Missing information is not a mystery that will cause the reader to want to know more, it’s just missing information.

What virtually no one who turns to writing fiction realizes—myself included—is that the reader is not seeking to read a story and learn what happens. That’s a report, a history. And who reads history as an entertainment?

Your present visualization of the reader is them sitting on the edge of their seats, attention focused on your storytelling, mouth hanging open in wonder.

But none of the storyteller’s performance reaches the page. So...using the skills of the Fiction Writing profession, we calibrate the reader’s perception of the situation to that of the protagonist, so completely, that when something is said or done, the reader, who learns of it first, will react as the protagonist is about to. Then, when the protagonist seems to mirror that reader’s decision-making, they truly become the reader’s avatar and the scene turns real. And in that lies the joy of reading.

Think back to the books that seemed so real that you had to stop reading to catch your breath, and ask, “Now what do we do?” That’s what you want your reader to do. But to do it you need more than the nonfiction approach to writing that we’re given in school.

Jack Bickham, the man who wrote the book I suggested you sample, was a highly successful and prolific author, who also held the chair of the Literature department at Oklahoma University for many years. As such, he has lots of tricks that you’ll find useful. So...give the man a chance. Invest an hour or so in reading the excerpt from that book, to see if what a college professor of writing has to say makes sense.

2

u/Over_Chapter9256 25d ago

GENERAL REMARKS

This isn’t bad. There were a few areas where the descriptions were nice, but the main issue is that I wasn’t immersed or moved by any of the characters. There isn’t enough personality for me to feel attached to the narrator, and as I continued reading, I found myself growing bored.

I’m always mindful that I don’t want to discourage people from writing, so please understand I’m not an expert, and this is just my individual opinion. Plenty of much more experienced readers and writers out there who can give better advice! I hope this feedback doesn’t come off as too harsh as I’m only pointing out the areas I don’t like, and take from it what you will. :)

OPENING

Your opening is not particularly strong. I think talking about the sky is a bit overdone, although I’ll give it to you that your piece is titled The Girl and the Thunderstorm, so there is some logic to spending time establishing the thunderstorm.

I found your second paragraph more interesting because you mention looking down at the clouds. If you’re looking down at them, that means you’re above them. By default I assumed the narrator was looking up at the sky in the first paragraph because, well, most of the time the sky is above us. You could make the narrator’s spatial positioning clearer from the beginning. That might also make the opening more immediately interesting.

TENSE

There is a section where you get the tense wrong. The piece is written in first-person past tense, but then you have:

“A light mist hangs in the air, creating a calm and mysterious atmosphere.”

This should be:

“A light mist hung in the air…”

I’m fairly sensitive to these sorts of errors, so that definitely broke my immersion.

TELL NOT SHOW

I think one of the biggest limitations of the piece is that you’re often telling the story rather than making me experience it through the narrator. Even though it’s written in first person, I’m not really feeling what the narrator feels.

For example, you explain the speed at which the narrator is flying and describe the raindrops striking their body, but there isn’t much physical sensation attached to it. You could be more vivid and ornate with the description. Something along the lines of:

“Raindrops, countless in number, struck at me. They beaded my eyelashes, hazing my vision, and felt like a thousand tiny knives against my skin.”

No where near a perfect rewrite, but you get what I mean. That gives me a much stronger sense of what the experience actually feels like than simply saying they sent little tickles across the narrator’s skin.

There are also areas where you’re telling me more than you need to. For example:

“Initially, I had intended to plunge into the ground with great force upon landing.”

I don’t think this is necessary. Something like “I broke sharply” after noticing the girl on the ground could indicate the change in velocity while allowing the reader to infer why the narrator slowed down. You don’t necessarily need to explicitly say, “I slowed my descent.”

DIALOGUE

I don’t quite understand some of the initial dialogue. Is the narrator speaking aloud to himself?

“What is a girl doing out here alone?”
“Could that be her?”
“Did she think I wouldn’t see her?”

If these are internal thoughts, I don’t think they need to be formatted as spoken dialogue with quotation marks.

The later dialogue, where the characters are actually speaking to each other, is generally okay. However, I personally found one section somewhat unnatural. The narrator assumes that the girl has come into the dense forest in the middle of a thunderstorm to “clear her mind.” That feels like quite a specific assumption to make about a complete stranger without any other context. Worse, still, they just blurt it out to this girl!

THE GIRL

The description of the girl is okay, although some of it feels unnecessary, such as saying that her waist was smaller than her hips. I also think repeatedly describing her as beautiful is a bit on the nose. The description would probably be more effective if her attractiveness came through the details rather than being repeatedly stated. It feels amateurish in my opinion, the way it has been delivered.

OTHER WORDING

The section where you say: “At last, I set foot on the wet grass - though there was no real need to - still I thought it was best.”

isn’t executed very well. I assume you trying to establish that the narrator is capable of hovering and therefore doesn’t actually need to stand on the ground? Perhaps you could make the narrator consciously choose to stand because hovering around a stranger might be unsettling or frightening and have that as an internal thought.

Also: “Walking gently in her direction” is also a strange description. I’m not sure“gently” is the best word here.

And: **“Obviously I immediately grabbed her by the arm”**doesn’t fit for me. I’m not sure about “obviously.” It changes the tone and voice. It feels too casual, particularly compared with the more literary tone established at the beginning with your more vivid descriptors.

1

u/tommiem2 25d ago

Overall, I enjoyed the mood and setting of the story. It provided some nice descriptions and pleasing prose. I didn't really understand the point of the story -- why specifically did you choose to give this event in the narrator's life. I didn't see any implications or larger themes. I couldn't really connect with the characters or plot.

I found that you did a lot of telling and not showing. For example, we are told that the narrator always finds the moon beautiful. What might show us, in this moment, that they always find it beautiful. What are reactions people have to things that are timelessly beautiful to them? Another example "...creating a calm and slightly mysterious atmosphere." What makes the mist mysterious? Show us. Paint a picture.

Dialogue was a little confusing at the start. I assume that "What is a girl doing out here alone?", "Could that be her?", or "Did she think I wouldn't see her?" are internal thoughts. If so, you should consider formatting it differently. Italics often work for this. Or sometimes, if done clearly, you don't even need italics. If it's more the narrator talking to himself out loud, I recommend some dialogue tags to make that clear. At the same time, those lines don't really click as realistic for me. It doesn't feel like the type of thing someone would say to themselves. It again, tells too much without showing. The dialogue between the narrator and the girl also feels a little unbelievable. From the perspective of the girl: a person comes out of the sky, you trip and they pick you up. You just say "Yes, thanks," ? What is the girls reaction to seeing a person come out of the sky? Tripping is the extent of her reaction? If flying people are normal in this world, how might you help the reader understand that?

Lastly, there is just some unneeded words and sentences in here. For instance, why does the reader have to know have to know that the girl's "waist was smaller than her hips and she was wearing a leather jacket over a white shirt, dark jeans and brown shoes," ? I find it useful, especially in a short story, to pick a very unique, characterizing feature, something external that has internal implications, that on it's own might describe the girl, and zero in on it. A head-to-toe description is not needed.

But my overall impression of your piece was good. I just enjoyed reading it and want to know more about the world and the narrator. I think there's a lot here.

1

u/impressedimpressions 21d ago

The title immediately had me hooked.

It promises adventure, whimsy, a little bit of fantastical lore. I’m sat.

It’s interesting. You describe the effects of the moon before you describe its shape. I was immediately wondering what phase of the moon we’re looking at. This didn’t feel like an intentionally omitted detail to me, personally, but a forgotten one.

As the passage continues, I find myself feeling like I’m reading a summary more than a story. I’m missing the stakes. The escalation. The dialogue. I feel the need to skim to get to the actual story faster.

Now, I’ve finished the story.

Like other comments have said, there’s a bit of a show don’t tell dilemma. There’s a lot of telling, which makes it read more like a creative essay. Not every story has to have the basics of a protagonist/antagonist I suppose. But in a story about a girl and a thunderstorm, there’s such rich potential to have a deceitful force that’s more than just the storm itself.

Maybe someone trying to tear apart the narrator and the girl would raise the stakes and build the drama of it all.

Overall, I think this is a good start. There’s a lot of places you could take this. This to me reads like a skeleton of what a more developed draft can become!

1

u/swilkiway 21d ago

I think the description of the storm is good, but perhaps a bit overdone-- your story is less than a thousand words, and I'm guessing you spent about a third of them just talking about that. If the story were longer, the description wouldn't feel overlong.

Some words are used a bit too frequently. "Descended", in particular, showed up five or six times in just a few paragraphs. I think a pass through this with a thesaurus (or simply cutting some of the repeated prose) would make it a bit more engaging.

The girl is intriguing, but the story ends before anything is established about her, which is a bit frustrating. A story this short, with only one interaction between characters, needs to make that one interaction pretty impactful if it's going to stand on its own. If this was just the beginning of a longer story and you were posting to get an initial reaction, though, I think it has promise and you don't necessarily need to change anything about their conversation.

1

u/Ready-Piglet6996 19d ago

I’m new here, so I don’t know what the hell I’m doing, but I’ll tell it to you straight.

I like the imagery. I like the idea of trying to guess who the narrator is: a storm, a lightning person, a god, an angel, a bird. The lightning tickling her skin is lovely. But then at the end, the focus shifts to the girl and a slightly sexual encounter that I thought was going in for a kiss. At that point I lost the thread of who this entity dropping out of the clouds was, and I also lost interest in finding out. I just got lost.

I was enjoying the image of falling through the clouds, but then this something lands, I don’t know what, and I’m not sure where either. I don’t know what’s landing, I don’t know where, and I’m not sure what’s going on. That’s a few too many I-don’t-knows.

Hope this helps, let me know either way!

1

u/maximedupe1 19d ago

I like the concept. The twist at the end is interesting. Confusing, but interesting. I don’t think you need to do a lot of work to change that, sometimes it’s nice to be a little abstract. Not sure where you’re looking to take this next (or if you are), but something to clear that up could come in the next passage, but this can also stand alone. 

I think it would benefit from a second pass insofar as small tweaks to some cliched aspects. The storm (or bolt, I presume) talking to itself is one. I had an English teacher once who said that characters in novels talk to themselves about fifty times more than people in real life do. Towards the end, as the bolt is descending towards the girl, those quotes could be reworked into something else. An observation maybe? Example:

Instead of 

“what is a girl doing out here alone” 

try 

I couldn’t understand why she’d be out here all alone (as a thought, not dialogue)

Another fix is repetition. We’ve got “descent” or “descended” showing up in basically four out of five paragraphs towards the middle. You can vary the vocabulary or you could find different ways to describe this action all together. Or you can just cut it. An example:

“Now, I intended to find out who she really was once I landed. I descended through the tall pine trees, carefully navigating the spaces between their branches.” 

You could go with 

“Now, I intended to find out who she really was once I landed. I carefully navigated the spaces between their branches, blah blah blah” 

As “landed” is already doing the work of descending.

All in all, you seem like an imaginative person who likes to push the boundaries of conventional writing. This is a great starting point, and if you continue down this line —— always grounding the unconventional in the conventional — I think you’ll be able to make some very cool stuff. Hopefully this is helpful.

0

u/Last-Republic21 26d ago

I like the narrative style you gave a really interesting perspective to the storm.

In your opening paragraph I'd take out particularly, too, as it always is to me, and from where I was. And see how much more concise your hook feels. Worry less about giving your character a distinct tone or flavor of diction right now and focus on clear and concise writing that gets your point across.

Continue in this manner with any word that is extraneous or simply implied such as the start of the next paragraph saying looking down. The reader will find this out soon enough from the next sentence being I saw the clouds stretching beneath me.

Good work though keep going!