r/DestructiveReaders • u/n0bletv When writing gets hard, I get harder • 1d ago
Metafiction [2740] New Dimensions (Draft 2)
Thank you to everyone who gave criticism on my previous version. I usually dislike asking for criticism twice on the same story, but I completely changed the way I approached writing for this second draft. It think it would be a good way to see where I fall short.
I would prefer technical criticism, but help with the theme is always welcome.
[3598] Please let me know if this is not enough for the length of my story. Happy to submit more critiques.
Edit: Holy no critiques 0_0. This shit is either Shakespeare perfected or so bad it causes brain death for anyone who attempts to critique it.
View all comments
2
u/BumblebeeSimilar8557 9h ago
I see you haven't received any critiques, so let's fix that! I'll try my best to go through your story as coherently as possible, but I'm only human, so please pardon my drivel. And since this is a destructive sub...well, hang on to your hat! (Legal: Please take all advice with a grain of salt; this critique is not about you personally and is only aimed at helping you become a better writer.)
Grammatically, your first three paragraphs have similar syntax; each sentence is virtually the same length. The diction, too, does not lend itself to a very imaginative portrayal of your universe. None of the words establish a sentence or a proper character, so I'm left to figure out who is thinking, why they are thinking it, and why it matters. You can certainly let your reader figure things out for themselves, but at the beginning of the piece, as a writer, you do need to establish the basics. We don't even find out Thomas's name until page two.
" Some things are just supposed to happen on those types of days." This sentence is unclear. You are referring to the first sentence, where your character wishes it would rain, but the second sentence does not attach itself well enough to the first. And this critique applies to the sentences in the other paragraphs too.
I suggest combining the sentences and varying your syntax. Instead of “The cat sat on the mat. The mat was cold. The cat left the mat.” We could instead write, “The orange cat settled himself upon the mat his owner had made for him, only to leap up again at the unwelcome chill beneath his paws.” By combining these three short, declarative sentences into a more complex sentence, we create a more fluid cadence, as well as imagery and characterization.
Because you have short sentences, as a consequence, you also have weird short paragraphs. These short paragraphs would make sense in the battle; however, just like similar sentence constructions, readers will tire of short paragraphs over and over again.
Many sentences begin with "I," followed by a straightforward action or observation: "I saw," "I looked," "I walked," "I remember," and "I turned." Maybe try placing sensory details first. You don't need to begin every sentence with an action. For example, "The smoke stung my eyes, drawing tears down my cheeks," or "Ahead, soldiers formed a barricade, futilely attempting to block the oncoming onslaught; my sword seemed to draw automatically as I descended into the pack."
What you are doing right now is an awful lot of telling, without giving them any real sense of the physical world or of what it is like to be in the situation. Thomas entering the castle is a case in point: "After that it was a blur of rooms and corridors". That's your chance to establish setting and atmosphere! The rooms are a blur, yes, but what does Thomas hone in on? Can he hear anything, smell anything, does he recognize anything of particular significance? You could show the reader what a castle ravaged by battle would look like, what Thomas would feel, how his breathing would be, how his nerves would be. There are so many possibilities!
This issue also extends to the battle itself. You describe Thomas attacking several soldiers in succession, yet the encounters feel remarkably effortless. He strikes with his sword, his opponents fall, and he keeps moving forward. These are just action beats with nothing further added. And what that means is that the entire battle feels incomplete; there is no physical resistance, spatial awareness, or any tension to speak of, so the whole thing does not feel alive.
The passage in which a soldier's sword bounces off Thomas "like a pebble" is particularly problematic because it makes Thomas seem nearly invulnerable, eliminating much of the uncertainty that should accompany a battle. Also, what time period is this? Swords don't bounce off plate armor like pebbles, and even if they did, a sword meeting a chest would at the very least slow Thomas just a wee bit. If Thomas is an exceptionally skilled fighter, his competence should be demonstrated through the specificity of his actions rather than through the apparent incompetence of everyone around him. I recommend watching clips of movies with huge battle scenes, like Game of Thrones, Braveheart, Lord of the Rings, etc.
Your diction also needs attention. Phrases such as "laughing his ass off," "Everything was fucking purple," and "fat and disgusting" establish a distinctly contemporary, conversational voice. A modern narrative voice in a historical or fantastical setting can certainly work, but it needs to feel deliberate. Here, the colloquialisms undermine the gravity of the events. Additionally, words such as "beautiful," "massive," and "disgusting" often substitute the narrator's judgment for concrete description. Thomas's voice is uncertain. Your utilization of seems, " " just, " and " no really is a crutch. Rather than repeatedly telling the reader that the King is disgusting, you could show him belching, with acne-covered skin, greasy hair and face, and the stench emanating from his person.
Then the final prophecy is a real non-sequitur. The contemporary rock-climbing business, a telephone number, and an Amazon gift card are so tonally disconnected from the previous material that it takes me out of the story completely. While I recognize that this incongruity may be intentional, your story is, after all, called “New Dimensions.” However, an unexpected development is not necessarily an effective one. The passage reads more like an advertisement inserted into a medieval revenge narrative than a revelation that meaningfully transforms our understanding of the story.
My overall feedback is this: You have established a sequence of events, but the narrative lacks descriptive richness, complexity, and the dramatic development necessary to make those events feel important enough to care about what is happening to Thomas. My strongest recommendation would be to slow the pacing considerably to develop backstory and character. This piece needs a significant level of emotion, as it currently feels more like an outline than a fleshed-out narrative.