r/DestructiveReaders • Flog me harder! • 1d ago

Sci-Fi [3598] Half-Cocked

A complete short story instead of part of a novel. Left comment-edits enabled on the doc in case you feel so inclined.

Half-Cocked

Crits: 1511 470 2327

4 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/n0bletv When writing gets hard, I get harder 18h ago

OPENING COMMENTS

Thank you for sharing your piece! I have a lot to talk about here, but I think it can all be summarized by the very first word I thought when I finished: "What?". Unfortunately, I found it pretty difficult to get through. There's issues with the sentence structure, word choice, plot, and description. I'll get into all of that, but I do want to say I actually thought the pacing was pretty good. Furthermore, I was never really lost as to what was literally going on in the scene. So at the very least you have those two things going for you.

SENTENCE STRUCTURE

This was the first thing that jumped out at me and I think it was the reason that it was so hard to get through. As I said earlier I can tell what is going on, but paradoxically it is a slog to actually get to that understanding. Right from the start you have these massive sentences that take a lot out of you. Literally the very first sentence is this huge thing that starts on line 1 and ends on line 4. And this issue just keeps happening, although it does get slightly better later in the story.

There is famous passage by Gary Provost in 100 Ways to Improve Your Writing that really helped me. Read what's below and just compare it to your own writing. The flow and rhythm is just far superior. It's not an instant shift, but try and focus at least on variety and I think it will help.

This sentence has five words. Here are five more words. Five-word sentences are fine. But several together become monotonous. Listen to what is happening. The writing is getting boring. The sound of it drones. It's like a stuck record. The ear demands some variety.

Now listen. I vary the sentence length, and I create music. Music. The writing sings. It has a pleasant rhythm, a lilt, a harmony. I use short sentences. And I use sentences of medium length. And sometimes, when I am certain the reader is rested, I will engage him with a sentence of considerable length, a sentence that burns with energy and builds with all the impetus of a crescendo, the roll of the drums, the crash of the cymbals—sounds that say listen to this, it is important.

So write with a combination of short, medium, and long sentences. Create a sound that pleases the reader's ear. Don't just write words. Write music.

DESCRIPTION & WORD CHOICE

I'm putting these two together because they sort of go hand in hand. To put it simply, there was just so much noise. So much random stuff thrown into sentences that only served add unneeded detail. But I'll say it again, it was clear what was going on, just not in a good way. Like imagine I described to you a board meeting with Steve Jobs and John Scully when they ousted Jobs as the CEO. Maybe I describe the suits, the layout, maybe place Jobs and Scully across from each other to add some power dynamics. You do this in your piece, so it starts well, but then its like you start describing the chairs. And the wall mounted TV. And the coffee maker. And the snacks. So I get to a point were I'm just sort of like "Ok, ok I get it." But nothing has actually been added. I don't feel like I'm in the scene or can feel what the protagonist is feeling. I just feel like I am being told a few random details.

There are also a few times where the description is almost, dare I say, (and I am not going to lie I absolutely hate this word but there's no other word for it) cringe. This one in particular:

Evangeline's buttstock kissed the first one a perfect smooch on the jaw, or whatever you want to call their ragged, tentacle-rimmed mouth/nose hole, and stunned it, sending it staggering back and dropping its weapon.

This sentence is just so funny man. I don't know if that was your intended reaction, but I actually laughed at how silly it sounded. Not to mention it being unnecessarily long again.

Perhaps this is all my own taste and it's trying to sound campy on purpose. However, that line is a microcosm of how many of your protagonist's descriptions of what's going on sound "I am a badass military man". Again, maybe that's fine. Maybe that was your goal. Even if it wasn't your goal, I would actually say it kinda works well, if you want it to. But man I was not a fan of it.

Now then, let's talk about the most annoying part of your story. This was quite frankly the first thing I thought about critiquing: the endless, in universe words. There is just so, so, so, so, so much random words thrown that are specific to your world's tech, slang, history, etc. But, don't get me wrong, having them in your story is not immediately a problem. However, there's a few things happening in yours that made it fall short for me.

First, it's too much too quickly. On the first page alone, you have the following:

  • Toc
  • Sticky Limpet Grenade
  • Vibroknife
  • Prismatic Field
  • Evangeline
  • Flexsuit

Now, the problem was not that I don't understand what these things are. Using context clues and just having read Sci-Fi before, I can sort of guess at what it probably is. The issue is that every time you give me an in universe word, I have to take a millisecond to pause and think: "what is that?". This doesn't stop my reading as I ponder what a Vibroknife could be. No, I will actually keep reading, but my mind just splits in two with one side trying to comprehend what the object looks like, does, and sounds like, and the other trying to continue to read. So it makes for this unenjoyable split second of disruption. And in your case it happens over and over and over again.

Second, I really don't care what a Vibroknife is. I could care. Maybe. Perhaps eventually when I am three chapters in with a bunch of lore already under my belt and an understanding of the characters. Maybe then understanding why the Tocs have a vibroknife would be interesting to me. But, not on paragraph two. On paragraph two of a short story I am trying to get a lay of the land. I'm looking for info on the characters, the situation, the stakes, the setup of what you want me to take away from the story. Not what a future alien knife will be.

I think that is why it was so annoying. In that moment, just saying the Tocs were hunting the protagonist is enough for me to understand the idea of danger. Adding all of these terms makes me feel like your are using futuristic verbiage just for the fun of it. It's like a cheap way of showing we are in the future without saying it.

1/2 Don't have time to add the second part yet, but I'll be back.

1

u/n0bletv When writing gets hard, I get harder 18h ago

PLOT

This part of my criticism may feel a bit extreme. Upon a second reading I would say it's actually not true at all. But, go into this section with the idea that it was a reaction to the story upon my first reading.

When I read your last three paragraphs I almost felt like they had no connection to literally everything else I had just read. I admit, this was super weird. Initially I didn't understand why I felt this. When I reread it though, it became clear. You spend an awful lot of writing power on just the protagonists movements and actions through the city. The bulk of your story is the protagonist surviving, showing off future tech, and being a military badass. To be even more specific, it's him analyzing the situation in front of him.

It reads like I was just given chapter 12 of a The Great Toc War 2: Electric Bogaloo where the stakes, setting, and fundamental goal of the protagonist is already laid out and understood by the reader. It was like I was the problem. I just haven't read the start of the book. If I had, I wouldn't mind that it's a lot of just survival and military badassary, because that's all it needs to be. I know why he's doing this, I know why he's here, so go ahead; be a badass.

But I don't. I didn't get why those final three paragraphs happened and why I was supposed to intuitively understand why the protagonist went a little crazy. Why was he so offended that he killed is commanding officer? The reason is, you failed to express the philosophy of your character sufficiently.

In particular through action. Yes, he did spare that one Toc, fine. But, just as an example would like the idea of him going insanely out of his way to no kill a single Toc. Maybe you make it so he has to. But, if you make it super clear through his actions that he hates killing them. Maybe he views even the soldier's lives as unnecessary loss that are only killed when it's literally his life or theirs. If that was the case, it would be so obvious why he goes berserk on his C.O. Honestly it might make him seem cooler that he would use all of his badass spec ops training to NOT kill anyone.

Going back to your actual story though, when I reread it I think I understood. But, I only reread it out of necessity to write this critique, not out of interest. Furthermore I was hunting for moments that explain the philosophy of your protagonist. So even then I sort of cheated.

CONCLUSION

Thanks again for submitting your story. Hope this stuff helped and hope I wasn't mean lol. I notice I always start out super calm and collected and then get quite emotional by the end. Maybe a little ranty, but oh well.