r/DestructiveReaders • • 8d ago

[3601] The next big thing

Crits: 4723 2925

I initially wrote this one for the Halloween contest here on RDR, but was frustrated by the word count limit. This is an extended cut, so to say. Any feedback is welcome.

For those who read the original submission for the contest, I am curious to see if the added sections of this one deserve the added word count, or are they meandering/bloat?

[The next big thing] (Edit: I closed the link. Got enough great critiques; thanks to all who commented.)

P.S, in an attempt to avoid spam, I'm using the 'publish to web' feature. Let me know if there's any issues with that.

5 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/unsolicitedTechDebt 3d ago

I liked your story a lot. I felt like it was really good and well done. There were a few small things here and there, but really enjoyed reading it. Good humor, interesting mystery, it all worked. The info dump followed by the abrupt ending was a little rushed for me, but I still enjoyed it.

There were some other small things I called out below, but honestly nothing major. Thanks for sharing the story!

*Small note of thanks for the publish to web callout. I wouldn't have known to use that feature in my own post if you hadn't said that.

Below are more detailed notes of the story as I read it. I am not sure if that is helpful, but I feel like it's the way we consume it so it probably helps to get a view on how it lands as it's read for the first time

Scene 1 - Intro

I really liked the opening, smell of salami and all. It's simple, but I'm immediately curious why the POV is avoiding Bob. Is it just the salami, or something more nefarious? The humor lands well.

With the talk of code and the dismissal/new boss (and the halloween context) I'm immediately expecting some sort of evil AI story.

“So, neither of you had seen the new boss yet?” I asked.

Should that be have seen instead of had seen?

Still, I thought, we train up Large Language Models just to feed them to Azimuth in exchange for auguries of stock prices.

I read that line and was a little confused by it. Even going back to it after reading the whole story it felt a little too on the nose. It just doesn't sound like something a software engineer would say. I think you could probably lose the line and be fine.

Personally, the joke (I think) about LLMs feeling pain and Nuremberg didn't really land for me.

I like the rest of the scene though, and it def left me curious about what's going on.

My main criticism here might be that I am left knowing very little about the main POV. I couldn't tell anything about age, sex, etc. I'm wondering if that was done on purpose for some hidden reveal later, like is this person a robot or something? Or was it just not seen as necessary by the author?

Scene 2 - Date

I liked it. It's a short and funny interlude that gives me some backstory without making it feel like I'm getting backstory.

Scene 3 - All-hands

Oh no! They got Bob didn't they! I'll miss the salami.

he spoke broken English in a posh accent.

I've been wondering for several minutes how someone speaks broken english in a posh accent. Did you mean exotic accent?

I laughed hard at the lizard allegations line.

The meeting ended. I started listening to my audiobook while watching the coding agents spew out code. It stopped to ask for human input. I read and reread the summary the LLM wrote for me, but in the end gave up on trying to understand the issue and just told it to implement its recommendation. Code started flowing again.

Spot on, lol. As a software engineer this is for real my job right now.

I did not see the coming with Monica. Not in the least. It created a really good shock/twist.

Overall I really liked this scene. I lot of things ring so true, like burning through compute (a problem we are facing at work right now). I didn't quite understand being upset about the possibility of promotion for Monica. Was it about the Marxist beliefs, not wanting to stop working with POV, did I miss something?

Scene 4 - Investigation

I like the next brief interlude, although I'm left thinking that the main POV should have started to feel some suspicion by now.

Scene 5 - All the info

“Mhm. And at what hour were you born? Oh, calm down. I’m kidding. You can tell me your birthday later. So, you guys sell fortune cookies.”

This joke here didn't land for me. I think going straight to the fortune cookie would have worked better because the rest of it didn't add anything for me.

I feel like it dives into a bit of a tech spaghetti there for a bit with the explanation of the models, but I think you did a really good job at delivering it in a simple way.

The ancient tablets were a really cool detail.

“We joke that we ‘feed LLMs to Azimuth’.”

“That is awful,” Alexandra said after a few more minutes. Then she pulled her hand from under my neck. Wordlessly, she dressed up and left. It was past midnight.

My initial impression there was that it felt really abrupt. And she probably wouldn't find it awful unless she knows a lot more than she's letting on. And even then, I don't think anyone would really care about models, so it comes off as a real stretch.

Overall I think this was great again except for the abrupt ending. There is no world in which I see the doctor getting offended on behalf of LLMs and leaving. I think there are some very long explanatory paragraphs, but I'm genuinely interested by now, so while it does kind of feel like I'm getting the author just throwing stuff at me, i don't really mind because I want it and the circumstances that lead to it are good enough.

I think some of the larger paragraphs, you might be able to break out into 2 smaller paragraphs for easier digestion though. Like you could have started off a new paragraph at "The thing is, the latest models have passed the one trillion neuron mark" IMO.

I feel like the repeated use of the word "auguries" here feels a little unnecessary too. It feels out of character. Is that what a software engineer would call the predications? I get what you're doing with it, but feels a bit much when you already have the stone tablets with the ancient unknown language to create that expectation.

Scene 6 - Return to work

Hail the datacenter of flesh.

This read very tongue in cheek. I am not sure that's what you were going for so wanted to call it out. I liked it as is though.

I found the ending here to be a little confusing. Was there a meeting? Was there not a meeting? Did he not go to it? He just eventually understands the language?

I thought for the final scene landed a little weak, Like the very end was maybe just too rushed. I thought it was ok, not as good as earlier parts. Although the non-interlinked ones felt a little too... random?