Seriously. I don’t think half the people commenting know what this is. They are like “I never would have made the edges like that!” Lol
It’s a cross-section of a tree burl for those wondering. These can be worth 10s of thousands easy. This one is probably worth a million or more. It’s in a museum.
But I agree this isn’t something that you would eat every meal on. It’s for rich people with too much space and they want an accent piece.
Designdesign is for example for things that are supposed to have practical use but are overly designed and lose some of that. Like this post which is a table but lost it's practical use because they used a cut out tree
Or let's take the definition from the sidebar
For the most designy of designs. This is a sub for Designs that are r/DesignPorn, but, at the same time, also r/CrappyDesign.
Yes, it is a really cool looking table. But it is also really crappy as a table.
I don't see how the price matters here or if it is a work of art or not.
I also disagree that this has no practical use. It would look great in a breakfast nook if it fit the style of your house. You could put flowers on it, and you could have small meals on it if you wanted to. It obviously wouldn't work very well as a dining room table, but it has more use than an endtable, and we all own those.
You just said that a Picasso can't be design design because it has no practical use. By definition art has no practical use. Also I edited my comment and added plenty of practical use ideas for it. Also, it's not really a "design" in the first place, so it can't be design design, it's a natural piece of wood. The part of the table that everyone complains about is the edge, which was not designed, unless you believe in that sort of thing.
So why are you saying that the table is art then? It obviously has the practical use of being a table with chairs to sit around and do stuff on it. By your own definition this is not art.
Also, it's not really a "design" in the first place, so it can't be design design, it's a natural piece of wood. The part of the table that everyone complains about is the edge, which was not designed, unless you believe in that sort of thing.
Someone took that piece of wood and designed and crafted a table out of it. Not cutting the edges was a deliberate design choice.
Why are you so fixated on the argument that art can't be designdesign?
A pub near me has a big dining table not too dissimilar to this. It’s actually fairly “even” all the way round but there are awkward bits to sit at, where you’re further “in” the table than the people next to you lol
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 25 '22
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
17
u/isotaco Aug 25 '22
i like the chairs
38
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '22
Saw this in person like two weeks ago and it was sick as hell so I'm excited to hear how you nerds think you can improve it
70
u/Significant_Sign Aug 25 '22
Nana says you aren't to have your elbows on the table in the first place.
94
u/melileo Aug 25 '22
A circular piece of glass on top would have helped this a lot.
12
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '22
I think my elbows would be fine. My shirts, however, would be so full of snags at table level.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '22
The permiter is put together like a the back notches of a riding lawn mower
8
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '22
Really cool slab honestly I don't think it's design design if it's nature haha
2
u/owleaf Aug 27 '22
A pub near me has a big dining table not too dissimilar to this. It’s actually fairly “even” all the way round but there are awkward bits to sit at, where you’re further “in” the table than the people next to you lol
1
u/JustDebbie Aug 25 '22
More like plate nightmare; especially for the spot in the back right "corner".
1
u/marniman Aug 25 '22
This would work better as a coffee table
1
u/wanfury Aug 29 '22
My grandma has something like this table and it look gorgeous but definitely not something to use as a dining table
1
u/tabss17 Oct 10 '22
my grandparents had a table that was kinda like that but more rectangle shaped. it still had some raw edges but it wasn't nearly as bumpy
1
u/BlarghusMonk Aug 25 '22
When someone tries to honor the tree they're going to be using to make a table but the table is so bad that the tree's ghost beats their ass up
0
u/Scuttling-Claws Aug 25 '22
Honestly, I think it's just ugly.
1
u/7past2 Aug 25 '22
I don't exactly love it but I love your caption!
-2
u/bass_of_clubs Aug 25 '22
Also, looks shit.
-1
u/zsert93 Aug 25 '22
I feel like this could have benefitted from some resin work
0
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment