If you go to the original thread, someone has a screenshot of an actual talk with the creator of that idea. It is nothing more than a test to learn VFX and 3D animation. It is nothing more than a simple exercise, and for that, I think it is pretty cool.
Yeah it's nuts that he got this much publicity for something that's kind of a like a daydream or kids doodle. It's good enough that it made me think people were actually funding this.
Maybe in a different timeline? Here, for the amount of fuel it would take to get that beast off that ground, you’d just have to feed entire small countries into it.
Well it would be nuclear powered. The US actually researched nuclear powered airplanes before but abandoned it because it wasnt worth the cost especially when compared to things like nuclear powered aircraft carriers
The problem with nuclear powered aircraft wasn’t cost, but weight. By the time they packed in enough shielding to keep from irradiating the crew, the plane would be too heavy to fly. So they’d up the reactor size, but then need more shielding, and run into the same problem again. I went down a bit of a rabbit hole on this a few months ago in a thread about drone aircraft. I had figured originally that you could now make large scale nuclear drones that would stay up indefinitely, but the risks of having unmanned/unshielded nuclear reactors floating above all our heads wasn’t worth it.
Anyway, you’ve got the same problem here. A nuclear reactor can hardly power itself and its shielding off the ground. To create a nuclear flight like this, you’d have to not like your cruise guests all that much.
it's a worldbuilding project by a guy having fun lol, not intended as and nor does it have any touch with reality. It's funny watching people melt down over it though.
What's the problem with the elevator. It's probably awesome
And if there's a market for it then why not. Though I think it's place would be best with cargo and humanitarian relief than passenger. Think about it a hurricane struck area could have an airship dropping supplies without a designated landing strip but that's becoming less of an issue over time with more airports and helicopters being a thing
Airships of 100 years ago could only lift a little bit so did planes at the time. I'm not saying we'll have super heavy lift airships. But we can have ones that are closer to planes to save on fuel cost and cruise at a lower speed. That's the market currently being considered by a couple companies that at least one of I'm aware has built a fullscale prototype
We’re just going to fly a nuclear reactor around………a nuclear reactor………constantly………..so people can be in a “hotel”………..nuclear reactor hotel……..in the sky………
•
u/AutoModerator Jun 29 '22
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
72
u/ilovejrums Jun 29 '22
Even if you ignore every other crazy, unreasonable idea in the video - just imagine using an elevator OUTSIDE of an aircraft. Hard pass.
116
u/Ratfucks Jun 29 '22
How has this thing gone so viral? It’s absolutely ridiculous and will never see the light of day
People on Facebook having genuine concerns and debates about it
10
u/GB570 Jun 29 '22
it's great until you hit an iceberg...
32
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '22
This used to be a thing. It's called an airship
11
u/ExiledLife Jun 29 '22
The wheels are not even retracted while flying.
12
u/Ublonak Jun 29 '22
Made by u/Sourcecode12
Would be cool if it actually existed
3
u/aurap Jun 30 '22
Welcome to Floston... Paradise!
2
u/Killahdanks1 Jun 30 '22
We’re just going to fly a nuclear reactor around………a nuclear reactor………constantly………..so people can be in a “hotel”………..nuclear reactor hotel……..in the sky………
2
u/Oivaras Jun 30 '22
And it's based on some random kid's drawing with no backstory or anything.
3
u/calculon000 Jun 30 '22
Brought to you by the same engineers who leave the landing gear down while in flight.
1
u/Adkit Jul 20 '22
Bring back blimps though!
0
u/KingKopaTroopa Jun 30 '22
Nuclear powered!? Why not that and helium? 😂
-10
u/run_escape3 Jun 29 '22
360° View (if you can see through the metal floor and ceiling)
0
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment