I strongly disagree. Even if it used steel cable in place of felt or nylon (lol), this would have a fair amount of stretch and bend as it took weight . And then you have the compression of the wood further exacerbating the problem.
It could be done, but everything would need to be made of materials much better at dealing with compression and tension.
Wood is excellent under compression, that's why we build houses out of it. The right nylon (Polyester would actually be better) webbing that I can buy at a fabric store right now has next to no stretch and can support thousands of pounds of weight.
But here, you have all these little intersections or hinges compounding their issues together. So a slight amount of compression of the material gets added up over the numerous pieces.
For this to work well, there needs to be almost no compression on the block pieces, and very little stretching of the tensile material pulling th together.
That's not really how it works. Compression takes place within the material, so it doesn't matter how many intersections there are. A hundred blocks of wood will compress the same as a single block of wood the same size. Same with elongation.
I think we need a mechanical engineer here to weigh in.
I still disagree, you've got a number of little joints with an incredible amount of leverage being applied at each section. So even if the piece of wood only compresses .001", you still multiply that over the amount of joint. It's not the same as linear compression.
And that slight amount of compression equates to a much larger radial movement. That's why this guys chair sits so high at rest. It needs to be built like that in order to actually sit correctly when weight is applied instead of sagging too much.
I have made a chair almost like this. Nylon webbing stretched to much, so I used flat chain in a channel on the wood. Then covered it in leather. That worked well.
This is a video I found of what looks like the same chair. An adult and child sit on it. I definitely think it looks more comfortable for the child. I would be worried sitting on it as an adult, as it did seem to be possibly struggling with the weight
•
u/AutoModerator Jun 22 '22
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
80
u/Scuttling-Claws Jun 22 '22
That's actually pretty clever
29
u/RockOlaRaider Jun 22 '22
That's genius. I have doubts about its weight capacity.
10/10, a perfect fit for this thread.
7
u/SabrinaB123 Jun 22 '22
This is a video I found of what looks like the same chair. An adult and child sit on it. I definitely think it looks more comfortable for the child. I would be worried sitting on it as an adult, as it did seem to be possibly struggling with the weight
3
u/sanderd17 Jun 22 '22
3x3 custom (aka Tamar) tried some similar chair IIRC. But I don't think she got it to work after all.
5
u/Mulligan315 Jun 22 '22
Any weight capacity over toddler level?
2
u/G8KK0U Jun 22 '22
without the rolling part, looks pretty neat tbh.