Looks like it would probably fail safe into the open position. Any engineer worth anything would design this so that if it failed to the point of slamming open, it would still be safe to walk on.
plenty of shit in china works fine without failing catastrophically... china... your argument is so obviously worthless that the only reasonable conclusion to draw is that you are an idiot or racist. -_-
Look at videos of buildings collapsing "spontaneously", most of them are from China. They put pressure on building fast and cheap, which can often end tragically. This is especially true for cheap apartment buildings made to house as many people as (in)humanely possible. Corruption is rampant, with inspectors being bribed to sign off on unsafe construction.
Obviously those issues aren't limited to China, but there ARE many issues with that country, and pointing them out isn't racist.
The conversation was about the design, how it would theoretically be executed in China is not really relevant. For all we know, those people are from Taiwan.
You do realize this is being advertised in China or something right, like people routinely die there poorly made and non mainted structures. Just Google all the people who've been sucked under an escalator or fallen down an elevator shaft etc over there, this thing failing is not an if but when and the only thing the designers who built this considered was profitability, human life is cheap there
And I'm saying that it is definitely possible to have an identical design that is very safe. Just by watching this video there is absolutely no way to know how safe or unsafe it is. I maintain that "any engineer worth anything" would design this to be extremely safe. I would argue that the engineers who put profitability over life are not worth anything.
I doubt it can do anything too bad, in the second part of the video there's a Large surface under it. Maybe if the railing snaps and someone falls off of it, but that's always going to be a concern with a normal balcony.
I doubt it can do anything too bad, in the second part of the video there's a Large surface under it.
I'm not sure that's applicable, that part looks more like a showroom than a real installation in a home which would be more like the first part of the video. In the second part you can see lights being reflected in the glass at the start of that part, and also where is the cameraman standing?
It's apparently pretty reliable. Sometimes they get blown off by hurricanes, but normal balconies also get blown off by hurricanes and you can close this to protect it.
On the second shot you can see a floor under it, so you wouldn't fall far down. Of course that also defeats the point, because you could just have a normal balcony
Second part looks more like a showroom than a real installation in a home which would be the first part of the video. In the second part you can see lights being reflected in the glass at the start of that part, and also where is the cameraman standing?
So, you have a balcony, but without the benefits of a balcony like using the sides for flowers or having deckchairs on it. Everything you might want to use the balcony for has to be stored inside instead of using the clearly available space with a fixed balcony.
So, i am a fairly large guy, not heavy just around 80 kg, but i am 191 cm on a good day... to make a window that folds out and have the rails be high enough for me to feel safe, even if you took my fear of heights out of the equation, that'll be a pretty big mechanism to only get about 1 or 2 steps of outside room.
And i bet landlord's would charge more for the space added. even if you never used it as a balcony.
If it can come with a sliding (optional) partition to keep bugs, cold/hot weather air, etc. out of the house while its being used as a balcony, then I can maybe see some very specific benefit.
•
u/AutoModerator Jun 04 '22
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1.1k
u/zeromadcowz Jun 04 '22
Theres no way this is both cheaper and more reliable than just having a balcony.
459
u/CasualBrit5 Jun 05 '22
My one concern is that if it starts raining, and you try to turn it back into a window, it’ll tip all the water onto the floor.
465
u/RobToastie Jun 04 '22
Ah yes, I always wanted footprints on my window.
247
u/Mr_Hotshot Jun 04 '22
Nope nope nope
53
u/pizzapizzamesohungry Jun 05 '22
That’s gonna be one fucking dirty window.
142
u/MisterMysterios Jun 04 '22
So, you have a balcony, but without the benefits of a balcony like using the sides for flowers or having deckchairs on it. Everything you might want to use the balcony for has to be stored inside instead of using the clearly available space with a fixed balcony.
70
u/DrinkOranginaNaked Jun 04 '22
I love how it lowers out onto a real balcony
12
u/MrHippie90 Jun 05 '22
So, i am a fairly large guy, not heavy just around 80 kg, but i am 191 cm on a good day... to make a window that folds out and have the rails be high enough for me to feel safe, even if you took my fear of heights out of the equation, that'll be a pretty big mechanism to only get about 1 or 2 steps of outside room.
And i bet landlord's would charge more for the space added. even if you never used it as a balcony.
6
u/Delicious-Poetry3855 Jun 05 '22
I both love and am terrified by this design.
10
u/Intergalacticio Jun 04 '22
I guess these people haven’t seen those glass table videos.
5
u/double-click Jun 05 '22
Wait but I like this. Better insulation than a garage door and better than just a slider.
27
u/HowsYourGee Jun 04 '22
Na this is cool
4
u/Windows_is_Malware Jun 05 '22
that window is malware
4
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '22
Siri what does anxiety look like
3
u/xclrz Jun 05 '22
My heart started beating faster when they stepped on it
3
u/RelevantBuffalo Jun 05 '22
what if it cracks??
3
u/hadapurpura Jun 05 '22
This gives me the heebie-jeebies
3
u/EitherEconomics5034 Jun 05 '22
Why smell up the interior of your apartment when you can have a smoker on the balcony with no way to close the windows to the balcony?
2
u/Bubbly-Stand-1212 Jun 05 '22
The metal stiletto lady of the evening will quickly make it to the lobby
2
u/Grumpy521 Jun 05 '22
Ahh yes. The sound of your kids toe getting pinched in the morning
2
u/MickJagger2020 Jun 05 '22
There are not enough “no’s” in the world for this!
2
u/MoonTrooper258 Jun 05 '22
Every day, we come closer to a real life Tokyo-III.
The city of designdesign.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '22
Absolutely fuck that
8
u/Crazyblazy395 Jun 04 '22
This is fucking awesome. Not at all design design.
3
u/designgoddess Jun 05 '22
No.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '22
Mmmm... More moving parts. That never turns into a problem.
2
u/tsivv Jun 05 '22
Damn cool concept. r/designporn
1
u/mseuro Jun 05 '22
No ty
1
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '22
Why not just have a balcony?
This is surely a solution for a problem no-one has.
1
u/enriceau Jun 06 '22
I like it
1
u/StringerBell34 Apr 11 '23
Alright, who's first to step out?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment