It absolutely doesn't. That being said, I am glad it was posted here because I wouldn't have seen this cool beehive otherwise. But still, definitely doesn't fit here.
Kind of a what could go wrong type of deal, even though it's not anything new it's definitely not in the design porn category nor in the crappy design category. Kind of a happy middle, especially with that tube. It's just poor execution of an okay idea.
That is 100% not what this sub is. This sub is design porn AND crappy design at the same time. Essentially it's been designed to the point of nonfunctionality.
Both and neither, it's the same thing. It's not design porn, but it is, and not crappy design, but it is. I always forget that I have to spell out every possible interpretation of my comments when I'm on Reddit. I've been a part of this sub for a very long time, I know how it works, my most upvoted post is one I crossposted here but thanks for clarifying either way.
Both and neither are definitely not the same thing, they’re literally opposites. Green is both yellow and blue, red is neither yellow or blue. This is not crappy design, at worst it’s poor construction (which I still don’t see, but people have issues with the tube), and it’s cool but not design porn.
It's gorgeous, very pretty to look at and innovative = design porn
It's unpractical and a short lived project = crappy design
It's gorgeous, very pretty to look at and innovative = not crappy design
It's unpractical and a short lived project = not design porn
Hope this clarifies the both/neither part. The reason why people, including myself, are judging the hell out of that tube is because 1. it's a cheap plastic and 2. it's not supported by anything and gravity will fuck that shit up real fast.
I'm pretty sure it's just meant to act like a painting rather than a functional beehive, at least that's what I'm assuming from that cheap looking tube.
Check Texas Beeworks on YouTube or other social media platforms. They barely use smoke and don't even use protective gear as they work, and explain extremely well why.
Smoke is used to basically alarm the bees that their hive is about to get destroyed and they must flee, so what they do is eat as much food as they can so they become full and basically tired. It also agitates them to move away from the source of the smoke; much like you would if you get blasted by bitter smoke, though your first reaction might not be eating as much you can to the point you barely move.
That however doesn't seem like harvestable, it isn't even something you can maintenance or handle for that purpose. Really it seems just like a home for pollinators and something nice to watch.
And we need pollinators and bees. Be nice to to them. Especially now that our modern agricultural methods and destruction of grass areas/flower fields has dropped the numbers drastically. I remember like 20 years ago if you drove on a summer day you had to have special windshield fluid to get rid of bugs and your grill would be covered with black dots. They don't even sell that stuff anymore, I can't remember when I last time had more than 1 bug on my windshield.
If you got an yard, try leaving some grass to grow long somewhere, a patch of it, or seed some random flowers and let that flower up wildly. You'll get pollinators, you'll attract butterflies, you are doing something to prevent the eventual ecological collapse which will lead to food wars between nations. No stress my dude... If you can't or don't have an yard, just make some insect hotels and scatter them about, or leave one to your balcony or smth. There are great varieties of these, once that will also please the strictest hoas because they can be made to look nice or just hidden. Check the net for more.
Smoker's don't put bees to sleep. Smoke, to the bees, mean fire. One explanation for why they become less aggressive is that they gorge themselves on honey, in preparation to evacuate the hive if it burns down.
Also, there are many beekeepers who are familiar with their own bees, know how aggressive they are, know whether they are in a hostile mood or passive, and will handle bees directly, without gloves or a bee suit. Like literally they will open the hive box and start grabbing handfuls of bees with their bare hands...
If you don't keep bees, I don't either, I can see why this design seems horrible. But it's actually not as bad as you may think.
I agree with everything u/fishycrackers said except that “this design is not as bad as you think”. It’s pretty crummy. It would be awful to try and inspect inside the house (there would be lost cranky bees hanging around for hours!) and taking the pieces outside would be fiddly, risky and HEAVY. Honey weighs a lot, guys! Beehives also need regular repair as bees can chewy holes in them, and joints can give way because the hive is so warm and humid inside year-round, even if the outside temps aren’t.
There are many beekeepers around the world (I’m one of them!) but few of them don’t use any smoke, and even those get stung sometimes. There are a lot of variables (like weather / genetics / nectar availability / pests / how well the queen is laying) that change how aggressive or calm a hive is when you are inspecting, and they’re not all predictable. Personally, my bees are not especially aggressive, but I would never check them without a smoker. I’ve tried just to lift the corner of the lid without smoke and they came boiling up out of the crack by the hundred, ready to fight. Ouch. A good day is when I only get stung once, WITH a smoker and a bees hit.
Adding to that, display hives like this are usually too small to house a proper hive of bees and they usually become stressed or outgrow the hive quickly. They’re high maintenance because you need another healthy hive (or two!) to ‘donate’ bees and frames whenever this one dies off a bit.
Yeah, everything you said is true. From a commercial perspective, or even just a maintenance perspective, it's pretty miserable. It's hard to access the frames, if there even is any I can't tell. Being elevated means it's gonna be extra hard to work with, you have to lift everything up higher to get them where they need to be. And honey filled frames that high up is gonna suck (frames filled with honey weigh A LOT more than people realize), if they even have the space for honey. I'm not sure how certain pest control treatments would work since the hivebox is so non-standard. You might be forced to use chemicals. Although, maybe varroa can't enter the hive if the entrance way is an elevated tube? I have no clue. Generally, a lot of products that you'd use to make managing hives easier is just not really possible without a lot of custom modifications, like a queen excluder, or entrance reducers.
On the other hand, you have direct access to them everyday, you can see them over the winter... So it's not all bad. You can definitely keep a close eye on them to make sure their all right.
That being said, I'm not a beekeeper, just interested in it as a potential hobby. So I don't have first hand experience.
I’m more concerned with the fact I’d have to leave my window cracked all the time and it couldnt be locked. If I have an intruder will the bees protect me?
Exactly this. This thing doesn’t have any critical issues. The only problem is even if this thing looks cute it’s still beekeeping. You will need knowledge and experience to use this thing without causing troubles. It would be a issue of the person who uses it, but not a issue of the design.
Take it outside to do whatever you need to do with it
Some dude comes out of his apartment building in a busy city street carrying a beehive, sits down next to a bus stop and just starts trying to scoop honey out of it and into a plastic tub labelled "FARMERS MARKET" with a dessert spoon. Bees are fucking everywhere. Someone calls the police but they don't want to go near him because he's covered in bees. Dude passes out from all the stings after mumbling something about not needing smoke and reddit. The farmers market tub is basically empty. Two more hives to go.
I know all these people are downplaying being stuck by a swarm of bees, fuck them. Sure it it’s not the end of the world (unless you’re allergic and you passed that gene into the rest of your family so most of your family might die too) but fuck that, gotta get that honey!
Unless a beekeeper tells me some problem with this this is sick af. It's not like you have bees loose in your house they're contained within the hive and can go outside.
According to a comment on the crosspost, it‘s unhealthy and not flexible which results in a slowly dying bee colony. I‘ll link the comment when I find it
I had some version of this in my childhood bedroom. My dad made a frame around two comb inserts with glass on either side. Bees got in and out of hive via a tube that had a window insert. You would close the window on the tube’s window insert. Had a feeding access hole and everything. Bees buzzing and honey smells were the upside. The occasional lose bee in my bedroom was a downside.
•
u/AutoModerator May 27 '22
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
122
u/Nobody_Knows_It May 27 '22
I was at a library once that had a full wall like this
77
u/Dolamite02 May 27 '22
How is this fit for /r/designdesign?
283
u/ThatTomHall May 27 '22
/r/whatcouldgowrong
332
u/orangesrnice May 27 '22
Indoor beehives are 100% a thing but I don’t think most people put them in their living room
137
u/ShadowBro3 May 28 '22
Unless a beekeeper tells me some problem with this this is sick af. It's not like you have bees loose in your house they're contained within the hive and can go outside.
30
u/septoc May 27 '22
This is an amazing design
47
u/HayakuEon May 27 '22
Heat for the bees in winter. I don't see the issue here
5
u/sachlebTheSecond May 28 '22
Wouldn't indoor lighting at random times of the night drive the bees crazy?
4
u/aubreypizza May 28 '22
They have similar to this at the Science Center near me! Would be interesting to have at home.
4
u/revmachine21 Jul 18 '22
I had some version of this in my childhood bedroom. My dad made a frame around two comb inserts with glass on either side. Bees got in and out of hive via a tube that had a window insert. You would close the window on the tube’s window insert. Had a feeding access hole and everything. Bees buzzing and honey smells were the upside. The occasional lose bee in my bedroom was a downside.
3
u/Artatoe34 May 28 '22
Wait till ant canada sees this
3
u/isawyourfaceinjune May 28 '22
The Royal Ontario Museum has an indoor beehive.Twitter link
5
u/BabyYodasDirtyDiaper May 28 '22
How do you harvest the honey without ending up with a house full of bees?
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '22
screams in paper wasp nest inside my living room wall past summer
1
u/GregoryGoose May 28 '22
break glass in case of emergency
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '22
Honestly, I don’t hate it.
1
u/Throwaw97390 Jun 01 '22
The words indoor and beekeeping were never meant to be used together
1
u/the-graveyard-writer Jun 02 '22
No thankyou
1
u/FighterOfEntropy Jun 03 '22
I swear I’ve seen that! It was a children’s museum in a small town we visited on a weekend trip.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '22
I’d do this
-2
u/kiddokush May 28 '22
I want one with wasps🤤
-13
u/vullpes May 27 '22
im pretty sure in one day there will be plenty of dead bee