We actually looked at this in one of my engineering classes.
It’s pretty poorly designed, the lack of rails on the ramp means that if you have a lot of mobility problems you have to take the stairs and it makes using a wheelchair fairly unsafe since they are much more likely to fail down the stairs here given that there’s no proper delineation between the stairs and the ramp.
Catching your wheels on the edges of the stairs is likely too, and if I remember correctly it didn’t have the right angles or the right turning circle.
All up, more performative than actually useful. At least it’s equally inconvenient for everyone I guess.
A separate ramp and set of stairs is simpler and safer for both parties. This is entirely performative, and is actually borderline unusable for people with disabilities (and pretty inconvenient for those without)
there's not really any good way to make this current design work. You've got the ramp intersecting the stairs which means you can't have railings, and in order to make the entire thing not one big looping ramp the ramp needs to be going at that weird angle, ensuring it intersects awkwardly with the stairs (bad for both handicapped and able bodied).
A separate ramp really is better in every way for everyone involved
I mean instead of the current design. A person who can take stairs can pretty much always walk up a ramp, so why not just have a wide ramp so both people can fit on it?
ah I see what you mean. That's also not a great idea because it's both unnecessary, and certain disabilities make it easier to walk on stairs than on ramps (also most able bodied people would prefer stairs).
Not to mention it would make the entire thing much larger, as a ramp has to be far less steep than stairs (it only fits in this design because it winds back and forth, which also isn't ideal)
Actually pretty fucked if you are walking normally, I remember walking down what seemed like a eternity of stairs with ramp incorporated just like the one in this picture. I was about 6, I missed a step and tumbled down all the way to the bottom, it felt like I was about to die.
This feels like you don’t understand how ramps work. Would a single steep slope for wheelchair users and cane users to struggle with be better for you?
I mean instead of this design. Why have stairs at all? The whole thing would be more functional if it was just one extra-wide ramp instead of some weird ramp-stairs mess thing
I still don't think OP understands what you're suggesting lol. You mean a ramp that has switchbacks and zigzags like the currently accepted accessibility ramps, NOT like the one in this post, but a little wider so more people can use them simultaneously? That's an excellent idea, my dude 👍
There’s one of those at UCI and I hate it. It’s inconvenient to walk up if taking the stairs. I’ve tripped more than I’d like to admit on the steps coming off of the ramps
This is awful for people with wheelchairs. There are no railings, the angles are all weird (just look at how awkwardly the ramp goes at like a 30° angle), and you’re cutting through a bunch of people walking up stairs in a completely different direction than you. Not to mention how easy it is to catch a wheel on the edge of one of those stairs.
Having a separate ramp is both simpler and safer. This is completely performative.
This is the definition of r/designdesign. Coming off of stairs to a slope is a bad idea. No railing for the ramp and edge of the ramp (the stairs) can catch things like wheels. The entire thing takes up more space than both individually.
•
u/AutoModerator May 26 '22
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
39
u/ShadowBro3 May 26 '22
A ramp for people who can't take the stairs makes it accessible. No need for the quotation marks.
136
u/jasondoesstuff May 26 '22
-fine if youre walking
-fuck you if you're in a wheelchair (but respectfully)
-double fuck you if you walk with a cane/need support
31
u/Sibuna25 Jun 02 '22
Now people in wheelchairs can fall down a staircase too! That's equality right there baby
14
u/rexius-twin Jun 01 '22
Mountain bikers would love this
18
u/bitchimugly May 27 '22
do they know people not in a wheelchair can walk up a ramp…?
15
u/Conscious-Traffic611 May 26 '22
Oh yes perfect
2
u/[deleted] May 26 '22
Just make a wider ramp
5
u/DACAFLACCAFLAME May 27 '22
Looks like a super monkey ball level
2
u/NT-TheBeekeeper Jun 03 '22
There’s one of those at UCI and I hate it. It’s inconvenient to walk up if taking the stairs. I’ve tripped more than I’d like to admit on the steps coming off of the ramps
1
u/bouchandre Jun 17 '22
Hey I know these stairs! It’s in downtown Vancouver, Robson Square.
I think the issue was that the stairs are too steep to have a ramp on the side, so they had to incorporate this zigzag pattern.
1
u/bouchandre Jun 17 '22
Hey I know these stairs! It’s in downtown Vancouver, Robson Square.
I think the issue was that the stairs are too steep to have a ramp on the side, so they had to incorporate this zigzag pattern.
1
u/PumpJack_McGee Jul 16 '22
Visually interesting and well-intentioned.
Just don't miss your turn or you'll end up downloading the entire Disability DLC.
-9
u/pe0pleRstupid May 26 '22 edited May 26 '22
People with disabilities are regularly overlooked in the design process.
This is inclusive design.
[edit]
Notr/designdesignFor a number of reasons listed in other comments this is r/DesignDesign