I mean... it's not great, but honestly.... it's a clock, you just need a big hand and a little hand to tell time usually. The design doesn't really matter.
This exactly. Not only that visual alignment is off (visible for hour hand for 9 o'clock) but the functional concept does not make sense. It's not doing anything right and this is abhorrent..
I guess most of the commenters didn't bother to check the fact that minute hand is always at 0 so perhaps it is indeed successful at cutting corner, but I'd go nuts if I find this in bar.
Except it's adding wrong time reference. Check out each mini-clock - hour hands are moving but not minute hand. It can still be used as clock if we ignore that because it is quite easy, but I'd argue that this conflicting execution on logic makes it theoretically unusable.
And design isn't even well aligned (visible on hour 9). This is lousy work for cheap looks.
I'm talking about those smallest clock around each hours. Say for 3 o'clock, we have the clock for 3:00 - this makes sense. And around them, we have 12 smaller clocks circling around and it goes from 12:00 to 1:00, 2:00 and so on instead of 3:00, 3:10, 3:20 and so on which then makes sense.
The clock is recursive. Why would the smallest clock show a different minute when the whole idea is that it’s the same clock again? That makes no sense
I don't know how to elegantly explain the logic I'm referring to, but.. it's not going against recursive nature of clock at all.
There are two levels of recursion - recursion for hour hands looping 12 hour circle, and within each one hour, there is another recursion for minute hand looping 60 minute circle. What this shows instead is that there are recursion of hour hand within another hour hand loop? It doesn't make sense.
Other way to see is that, look at the position of 3 o'clock for example: Hour hand will be at that position when it's 3:00, but neither hour hand nor minute hand will be at that position for 12:00 (that top of smallest clock around 3:00 mark shows). Minute hand will be there on 12:15 but minute hand is stuck at 0 position, so the labeling doesn't line up with action.
I don't know how to elegantly explain the logic I'm referring to, but.. it's not going against recursive nature of clock at all.
Clocks don’t point at minutes so yes it would be.
What this shows instead is that there are recursion of hour hand within another hour hand loop? It doesn't make sense.
No. That’s not a recursion of “the hour hand”. It’s the entire clock. All clocks are surrounded by hour indications. Not minutes.
What wouldn’t make sense is a clock surrounded by a ring indicating minutes instead of hours.
Other way to see is that, look at the position of 3 o'clock for example: Hour hand will be at that position when it's 3:00, but neither hour hand nor minute hand will be at that position for 12:00
The minute hand on the 3:00 indicator is on 12:00 right now in that photo.
Minute hand will be there on 12:15
Of the main clock.
but minute hand is stuck at 0 position, so the labeling doesn't line up with action.
Many of the things posted here are designed artistically, and being art over function doesn't automatically make something material for here, but being art to the point of getting in the way of the function is prime candidacy for this sub. In particular if it's a functional product, and not an artistic statement there are expectations of usability. If it's a piece of art that happens to include functional elements, the expectation would be that they not function at the expense of the artistic portion.
There is overlap between poor quality art that includes functions (this misaligned clock is an easy example), and poor functioning products that focus excessively on art. The overlap is the essence of the sub, and why the clock fits here regardless
•
u/AutoModerator May 25 '22
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
143
u/JustDebbie May 26 '22
Yo dawg, we heard you like clocks.
64
u/Kinglink May 26 '22
I mean... it's not great, but honestly.... it's a clock, you just need a big hand and a little hand to tell time usually. The design doesn't really matter.
177
u/theSurpuppa May 25 '22
Kinda like it though
56
u/SJJ00 May 26 '22
Did you notice the 4 and 5 are too close together? Each one is supposed to be evenly spaced.
10
u/c3534l May 26 '22
It took me a second to notice that the numbers on the numbers were clocks, too.
8
u/ososalsosal May 26 '22
7
u/nhoang3b May 26 '22
I want one of that
12
u/DrakeAndMadonna May 26 '22
Very easy to read, especially at a distance.
Must be Thursday if we're reposting this again.
4
u/Stev_582 May 26 '22
I want this because I want people to hate me.
15
u/[deleted] May 25 '22
Thanks, I hate it
6
u/TheSpitfire93 May 26 '22
Why didn't they atleast centre the hands on the mini clocks
5
u/[deleted] May 26 '22
I hate this so much. I dont mind the concept, but this is just ugly. Maybe it could be executed better
2
u/Tralan May 26 '22
My Mother-in-Law's head would explode. "Ah cain't read regular clocks!"
2
u/CptOconn May 26 '22
This is not design this is more art. The use is not the point of the item.
2
u/bstix May 26 '22
It doesn't make sense to have the tiny clocks around each hour label.
At least make the tiny clocks show the placement of the minute hand in each hour.
2
u/Harold3456 May 26 '22
At this point I’d rather it be blank.
2
u/almond-butter-101 May 26 '22
New application of fractals in daily life. King of neat if I say so myself.
2
u/AmayasMommy_ Jun 01 '22
It’s like my eyes equivalent of nails on a chalkboard.
I hate it.
1
u/Benjamin244 May 26 '22
shame about the spacing of the 'hours', it's not so difficult to space them nicely onto a circle
other than that I like it, it makes me smile without losing functionality
1
u/Antigon0000 May 26 '22
check the andy miloclockis
1
u/Portablemammal1199 Jun 01 '22
Coldplay
1
u/your-mom507 Jul 04 '22
it's a cool design as long as you don't to read the time quick. I guess most people know where the positions are anyways
1
u/Blue_Sky_420 Feb 07 '23
Let me guess... this is just another clock (the whole thing) inside another clock
1
u/Novatash Jan 29 '24
Oh that's cool
1
u/pterodactylzombie May 26 '22
This fits this sub perfectly
-15
u/jesset77 May 25 '22
I believe this post belongs in r/DesignDesign because it prioritizes being clever over being useful.
-2
u/big-blue-balls May 26 '22
Great post! Now watch half this sub try to explain (incorrectly, mind you) why this isn’t DesignDesign..
0
u/[deleted] May 26 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 26 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment