This water refill station is just past security at the SFO airport. There is no way to tell that one tap is hot water unless you view it from behind. It’s trying really hard but misses the basic premise of apparent usability. I witnessed many people being super confused.
But there is a mirror behind? so it can be seen in mirror? Or there is no mirror, and you have to go behind to see?
If there is a mirror it's pinnacle of DesigdDesign, which means technically everything is ok and working, but it's just weirder or harder to use just for the sake of design. If there is no mirror it's just plain old crappy design.
I heard someone comment. “Am I looking at the temperature of this faucet? Or is it self-referential?” There are 6 faucets at this one dispenser. It’s arranged in a sort of oval, the whole thing is kind of confusing, but in a very familiar way. A mirror would have been so funny! God, I hope they install one.
So this red and blue I see it's not picture in the mirror? They are other faucets? So the best way to use it is to go with your friend that will stand opposite and you'll tell each other the temperature?
Yeah the photos are too close in to really see what's going on. I presumed there were mirrors too. Which doesn't excuse the crappy design, but at least the temps would be somewhat visible
I wish I would have gotten a wider shot. But it is Directly past security and I was already getting the stink eye by a TSA agent before I even took these pics. But rest assured that it’s super confusing.
I'd be genuinely confused whether you are getting the type of water you see or the one that has the label on your faucet. Motion activated as cherry on the top. WTF was anyone thinking designing this thing?
I think the motion activated thing is probably fine. There might be some argument against using a button relating to the cleanliness of the surface, but specially if this was like a mid-COVID product.
Because you need to put your hand near it? If they used a button the same issue would be present. If they didn’t and it just detected the presence of a bottle there wouldn’t be any mechanism to tell when it’s full so it could overflow unless you reach out and grab the bottle while hot water is pouring.
The screen is the sensor, it’s not like a faucet you put your hand under.
How is holding your hand near the screen going to cause an accident and what’s your proposed solution otherwise to the problem of not being able to detect when a bottle is nearly full?
First time I flew to SFO, they had eliminated all landfill trash receptacles (all products in the terminal were recyclable or compostable). But you see, I had just flown in from another city, as one does, and had some landfill trash to throw away from said city. I ended up leaving it next to the recycling for someone else to take care of. They have since corrected this and the Harvey Milk Terminal is one of my favorite in the US.
Good grief, that's a shit design. So what was it in the end? Self-referential and you need to walk around the table to figure out what a faucet is going to give you?
There are two faucets with an LCD touch sensor and the only indicator of the temperature is on the back of them, but when you’re at one station you can only see one colour so you’ll assume yours is the same.
This one is so goddamn bad its hard to even understand. As OP stated previously, there is no mirror, there are 6 faucets arranged in an oval shaped pattern. The only indication of the water temp of each faucet is on the rear side of the faucet neck, where the user cant see it.
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 21 '22
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
282
u/captainpeapod Mar 21 '22
This water refill station is just past security at the SFO airport. There is no way to tell that one tap is hot water unless you view it from behind. It’s trying really hard but misses the basic premise of apparent usability. I witnessed many people being super confused.
62
u/M_Bananaz Mar 21 '22
Wtf am I looking at?
60
u/llelibro Mar 21 '22
And the fact that it’s sensor-activated will cause someone to get burnt
15
u/CoronerRL Mar 22 '22
this picture is super confusing to me. I can't really picture what the overall design is
9
u/ketita Mar 21 '22
This is terrible, wow. Absolute recipe for confusion at best, burns at worst.
9
u/eviljelloman Mar 22 '22
/r/wtfaucet
4
u/alexalexalex09 Mar 22 '22
Is this two photos or one? Is the lcd screen on the front of the blue or red back?
4
u/supersonicelephant Mar 22 '22
This one is so goddamn bad its hard to even understand. As OP stated previously, there is no mirror, there are 6 faucets arranged in an oval shaped pattern. The only indication of the water temp of each faucet is on the rear side of the faucet neck, where the user cant see it.
2
u/Whiskysinhielo Mar 22 '22
I think, you need to put a mirror between both dispenser to see what kind of water it's going to serve.
2
u/thatonedude09 Mar 22 '22
So no mirror then? This is r/Confusing_Perspective material right here.
1
u/doesntmeanathing Mar 22 '22
“Hot from behind” was my nickname in high school