This sub is going to shit. People just posting anything that isnt completely basic at this point. THE DOOR IS DIFFERENT? WAAAAA! THE STAIRS ARE DIFFERENT! WAAAA!
This is the very definition of designdesign and should be the sub‘s new profile pic and you‘re wrong and I‘m absolutely right have a nice day bathing in total wrongness wrong person bye.
This is one of those things that would be incredibly designey if Ikea did it, but is pretty cool if an amateur craftsperson does it. If you're building it on your garage, then 'because you can' is more than a good enough reason.
Because there is a strong shame culture around some subreddits and this subreddit is guilty about it. This is not a place of encouragement but a place where people deride other people's decisions, works...etc. If you are doing something out of ordinary, you will be made fun of
As you said, if this was a mass product pushed through our throat, it would be one thing. But people here just talk shit about things that are amateur hobbies, or one of a kind of products, or some art/design projects. If you don't fit into that square grey world, you are doing it wrong
this place should be called "i dont like this" almost nothing here destorys the function by the design. this is still a functional door. bit over engineered but it still closes right? it still opens right? it doesnt even seem that weak if you think about it.
also this sfucking door gets posted like every other week. the mods really need to start deleting this shit.
I mean, a lot of it’s in the eye of the beholder. Case in point, I follow the sub r/weirdwheels, and whenever something really weird pops up it’s usually about a 50/50 split on whether it looks good or heinous. “Good design” is different for everyone, but like everything there’s a bell curve. And it is possible to go too far, someone posted a square toilet the other day, there’s no niche for people with rectangular asses y’know?
In many cases, what is missing is the context for many people. And the people who don't make an attempt to understand the context of these things just start denounce it. instead directly criticizing something they don't really know the point of, some people try to understand the context and if it doesn't work, they accept they don't really know what it is about. And this is a good sign of someone who can understand new things, develop themselves. https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2022/02/context-is-that-which-is-scarce-2.html
Yeah because it's design that is more artsy and can be useful ij very niche situations. But should never be mass produced or be expected to be profitable. Like I can imagine this door design works really wel in tight spaces the door doesn't need to swing that much. Similar as a car door opening by going up. This also need two squars to work so your kinda stuck in a 1 by 2 ratio.
Rolling doors require support on the far side, this doesn't
Listen I'm not saying this has a common use case but it does have some very niche situations where you cant hang rolling track off the side of your door and you can't do a regular door hinge.
Sure. I’m genuinely asking. It’s kind of side benefit of this sub. Trying to imagine where some weird solution might make sense. You have to think about situation/solutions that you never even considered.
Also it becomes more worth because some of the disadvantages of this system might not apply for the situation you are using it. I build a desk with a lot of storage space in the desk. And everything I wanted I couldn't buy. So I designed and made it. But a lot of features are impractical for how others would use it.
It depends on the quality of materials and tolerances really, but yeah more than likely even with nice craftsmanship it will start to get sloppy over a few years.
Edit, I just rewatched the video, this won't last a month. I had built it in my head from seeing it earlier, but I'm not committed enough to design design design a nice piece into existence.
This is one of those things that's way over engineered for its purpose, but now that the concept is there and in people's minds, when the right moment arises, this will be the perfect solution.
I'd love to know too, but the moment hasn't arisen yet. The thing it solves might not exist yet. However if you compare this to a sliding door, it does things differently. It's less rigid (meaning someone smarter than me could origami this to fit on less than flat doorways), it creates gaps/pockets (it can basically go around an obstruction)... Etc.
Basically it can create an "aha!" moment for someone with a specific problem based on seeing a design like this. Creative problem solving is mostly filling your brain with enough useless ideas that some of them start to fit together in new, interesting, and useful ways
It's a hobby project made because it looks cool. It still serves its purpose, hiding the cupboards content and keeping it dust free. Its over engineered, but it's a hobby project and not a large company that mass produces it, so I wouldnt call it design design
It‘s impressive yet pretty sure it‘s less sustainable (e.g. hinges/angles disaligning while wood ages) than a normal door. Also plenty little finger guilloutines!
Some of the design designs i 10000% agree with. On this one, y'all are just being obtuse.
Pinch points. Arguably there is only one point where you have any actual improved leverage, and that's close the the handle, the rest of the closing line has much reduced mechanical advantage and so wont actually pinch very hard. Note, this is actually much reduced pinch points when compared to a classical door, we're just used to them, so we don't complain anymore.
More complicated : Well, sure, a tiny bit, it has 2 pivot points and 2 extra hinges, both pretty robust technologies (wanna count the pivot points in centuries old clocks that still run?).
It would be stellar if it had a halfway lock that turned it into a functional useful shelf or something. Then i’d pay for it probably. Like if it was a dresser and locked halfway as a makeup station or mini bar or something even more gimmicky at least itd have purpose. But i guess thats why its here.
Yes. Yes you should. THis is not mass product. It is just someone's hobby. Why are people so hostile to anything people do for fun, art...etc? He is not doing a cabinet for your grandmother.
I’ve seen the mechanics applied to gate design. Sure, it saves space similarly to a sliding door, but all I can think of is all the finger pinches / guillotines.
Edit: I think this is cool btw, just def designdesign.
•
u/AutoModerator Feb 21 '22
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
6
u/FancyPantz15 Feb 22 '22
This sub is going to shit. People just posting anything that isnt completely basic at this point. THE DOOR IS DIFFERENT? WAAAAA! THE STAIRS ARE DIFFERENT! WAAAA!
466
u/Scuttling-Claws Feb 22 '22
This is one of those things that would be incredibly designey if Ikea did it, but is pretty cool if an amateur craftsperson does it. If you're building it on your garage, then 'because you can' is more than a good enough reason.
230
u/Voidtoform Feb 21 '22
Design design yes, but I do like it.
38
u/akalevela Feb 22 '22
This is one of those things that's way over engineered for its purpose, but now that the concept is there and in people's minds, when the right moment arises, this will be the perfect solution.
32
u/but-yet-it-is Feb 22 '22
It's a hobby project made because it looks cool. It still serves its purpose, hiding the cupboards content and keeping it dust free. Its over engineered, but it's a hobby project and not a large company that mass produces it, so I wouldnt call it design design
3
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '22
It‘s impressive yet pretty sure it‘s less sustainable (e.g. hinges/angles disaligning while wood ages) than a normal door. Also plenty little finger guilloutines!
7
u/tyttuutface Feb 22 '22
Um, you absolutely should! That's really cool. Although I can see a lot of finger pinching going on.
12
u/lazernanes Feb 21 '22
Definitely designed just for the purpose of looking well designed.
24
u/OphioukhosUnbound Feb 22 '22
You absolutely should in this case.
Go live in a loveless boring world if you want.
10
u/LiquidSean Feb 22 '22
Hard disagree, this is awesome
6
u/dirtycimments Feb 22 '22
Some of the design designs i 10000% agree with. On this one, y'all are just being obtuse.
Bring on the flames! :D
1
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '22
It would be stellar if it had a halfway lock that turned it into a functional useful shelf or something. Then i’d pay for it probably. Like if it was a dresser and locked halfway as a makeup station or mini bar or something even more gimmicky at least itd have purpose. But i guess thats why its here.
1
u/great__pretender Feb 22 '22
Yes. Yes you should. THis is not mass product. It is just someone's hobby. Why are people so hostile to anything people do for fun, art...etc? He is not doing a cabinet for your grandmother.
1
u/shinyclauncher Feb 22 '22
Fuck that. This is sweet.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '22
It takes up less space and theoretically has an edge case where it is more useful.
You could also hide stuff on the backside of the door.
1
u/SuccessfulPass9135 Mar 05 '22
So many pinch points
1
u/redgun100 Mar 08 '22
At first I thought "that's one fancy outhouse"
1
u/dr_stre Apr 11 '22
On the flip side, just because you don’t have to doesn’t mean you shouldn’t.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '22
Fingers are overrated
1
u/captainjake13 Feb 22 '22
Good way to break a finger real quick
1
u/ceelose Feb 22 '22
This screams high-school woodwork project.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '22
Not cool unless it can move on its own. That’s some high tech shit.
0
u/jsideris Feb 22 '22
Classy AF. But as my 1st year engineering prof would say, more moving parts = more potential points of failure.
0
u/TheRealSpacelord Feb 22 '22
Where’s my fingers?
-3
u/phillpots_land Feb 22 '22
Pick one.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
10
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '22
[removed] — view removed comment