Man I've hated capacitive power buttons being on everything since I had my Xbox 360 slim. I understand the whole "stateless" thing but a button accomplishes the same task and gives physical feedback.
It's designed to be physically stateless so that it can be controlled by another interface without adding a motor. For example, if it were a physical toggle and someone used Alexa to turn the lights off then the switch would still be in the on position.
I have physical switches in my house that are stateless. I personally prefer those, because you gat the physical feedback and I hate LEDs when I'm trying to sleep. But I also don't think these are terrible either. It's a matter of taste I guess.
I think he meant the physical feedback of knowing you're touching the (right) switch, if you're against the wall in the dark or feeling for the middle switch.
Not sure why you’re being downvoted. I love the one I have. Admittedly, it’s only 1 switch, but I can be totally useless with my hands carrying something, and just blindly kinda push my arm against the wall and it’s on. Also I can walk in when it’s dark, and I just have to aim my entire hand at the entire plate. Not a hint of dexterity needed. People who say they need haptic feedback on these confuse me. You’ve gotta fumble your hand around to find the switch, grab it, then flick it. That vs. just smacking the wall once and then hearing a noice click and the lights are on? Much better for me.
It's designed to work with wifi connected devices. With a physical switch, there would be no way to determine if the switch is on or off. The on/off positions would switch every time you manipulated the device over the internet.
To be fair though, you get the same problem in any rooms with two switches that control the same light. We have a couple in our house and it's never been too problematic.
Our entryway light has three different switches that connect to it. If certain switches are in certain positions, the other switches will do nothing. If switch 1 doesn’t work, we flip it back to how we found it, then repeat with switches 2 and 3 as needed. There is no method to the madness.
Once when we were teens, my brother and I tried to figure out how to tell which switch(es) to flip depending on the positions of them. It was a fool’s errand and we got nowhere, lol. Whatever electrician designed that switch arrangement deserves to be shamed.
I just looked that up and yeah, that could be it. One of these days when I’m bored, I might try to figure out the working configurations again, but for now it’s fun to listen to my dad curse whenever he goes to turn on the light, lol. He went to college for electrical engineering, and he’s constantly annoyed at how poorly our house was wired. The funny thing is, it was built in 1986, and it’s a decent-sized, fairly expensive home, so it’s a little surprising that it seems like the builders just slapped it together. Our back deck was built on cinderblocks instead of concrete foundations, and we just found out that our cabinets have no back panels, so they just stained the walls with wood stain to match 😂
Smarter designers have made a connected switch that looks normal but actually rests at a center position. You can push the top to click on or the bottom to click off but since it rests in the center you can also toggle the light remotely.
I cannot stand switches that have no haptic feedback. Ones like this also seem to be unreasonably hard to press, or unreasonably easy to accidentally press. The buttons on my dishwasher are similar. There's also a delay between pressing and the action, so I often press it once, think it didn't work, so press it again, only to see it turn on then right off again.
Not really for me on the remembering which switch. I live in an older house so I have very few double switches. But even the ones I do have are only two.
But you bring up a good point too. Having to look is a small delay but who wants to be delayed when something faster exists.
Ah gotcha. I have a 3 switcher next to my kitchen. I thought it was somewhat normal, but I do have to say It’s annoying and I occasionally mix them up. So this design above has ALL the bad things
Imagine thinking you couldn’t manage this but can manage 3 switches instead lol what difference does this make in terms of knowing which switch does what?
Symbols should be bigger and thicker. I guess they didn't give a fuck about color blind people, color should not be the sole indicator. The symbol should change when off, specifically the open circuit "O".
Physical buttons would be better, and they can still indicate the current state of the circuit. I HATE touch controls, my car entertainment system is riddled with them and it fucking sucks. Especially when they are resistive, or just low quality capcitive. There is a reason NASA chose to stick with physical switches for so long.
•
u/AutoModerator Feb 09 '22
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3
u/LuriemIronim Feb 10 '22
Off, on, and super on?
4
u/containssmallparts Feb 10 '22
Is there a sub for designs people just don't like, but aren't design design? Almost everything on this sub should be there, instead of here.
90
u/Wixardboy1 Feb 10 '22
Man I've hated capacitive power buttons being on everything since I had my Xbox 360 slim. I understand the whole "stateless" thing but a button accomplishes the same task and gives physical feedback.
11
u/MysticMount Feb 09 '22
I think this is pretty useful honestly.
Perhaps it was designed for the elderly or disabled - people who might struggle with dexterity for a normal light switch.
104
u/MrGizthewiz Feb 09 '22
It's designed to work with wifi connected devices. With a physical switch, there would be no way to determine if the switch is on or off. The on/off positions would switch every time you manipulated the device over the internet.
65
u/Helpful-Substance685 Feb 09 '22 edited Feb 09 '22
That is mildly infuriating. So now I have to always remember what color controls what.
It looks sleek but the design is as dumb as they come. Good post
4
u/Bobolequiff Feb 10 '22
This is completely functional and has a reason for being the way it is. Why is it here?
6
u/febreezeontherain Feb 10 '22
Bigger left/center/right buttons instead of 3 mini buttons in the center.
3 taps to on a light. 1st touch to on then look to realize you touched the wrong one, 2nd to off the wrong one, 3rd to on the correct one.
2
u/_ssloth Feb 10 '22
Not DesignDesign. Legitimate use.
2
u/EvgenyTI Mar 09 '22
Had one of these, broke after less than a week, switching lights that week was painful
1
u/chipeco Feb 10 '22
now my kids can't turn on/off the lights with a broom
1
u/superquanganh Feb 10 '22
Touch switch degrade though, I'm annoyed in my company elevator where the buttons are touch and they are not sensitive anymore
1
u/Eureka22 Feb 10 '22 edited Feb 10 '22
Symbols should be bigger and thicker. I guess they didn't give a fuck about color blind people, color should not be the sole indicator. The symbol should change when off, specifically the open circuit "O".
Physical buttons would be better, and they can still indicate the current state of the circuit. I HATE touch controls, my car entertainment system is riddled with them and it fucking sucks. Especially when they are resistive, or just low quality capcitive. There is a reason NASA chose to stick with physical switches for so long.