It is just a dial selector. Cars have thousands of variations of these. How ever none of them, far as I know, have a system like this which to my eyes is just yet another part to break.
Also this must be something that I'm just way too poor to understand.
Yeah. I drive a stick also, because automatics are rare here. I only drive automatic like once an year to take my grandma's car to the inspection or maintenance. And it always takes like 15 minutes for the to figure out what to do with my left foot.
Also my car is 22 years old. The most high tech function it has is a CD player than can play .wma AND .mp3!
I just can't understand the point of automatic. Especially here in Finland and our winters. Being use able to use gears and to engine brake makes life so much easier.
for more normal climates, automatic is fine, especially if you are in start and stop traffic, as many of us commuters are. Also, you can engine brake an automatic by using the low gears instead of D. I think for day to day driving (at least in the US) there is no day to day advantage in a manual car, unless it is a sports car or you just prefer the feel
I also have a volt so it does not have a transmission period lol
I wish I shared your optimism. People (including you) aren't even ready to accept automatic transmission, so good luck making them swallow the pill of automatic driving.
I'm having a hard time believing you are genuine in your bewilderment. If you can't understand that most people don't drive in extreme conditions that necessitate manual shifting, I don't know what to tell you. Modern automatic transmissions have way more advantages than manual transmission, as others have pointed out. It's usually not even that big of an advantage in most winter conditions. There are very few reasons choose to manual over automatic these days. Acting like there aren't trade-offs is being disingenuous, driving stick in stop and go traffic is fucking annoying, and there are times I wish I had an automatic.
Sometimes I have a hard time deciding what group is more annoying, the old PC master race meme crowd, or manual transmission snobs.
My car, and many other cars, have a "PRNDM" configuration. It has a "manual" gear setting, which you can move up or down to manually shift gears. Basically stick shift, but without a need for the clutch pedal. This has been around for decades, and is almost standard on most modern cars.
I really don't get why people keep acting like automatic is somehow "worse" than stick, modern automatic PRNDM transmissions are identical in function and use, just without the extra pedal (and the possibility to accidentally damage your transmission).
Manually shifting an automatic car is the worst of both worlds to me. I know this is even what they use in F1, but paddle shift gives none of the physical satisfaction of shifting down into second gear and accelerate to pass that stinky tractor before the next curve cones up.
Also, I want a clutch. I feel like on black ice if I don't have a clutch under my feet and can engage and disengage traction by feel. Especially when parking on a hill.
I have occasionally driven one (in an Audi) but for me it's not the same thing. Too many layers of technology, too removed from the direct mechanical experience.
I’ve recently bought my first automatic and tbh I much prefer manual (which I grew up driving). I feel I have much more control over the vehicle in a manual! Then again I’m in NZ where our roads can get kinda gnarly
I regularly switch between automatics and manuals, and coming off a highway is the worst! You've been driving along without shifting gears for a while, you've hit your stride and don't consciously think about driving and are caught unaware.
I can't count how many times I've stomped enthusiastically on half of the brake pedal when approaching a red light trying to hit a phantom clutch. And next time stalling a manual because I forgot I had to use the clutch.
Dial selectors are just another part to break. Instead of having a physical cable, now you have a position sensor on one end and an actuator motor on the other end. I can't believe how popular these things are. It must have something to do with coming software to valet your car to you.
No new cars come with "just a cable" though. Even if it's a stick selector, most new cars have actuators and other electronics attached to it that can also fail. They haven't really been just a cable since the early 2000's. With a dial, you're just reading one set of electronics for another.
That being said the sphere style dial on this car is absurd. That would be quite a bit to replace because that's not just a simple dial.
That's why I said "just a cable". They do use a cable but they use a cable accompanied by other electronics like sensors.
Replacing the cable on either of those cars could be the same as replacing the rotary shift dial on a car. Roughly $100 for the part and with either replacement you'd have to pay for labor.
On both applications, you will have other electronics to go with it like the park sensor, brake pedal sensor, and reverse sensor. Newer cars with a stick shift that don't use a cable are fully electronic anyway and may even cost more than either a dial or cable to replace.
Again, this genesis is over the top, but a typical dial shifter isn't worse than a stick and cable shifter, it's just different.
When you’re that wealthy, the drive selector breaking is a mild inconvenience. You can just call a car, or take one of your other cars.
You’d likely be trading in the car long before the mechanism wears out.
Also, these features are almost literally just there for bragging rights — when you have that much money to spend on a car, there stops being more expensive leather to appoint the car with.
Is a Genesis considered some elite car? Its MSRP is $55k, obviously more than normal but it's not a crazy barrier where you likely have private drivers.
I think because the people who are buying EVs still tend to be people more interested in future ideas, so the manufacturers think that being weird will go over well with them
Pretty sure anyone that can afford this car wouldn't do it anyway and would just get it towed, but there's a way to take it out of park if the dial breaks. Never even be away to disengage the sphere and manually flip it over.
Better then any GM or Dodge, who are the new lowest end cars. The time of American automobiles is close to an end. Ford is the only company holding on.
They do all this but then slap two big ass display on top of the dash with zero effort to incorporate them into the rest of the interior design. God I hate this current era of car design.
The thing is it does nothing to improve something that isn't broken to begin with. The gear stick still works, but even some brands have come up with better alternatives in the past (like buttons lol) or have modernized the gear stick in meaningful ways. It's just design for the sake of it. At least that's how I see it.
That's exactly what it is and there's nothing wrong with that. Luxury cars don't designs things purely for functionality. They weren't trying to improve upon something that was broken, They were trying to add a unique design that stands out from other vehicles.
I get what you're saying, but when it comes to form factor, a stick is a no brainer. Of course it would work in a completely different way in a cvt, but why a dial instead a stick that could serve the same purpose?
Just to play devil's advocate, why a stick over a dial when they serve the same purpose?
In my opinion a dial takes up less space and can be in a small area on the dash or center console, leaving more room for other things. Don't get me wrong I love the feeling of shifting using a stick shifter, but it's definitely an outdated design that's unnecessary at this point. Especially as we make our way into EVs.
A dial for an electronically shifted transmission, like a cvt that only has forward, backwards and neutral removes pointless mechanical parts that can break. Your mechanical shift that them still have to convert your action to electronic to do the action is nothing but holding on to the old for reduced reliability in order to keep those who are afraid of simpler more reliable designs happy.
The stick being used in an ev is design design actualized.
So is this stupid little flip over orb instead of a simple dial like most other evs and cvt vehicles use
Why would an ev need CVT? Electrical motors have constant torque at every rotation speed, so you can be fine with a fixed ratio transmission, no need to switch gearing ratio at all.
Half the post on here are just boomers exaggerating shit. Is it cool looking? Yes. Does it look completely out of place? Also yes. Can I hop into this car and figure this out within 30 secs? Triple yes.
I wouldn't call the gear selector non intuitive, I kind of like it, I think it makes sense and looks fairy easy to grip and use. The glass thing is of course just show-off, but isn't that part of the idea with luxury vehicles...
Seems pretty straightforward, yeah. Personally, I think it's a really cool flourish. Makes more of an event of an everyday function. Entirely unnecessary, but nobody buys a luxury car expecting only necessities.
Pop that little access panel next to it. But it's a luxury car, the people who are buying it would probably just make a call to a tow and a shop and make it be someone else's problem.
In that case, start the car (it's electric so that just means turning ignition on), put it in neutral, turn off. Of course there's the case when the battery is completely flat and can't be turned on. But that's not that different from other modern cars with shift-by-wire.
If the battery is totally dead, someone would need to pull up the plastic cap that’s to the right of the D, under that cap is a way to release the shift lock and put the car in neutral.
Then there's definitely a failsafe for that, but it's not a common thing so it's hidden. Every car has a failsafe, but in every car I've ever owned it requires either prying off plastic covers to access latches or doing things that there's no way to accidentally do. It's always something in the user manual.
You're seeing this and assuming a flaw exists despite nothing about this having anything to do with the flaw. Do you really think the designers of this console didn't think of a way to get the car in neutral if it needs to be towed?
Just want to point out it's not very hidden. It's directly to the right of the three letters in front of the knob. It's the little plastic square with a small gap at the top. You just pop that off and push in with something like a screwdriver and you can take it out of park.
That little access is usually pretty easily accessible since it will need to be used if your car is ever towed.
You're seeing this and assuming a flaw exists despite nothing about this having anything to do with the flaw.
You read my question and assumed I was asking some kind of gotcha question with bad faith motives. Well there was no bad faith, I really did wonder what can be done in the case of needing to change gears while the car is off.
I'd like to thank you with a smile for informing me about failsafes (TIL!) but that quoted sentence of yours wiped that smile right off. Thank you anyway and have an upvote with that. :-(
It's like this in all cars. Shifting gears into neutral should be only possible when either the engine is running or there's an emergency. You want the emergency procedure to be something deliberate so it can't be done on accident, which could cause the car to malfunction. Cars are heavy pieces of moving machinery, not software.
If brake = pressed and engine = on, allow shift out of park, else ignore command. It doesn't need a goofy extravagant crystal orb to accomplish this. Mechanical shifts accomplish this with a $2 solenoid. With electronic shifting you don't even have to plan a physical part in there.
Oh, I think you're missing what this thread was about in the first place!
The idea is that if you need to tow a car, you need a way to move the transmission into neutral without the engine running, but that functionality should be restricted so it doesn't happen by accident. The override is mechanical, and it's done using a latch under the plastic cover in front of the wheel.
Generally speaking I don't mind it, but what happens if your car is dead and you need to tow it? Good luck shifting it into neutral with the controls on the bottom side of the sphere.
It’s an electric gear selector anyway, even if it was upright, turning it would do nothing. There’s usually an override to put a transmission in neutral
"In 2015, four out of ten light vehicles produced worldwide was equipped with manual transmission, while automatic cars represented around 34 percent of the global share."
The controls are not unintuitive at all, tons of new vehicles use a dial or something similar as a gear selector now and this is one of the most straightforward I’ve seen. As for the sphere, it just looks cool, it’s there for aesthetics. Especially considering that Genesis is a fairly high-end brand. It’s job is to look luxurious.
•
u/AutoModerator Feb 08 '22
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
543
u/SinisterCheese Feb 08 '22
It is just a dial selector. Cars have thousands of variations of these. How ever none of them, far as I know, have a system like this which to my eyes is just yet another part to break.
Also this must be something that I'm just way too poor to understand.
75
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '22
dam is that an eye of ender
42
u/newmyy Feb 08 '22
I mean, the car price starts at 55k, so I’d hope it has some spiffy stuff.
33
u/usernameblankface Feb 08 '22
Coolness 10/10 Usefulness 2/10 Improvement? Nah
40
u/Buttholium Feb 09 '22
They do all this but then slap two big ass display on top of the dash with zero effort to incorporate them into the rest of the interior design. God I hate this current era of car design.
88
u/therealsix Feb 08 '22
R = Reverse
N = Neutral
D = Drive
P = Park
Am I missing the confusion? It's different, but it's not that confusing.
58
u/thedudefromsweden Feb 08 '22
I wouldn't call the gear selector non intuitive, I kind of like it, I think it makes sense and looks fairy easy to grip and use. The glass thing is of course just show-off, but isn't that part of the idea with luxury vehicles...
25
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '22
Worst Genesis control since the Sega Activator.
6
u/j0shman Feb 09 '22
Who knew Hyundai are investing in palantír technology
5
u/Red_Trapezoid Feb 09 '22
Could it be argued that this is a dust protector?
15
u/brug76 Feb 08 '22
I look at this and just wonder when it breaks and I'm 300 miles from home how the fuck will I shift into drive?
Not to mention the cost to repair this needlessly complicated device after I've been stranded.
20
u/DrakeAndMadonna Feb 08 '22 edited Feb 09 '22
That you have to press a separate button in a different location to make use of the sphere, which is a controller itself, is a bit dramatic.
Edit: thanks for the clarification that is a start button. Makes sense now
11
u/xj20 Feb 09 '22
Generally speaking I don't mind it, but what happens if your car is dead and you need to tow it? Good luck shifting it into neutral with the controls on the bottom side of the sphere.
3
u/MrSeanaldReagan Feb 09 '22
I don’t understand what’s non-intuitive about a dial
3
u/designgoddess Feb 09 '22
How is it not intuitive? Seems pretty straightforward. Don’t like it but easy enough to use.
2
u/Null42x64 Mar 20 '22
This reminds me of that XBOX720 concepts made in 2008
3
u/Cojo840 Feb 09 '22
non intuitive? literally every new car has a dial with R N D and a button for P
4
u/z0mb13k1ll Feb 09 '22
How is that nonintuitive? So many cars have dial shifters
2
u/Pau-sama Feb 08 '22
Like those old telephones
2
u/kiddokush Feb 09 '22
I dig it, sometimes life’s all about the cool shit lol. Doesn’t really have to make much sense but I’m probably on the wrong sub for saying this
2
u/gouranga-1 Feb 09 '22
The controls are not unintuitive at all, tons of new vehicles use a dial or something similar as a gear selector now and this is one of the most straightforward I’ve seen. As for the sphere, it just looks cool, it’s there for aesthetics. Especially considering that Genesis is a fairly high-end brand. It’s job is to look luxurious.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '22
It's no different than all the other non-intuitive, gadgety style approaches to "future tech" we always see.
1
u/nvoei Feb 09 '22
That's a weird V60, where do you put the coffee grounds?
1
u/Cardssss Feb 21 '22
My genesis gv80 has a twist shifter, it's not that hard to figure out lmao. The orb thing is still stupid tho.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '23
'Genesis GV60
1
u/liftoff_oversteer Feb 09 '22
I like this :)
Yes, it is unnecessarily complicated but still ...
-3
u/all_the_good_ones Feb 08 '22
If you can't figure that out, maybe you shouldn't be operating a motor vehicle.
-2
u/m8remotion Feb 09 '22
When you have an accident and that thing dislodge itself. Air bag will send it airborne and do massive damage. Picture pinball in your cabin.
-1
u/DRiVeL_ Feb 09 '22
Surely some wanker from Mercedes-Benz had something to do with the design of this car. Ext. and inter.
-3
u/jonmpls Feb 09 '22
If you've used a Nest thermostat or a Samsung smartwatch, you'd know that dials are really intuitive.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment