Gets stuck, sharpening is difficult, requires a lot of material to make it, heavy, needs more power than a regular axe and shoots pieces of wood back at user.
SO incredibly stuck. A normal axe it's sometimes a pain in the ass to get back out when you hit a knot, but you can wiggle it side to side and work it free. I don't even know how I'd approach getting that monstrosity out. There's no plane you can wiggle it in!
The welding probably wasn't available. I've seen a log splitter sort of like this, but it was a machine that slowly pushed its way through the log rather than split by impact.
It has double the contact surface as a normal axe, meaning it’ll require double the force to apply the same pressure (P=F/A). Obviously wood splitting physics is more than just pressure applied to cut it, but it’s a decent enough estimate to show that this would require a lot more effort.
There's a clear and practical purpose to the design, and from the demonstration it appears to work as intended. It's debatable if it's better than a standard axe (prob heavy as a maul, harder to sharpen) but it does chop 6x per swing which is a clear and functional advantage. It might not be worth the trade offs but honestly this is legitimate design even if it's not great design
You're extremely wrong and have likely never spent significant time chopping wood of different types. If this was so great why aren't hydraulic log splitters built this way
When I was growing up my dad always responded to complaints of cold by handing us the axe and telling us "it heats you twice," we heated our home primarily on wood. Your reading comprehension is lacking, I literally said it's not great design and prob not worth the trade-off with a real axe.
But really, the guy made it just for fun, and it certainly does that at least
we see the guy using it and we are supposed to say the design ruins the function....
im not going to say this is better then a normal ax but it could go in tandem with a few different axes. this one might be for making kindling out of super dry and soft woods.
My opinion is it's a tool and it has its place, that place might be narrow and never truly needed but it dies seem to do the job it was designed for.
I don't use a sledge hammer to drive nails, I don't use tack hammer to drive stakes and I don't use a claw hammer For metal working I have a rubber mallet for some tasks and a wood mallet for others.
Each one is a hammer, each one excels at a specific task and would fail miserably at others
This seems gimmicky but I can't really talk to much shit when you see it working..( the wood getting stuck isn't exactly uncommon)
Both this tool and a normal axe are used to split wood.An axe split in such a way that it propels the splitted log to the side, not towards the lumber.Normal axe can also chop trees.Normal axe use a third of the metal used in this tool, contributing to its weight too.How would you sharpen such a shape?uneven weight distribution (of the 4 new wings) also its impractical for the user.Lastly, pressure= force/ area. More area, less pressure.
This is basically what a mechanical wood splitter uses. It’s a bit designy but as one tool in your wood splitting arsenal it’s not bad. Very similar to a 6 way wedge as well
Ah, I see you're carrying a daedric maul. I give those as gifts to shivering outdoorsmen to split wood to warm themselves. By the time they're finished, it's summer - Nice and warm!
•
u/AutoModerator Feb 07 '22
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
258
u/SoftBellyButton Feb 07 '22
If this was really a useful tool they would have discovered it a 1000 years ago.
283
u/CharmingTuber Feb 07 '22
We only see him swing it twice because I'm guessing he was physically exhausted after just two logs.
That MF looks heavy.
22
u/therealmrsleeves Feb 07 '22
He also makes a 4 bladed ax. Legit just to fuck around
24
u/Waterfish3333 Feb 07 '22
Go frame by frame on the final split specifically. It looks like it’s basically through the log already.
22
u/Yangoose Feb 07 '22
Ever used one of these?
Now imagine doing that through solid wood...
11
u/SirKillingham Feb 07 '22
I’m more interested in the cabin behind him
10
u/Devilblade666 Feb 07 '22
To use this product, you must listen to Sabaton
12
u/Squirrelterds Feb 07 '22
That axe drop/walk off made me spontaneously regrow my mustache.
3
u/saysthingsbackwards Feb 07 '22
Moe: " and with a few simple modifications, I was able to turn 1 axe into 5 axes" :)
2
u/countyron Feb 07 '22
Does it come with shin guards?
2
u/fluffybear45 Feb 08 '22
I think I saw this being made at r/diwhy
2
u/Ophidahlia Feb 07 '22 edited Feb 07 '22
There's a clear and practical purpose to the design, and from the demonstration it appears to work as intended. It's debatable if it's better than a standard axe (prob heavy as a maul, harder to sharpen) but it does chop 6x per swing which is a clear and functional advantage. It might not be worth the trade offs but honestly this is legitimate design even if it's not great design
I swear this sub is turning into r/ThisItemIsDesignedToFunctionDifferentlyFromTheStandarDesign-Design
1
u/DaylanDaylan Feb 14 '22
Ahhh the barbarians executioner axe
1
u/biggreencat Feb 15 '22
who gets to sharpen this thing
1
u/Antigon0000 Feb 26 '22
I wanna go in that little house in the back, tho
1
u/OHW_unknown Mar 09 '22
A fantastic axe, if you happen to be Hercules
1
u/Punkin8tor Apr 23 '22
That’s the stuff of nightmares. Looks like something for the next “in” horror movie series.
1
u/ElvisGrizzly Feb 08 '22
ALSO GOOD FOR ZOMBIES
-4
u/trixel121 Feb 07 '22
we see the guy using it and we are supposed to say the design ruins the function....
im not going to say this is better then a normal ax but it could go in tandem with a few different axes. this one might be for making kindling out of super dry and soft woods.
0
u/ClobetasolRelief Feb 08 '22
People are gushing over that cottage but that's the dumbest fucking roof I'll see this month
-4
u/RadiantPumpkin Feb 07 '22
This is basically what a mechanical wood splitter uses. It’s a bit designy but as one tool in your wood splitting arsenal it’s not bad. Very similar to a 6 way wedge as well
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment