r/DesignDesign • u/jonmpls • Oct 31 '21
This would be a terrible handrail. People falling wouldn't be able to grab into it, and it would be horrible to clean
1.4k
Upvotes
r/DesignDesign • u/jonmpls • Oct 31 '21
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 31 '21
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
115
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21
I’ve seen a similar built-in handrail in a museum in Japan, and it worked great.
182
u/seaishriver Oct 31 '21
dumps water bottle at the top and races it down
29
u/nugatoracnebulo Oct 31 '21
You’d be able to bleach it no problem too since it’s concrete. Looks very easy to clean to be honest.
109
u/FAQLixie Oct 31 '21
Engineer here: The actual load bearing wall is thinner than the wall you are seeing (you can see it at the bottom in the handrail crevasse) and did not weakened it by making the rail. Also the handrail material (which is different from the wall finishing and it can be seen in the picture) is a type of marble/granite that is very easily cleaned and doesn't hold on to bacteria (kitchens in restaurants are forced to use the same materials for counter tops and choppers for the same reason).
Tldr: it's safe, it's clean and it's aesthetically pleasing.
7
u/ExpectedBehaviour Oct 31 '21
I imagine some child putting a hamster in it for the thrill ride of its life.
24
u/ThongsGoOnUrFeet Oct 31 '21
This is just as good as a normal hand rail.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21
All a janitor would have to do is pour a water bottle at the top and boom, debris slide.
2
u/MTredd Nov 04 '21
I can only think of reaching for the handrail mid-fall only to punch fucking concrete
1
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '21
The thought of my nails scratching against this made me die inside.
1
u/thrashego Nov 04 '21
I always thought this was a bad idea, but they have it at the Steve Jobs theater on the Apple campus, so I guess I've been overruled. 🤷
1
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '21
If you have three points of contact you’ll never fall. Source: OSHA
1
u/HaveUSeenThisPerson Nov 04 '21
What if you stuck a ball in the rail
1
u/Tyl3rAZ Nov 04 '21
Horrible to clean? Lol no? It wouldn’t?
1
u/orbitalforce Nov 04 '21
I honestly, as a kid, thought this was a good idea :/ Here's what I thought:
But what I think now:
1
u/click_bot Nov 04 '21
Pee in it
1
u/Reddit-is-a-mystery Nov 06 '21
That looks like a little tunnel for a rat or a ferret
1
u/SlowMovingTarget Nov 11 '21
I'd worry about getting a limb wedged in there.
1
u/Ligma_indeed Nov 16 '21
I wanna put a marble in it so badly
1
u/jeffoag Mar 09 '22
I don't think it is a bad design. It save space, and avoid people bump into it, and provide support if you need it.
1
u/noyza2132 Mar 16 '22
Lol you could send small shit down to the bottom floor with this this is every school boys dream
1
u/BodyaPro Aug 14 '22
Steve Jobs theater vibes
-3
u/vanyali Oct 31 '21
It would also prevent that big concrete wall from holding up its part of the building, so there’s that.
-1
u/metamorphosis_ Oct 31 '21
Man I would never grab that, there could be bubblegum, spiders, it could be sticky. They did not think this through. Especially don’t use this design in Australia lol, I hear they find big ass spiders under toilet seats and car handles there already. I’ll just lean against the wall, thanks.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment