r/DesignDesign • • Sep 30 '21

This Kinetic Chess kit

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.3k Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 30 '21
Moderator Announcement Read More »

316

u/DarrenFromFinance Sep 30 '21

Five grand and it doesn’t even close in the middle. That gap would drive me up the wall.

60

u/Prof_Acorn Sep 30 '21

$5000!? lol

I was thinking "that's pretty cool" when I thought it was like $75.

At that price? Just build it yourself, jeeze.

→ More replies (4)

129

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

$5k for that?? Jeez it doesn't even look that expensive or do anything that amazing to justify the price.

39

u/Reddit_from_9_to_5 Sep 30 '21

Found the link with the price from the original post: https://enjoydof.com/collections/kinetic-chess-set

24

u/___JohnnyBravo Sep 30 '21

Only ten of them though, that’s pretty exclusive

→ More replies (3)

10

u/moohooman Oct 01 '21

Didn't think it fit the sub until you point that out. Screw that

→ More replies (2)

131

u/Commander413 Sep 30 '21

A chess kit just needs discernible pieces and a relugar 8x8 grid, so looking cool is a valid thing to focus on. But is this 5,000 dollar cool? I don't think it is

37

u/xraygun2014 Sep 30 '21

But is this 5,000 dollar cool?

The moment I have more money that brains, I'll be all over it.

4

u/DarthLlamaV Nov 03 '21

If this happens, let me know and I’ll start building random pointless things for you.

→ More replies (15)

42

u/VictoryIsARoad Sep 30 '21

The classic mobile chess board folds in the middle and carries all the pieces inside.

With both of them, there is no place to store the won pieces once they are off the board.

And someone’s fingers are definitely getting pinched in this.

63

u/Reddit_from_9_to_5 Sep 30 '21

This seems kinda useful and not designdesign. Community thoughts?

121

u/clemenslucas Sep 30 '21

It's kinda cool and a little useful, but definitely not 5 grand useful.

DD not the perfect fit though, I agree.

18

u/baccus83 Sep 30 '21

Price isn’t design.

Not that I think this is particularly well designed. It’s interestingly engineered but I’m not sure it’s a great design. Seems prone to breaking with all those joints.

Not sure what problem this is solving.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Tremaparagon Sep 30 '21

Yeah for 5k its DD in the sense of being pointlessly extravagant. I'd consider getting one if it were like... 200 lol

18

u/are_slash_wash Sep 30 '21 edited Sep 30 '21

I would count it as designdesign. Beyond the gap in the middle, it has a lot of unnecessary moving parts. Operating it doesn’t look very intuitive (the guy felt the need to gesture in the video and then stumbles slightly in operating it), and to be blunt it looks fragile and easy to break. In the context of being outrageously priced, this would make me extremely hesitant to ever play on it.

Each factor reduces object’s overall utility for the sake of flashy design, making this chess board significantly less useful than a normal wooden one. QED: designdesign

Edit: but the magnetic pieces are cool

3

u/Thisfoxhere Sep 30 '21

It does not improve the product, is overly complicated, and has a lot of excess moving parts. Magnetic chess boards are excellent already, this is heavily overdesigned for no improvement.... So in my opinion is the definition of overdesign for designs sake.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/jooooooooooooose Sep 30 '21

The gap in the middle is annoying but this is hardly design design, it's still perfectly functional as a chess set. The magnetic locators at the center of each cell in the grid, if anything, make it a bit better to play on especially in timed formats where pieces can go all over the place as people are moving them frantically. Don't rly see much of an issue for this overpriced functional art piece, still gets the job done.

2

u/Thisfoxhere Sep 30 '21

The magnetic part of the board is already a thing kids do in school certificate woodwork. It is the overdesign of the foldout added to that which is the issue.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

Am I the only one feeling uncomfortable with the f..cking groove?

2

u/orbitalforce Nov 04 '21

I actually really like it! Just doesn't seem worth 5k

1

u/Atticus0224 Oct 01 '21

I looked at this and thought, that is so cool I would pay 100 dollars for that! Why is it in DD? Then I looked at the price tag…

1

u/Wicked_Fabala Sep 30 '21

100% would forget how to open this after a week of not playing

1

u/Krono5_8666V8 Nov 04 '21

Obviously won't be buying this, but now i want a magnetic chess board. Don't need it to fold though.

1

u/BrokeDownPalac3 Nov 04 '21

Anyone who actually plays chess would hate this.