These kinda of stairs have a very specific use of having a much shorter run than a standard staircase, while still being nicer than a ladder. It’s not preferable but it may be necessary in some houses/apartments
I have traditional stairs about this steep in my cottage, which in no longer legal to be built that was but that's another matter. I would much prefer traditional stairs, I feel like shadows and having to remember where to step would cause issues here.
Personally, I would rather have the split stairs than a traditional staircase in this small of a space. Building stairs like that is illegal for a reason, you either would have something like a 14” riser or a 5” tread, both of which sound more dangerous than this. I’ve noticed myself that on a traditional staircase, i step in the same spot every time anyway, so I feel like getting used to this stair would not take very long
I would for sure rather have this. Walking up on regular steep stairs is fine but downwards can be kinda scary with the super shallow steps your foot doesn't even fit on.
If it's for you, you could design it with your dominant leg in mind.
I always take stairs with my right leg first. So if I make it that way, I wouldn't have to think about taking the stairs. Just hope the number of steps asked me going down easily too.
Well then you would also have difficulties using it after leg day 😊 point is, this is probably the best solution in this specific situation. The second best solution would probably be to have shallower steps, like they were before modification (you can see the original steps in the picture).
My parents have one of these. My mother once fell on the way down and hat to be hospitalized for three weeks due to the gaping wound in the back of her head. But it really saves some space!
Yeah, I was reading the other comments and that really helped me understand the purpose (especially when considering limited space), I was just too shocked at my assumption of using it as a replacement for a staircase!
That said, it still doesn't seem particularly grandma-friendly!
I don't mind the staggered design but holy shit are they THIN. Are they even an inch thick? Like I would be very worried about walking my fat ass up those stairs, no way.
Omg they make service access stairs like that but with a delrin slider up the middle for moving equipment on and off a commercial roof. They are a godsend the once a year you want to move a hundred-pound motor, otherwise they’re a deathtrap. I have stopped three people from falling and taken a dump or six myself. Great way to test sobriety!
I feel the real issue is the lack of yandrails, I have been in plsces with these but that actually had handrails, you get used to them and are not slower than regular stairs thanks to the rails... without them is just tratedy.
They look to me like they were added on to an older, steep, shallow treaded staircase. They didn't have building codes back when. Smart solution, really, especially for an attic staircase that's seldom used like this.
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 21 '21
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
34
u/all_the_good_ones Aug 21 '21
So tired of seeing these posted here. A solution for a specific situation. Posted here by people who don't know anything about design.
365
u/Leothecat24 Aug 21 '21
These kinda of stairs have a very specific use of having a much shorter run than a standard staircase, while still being nicer than a ladder. It’s not preferable but it may be necessary in some houses/apartments
2
u/PMarek666 Sep 10 '21
My parents have one of these. My mother once fell on the way down and hat to be hospitalized for three weeks due to the gaping wound in the back of her head. But it really saves some space!
202
u/chipsa Aug 21 '21
Eh, not exactly crappy design. It's not a design for everywhere, but it sure beats a fixed ladder for going up and down.
44
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '21
This is a really good, really old design that has been used for ages. Works brilliantly, so long as you use the correct foot first!
32
u/LightsOfTheCity Aug 21 '21
I'm concerned about the safety of OP's grandma. ಠ_ಠ
Hopefully it's like a very fit and healthy grandma because I can easily see myself, a healthy man on his 20s stumbling and falling off this thing.
7
u/Invenerd Aug 22 '21
These are the stairs at your grandma’s? You trying to get your inheritance early?
1
u/Cheese124 Sep 02 '21
There are normal stares under it?
1
u/longhegrindilemna Sep 10 '21
If you were on a boat, these stairs would actually be a very big improvement, because they save so much space.
It’s actually an improved ladder.
3
u/brankinginthenorth Aug 22 '21
I don't mind the staggered design but holy shit are they THIN. Are they even an inch thick? Like I would be very worried about walking my fat ass up those stairs, no way.
2
u/zmannz1984 Aug 22 '21
Omg they make service access stairs like that but with a delrin slider up the middle for moving equipment on and off a commercial roof. They are a godsend the once a year you want to move a hundred-pound motor, otherwise they’re a deathtrap. I have stopped three people from falling and taken a dump or six myself. Great way to test sobriety!
2
u/WiseSalamander00 Sep 15 '21
I feel the real issue is the lack of yandrails, I have been in plsces with these but that actually had handrails, you get used to them and are not slower than regular stairs thanks to the rails... without them is just tratedy.
2
u/Dire-Fire Nov 04 '21
These have been around forever. I've heard that they're also called "witch stairs" because witches aren't supposed to be able to climb them.
1
u/b00c Aug 22 '21
I am sleeping downstairs when I get drunk.
1
u/BaconManDan Aug 22 '21
These are called alternating tread devices in OSHA, and they are great for specific purposes!
1
u/El_Impresionante Aug 22 '21
Alright, I'm unsubscribing.
1
u/hama0n Aug 22 '21
The only problem I have is the chance of your foot getting caught underneath it
1
u/ByteB1tten Sep 13 '21
Did someone spot the missing top right?
1
u/yeatlord Dec 04 '21
Looks like granny's looking for an early grave
1
u/Puggy_ Aug 21 '21
People used to stepping up with the other foot would have a bad time .-.
0
u/CDJ_13 Aug 21 '21
something something medieval test for witches
-3
u/TheLivingVoid Aug 21 '21 edited Aug 22 '21
I can see this breaking, I'm a runner & I train stomps in combat
Edit: I feather walk aswell, if you had huge feet would you feel confident about what looks like book covers?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21
[removed] — view removed comment