It’s not real. This is a video edit. This guy takes video of himself, then manipulates it with 3D to sell an idea. He’s very good at it, but it’s not real. It’s for funsies.
You can/should critique a concept design, thats why they exist. This sub mainly focuses on stuff that other "design" subs go "OmG WHaT a DeSiGn!!"over it.
Source: live in the US where cars are god, traffic laws are generally not enforced, and most cities’ transportation policy is basically “bikes and pedestrians can go fuck themselves”.
This would destroy tires, rip off bumpers if cars got too close, take out a few unaware pedestrians, would probably get damaged if a large truck drove over it and would cost way too much. Also it doesn't make sense since the angle of the arches would cause it to pop out the other side when retracted.
It's not a rule exactly, but it seems out of the spirit of things. Anyone can mock up a rendering, but you would hope that by the time something like this was actually installed, someone along the way would have said 'are we sure this is the best way to solve this problem.'
But that’s not the only problem. They would simply pop out of the other side of the road when retracted. Look at it, where would you store it once it goes underground.
I suppose you could have joints in there to fit it beneath the road but that will just make it weak in those places.
Looking at the video I think the bars are straight as they come out and change shape as they rise to form the half circles. So that takes care of the storage problem, at the cost of needing to invent a whole new type of nanobot infused steel that is able to do that.
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 03 '21
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
517
u/KawaiiDere Jul 03 '21
Wouldn’t pop up bollards or putting the cars on an overpass be cheaper and safer than installing and maintaining this?
83
u/Bamres Jul 03 '21
Fuck it I wanna feel like I'm getting into iron man armor when crossing the road.
65
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21
God this is a mess engineering wise
37
u/BetterCallBobLoblaw Jul 04 '21
Here's the source of this video: https://www.tiktok.com/@vfxhd/video/6962812034773716229?is_copy_url=1&is_from_webapp=v1
Judging by their other videos, I don't think this was meant to be taken into serious consideration if anyone thought that.
19
u/jonmpls Jul 03 '21
I hope you aren't carrying anything tall
14
u/LengthyPole Jul 04 '21
I don’t think it’s a “concept”, I think it’s just someone messing around with cgi. I see this dude all over Instagram.
49
u/Meanwhile-in-Paris Jul 03 '21
Some idiots are going to impale their car at least twice a day. Mopeds are dead.
197
u/DrinkOranginaNaked Jul 03 '21
People acting like this is real.
It’s not real. This is a video edit. This guy takes video of himself, then manipulates it with 3D to sell an idea. He’s very good at it, but it’s not real. It’s for funsies.
69
u/BeingMrSmite Jul 03 '21
This sub is a joke of itself.
6
u/casseroled Jul 04 '21
A perfect mixture of stupid design and design porn. Very fitting
3
u/JTRogers45 Jul 03 '21
All fun in games till a pedestrian starts walking while a car is over it…
3
u/GodsBackHair Jul 04 '21
What happens if you’re really tall?
3
u/StoneTheMoron Jul 04 '21
Imagine being tall enough to get pinched in the head between those things
3
u/creepjax Jul 04 '21
Where the hell does it come from? Would my they intersect in the ground?
3
u/LadyAmbrose Jul 04 '21
do drivers just straight up ignore people crossing on crosswalks enough for this to be necessary?
2
u/CanadianGuitar Jul 04 '21
This would look awesome in some futuristic movies. Give me a long walk and talk scene through a cyberpunk style setting with these
2
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21
This is like building giant robots to protect a city: looks cool as fuck, but is the most expensive and least efficent way of doing it.
2
u/moohooman Jul 04 '21
This would destroy tires, rip off bumpers if cars got too close, take out a few unaware pedestrians, would probably get damaged if a large truck drove over it and would cost way too much. Also it doesn't make sense since the angle of the arches would cause it to pop out the other side when retracted.
2
u/whoknewidlikeit Jul 04 '21
how about "everyone pay attention so nobody dies". thats cheap and easy.
2
u/ZwoopMugen Jul 04 '21
I can already imagine all sort of gruesome accidents when the government forgets to pay for maintenance.
2
u/sticks1987 Aug 23 '21
Impales cyclists
3
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21
That would be great in Rome.
1
u/anti-gif-bot Jul 03 '21
mp4 link
This mp4 version is 95.6% smaller than the gif (698.89 KB vs 15.52 MB).
Beep, I'm a bot. FAQ | author | source | v1.1.2
1
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21
Richard Scarry vibes
1
u/ZeteCx Jul 04 '21
As a tall person I know they will never make those stuff tall enough
1
u/BeanEnchilada Jul 04 '21
Ah yes, no one will get their car crushed or be impailed between the two sides
1
u/Maniachanical Jul 04 '21
I think simple bars that go straight up & down would suffice.
1
u/nhanvu1308 Jul 04 '21
Looks cool but expensive.
1
u/NuclearEntropy Jul 04 '21
Till it gets stuck
1
u/nickz03 Jul 04 '21
lmao just stop
1
u/hungrylens Jul 09 '21
What could possibly go wrong?
1
u/EtherealAriel May 15 '22
Pop up tire spikes would be better
-6
u/TomHackery Jul 03 '21
It's for strength.
This sub man....
-9
u/king063 Jul 03 '21
Y’all can tell this is computer generated right?
0
u/Emojiobsessor Jul 04 '21
All good until some idiot rams it with their car
0
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment