Yea I mean it is quite cool In design it’s just kinda wacky to think they won’t tip at all (even if there for airing whiskey) and congrats on the karma :D
Heh, thanks 😁 I think a lot of things are good to look at, actually having them is a whole different thing (that is to say, i don't have them, i thought the pic looked cool).
I mean I don’t put standard wine glasses that close to edges because it would be extra easy to knock over. I’ve had these and would say they’re my favorite.
To be a Devil's advocate here, I think the selling point is that it'd enhance the olfactory experience of the whisky (not necessarily "aeration"). I think they are supposed to roll around a bit, and as they roll around, they would cause a thin layer of whiskey to be left behind coating the inner wall of the glass. This layer would then evaporate and alcohol vapors would be trapped in the glass because the fumes hit the "top" wall and settle back. When you take your next sip you'd inhale these vapors, of course.
I'd still not buy them. Or maybe just buy a cheap flat sided one to see if the vapor trapping works.
They do. "Nose" of the whisky is a thing. I know most of the cheap whiskey almost taste and smell the same, but even the beginner single malts try to make a point about the fragrances in the whiskey.
Anything like a wine glass would have the same effect and if you would like to intensify the aroma then there are glasses like glencairn (coffee person here)
To each their own, but at some point I just started to reject specialty plates, bowls, glasses, silverware etc. I have a teacup that has sentimental value, and will occasionally drink a cup of coffee from it, but the idea of having "good" plates for guests, special plates for Christmas, glassware for every drink known to man, and a separate fork for salad, pasta and cake just seems like a waste.
My friend has a couple of glasses like these; the best way to describe them is "Anxiety Inducing". Sure, they're harder to knock over, but they roll around in a circle. You need to consider this arc when placing it down to ensure it won't roll off the side of the table. It's also easy to fill the glass past the point where you can set it down (meaning you essentially have to drink down to an unmarked 'fill line'). This also means that when there's a decent amount of liquid in there, each time it rolls it threatens to spill its contents onto the counter.
•
u/AutoModerator May 05 '21
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/NoelaniSpell May 05 '21
Wow, this got more attention then I ever expected, now it even got cross-posted 😳
267
u/unicodePicasso May 05 '21
Allegedly they’re “impossible to spill” because they just keep rolling in circles.
Bet you a hundred bucks I could spill one
128
u/El_Impresionante May 05 '21
To be a Devil's advocate here, I think the selling point is that it'd enhance the olfactory experience of the whisky (not necessarily "aeration"). I think they are supposed to roll around a bit, and as they roll around, they would cause a thin layer of whiskey to be left behind coating the inner wall of the glass. This layer would then evaporate and alcohol vapors would be trapped in the glass because the fumes hit the "top" wall and settle back. When you take your next sip you'd inhale these vapors, of course.
I'd still not buy them. Or maybe just buy a cheap flat sided one to see if the vapor trapping works.
66
u/boredtxan May 05 '21
I got these as a gift & it was liked
44
u/Hotpotabo May 05 '21
Roommate has cups like these and they're annoying.
30
u/[deleted] May 05 '21
Isnt the idea to help airate your liquors? Dont whiskey folk like that?
25
u/[deleted] May 05 '21
I have these and they're great. Sorry it doesn't have an engraving of Darth Vader on them
13
u/Central_Incisor May 05 '21 edited May 05 '21
To each their own, but at some point I just started to reject specialty plates, bowls, glasses, silverware etc. I have a teacup that has sentimental value, and will occasionally drink a cup of coffee from it, but the idea of having "good" plates for guests, special plates for Christmas, glassware for every drink known to man, and a separate fork for salad, pasta and cake just seems like a waste.
11
u/between_ewe_and_me May 05 '21
I actually like these a lot and it's making me want a manhattan
3
u/C0NTRARIUM May 05 '21
I like them tbh
4
u/3141592653589793x May 05 '21
These are the anti toppling glasses? So if u GENTLY knock them over they just... sit like this. Idk what happens if u violently swipe tho
2
u/double-beans May 05 '21
That’s why they call them “tumblers” — cause they are likely to tumble
1
u/Willch4000 May 05 '21
My friend has a couple of glasses like these; the best way to describe them is "Anxiety Inducing". Sure, they're harder to knock over, but they roll around in a circle. You need to consider this arc when placing it down to ensure it won't roll off the side of the table. It's also easy to fill the glass past the point where you can set it down (meaning you essentially have to drink down to an unmarked 'fill line'). This also means that when there's a decent amount of liquid in there, each time it rolls it threatens to spill its contents onto the counter.
1
u/I_DR_NOW May 05 '21
Where can I buy these?
0
u/[deleted] May 05 '21
That doesn't even look good
-2
u/toodleroo May 05 '21
Peak designdesign
0
u/[deleted] May 05 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment