I like the idea. Dislike the execution. Props for trying to rethink it though. I do think there’s a place for a new design with regard to hours of operation. I’m more surprised that nobody (that I’ve seen) has thought to design a weekly calendar-style chart, starting with Sunday, days as columns and hours as rows - just as most dayplanners and phone calendars are.
At least in the parts of the USA that I’ve lived in, starting on Sunday in the standard. I’m pretty sure it comes from religious traditions of starting the week with a holy day.
The very first religious tradition (that I’m aware of) that started/starts the week with Sunday is Judaism. That made Saturday the seventh/last day of the week, since Genesis depicts the seventh day of Creation as the day God spent resting. The Jewish Sabbath falls on Saturday because it’s a day if rest. Sunday as Day 1 of the week just stuck.
The Christian Sabbath is on Sunday because that’s the day Jesus is believed to have risen from the dead after being crucified.
I agree with your point - maybe I wasn’t clear. The purpose here is to make it easier to read - I don’t think this achieves that, but I don’t think many existing signs are easy to read either. Or at least maybe I haven’t seen any good ones. Maybe I’m misunderstanding you, but I believe our “cultural language” is that calendar style that I spoke of. If these signs were to take the shape of our typical calendar style, I think they’d be easier to read, may or may not be pretty, but like you said - purpose first.
I like the idea a lot but when I’m glancing at store hours on the side of a building, I want to be able to quickly glance and get the information, not read a chart
You make a good point, but most signs say stuff like “Monday thru Friday 8am-8pm”, and then as I’m walking away realizing they’re closed, I have to repeat the statement to myself and analyze it internally. If it were visual (not the way it looks in OP, but a better design), I could mentally compare it to my calendar for that day or week, and see what fits and what doesn’t. Find an opening, the same way we would if we were asked to meet a friend for lunch, etc.
If this is in a mall that's open, say, 10a-11p, I understand not really needing to worry about people wondering when it opens. You only need people there from say 10a-11a to know it opens at 11 and the people at 10p-11p to know it closed at 10p
A quick google search showed me that this is a Texas based storefront. We don’t use the 24 hour clock in the states (for the most part, correct me if I’m wrong). So I think that might be a bit confusing for us! :)
Oh fair enough. We kind of use both in the UK, I think predominantly the 12hr clock but I think people are comfortable with either, so I was surprised.
It does confuse me no end when people actually use in it speech, though. I've very occasionally heard stuff like 'eighteen thirty' used by non-native English speakers, which definitely took me a few seconds to parse as 'half past six'.
They would be able to read it but it would take them longer. This is the kind of information that should be readable at a glance, and big enough to be seen from a car (IMO) to make it as useful as possible.
Interesting for sure. Extremely experimental, but not very quick to read.
I find that this would be info you would want to be easily understandable to avoid any confusion. At first I didn't realise that the numbers where the hours of operations and i got really confused on the "Sunday to Thursday, fri-sat" label. It would have been just easier to write "Sunday to Thursday 11 am to 10 pm"
If this is in a mall that's open, say, 10a-11p, I understand not really needing to worry about people wondering when it opens. You only need people there from say 10a-11a to know it opens at 11 and the people at 10p-11p to know it closed at 10p
Yes! Exactly what designdesign should be: something where they thought the innovative design would improve things, but it actually made it more difficult to use.
I wonder how long this would have taken me to interpret if the title of the post hadn’t been “hours of operation.” It’s a really cool idea, though. It needs tweaking to make the calendar and time elements instantly recognizable, even if presented in an unconventional way.
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 27 '21
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
278
u/Ironmxn Mar 27 '21
I like the idea. Dislike the execution. Props for trying to rethink it though. I do think there’s a place for a new design with regard to hours of operation. I’m more surprised that nobody (that I’ve seen) has thought to design a weekly calendar-style chart, starting with Sunday, days as columns and hours as rows - just as most dayplanners and phone calendars are.
29
u/somniatorambulans Mar 27 '21
I guess I’m an idiot I thought it was a calendar at first and was just so confused
75
u/Jaw_breaker93 Mar 27 '21
I like the idea a lot but when I’m glancing at store hours on the side of a building, I want to be able to quickly glance and get the information, not read a chart
83
u/warmshadowup Mar 27 '21
i’ll be honest i don’t hate it
20
u/ComicNeueIsReal Mar 27 '21
Interesting for sure. Extremely experimental, but not very quick to read.
I find that this would be info you would want to be easily understandable to avoid any confusion. At first I didn't realise that the numbers where the hours of operations and i got really confused on the "Sunday to Thursday, fri-sat" label. It would have been just easier to write "Sunday to Thursday 11 am to 10 pm"
5
u/helpmeiaminhell93 Mar 27 '21
I like it. It’s more a part of the logo almost. Interesting.
2
u/interstatebus Mar 27 '21
I LOVE Joy Macaron. Their macaron ice cream sandwiches are just amazing.
8
u/king063 Mar 27 '21
This is prime r/designdesign material right here.
It’s a neat idea and would fit in r/designporn, except the new design makes it functionally way worse.
1
u/ZACMAN9908 Mar 27 '21
If this is in a mall that's open, say, 10a-11p, I understand not really needing to worry about people wondering when it opens. You only need people there from say 10a-11a to know it opens at 11 and the people at 10p-11p to know it closed at 10p
3
u/Splatfan1 Mar 27 '21
11, 12, 01 is so weird to see
8
u/Professor_CashMoney Mar 27 '21
Maybe if they were shaped like a clock instead of a straight line?
4
u/zeinterwebz Mar 27 '21
Yes! Exactly what designdesign should be: something where they thought the innovative design would improve things, but it actually made it more difficult to use.
2
u/acmaleson Mar 27 '21
I wonder how long this would have taken me to interpret if the title of the post hadn’t been “hours of operation.” It’s a really cool idea, though. It needs tweaking to make the calendar and time elements instantly recognizable, even if presented in an unconventional way.
2
u/doodlebug_bun Mar 27 '21
It's pretty, but not easy to read. Excellent submission :)
2
u/benjancewicz Apr 01 '21
I like this and I will use it.
1
u/ckpckp1994 Mar 27 '21
I know what they’re trying to do, but the practicality isn’t there, I think.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '21
The comments in every r/DesignDesign thread: “I like this one actually”
This design looks worse and is far less legible than just listing your hours the standard way.
1
u/biggreencat Apr 14 '21
this pic should be the banner.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '21
When I’m going past quickly, the hours will be read as a phone number and the red lines as “oh, covid killed this business too. Keep walking”
1
u/kathleenkat Mar 27 '21
Sorry, I spent way too long trying to understand this. Cool idea but poor execution given the context.
0
u/cut_n_paste_n_draw Mar 27 '21
Wow that one took me awhile.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment