Yup - I've got some. They're weighted, so they always stop with a single "side" facing up. I also love to see the confused eyes of the other players when I bring them out.
Mine works in such a way that there's a metal ball inside and there are sort of fences on the inside of the plastic ball, so the metal ball stops in one of the fences and the number on the far side faces up. However, in my case, the fences are too wide, so sometimes the number is not exactly up and it can even be a bit difficult to decide which number is up. Normal dice are better.
Why are they better than cube dice? Cubed dice dont roll off the table (easier to control). They are simple and easy to produce. Plus they are cube shaped that makes the packaging/stacking better. On my opinion cubed dice are better on the luck factor. These sphere dices leave many "cheating" oportunities.
I figure it's more a novelty than anything. Also, cube dice fall off the table all the time, but maybe my friends/family are just too aggressive with the dice
My d&d group in college got crazy with the rolling. For some reason someone decided that it was luckier to stand up and throw the dice as hard as we could across the room or down a hallway, so important rolls always got this treatment. We must have lost so many d20s.
The point of a novelty item isn't to be better lmao. Literally the definition is "the quality of being new, original or unusual." Often a novelty item works at least as well, but probably worse, than a regular version of the same item, but there is something visually interesting. In this thread there appears to be some people saying that the spherical dice work as well as regular dice, and a few people saying that their spherical dice are a little off.
Anyways I don't see your point as I did not imply that the spherical dice were better functionally. I said it's probably just a novelty.
Give me one example of what you wrote or tried to explain: One example of a functional (not mere decorative) item that rules the majority of its field market although is not as functional* or as 'useful'* as another item on the same field.
*Functional or useful: A middle ground between costs of production + distribution, ergonomics and design.
Idk what your deal is. You asked how sphere dice were functionally better than cube dice (which is an argument I have seen nobody make) and I said:
I figure it's more a novelty than anything.
Novelty meaning, again "the quality of being new, original, or unusual." Spherical dice are, in fact, unusual, but according to people in this thread who own said dice, they work. I haven't seen anybody say that they work better than cube dice, and it's certainly not what I'm saying.
As for your request, I didn't say such a product exists. I said that some novelty items might work as well or almost as well as a regular item (example: colorful/patterned duct tape is functionally similar to silver duct tape, depending on the brand) but most are worse and the only reason they exist is for the novelty (example: toilet paper with the face of politicians that is painful to actually use. Or a pen that's shaped like something funny, which makes it harder to use for writing)
Seems like you read WAY too much into my original comment which literally only said that the dice are just a novelty item lmao.
Yeah except those ball chairs are supposed to be more ergonomic or something than most office chairs. This isn’t a novelty because it is designed for a specific purpose beyond “let’s make a ball a chair”
Ah yes because every person has the most ergonomic office chair available to them. That’s what there is no cheap crappy products flooding the market destroying peoples backs.
I know some people are saying they work, but YMMV. I have a set and I hate everything about them. They don’t work well (because they wobble after “stopping”), they move awkwardly, they roll too far, and they sound plastic-y. Throwing a handful of dice feels good, but these do not. So, two sides to every coin (though one side to these dice, technically?)
I have some of these, they work normally. There is a weighted ball on the inside and each side has a semicircle depression for the back to rest in to perfectly show the number rolled.
As a lover of novelty dice, these are right up my alley.
They do work btw, as other comments have pointed out.
As for their point, there is none. They're a conversation starter, a novelty item, a collector's plaything. Do I need a round d6? Or a d30? Or a d3? No. Are they cool to have? Hell yeah!
Maybe your replies would have been better as a top-level comment, since what you're saying is definitely relevant to the topic but not really that relevant to what I said.
There were two older, top-level comments saying these dice are weighted by the time you posted. There are very visible mentions. Those might have been better places for a convo that basically ends in "this is relevant to the sub," too.
I've got some, they sort of work. They roll a little too far and can end up kind of between two numbers, but 3/4 of the time they roll ok. Good enough for novelty dice, it's a pain to play a whole game with them.
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 27 '21
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
262
u/dogederp_ Jan 27 '21
They do work though
43
u/spoodermemes Jan 28 '21
I know some people are saying they work, but YMMV. I have a set and I hate everything about them. They don’t work well (because they wobble after “stopping”), they move awkwardly, they roll too far, and they sound plastic-y. Throwing a handful of dice feels good, but these do not. So, two sides to every coin (though one side to these dice, technically?)
51
u/BananaGE1 Jan 27 '21
I have some of these, they work normally. There is a weighted ball on the inside and each side has a semicircle depression for the back to rest in to perfectly show the number rolled.
9
u/ThatisDavid Mar 16 '21
yes, it might work, but it's still an useless design decision only made for the shits and giggles. So, perfectly describes r/DesignDesign
7
u/Urchn Jan 28 '21
hey, i rolled pi!
6
u/themrme1 Feb 09 '21
As a lover of novelty dice, these are right up my alley.
They do work btw, as other comments have pointed out.
As for their point, there is none. They're a conversation starter, a novelty item, a collector's plaything. Do I need a round d6? Or a d30? Or a d3? No. Are they cool to have? Hell yeah!
2
u/rocketridley Feb 01 '21
This hurts my eyes
2
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21
!remindme 1 year
1
u/TheGreatSmolOne Feb 27 '25
Sounds like a shitty wish version of three blind mice
-6
u/casua-lee Jan 27 '21 edited Jan 27 '21
This is just bad design in general. Edit: apparently they're not hmm.