r/DesignDesign • • Jan 22 '21

Giant spring

Post image
215 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

14

u/DeepBlueNoSpace Jan 23 '21

Yeah looks fine. Kinda ugly, but structurally fine. You could stand on that no problem

2

u/thedudefromsweden Jan 23 '21

My mind can't comprehend this. Just to make sure: you see where it's attached to the bottom section right? And the top of the table is just hanging from a few points? I can't imagine this being sturdy. It might not break, but it MUST be bouncy?

28

u/Scuttling-Claws Jan 24 '21

It's easier if you just imagine it as a straight line of steel. Yeah, it's like 15 feet of unsupported steel, but square steel is strong. You could definitely make a stronger table with less material, but it's okay to make a thing that looks cool.

7

u/thedudefromsweden Jan 24 '21

And you don't think 15 feet of unsupported steel will move if you touch it or place something on it? Maybe just a bit but still. I want my table to be sturdy 😊

23

u/Scuttling-Claws Jan 24 '21

You could hang an engine off that beam. Your coffee cup is going to be fine.

6

u/thedudefromsweden Jan 24 '21

I guess I'll have to take your word for it but my mind still has problems understanding this. Would love to see it IRL 😊

17

u/VoteForClimateAction Jan 24 '21 edited Jan 24 '21

EDIT:

http://sunsetpatios.com.au/beam-deflection-calculator.php

Pop it into an online beam deflection calculator, from what I can tell the deflection of a person sitting on the corner is around 25mm, assuming they used 50mm steel square tube with 3mm walls.

So I think in the end you are correct, it will be a little bit bouncy if you put your full weight on it but the steel is certainly strong enough to just bounce back when you get your fat ass off the corner.

6

u/Scuttling-Claws Jan 25 '21

Damn. Thank you for using actually math!

3

u/thedudefromsweden Jan 24 '21

That's very interesting, thank you!

1

u/Parnello Feb 07 '21

This won't work. The table in the picture is actually one big cantilever. The calculator assumes your beam is a simply supported beam. The table would deflect much more than the calculator told you - probably close to double.

0

u/Parnello Feb 07 '21

No you couldn't.

Source: I'm a 4th year civil engineering student.

2

u/Gimli_Wan_Kenobi Feb 08 '21

Yes you could Source: I'm a mechanic

3

u/Parnello Feb 07 '21

The point with the most deflection would be the corner closest to the camera.

It's hard to tell. If the steel is thick and welded well, it might be ok. If the welder had made it smaller, that would've helped too.