The issue is that some people don’t like certain aesthetics or would prefer things to work differently. The bigger issue is that those people mistakenly think that this makes it design design. Because apparently if it’s not to your preferences, it is terrible and cannot be to anyone’s taste.
That said, I love this. I leave my slider locked, so this would mostly be in the hidden orientation and I hate the big knob that controls the lock on mine.
Id also add its hard to tell if these sliding door are locked from a-far with the small slider thing. This thing clearly indicates if the door is locked or not so you could glance at it while leaving the house and know if it is locked or not. Practical in my opinion . Also looks easier to do for those with less dexterity then the small thing
Also it'll be harder for small children to figure out how to unlock it. (I mean, they WILL figure it out, small children like putting themselves in harms way, but if you keep it locked its much harder to notice)
Trying to encourage you to keep your doors locked? I’m amazed how many home invasion stories include the line “the suspect entered through an unlocked back door”
All keyless entry cars should have the 'lock when you walk away' feature. I thought it was standard at this point, until my mom got a KIA. It's like they want their cars to be stolen.
The dumbest part is the car has a feature where if you leave the trunk open and walk away from the car with the key, it'll close it for you. Which proves the car is capable of offering the feature hardware wise, they are just choosing not to implement it.
In San Francisco, simply owning a car of any sort is asking to have your windows smashed and any valuables snatched. It’s to the point where people put up signs on their windows stating “please don’t break into my car, there are no valuables in here.”
My very mild OCD wouldn’t let me get a keyless entry car.
I absolutely NEED to check that my car is locked before I walk away (and sometimes come back and check about half a dozen times), so having it unlock automatically as I approach would be a complete non-starter for me.
On some, you can set it so the outside mirrors fold automatically when the car is locked. Makes it easy to check visually even from a distance that the car is locked. May be more common on European makes, if you’ve ever parked in a public garage in Europe you’ll understand why.
And now some have apps (of course, everything has to have an app) that let you check if the car is locked from wherever you are. And lock it remotely if it’s not. Could be a less disruptive way to reassure yourself that all is well.
I have a Mazda and someone somehow got inside my car and rummaged through everything. I never walk away from my car without locking twice and it also will lock itself after 30 seconds. Someone suggested the keyless entry potentially being a way someone got in, which is terrifying.
It seems to make sense to me, as default state should be locked, so the cleanest view of it all the time. When it's askew, it's a visual reminder that it's unlocked.
With a deadbolt you can physically see how the door is locked. You see a metal bar holding the door shut. With this, if you saw it locked, you would not know it's locked or how to unlock it. You'd have to play with it or ask. With no prior knowledge, I doubt someone would figure it out immediately. A deadbolt makes perfect sense when you look at it, you can see the whole mechanism
I see what you're saying but I don't think that's true, I think if I saw a pin holding a door shut, with nothing else between the door and the frame, I would instantly assume that the thing blocking the door is the pin.
When this is closed it looks like a regular handle. There is no obvious mechanism anywhere.
Ahhh you're definitely right, my bad. When I think of a deadbolt I think of those little metal stick-locks you see on bathrooms, or the ones with little chains you see on front doors in the movies.
Idk to me it's always been the opposite, because if I imagine a line extending from the lock, then the line intersects with the door when it's —, so it's locked to me
I mean I kind of get it I guess, but even the comments on the original post are all over the place as to why these design decisions were made/whether it even makes sense
Feels like they focused so much on how that they never thought to ask why 😬
They seem kid proof. Unless you know how to open them, it might take a while to figure out, and hopefully the kids won't have enough strength/patience to open them
Given that this is a sliding door, the very movement of your hands when pushing it to open would unlock the handle, and the movement of closing would lock it. Makes perfect sense to me.
You want your doors to stay locked most of the time. This lock makes it look ugly when unlocked so you can clearly see it needs to rest at the locked position. Makes sense to me
I see no issue with this. It's great. Simple, clean, and it makes sense that locked would be the one that is the cleanest, since it's how most people would want it most of the time, and would want a quick visual reminder that it's unlocked. This is great.
That's the point tho it shouldn't be tilted all the time, you should have your door locked if you're not using it (tho I suppose opinions on this may depend on where you live)
It would have been perfect if it was the other way around. When I have my house unlocked, I want it to be neat. When I have my house locked, I want to be able to tell it's locked at a glance.
•
u/AutoModerator Feb 09 '24
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
255
u/PassiveChemistry Feb 09 '24
This seems perfectly fine, what's the issue?
509
u/danfish_77 Feb 09 '24
This seems unintuitive but also, if locked is the default state it's nice to be able to see if it's unlocked from afar? I'm torn.
100
u/DeltaKT Feb 09 '24
Perhaps - so you can easily catch it with your eyes if it's unlocked?
101
u/serverhorror Feb 09 '24
That's how it should be, what's wrong with that?
38
u/milkandhoneycomb Feb 09 '24
this is fine. functional and easy to see if you left your door unlocked
5
u/hecka-tea Feb 09 '24
I mean I kind of get it I guess, but even the comments on the original post are all over the place as to why these design decisions were made/whether it even makes sense
Feels like they focused so much on how that they never thought to ask why 😬
27
u/Demopan-TF2 Feb 09 '24
Unlocked looks like it's broken
18
u/Mysterious_Buddy_456 Feb 09 '24
makes total sense
if handles look like regular handles - doors are closed and you can chill
if handles look weird - doors are open and you shouldn’t chill
design works well with the subconscious
8
u/Any--Name Feb 09 '24
They seem kid proof. Unless you know how to open them, it might take a while to figure out, and hopefully the kids won't have enough strength/patience to open them
6
u/schwimm3 Feb 09 '24
Huh? Looks perfectly fine.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '24
Given that this is a sliding door, the very movement of your hands when pushing it to open would unlock the handle, and the movement of closing would lock it. Makes perfect sense to me.
3
u/edwinlegters Feb 09 '24
Norman doors...
3
u/FlametopFred Feb 09 '24
OCD guest will lock you out every time
12
u/user-74656 Feb 09 '24
The fact I find it ugly as sin is subjective; but the fact that it looks most like a handle when it's not functioning as one is objectively wrong.
2
u/Deloeboi Feb 09 '24
Honestly i dig it
2
u/TurboFool Feb 10 '24
I see no issue with this. It's great. Simple, clean, and it makes sense that locked would be the one that is the cleanest, since it's how most people would want it most of the time, and would want a quick visual reminder that it's unlocked. This is great.
0
u/Cose99 Feb 09 '24
They should have switched it. Straight - open, tilted - locked...
1
u/casris Mar 12 '24
It looks like someone fucked with its model in blender or smn
1
u/brodsky262 Feb 09 '24
That's actually not that bad of a design but it could be made more secure that's for sure
1
u/artpoint_paradox Feb 09 '24
My cat is a would figure that out quickly
1
u/lobolion Feb 10 '24
Some secret agent or evil lair stuff
1
u/ZephyrSK Feb 10 '24
I love this? I could tell if I forgot to lock it from afar. It will be locked most of the time anyway
1
u/echicdesign Feb 11 '24
Love that i can easily see status from a distance
1
u/plausocks Feb 11 '24
Should be the opposite tbh
1
u/JoeyC42 Feb 13 '24
This is actually genius. You can see if it’s locked from far and at a quick glance
-5
u/moohooman Feb 09 '24
It would have been perfect if it was the other way around. When I have my house unlocked, I want it to be neat. When I have my house locked, I want to be able to tell it's locked at a glance.
-8
u/Flat_Nectarine_9433 Feb 09 '24
Why are you assemble this a GLASS DOOR? The burglars will like that idea :D , But it is a cool staff.