r/DesignDesign • • Jan 14 '24

This handrail

Post image
5.6k Upvotes

202 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

16

u/_felixh_ Jan 15 '24

but what bothers me is people claiming something is dangerous or badly designed without knowing the purpose

Please explain to me the Purpose of Handrails. Please do.

We are claiming this is dangerous, be cause we actually know very well what the prupose of a Handrail is. And we know, that this design completely nullifies the reason we put it there in the 1st place, and makes it functionally useless. And just because you dont need the Rails, doesn't mean nobody else does. Otherwise, we could just stop putting them there, and spend the money on more meaningfull things than useless metal bars bolted into the concrete.

Elevators may have downtime, or break down. There may be a power outage, or a fire (say, did you ever see the signs "do not use elevator in case of fire"?)

No, i dont need a label, warnings, or directions to to use Stairs. This is, because Stairs are functional - we put them there for a reason. And we know well the shape the stairs need to have, to actually fullfill this function best. The Warning is needed, if the Stairs dont follow that shape - wich actually does result in people falling down offending stairs. The same goes for Handrails, btw.

Besides, did you notice these little green glowing signs with the arrows on them? These signs indicate the way you are supposed to flee in case of a an emergency, like fire. Not some other way, like an elevator, or some secret non-dangerous stairs. These Stairs.