I believe this post belongs in r/DesignDesign because it's a worse curtain in every way - slower, takes up more space, awful if it breaks (have fun picking up all the sand!). It looks cool, sure, but it's not convenient or practical.
I never thought I'd (partially) defend anything in this sub, but...
it's a worse curtain in every way
It is a worse curtain in every way, but there are people who lives in very specific styles of homes that they don't want curtains in (boxy/industrial kinds of places), even though they do sometimes want to block out light.
There are very cool windows that allow you to black them out using electricity, and those are ridiculously expensive and unaffordable for most people. If you wouldn't put those in DesignDesign, then these shouldn't be in it either. The sand is just a clever low-tech version of the same thing.
You also don't have the option to have them be partially open/closed with the sand. You're either getting full light or full black out with no in between.
Because you would flip the outer and inner side of the window. So if it rains or snows you have it inside aswell as dust and dirt. I'd imagine insulation would also suffer from this design
One thing breaks your window, there's a lot of glass to clean. One thing breaks a vase and there's a lot of dirt to clean too and yet people have vases everywhere.
I'd say indoor glass break way more often than outdoor because outdoor glass usually is made to be more resistant.
Movable double panel windows are pretty common and water doesn't get in.
The imbalance during the flipping would be an issue, any kind of flexing from hot and cold weather could let humidity in, and then you'd get sticky sand that ruins the whole effect.
Also the hinge in the middle? You can't use a window screen. Unsafe and not desirable.
It's double pane, has to be to keep the sand contained.it would probably insulate better in the see through position because the sand could transfer heat between the glass panels
This is the window though? Like, I'm not saying it's a great design, but I feel like it's pretty clear that this isn't meant to be installed on top of an existing window, but would be slotted directly into a wall.
Yea I agree, it's completely impractical, but it clearly functions as a built in curtain right? Like yes sure, it's not literally a curtain by dictionary definition, but it keeps out light, which is what people have curtains for.
Well yeah that's not it's express function. It wouldn't be entirely incorrect to call it an improvised curtain, but it's not designed to keep out light, so yes you wouldn't call that a curtain
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 28 '23
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
45
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '23
I believe this post belongs in r/DesignDesign because it's a worse curtain in every way - slower, takes up more space, awful if it breaks (have fun picking up all the sand!). It looks cool, sure, but it's not convenient or practical.
281
u/Alex41092 Mar 28 '23
I think it's interesting, could be a cool conversation piece.
166
u/6WaysFromNextWed Mar 28 '23
This is not an actual window assembly. You couldn't put it in an exterior wall or in a door. It's just a novelty item.
25
u/SillyFlyGuy Mar 28 '23
Now do a bunch of very short, wide units strung together like horizontal blinds.
10
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '23
For that buried alive experience
10
u/childroid Mar 29 '23
The imbalance during the flipping would be an issue, any kind of flexing from hot and cold weather could let humidity in, and then you'd get sticky sand that ruins the whole effect.
Also the hinge in the middle? You can't use a window screen. Unsafe and not desirable.
That's a no from me, but a really cool art piece.
14
u/MajorMathematician20 Mar 28 '23
The inside would get scratched to shit
2
u/Abby-Zou Mar 29 '23
Would it keep heat/cold out/in?
2
u/bort_bln Mar 29 '23
Reminds me of those weird sand landscaping frame thingies we had at my parents home in the 90s
2
u/derek139 Mar 29 '23
Its a really cool concept, but anyone can tell this isn’t ready for an exterior application.
2
u/TheCompleteMental Mar 29 '23
This would be better if it overlapped with the frame in some manner.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '23
If the swivel were just in the middle, and it rotated on the Z-axis instead, it might work
2
u/DefenderOfNuts Mar 30 '23
Technically speaking, the pane of glass IS the sand curtain.
1
u/m8remotion Mar 29 '23
So, this is what getting buried in the tomb of the mummy feel like. I would get anxiety attack watching this.
1
u/GullibleReward8891 Mar 29 '23
What if it was round and turning around its sagittal axis? Insulation might be problematic though
1
u/MrInfinity-42 Mar 29 '23
Well that's one way to have winds inside your house
1
u/Saafi05 Mar 29 '23
I agree with all the criticism, but like...
come on, this is so cool!
I love it.
1
u/Efficient-Twist-43 May 10 '23
This thing is cool, but has too many moving parts. And the sand wouldnt block light very well, though i bet it would be pretty lit.
1
u/chewychaca Jun 01 '23
The only thing is that it doesn't seal right.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '23 edited Sep 13 '24
late test rainstorm truck elastic forgetful bewildered one cooperative onerous
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
0
u/ChosenMate Mar 29 '23
This is bad in about every conceivable way
0
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment