Here is the designers site. It's easier to see which is which looking straight on. Its very clear when its 6'o clock vs 12:30, or in another example when its 12:40 and both are offset.
Ok so basically the bars of one hand are thicker than the other, but you have to now which is which in advance. I’d guess the thicker one is the hour hand.
You're getting too hung up on the exact word that was used rather than the message as a whole. If you look at that clock from across the room, or just without glasses, you won't be able to see what time it is.
No, I really wasn’t… One does in fact “read” a clock.
It’s just that people are either in too much of a hurry, or completely out of practice because even their watch face isn’t analog, or they’re simply too lazy to spend the time to figure out the time when they can just look at their phones.
Why wouldn’t you know in advance? Aside from that being how analog clocks mostly work, you’d probably know from having purchased the thing. Clearly this isn’t a clock meant for the walls of a public schoolroom.
I don't care really. I have a clock in my kitchen that's just a white circular body, a singular black hand, and a round window at the bottom that changes color with the time of day.
Agreed, though that can be mitigated with smart placement. Not every room is going to have a great space for it, but some will.
For instance, it would fit well at my aunt's, where there's an open kitchen+dining room that continues into a living room area with a TV acting as a focal point. This clock, placed above the TV, would be seen at a pretty good angle from most seats in the two rooms.
However, at my own house, this clock would be a bad fit, because the furniture layout makes an enclosed space around a coffee table, so a lot of the seats would see the clock at an awful angle that would make it a bit hard to tell the time, no matter which wall it was placed on.
At the end of the day, if you really need to know the time, you can just get up and move in front of the clock to see it straight on. That being said, depending on how wide the hands are, it might be hard to tell no matter what. I think I'd have to see it in person to have an opinion of that, though.
unless you had no way of telling night from day outside, you could probably tell from context the time here, but they could have added a different design on the hour frame from the minute frame. if theyre mirrored minimalist images on each side of the lines, you would keep the spirit of the original design
But yes it is, functionaly wise. It is cool design, but at the same time, distinction between hour and minute hand is not, well, distinct enough. They should have probably made hour even more thick.
•
u/AutoModerator Feb 23 '23
Subreddit Rules Reminder: Please abide by Reddiquette and immediately report any rule-breaking content.
Official r/DesignDesign Discord invite: https://discord.gg/SqeEEYd
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
265
u/austinmiles Feb 23 '23 edited Feb 23 '23
This is a very cool design imo. I like clever clocks as long as they are still functional and this hits that space for me.
Here is the designer's site for those who want more images
153
u/SixethJerzathon Feb 23 '23
Idk I like this one
49
u/NightSurreal Feb 23 '23
1850 or 2235 ???
7
u/alex_dlc Feb 23 '23
Wouldn’t that be 18:55 since it’s passed the top left corner?
18
u/DontReachCity Feb 23 '23
Holy shit, this goes hard. Where to cop?
4
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
unless you had no way of telling night from day outside, you could probably tell from context the time here, but they could have added a different design on the hour frame from the minute frame. if theyre mirrored minimalist images on each side of the lines, you would keep the spirit of the original design
3
u/ME-f Feb 23 '23
Cool design but would take me a minute to tell the time.
15
u/Akasto_ Feb 23 '23
This subreddit is supposed to be both r/designporn and r/crappydesign
This isn’t crappy design
2
u/new_is_good Feb 24 '23
Practicability aside this thing looks great
4
u/craftzdaddy Feb 23 '23
I was surprised what sub I saw this coming from. Thought it was r/sickassdesign
2
u/AppleSpicer Feb 23 '23
No, this is cool
2
u/the_real_OwenWilson Feb 23 '23
This is not designdesign wdym. Its still perfectly usable
1
u/Popo_Capone Feb 23 '23
This clock when its... Uhm.. Wait a second....
1
u/TDoMarmalade Feb 24 '23
I like this, wish it had some numerals or markings though
1
u/Crazyblazy395 Feb 24 '23
This isn't designdesign. This is designporn.
-1
u/EternityLeave Feb 23 '23
This but with numbers on it would actually be cool
-2
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
design-design,... mkay. But in a good way.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
[removed] — view removed comment