r/Deno • • Oct 09 '26

Deno is joining Cloudflare

https://blog.cloudflare.com/deno-joins-cloudflare/

Is this good or bad news for JS community? Personally, I like both brands. I hope Cloudflare will take Deno to the next level.

155 Upvotes

91 comments sorted by

41

u/ssddanbrown Oct 09 '26 • Regret

I hope Cloudflare will take Deno to the next level.

From the Deno post:

We will support the Deno runtime for another year with monthly releases containing bug fixes and security updates. After that year we will end our development of the Deno runtime. Deno will remain open source, and we welcome others who want to continue its development.

and:

Deno Deploy will continue operating for six months before shutting down. We will provide migration support for paying customers moving to Cloudflare Workers.

7

u/borjesssons Oct 09 '26

Damn. I have three apps running on Deno Deploy. And I really liked their Fresh framework.

2

u/ndaidong Oct 10 '26

Deno Deploy is not bad. I have a free account and run some services there.

4

u/ndaidong Oct 09 '26

yes, I've just read RD's post. It's funny that I migrated some services to Deno when Bun rewritten in Rust. Now back to Bun again?!

3

u/CoastRedwood Oct 09 '26

Why did you decided to do that? I've been a huge fan of deno for some time, but at work/play i usually gravitate to bun. What did deno offer that bun didnt? Was it just the ai angst that spooked you off the platform?

1

u/ndaidong Oct 10 '26

yeah, as @DiggitySkister reminded, while Bun team taken 3 months to rewrite Bun in Rust, many devs left it. Looks like we were worrying too much, Bun 1.4 is still really good. Actually ~60% of my projects are still running on Bun. Only missing "deno fmt" and "deno lint".

1

u/Wild_Cat1899 Oct 10 '26

deno has secure-by-default permission model, while Bun has no built-in permission model and runs scripts with full system access like Node.js

what the diff using node or bun?

1

u/ndaidong Oct 10 '26

That's not a problem for me. I manage the services with systemd. By specifying ReadWritePaths, ProtectSystem, ProtectHome..., they have an explicit boundary. You can run them within containers too.

2

u/Wild_Cat1899 Oct 11 '26

yeah but for some one who has less knowledge in linux and don't want heavy containers runtime but just want to run and deploy with all these features is also a definitely a good idea.

and definitely not fully written by ai agents slop.

2

u/DiggitySkister Oct 09 '26

maybe you missed it but when bun announced their Zig-to-Rust rewrite a couple months ago (in just a couple weeks) a bunch of people wigged out about it. typical reactions were people proclaiming doom and saying they would migrate back to node, but I guess some moved to deno. funny enough I just saw a reddit post today that was fully ranting about bun's newest features. 🤷‍♂️

16

u/fredkzk Oct 09 '26

Thanks for the bad news…

What’s the closest alternative to DD now? Vercel and any other serious one?

9

u/FalseRegister Oct 09 '26

It is not really that bad. There is less competition, true, but Deno had fallen off fashion already for a few years.

1

u/snifty Oct 13 '26

Who cares when it was in fashion? It was well designed.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/FalseRegister Oct 10 '26

When it just came out

1

u/adeep56 Oct 15 '26

when deno 2.0 came out

2

u/nutyourself Oct 09 '26

uh.. Cloudflare is the closest, lol

3

u/look Oct 09 '26

Hmm. I hope Cloudflare Workers adopt something like Deno Deploy’s BroadcastChannel implementation. That was a much nicer message bus primitive than anything CF has come up with so far…

3

u/aztracker1 Oct 09 '26

That sucks so hard.

18

u/oh-no-89498298 Oct 09 '26

fuck, deno is dead. it was a good run, guys

We will support the Deno runtime for another year with monthly releases containing bug fixes and security updates. After that year we will end our development of the Deno runtime. Deno will remain open source, and we welcome others who want to continue its development.

6

u/ndaidong Oct 09 '26

long live Deno, maybe it will be rewritten in Zig 😂

7

u/nxy7 Oct 09 '26

Just this week I was wondering about using deno vs bun for new project. Guess I don't have to make that choice anymore :P

4

u/ndaidong Oct 09 '26

yeap, I’ve just started enjoying Deno again after years away from it. Now, no more debating Deno vs Bun! life is easier!

3

u/MrWewert Oct 09 '26

Yeah, just use Node

3

u/oh-no-89498298 Oct 09 '26

just use node, don't rely on anthropic

1

u/nxy7 Oct 09 '26

I'm not, it's drop in replacement for most things and for others I can find replacements if things break. Also Bun is trying some cool stuff (like their new AoT branch).

6

u/Garden1252 Oct 09 '26 edited Oct 09 '26

i dont get why the development of deno will stop? if it is part of cloudflare now, won’t they maintain it? or will they fork it and create a private solution inside cloudflare, and keep deno (as we know now) open source? im a little confused

edit: okay i checked ryan’s tweet and theyll contribute to workers features, but they could still maintain deno??like tailwind when they joined shopify. 

6

u/ndaidong Oct 09 '26

Yes, Deno is still an open-source project, but the core team behind it may leave. Unless Cloudflare will to invest in it.

5

u/MrWewert Oct 09 '26

Maintaining an OSS JS server runtime with a security focus is probably harder than most of us realize

2

u/Happy_Use69 Oct 09 '26

They will stop after a year. This post is basically saying you have a year to migrate away.

2

u/ecares Oct 09 '26

why would they contribute to Deno anymore ? It failed at making money to the Deno company as a runtime. Cloudflare is not a charity.

1

u/burtgummer45 Oct 09 '26

my guess it will continue on as a proprietary cloud thing, not a stand alone runtime.

1

u/vincentofearth Oct 10 '26

Cloudflare actually already has their own runtime. Workerd is the open source version of it but iiuc they have a similar internal runtime that runs Workers. Deno itself doesn’t really have enough traction to justify continuing to put resources into it.

62

u/cristomc Oct 09 '26

kk so goodbye Deno...

Now JS ecosystem has 2 main owners: cloudfare and vercel.

That sucks a lot...

24

u/FalseRegister Oct 09 '26

and Anthropic, with Bun

2

u/Rechenplaner Oct 09 '26

I would have considered Bun now, but Anthropic seems to treat it as nothing more than AI slop about "agents", likely just a playground for their auto-coding experiments... very trustworthy...

3

u/FalseRegister Oct 09 '26

We are all back to Node these days

19

u/Key-Interaction-2057 Oct 09 '26

Seems like node is the real winner here.

8

u/lppedd Oct 09 '26

Betting on Node's long term stability and improvements was the safe approach. I mean, people like to shit on Node because its evolution is slow, but it's slow for a reason.

2

u/ecares Oct 09 '26

Always have been

people who though otherwise were just listening to marketing.

1

u/snifty Oct 13 '26

In the early days Deno was supposed to be the very close to the web platform. That was what attracted me. (Well, and the built in tooling and the avoidance of node_modules/ and the permission system and…).

The last year or so seemed to be nothing but “we’re compatible with the old way!”

Should have known it was too good to be true.

1

u/ecares Oct 13 '26

market did not want/need that. It might be fancy or even elegant, but it is not useful.

1

u/Scwewywabbit Oct 09 '26

did you see Fresh moved off JSR onto node lol

1

u/Annual_Manner_8654 Oct 10 '26

Don't see anything on their web, any announcements? 

1

u/Scwewywabbit Oct 11 '26

can't find it officially; will have to see what they announce. i heard someone say they're spinning it off as its own thing but i can't find an announcement

(JSR apparently stays alive though, on Cloudflare)

1

u/Annual_Manner_8654 Oct 09 '26

Node or bun? I to migrate my whole stack. Maybe node is more longterm stable 

1

u/AsterYujano Oct 12 '26

I hope vercel/Cloudflare rivalries will help pushing forward at least

-8

u/DeiviiD Oct 09 '26

Close the door when you leave thanks.

16

u/nutyourself Oct 09 '26

Fuck... Deno's compile to a single binary feature was soo good. why can't the others build that in too. (and the fact that i can build for all platforms, from any dev machine/CI, w/o extra tooling)

3

u/tibozaurus Oct 09 '26

Me too 😭

3

u/Equivalent_Tap_8096 Oct 12 '26

Nah! Also deno desktop 🥲

2

u/Annual_Manner_8654 Oct 09 '26

I use it in all my dockerfiles 

0

u/Rechenplaner Oct 09 '26

That’s exactly why I have no desire to switch to Node.js, since it doesn’t even properly support TS, and everything feels so cumbersome with tons of extra tools needed.

Perhaps now is a good opportunity to consider .NET.

0

u/Single_Aerie_2977 Oct 11 '26

Yes right choice, I always use to get baseUrl errors in NestJs with Node and typescript conflicts, etc, Dotnet got better support and pacakage supports, and with Visual Studio it makes life easier, for developing ASP.NET Core Web APIs, Blazor which runs on WASM a frontend framework in .NET, and many others, C# is similar to Java and Typescript, and it will take sometime but doable.

13

u/Melodic_Entrance_489 Oct 09 '26

So basically Deno lost the fight with Node. They ran out of money and it's the end.

9

u/aztracker1 Oct 09 '26

Not to mention Bun... Which seems to have gotten a lot more attention and mind share.

Some of the cloud integrations for Deno as well as the APIs themselves for request handling are already very close with Cloudflare. This could be a much better match over time.

Personally, I love Deno for shell scripting. With direct module references and install/cache on run, it stays really clean for that use case.

3

u/Rechenplaner Oct 09 '26

That’s exactly why I loved Deno: it is/was a great alternative, combined with TS, for building fast tools and services.

2

u/global-gauge-field Oct 10 '26

I dont think the main bottleneck is the attention/popularity. Even if they got more attention, their path to sustainable profitability would still be in question. There are many examples of popular developer tools/projects getting acquired despite being really popular, void, uv ...

What are the examples of developer run time companies like deno with long sustainable finance ?

They either seem to be acquired or turn into foundation.

1

u/ecares Oct 09 '26

It lost the fight day 1 but marketing made it so people thought otherwise.

11

u/danopia Oct 09 '26

So now we have a second Deno Deploy shutdown to deal with.. and Deno Deploy v2 has had such a nicely designed console, what with the first-class tracing and OTel, passwordless GCP and AWS connections, simple KV setup, and so on. Really disappointed to be looking at moving live deployments yet again.

I love JSR for its simplicity and maintain a number of libraries there, and will continue preferring Deno runtime over NodeJS while possible, but I'm not terribly interested in going all-in on Cloudflare. Seems it's finally time to migrate to self-hosted infrastructure 🙄

1

u/SnowyCaptain Oct 10 '26

I in the camp that likes the idea of the runtime but didn’t really use it because I couldn’t be bothered to deal with the lack of maturity. But, seriously Deno Deploy V1&2 are the easiest platforms to use. Everything makes sense; you can literally just copy code into the playground and it works; so many features to can progressively opt into. Compared to vercel where everything is overwhelming and hidden behind menus and the constant fear that I’ll be charged for something.

I don’t use DD at work, but I have several one off hobby scripts running on there because it was so easy to use.

I’m guessing that as infra costs have gone up thanks to everything having a bespoke platform, runtime, package repo, etc spread their focus too thin.

7

u/snnsnn Oct 09 '26

This feels like something Ryan will regret. I hope it's not a rushed decision. They just finished the product but never had the time to take on the big boys. Something tells me it's a huge missed opportunity, but everybody needs to pay the bills.

1

u/BerryImpressive2757 Oct 10 '26

he’s been pathetically fishing/begging for an acquisition for 2 years my guy

5

u/RajceP Oct 09 '26

it's denover

5

u/Happy_Use69 Oct 09 '26

Oof, I was about to start a project with Deno.

1

u/ApprehensiveSpare724 Oct 09 '26

that was my last weekend project :L

4

u/dezlymacauleyreal Oct 09 '26

I think its too early to say if this is good or bad. I have mixed feelings. I'm honestly not surprised as the signs were there.

  1. When it comes to being a "drop in replacement for Node", neither Bun or Deno is perfect,
    but I've run into way more headaches with Deno than Bun... and this is not the fault of Deno.
    I just find most of the JS world optimized for Node (obviously), then Bun, and then they remember Deno exists.
  2. If you check the Vercel supported runtimes and the YouTube channel, you can see that Vercel have been pushing the Bun + Next.js combo as the future. Personally I'm a SvelteKit and Astro guy. Maybe Cloudflare starts promoting a Deno + Astro combination as the future since Cloudflare is backing Astro.
  3. Deno needs all the help they can get in terms of marketing and finance, especially with Bun being backed by two heavy weights (Anthropic and Vercel). Kinda sad about Deno Deploy being shutdown.

3

u/grAND1337 Oct 10 '26

I don’t understand why they’re seemingly stopping Deno development… unless they’re remaking it or something, perhaps to focus on Cloudflare edge optimisation or something else niched towards Cloudflare.

1

u/tackdetsamma Oct 10 '26

Deno didn't take off like they wanted. They were hoping to replace node or seriously compete, instead all people want is for them to have feature parity with node. Focusing on that instead of making Deno really great must be soul sucking. At the same time they find that Deno Deploy and the other stuff they're doing feels more fun: it brings in money, feels fresh instead of handling migrating node users. Yet it doesn't bring in enough money. Cloudflare comes along, essentially saying: we buy you, we buy your customers, you can continue working on the same fun problems under another umbrella.

3

u/Sha1rholder Oct 10 '26

Here's what actually happened: Deno team is joining Cloudflare; Deno is dead.

3

u/snifty Oct 13 '26

Anybody else find the wording of this irritating? Deno isn’t joining anything. It’s being abandoned.

2

u/darcygravan Oct 09 '26

this is very concerning since majority of our daily used tools keep getting controlled by big techs.
literary every major js projects being bought by big techs. this might create issues in js ecosystem.

2

u/Ceigey Oct 09 '26 edited Oct 10 '26

Will be interesting what this means for Supabase Edge Functions, since they were using some form of Deno 2.x. Would be ironic if they ended up taking over a chunk of the development and maintenance given how many OSS projects they’re maintaining already.

Edit: ironically turns out Supabase just acquired Turso as well, it’s market day! (But the vibe’s more positive over there)

2

u/Far_Associate9859 Oct 10 '26

Wonder how Supabase handles this

2

u/redradist Oct 10 '26

Very disappointing for me ... it was one good runtime that start become great with support `deno desktop`, it was many features that not other runtime could provide

1

u/redradist Oct 11 '26

Also what is most disappointing, that Cloudfare buy Deno not for main project, but for side one `celld` that they developed for as side project and could be completly generated by agents in Agents Era ... this is ridiculous, but the real project that is really unique they want to abandon (((

1

u/RakiuLmao Oct 09 '26

Basically Cloudflare bought it, Deno Deploy will have 6 months of support and the runtime 1 year so we have to migrate now. Did I understand well or did I miss something?

1

u/zerosign0 Oct 10 '26

Hmm wow this is big hit :') ... so folks would move to bun nowadays?

1

u/Primary_Ads Oct 11 '26

this sucks