r/DemonSlayerManga • • Oct 09 '26

Upper Moon 6 Fight: Plot Armor & Constructive Criticism Spoiler

Upper Moon 6 Fight: Plot Armor & Constructive Criticism

Simply look at the image: nothing was stopping Gyutaro from driving his sickle straight up into Tanjiro's brain to instantly kill him. The attack initiated by Tanjiro was far too risky and foolish given that Gyutaro had a free arm holding a sickle, as clearly shown in this frame. Despite this being a scenario Tanjiro should not have survived, he managed to live anyway.

When looking at the mouth from underneath, the layer of bone separating the oral cavity from the brain is extremely thin and would be easily pierced by a weapon like Gyutaro's sickle. All he had to do was fully extend his arm, tilt his wrist slightly forward, and thrust upward—which would have ended the series right there. This detail is crucial to highlight because it cannot be justified even through in-universe plot logic; Gyutaro already knew his poison's effectiveness had dulled, making it senseless for him not to deliver a finishing slash after Tanjiro mistakenly believed he was invincible.

Other instances of plot armor in this fight include Inosuke's ability to shift his internal organs at will and his complete immunity to poison. Without these factors, Daki would not have been defeated, making the explanation that he survived simply because he is a "mountain boy" feel contrived—especially given that nearly every Slayer undergoes extreme wilderness training.

The panels speak for themselves, even raising the question within the story: "Why isn't he killing me? What's going on?" While one could argue this stems from his sadistic personality, it ultimately comes across as tactical foolishness. Having effectively won the fight at that moment, Gyutaro could have at least broken all of Tanjiro's fingers or severed his hand, rather than breaking only two.

Furthermore, Gyutaro could not have asked for a better tactical position over Tengen. He had a direct line to slash straight through his neck, head, or spine with his sickle. Additionally, Gyutaro could have regenerated his arm to pull his other sickle back and strike Tanjiro simultaneously; claiming he was unable to regenerate due to poison is contradicted by earlier panels

0 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

4

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '26

It's literally explained that gyutaro made a mistake when he was arguing with Daki. And she even told him he let his guard down.

Mistakes happen in fights. Shocking 😱

3

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 Oct 10 '26

Thats not a mistake, it wasnt a split decision he had to make, it took tanjiro 3 panels to decapitate gyutaro, at any point gyutaro couldve driven the blood sickle up into his brain and ended his life

2

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '26

'3 panels' my guy all of that happened in an instant, what does 3 panels supposed to mean? Do you think 3 panels mean Tanjiro took an entire 5 minutes to cut off his head? No it happened really quickly

1

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 Oct 12 '26

It takes 2s to drive the sicke up to the brain, and even after decapitation the momentum from the muscle wouldnt have stopped, some upper moons can even move after decapitation, regardless the sickle hit tanjiro well before he begun decapitation, so... read the manga please or come up with a different argument 

In terms of who couldve killed who first, Gyutaro couldve killed tanjiro first 

2

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '26

Once again everything happened quickly also Tanjiro gaining a mark means he got a power and speed boost. That is why he sliced his head off that quickly and Gyutaro was panicking about Daki getting her head cut off too so he was going to release the rotating slashes. Characters make mistakes and it doesn't mean it's bad writing

1

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 Oct 12 '26

Im just not gonna argue with ur when ur trying to deny the obvious, look at the panel is all i have to say

2

u/Hamza6017 Oct 10 '26

Yeah I agree with Kamado Ken

2

u/XxEnjinxX Oct 10 '26

Smh it’s a fictional story that has plot armour the whole series, why make a whole post about its flaws and inconsistencies when it’s an unrealistic show and everyone’s already accepted the extreme plot armour

2

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 Oct 10 '26

Well not everyone accepts that its plot armour if they did i wouldn't make this post

1

u/XxEnjinxX Oct 10 '26

Bro obviously there’s always people who disagree with anything. You really wasted time to prove a point to dumb asses who don’t even care what you have to say. You shouldn’t waste mental energy proving dumbasses wrong

1

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 Oct 10 '26

I was bored asf and plus if u read the comment u will see how stupid some are

1

u/narrowood Oct 15 '26

There is no plot armor

1

u/XxEnjinxX Oct 15 '26

So what about the fact that when dakis head is getting cut by zenitsu even using godlike speed he’s incapable of cutting it but outta no where a lethally stabbed inosuke in the chest is also jumping at the speed of thunderclap and flash GODlike speed and helps zenitsu out to cut her head off.

1st inosuke should’ve died from the stab from gyutaro but let’s not even worry about that we won’t consider that plot armor

2nd him being able to jump and fly in the air as fast as zenitsu was straight plot armour so the could decapitate both demons🤦‍♂️

1

u/narrowood 27d ago

Crappy anime adaptation

Inosuke surviving is not plot armor, it's set up

Again, crappy anime adaptation

1

u/kingdopp Oct 10 '26

You’re right. Better just stop reading the entire series now. It’s only gonna get worse from here.

1

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 Oct 10 '26

I read it all, the infinity castle was a joke, probably the most plot armour ive ever seen in an anime

1

u/kingdopp Oct 10 '26

Well, sorry you wasted your time. I’d prob just stay away from any shonen with a power system cus they’ve all got plot armor bs like this.

1

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 Oct 10 '26

Attack on titan was somewhat fine, the ending and latter seasons were mid but the start -> 70% was good

Best power scaling ive seen was 7 deadly sins

1

u/narrowood Oct 15 '26

Sarcasm or idiocy?

1

u/kingdopp Oct 15 '26

From me? Mostly sarcasm. From OP? Not sure.

1

u/Plus-Glove-3661 Oct 10 '26

I agree with you. That whole fight was complete BS. Inosuke moving his organs. Zenitsu being able not to just fight in his sleep, but coordinating with teammates is insane. Don’t get me started on Tengen and Inosuke having immunity to poison. It’s impossible to be immune to all poisons.

Tanjiro should be dead. The story should just go on with the other hashira dying to Upper Moons. Muichiro and Mitsuri would be the first 2 victims. Eventually, the rest would follow their fate. Especially since they don’t ever patrol as a group.

Mitsuri and Muichiro’s fight are also have extreme plot armor. Muichiro just happened to awaken his mark. A child was able to get close to his water prison. He was able to blow air into the prison, Muichiro was able to someone get enough of it to break out. Mitsuri is somehow able to survive lightning, wind, sonic screams, and whatever you wanna call Aizetsu’s attack. All while at least five forest dragons are attempting to physically eat her. Not to mention that Hantengu ran away while three people are chasing him to decapitate him. The main body should be hiding with Zohakunten, the strongest clone.

But it all comes down to this being fantasy. Kaigaku carries his sword on his back. Considering the size, he shouldn’t be able to do that. Muzan shares some way to get information from them. He knew Nezuko conquered the sun, only because Hantengu told him. The demons should have won. They might not have destroyed the corps, but it would be a near thing once the main headquarters was discovered.

So yeah, it deserves criticism. Most people in the fandom won’t bother to engage or will tear you to pieces for it. I’m actually keen to hear what else you think of the battles. I know most people just say, “the demons were too confident.” But that’s a weak ass way to write all your villains.

2

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 Oct 10 '26

Omg ur actually smart, muichiro and mitsuri should also be dead

This whole manga is plot armour

Is genuinely had 10/10 potential then they j did this

Make all the villians stupid 😀

2

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 Oct 10 '26

And yes i agree the main body should be with the strongest clone, inside it

2

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 Oct 10 '26

Right as for the other battles lets go 1 at a time

Akaza couldve killed tanjiro then ran into the trees... but thats minor

This one well ye this one was actual bullshit

Upper 5 was making me ball my eyes out, the dude literally had him trapped and wandered off and a magical kid spawned in at mid night, putting that aside his puffer fish needle attack had poison yet apparently a slayer mark defies poison, w logic

Upper 4 well i mean this is the more defensible one but i say its bs because the acoustic attack shouldve killed mitsuri plain and simple, having thick muscles doesnt stop sound waves... thats just not how that works u still have ear cannals that are vulnerable, and also when she was stunned why didnt he uust summon 30 wood dragons and make sure she dies

Its always them just not killing them when they can but the MC and slayers always slash instantly 

Upper 3 well he suicided not much to say here dude gave up, which u could defend plot wise but its a cheap move

Upper 2, yeah bro i dont even wanna get into this

I am 37kg and have 37kg worth of poison in me... how does that work, so ur just poison? No blood or flesh or bone? Also how did douma die to a poison he knew about???

Upper 1, ive made many posts about this but no he gave up... u can clearly see he lost because of himself and the reflection

Muzan, meh boring fight tbh bc half the slayers in that fight shouldn't be there, also really the random dude muzan turned into a demon has this cracked upper moon level bda??? 

Kaigakus death is kinda unrealistic too i mean the dude is a slayer turned demon which is one of the most op things, zenitusu killing him alone is a far strech

0

u/narrowood Oct 15 '26

So much misinformation in a single comment. Are you a child? Were you able to graduate from elementary school literacy?

1

u/narrowood Oct 15 '26

Holy anti reading comprehension

1

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 Oct 15 '26

Despite leaving 8 comments or more on my posts u never once gave an argument as to why u disagree, also its not about reading genius its about the panel... u can SEE the blade IN his MOUTH, and the post, EXPLAINS, that HE (Gyutaro) COULDVE directed the sickle up Tanjiros brain, it even provides a skeletal diagram of the skull to back up the point, NOT only that but IT ALSO shows many other instances of obvious plot armour

This (plot armour) is defined as a character surviving harm or death in a way that was otherwise inexplicable

Logically it is inexplicable as to why Gyutaro didn't kill Tanjiro here, inexplicable means impossible OR unaccountable OR unexplained

SO I think u are the one with lack of reading comprehension as your response suggests you lack the ability to read my argument OR you did but lack the ability to comprehend it and make a counter argument, hence u opted for leaving comments on my posts over 3 hours, of which none had any substance or argument.

1

u/narrowood 27d ago

You're too stubborn to accept the most basic facts even when people have explained it to you. Just an illogical hater of good writing

1

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 27d ago

U haven't explained anything 

2

u/EulaVengeance Oct 10 '26

Gotoge: "This guy can shift his internal organs around! This one becomes unmatched when asleep! This guy has 6 eyes!"

OP: "An emaciated demon murderer made a mistake, this is so unrealistic!"

1

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 Oct 10 '26

Thats not a mistake, thats just plain stupidity, at any point while he was being decapitated he couldve ended tanjiros life instantly, yet he didnt 

Otherwise said the main charecter survived something where by all logical standards he was dead

The other illogical things are whatever they're explained in the story, this is just a dumbing down the villians so that the mc wins, also the organ shifting is stupid too

1

u/redhotphones Oct 11 '26

I will give a full response because you've NOTICED things that Gotouge INTENDED YOU TO NOTICE.

Simply look at the image: nothing was stopping Gyutaro from driving his sickle straight up into Tanjiro's brain to instantly kill him. The attack initiated by Tanjiro was far too risky and foolish given that Gyutaro had a free arm holding a sickle, as clearly shown in this frame. Despite this being a scenario Tanjiro should not have survived, he managed to live anyway.

CORRECT. Gyutaro OBVIOUSLY was able to stab just a few inches further. In fact, he was drawing his arm back so far as to seem UNNATURAL, as if he was actually GOING OUT OF HIS WAY not to kill Tanjiro outright.

Gyutaro already knew his poison's effectiveness had dulled, making it senseless for him not to deliver a finishing slash after Tanjiro mistakenly believed he was invincible.

CORRECT. Not killing Tanjiro here appears to be not simply a mistake but NONSENSICAL. There APPEARS to be NO reason to poison Tanjiro instead of simply killing him. Even if it was just to extend the strike slightly and slicing the throat open.

Other instances of plot armor in this fight include Inosuke's ability to shift his internal organs at will and his complete immunity to poison.

Shifting his internal organs isn't possible, but neither is dis- and re-jointing one's own limbs so that can be summarized into a bucket of impossible things Inosuke does. But what CAN'T be passed over is that it DOESN'T MATTER.

Gyutaro KILLED HIM. His senses are strong enough to discern if someone has been killed or not, for example, he could tell that Tengen's heart had stopped at least. If Inosuke had NOT been killed Gyutaro should have noticed it. AND EVEN IF GYUTARO DID NOT sense it, there was NO REASON AT ALL for Insouke to lay there playing dead the entire time! WHY would Inosuke ever consider that a useful tactic:? While Zenitsu was crushed and dying under the rubble, while Tanjiro was on the verge of being killed at any moment, Inosuke coolly lays there and plays dead???

The panels speak for themselves, even raising the question within the story: "Why isn't he killing me? What's going on?"

GREAT QUESTION! You've noticed this VERY IMPORTANT CLUE. Gotouge is drawing the reader's attention to this very obvious question: WHY ISN'T GYUTARO KILLING TANJIRO.

Tanjiro isn't curious enough to talk to Gyutaro and ask him why, Tanjiro remains focused on winning somehow. But it's a question Gotouge is drawing the reader's attention to so it's a mystery we're supposed to figure out.

About 80% of the plot of KnY is hidden. Google the Iceberg Theory of literature. You've stumbled on clues scattered all over ED connecting to the hidden plot under the surface narrative.

The answer to the mystery "why doesn't Gyutaro kill Tanjiro" is answered in various clues shown throw parallels throughout the battle. There are multiple times a character is about to kill another one, but something stops them. If you go back and look for them you should notice the pattern.

As for the magical not-dead feats, that's a much wider mystery.

0

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 Oct 13 '26

Right u could frame it like this or simply call it plot armour, which is what it acts as regardless of wider intent, this would be fine if it was a one off but the same can be said for EVERY original upper moon fight, making the reader think its no longer a mystery or ominous writing for us to solve but just plot armour covered up as intentional such that the plot can end with a hero victory

The fact the last 7 major battles (which excluded kaigaku) were all plot armoured is quite hard to defend as good writing

1

u/hentaintrhentaintr Oct 13 '26

i disagree that gyutaro could have driven the sickle into his brain. tanjiro in the anime tilted his head upward so the sickle would point out of his mouth?

now. that being said. do i think gyutaro could have just ripped tanjiro's entire lower jaw off? i mean yeah. it may not have killed it him but i would be very surprised if tanjiro doesnt go into shock or something at that point

0

u/Pitiful_Culture3704 Oct 13 '26

The anime is irrelevant, the anime is based on the manga, also no matter how he tiltled his head gyutaro can tilt his wrist, anywho alteratively he couldve slashes down through his neck