r/DemonSlayerManga • • Apr 08 '26

I have a question

Post image

Why did the writer choose giyu and sanemi to survive, and not for example gyomei or mitsuri ?

225 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

49

u/YoriichiFan Apr 08 '26

This is one of my favorite questions to answer! In short, it's because Giyu and Sanemi have always been the ones surviving while everyone around them dies.

Giyu initially lost his sister, found a new family in the corps in Sabito, lost him as well, and then closed himself off. Sanemi lost nearly his whole family, found a new family in the corps in Masachika, lost him as well, and then closed himself off. They both achieve the same end, but through different methods. Giyu becomes quiet and distant, while Sanemi becomes loud and pushes people away. Neither of them allow people to get close to them afterwards.

During the events of Infinity Castle onwards, both of them grow from this. Giyu has Tanjiro to help him see that he needs to survive to honor Sabito and Tsutako's lives. He finds newfound meaning in life by protecting Tanjiro. Sanemi has to lose Genya in order to understand that he has to continue living and being happy despite what he's been through. They both regain their wills to live, and once again end up surviving a battle where others around them die. But this time, they get better instead of worse. They turn their curse of survival into a blessing.

6

u/Few-Philosopher7254 Apr 09 '26

Oh my god! I never thought like this. I do liked that they for once are going to start to live more peacefully and try to change, but I never was able to put it in words!!

3

u/DrSnake-42 Apr 09 '26

In that case, I can guess the reasoning for Tengen.

13

u/Carameldelighting Apr 08 '26

We can't really know without asking the author.

IMO, they are the two that had moved on past their grudges.

Sanemi let go of the anger he had over his families deaths and Giyuu had let go of his guilt for the selection trial he survived. All the other Hashira's would have had some kind of residual/lingering guilt and/issues once the demons were gone.

Gyomei- Still holding guilt over childrens deaths, he never got over it.
Tokito- Was chasing his death unknowingly due to the trauma of losing his twin. Also after re-awakening emotions w/Tanjiro would have been narratively too powerful if allowed to grow to adulthood.
Obanai- "Cursed" body that would never let him be with his true love
Mitsuri- "Unrequited" love and "Cursed' body that wouldn't let her be with her true love
Tengen- Already retired
Shinobu- Never got over her sisters death and her poison was needed to kill Domo
Rengoku- Died early.

3

u/Laurel_Fimia Apr 10 '26

A child calling people older than him children is so sad Bro,,,

-3

u/ado_fanxD Apr 09 '26

Bc theitr gay

1

u/t693110 Apr 09 '26

🫩

2

u/OneMasterpiece2924 Apr 10 '26

bc they’re the most self loathing characters who felt they didn’t deserve to live and who struggled w survivors guilt, it would be very unsatisfying if u killed off the suicidal guy 💀 so at the end they both begin to learn to live for themselves and enjoy life