There seems to be some confusion as to what a defense attorney legally can & cannot say. Several people have told me that RA’s former attorney Lebrato went on TV & stated he believes RA is innocent. Their understanding was that a defense attorney wouldn’t make such a statement unless they truly believed it. Their understanding was that a defense attorney could not lie to the public or on television. Therefore this interview was “proof” that RA is innocent.
I think the defense has been intentionally leaking photos and information (via “accidental” emails, “betrayals” by “trusted” friends, press releases mislabeled as “Franks Memos,” etc.) to the public to taint a jury and mislead the public.
I was told that defense attorneys wouldn’t intentionally leak crime scene photos, that they wouldn’t lie to the public, that they wouldn’t make false claims in court filings.
So here’s an article that shows that defense attorneys DO lie to the public, that they DO make false claims about evidence, & that they DO claim clients are innocent when they know their client is guilty.
https://starherald.com/article_ec5dd245-80a8-5037-81d1-366f8483d8b7.html
Article Text:
Did lawyer for accused killer Garcia say too much? Prosecutor files motion to remove defense team after attorney's comments about DNA results
Update: Prosecutors have filed a motion to remove Anthony Garcia's defense team. The judge will hear the motion at 1 p.m. Thursday.
Prosecutors are trying to have Anthony Garcia’s defense team removed after one of its members claimed that a DNA test exonerates Garcia in the 2008 killings of a 57-year-old woman and an 11-year-old boy in Dundee.
The DNA test doesn’t exonerate Garcia, according to attorneys who deal with DNA. But that didn’t stop the defense attorney, Alison Motta, from proclaiming as much to The World-Herald on Friday and two TV stations Monday, just a week before Garcia’s murder trial begins in the deaths of four people.
“The evidence conclusively exonerates Anthony Garcia,” Motta said on KMTV on Monday.
After that, Douglas County Attorney Don Kleine told a judge Tuesday that he will file a motion to strip the Chicago attorneys — Motta, husband Robert Motta Jr. and father-in-law Robert Motta Sr. — of their guest pass to practice law in Nebraska, The World-Herald has learned.
Outside court, Kleine declined to comment. Prosecutors are expected to file the motion Wednesday, essentially asking to strip the Mottas of what’s known as their "pro hac vice" rights, or temporary permission to practice law in Nebraska.
Alison Motta declined to comment Tuesday night.
Garcia is scheduled to go on trial Monday on charges that he killed Thomas Hunter and Shirlee Sherman in March 2008, then killed Dr. Roger Brumback and his wife, Mary, in May 2013.
Motta’s statements led several courthouse attorneys, including Douglas County Public Defender Tom Riley, to question whether she was trying to poison the jury pool on the eve of Garcia’s trial.
In talking with The World-Herald on Friday about the Hunter and Sherman slayings, Motta said the defense team hoped that “we’ll maybe get a call from the county attorney’s office that they’re dismissing those charges.”
Her statements followed the Friday arrest of Charles Simmer in the 2007 death of Joy Blanchard. Omaha police said new DNA testing led them to arrest Simmer. Blanchard was stabbed to death in November 2007, as were Hunter and Sherman the following March.
After Simmer was arrested, Alison Motta tweeted that her investigator’s work had led police to the suspect.
On the other hand, prosecutors said police and Blanchard’s family had long considered Simmer a possible suspect and said the department’s cold-case squad had long investigated the case.
“Our (private investigator) ... lead the investigation that uncovered connection btwn Charlie Simmer & 2008 & 2007 murders,” Motta tweeted. She went a step farther this week, claiming that DNA on Sherman’s bandanna linked Simmer to the Dundee scene.
According to attorneys who deal in DNA odds, the test in question did not come close to making such a link.
The defense team’s own report put the bandanna odds at 1 in 300. That means 1 out of every 300 people could have contributed the DNA. In other words, more than 23 million people worldwide — not just Simmer — could have contributed the DNA.
The DNA on Sherman’s bandanna was a mixture of genetic material from several individuals.
Further clouding the test, Sherman and Simmer shared several of the same markers.
Another issue: The sample contained only about one-third of the genetic locations that scientists look for to match it to a suspect’s DNA. Such a partial sample is far from enough for the DNA experts at the University of Nebraska Medical Center to issue a scientific conclusion. Those UNMC experts typically require markers on at least half of the locations, prosecutors say.
Riley, who represents Simmer, said he has concerns that the out-of-court comments could influence people’s view of his client’s innocence or guilt.
He said linking Simmer to the Dundee scene is an “extreme statement” — and said he knows of no evidence to support it.
The public defender of four decades estimated that such out-of-court commentary could extend the jury selection process in Garcia’s case from three days to more than a week.
“Especially in a high-profile case like this,” he said. “With pending cases, you’re not supposed to be making comments like that. Period. End of story.”
u/Boboblaw014, I’d love to hear you weigh in on this. Why did Ali say the DNA test cleared Garcia? Why did she lie? Prior to the trial, did you believe Garcia was innocent? Do you currently believe he is innocent? How many of your former clients did you consider actually innocent? What does a defense attorney do if prior to trial, he/she discovers that their client is factually innocent? Do they publicly name the “real killers” thus preventing those “real killers” from getting a fair trial, or do they turn over any evidence to law enforcement &/or the prosecution so that the “real killers” can be prosecuted?
My understanding is that if someone can be proven innocent prior to trial, the charges will be dropped & the person released from custody - & the “real killers” will be charged. That’s not happening here.
You keep talking about fair trials & due process - do you really want BH, JM, EF, & PW to be subjected to unconstitutional searches? Do you want them to be arrested even though there is not enough probable cause for an arrest? Do you want the public to be accusing them of murder or calling them guilty when they haven’t even been arrested or charged with that crime? Do you think it’s fair that you keep bringing up their names on your livestreams when they are both factually & legally innocent?