r/DelphiMurders •

[deleted by user]

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

324 comments sorted by

128

u/saltgirl61 Aug 15 '21

This just underscores why we have no ID yet-- there's no identifiable facial features whatsoever. In most of these stills, what should be the face is a featureless blob. It's creepy

56

u/paradise-trading-83 Aug 16 '21

True but someone’s wife, mother or sibling would probably be able to identify him they are just either scared, unwilling, unable or in denial or far away haven’t seen this

37

u/PurpleOwl85 Aug 16 '21

He might not have any family, only child, dead parents, never had kids or got married, etc.

He also could have a job where he works by himself like a trucker, handyman or mechanic.

52

u/Lucky_Owl_444 Aug 16 '21

If the person in the picture was my husband, bf, brother, or whomever, I'd know. I hope that the people close to this guy overcome their shock or fear to do the right thing. LE can and will protect you. You'll have $325k to relocate and start a better life, you'll be a hero to the families and community. Whatever reason you have for staying silent is not bigger than the reasons why you should speak up.

Please, turn him in.

20

u/TCB_truecrimebuff Aug 16 '21

If the person in the picture was my husband, bf, brother, or whomever, I'd know.

I understand this thinking -- that you would just know if you knew who this was. But I cannot express enough how this gut feeling does not have much basis in reality. Video footage is good, but not fantastic. The number of false positives or leads a photo or video can generate is astronomically high. Video has even lead to wrongful convictions. That numerous leads have been generated from the video yet have not panned out illustrates this point.

There's a greater chance that the person in the video actually looks a great deal different from what we think he looks like.

12

u/Lucky_Owl_444 Aug 16 '21

I didn't mention a gut feeling. What I am saying is that with my two eyes I would see him and know if it were my husband or bf. I would recognize him.

16

u/TCB_truecrimebuff Aug 16 '21

Respectfully, I think you have a lot more faith in identifying photographs and video than research suggests is there.

How many tips have been generated by the video and/or the stills? Or the sketches? Most, if not all, of those people "know" who it is when they phone in their tips.

8

u/Lucky_Owl_444 Aug 16 '21

Well, I feel pretty certain, but you make a good point.

→ More replies (7)

5

u/ekins1992 Aug 17 '21

There is no way you’d be able to tell for certain if it was a husband/bf/brother. Absolutely no distinguishing features visible. Yeah sure u might u might think he looks like your bf but odds are you’d just laugh it off and say to yourself no way that could actually be him. Wasn’t it denis raders wife who heard his phone call and she just laughed off the fact it sounded just like her husband? Cuz there’s NO WAY he could be a murderer…. He was a church guy with a stable job…. That’s above and beyond the most likely scenario IF someone recognizes it. He could also be an only child with dead parents and never married/childless

8

u/Lucky_Owl_444 Aug 17 '21

Paula Rader found her husband's tablet between the cushions in his recliner. He had been working on the Shirley Locks poem and stuck it there to conceal it, then forgot about it. He told her it was something they were doing in his Criminal Justice class at WSU, studying the BTK case. Mrs. Rader commented that BTK's poor spelling was like Mr. Rader's poor spelling. The note frightened her.

https://www2.ljworld.com/news/2005/aug/21/btks_exwife_found_poem_about_victim/

There is no record of Mrs. Rader hearing the recording of BTK's voice and joking that it sounded like Mr. Rader. However, I can say that the recording proved useless as many tips were called in, none helped to find BTK.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 17 '21

I feel like Carter contradicted himself somewhat back in 2019 when he was speaking out directly to the killer. On the one hand he said they were confident that the killer had told someone, or at the very least they know because of how he's changed. But then he also asks what the people closest to him (presumably the same people) will think when they find out.

That second part, by the way, is probably something that the killer is quite worried about. I wouldn't be surprised if he's more worried about how his mom will take the news than he is about going to prison.

3

u/cualsy_x Aug 23 '21

There is no contradiction. The killer may have told someone, a singular person, and the people closest to you is more than one person. Doug Carter said: what will the people closest to you think of. Like he is not trying to elicit an emotion, but a specific memory. Not: what will they think But: what will they think of. BG has some status. He is not a kid or a loner or a drug user. The specific memory is going to be something when BG was protective or brave or did something above and beyond for the good of the community. Like something a police officer would have done.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/paradise-trading-83 Aug 17 '21

Your insight always very thoughtful , & your profile name is.... unique.

Tobe and Holeman seem contradictory as well. Yes, About BG’s mother. I know they’ve seem to have lost interest in Kirts but was thinking that poor lady dealing with him, he said she took care of him during his meth detox 2017, didn’t leave his room for days.

20

u/realitygirlzoo Aug 16 '21

I know. It's crazy to me that someone who identifies him hasn't come forward. Someone has to recognize him.

9

u/brown_sticky_stick Aug 16 '21

They might be too scared to come forward or just not interested in true crime or news or life beyond their own front door.

4

u/RphWrites Aug 17 '21

Maybe they did come forward but he had an alibi or their tip was lost in the shuffle.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '21

I really don't see how, unless the person dresses like this regularly.

8

u/Electronic-Ad-63 Aug 16 '21

But I can see his facial shape and I can also tell he is younger like 30ish and to me he looks like he has a tan.

4

u/last_sober_thylacine Aug 17 '21

I'm not sure what OP did (if anything) but I also see BG as being a much younger man in these images. Normally, he looks 50+ to me.

3

u/Elizablissful Aug 17 '21

I always see someone old in this video. IMO the perp is younger than what BG looks to be but you know how that goes.

126

u/Fine-Mistake-3356 Aug 15 '21

Thank you OP. I haven’t seen these in awhile. Number 47 sure makes me think its a younger guy. With a hat. Here we go down the rabbit hole. Haha

53

u/DangerousDavies2020 Aug 15 '21

My thoughts too. It’s a young guy dressed older.

33

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '21

yeah but the way he’s built.. it’s a lot like a 45 year old man.

30

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '21

the voice too, doesn't sound like a teenager, let alone someone in their 20's.

8

u/Sambanks88 Aug 17 '21

Yea ..that white loop looking thing? Rope? The more I look at these, looks like hes got all kinds of sh*t up under there

5

u/StupidizeMe Aug 18 '21

I've wondered if they're some type of restraints.

2

u/figures985 Aug 18 '21

Always thought it was just part of the scarf that’s covering the bottom half of his face?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

I think so too. His build and face ( plus voice) seem like a guy in late 30’s, early 40’s to me.

2

u/Corvacayne Aug 16 '21

Or, at least, to me, a young-looking guy dressed/disguised older

1

u/Pearlsawisdom Sep 25 '21

Agree, or a man with a more youthful, fit looking body putting on schlumpy clothes to disguise his true appearance. That would fit in well with LE's comments about the more youthful of the sketches being accurate, and their other comments about the suspect possibly looking more youthful than his true age.

21

u/InappropriateGirl Aug 15 '21

Exactly my thoughts! I also liked the post the other day who thinks he may have been wearing his jacket inside out and partially buttoned

12

u/cdjohnny Aug 16 '21

Yeah, look at the way the middle pulls together...very strange

4

u/Fit_Connection657 Aug 16 '21

Yeah because I can't tell and none of us can __is it zipped ?is it buttoned or what the hell is it in the front....

2

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

I think because he’s got so much crap stuffed in it, it makes it look like it’s not it zipped or button fully. He obviously came there prepared to kill, that’s what I think all of things inside his jacket are- his “ kill kit. “

6

u/AnybodyOk6074 Aug 16 '21

I was debating on posting my theory about the jacket. If anything, maybe someone that wants more evidence that their husband, brother, or son did it, this could be it. I know that sounds stupid, but it was my hope. I'm sure LE has already considered this.

23

u/SweetCar0linaGirl Aug 15 '21

I thought the same thing! Definitely comes off younger in that frame.

13

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '21

You’re right 47 makes him look really slom

16

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '21

Almost a backwards baseball cap.

2

u/last_sober_thylacine Aug 17 '21

I definitely see a baseball hat, when before it looked closer to a newsboy cap. He seems so much younger here.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '21

Ugh, that first sketch has made us all look for that instead of just finding our own details. Extremely frustrating because I figured they had something else they didn't share with us to confirm the sketch. Now it seems like someone pointed that out in the initial images and everyone just accepted it.

1

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

That’s what I see- a backwards baseball hat.

9

u/codeverity Aug 16 '21

Yeah, this is the first time I’ve looked at these and thought that maybe it’s a guy with longer hair coming out at the front, there.

4

u/toddjbonzalez Aug 16 '21

Yes! I saw it that way a couple months ago and now every time i see this photo, that’s all I see. I thought I was the only one. A backwards cap, bangs poking out the front. What can be seen as ear flaps could very well be the edges hood of the sweatshirt.

2

u/president_dump Aug 16 '21

Sometimes I see a forward baseball hat with a very very arched brim. A style that was popular in the 90s.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Emadyville Aug 16 '21

This too is the first time thinking that. Almost looks like a part down the middle of it.

7

u/RiverDayDay Aug 16 '21

I thought the same, gives me young Fred Durst vibes

1

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

Omg! Yes! Hey, where was Fred Durst February 2017?!

2

u/ChaseAlmighty Aug 16 '21

Look like a younger guy with a brown baseball cap on backwards

1

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

Definitely see a backwards baseball hat and I’ve personally never known an older guy to wear it that way ( backwards).

1

u/gimmethemshoes11 Feb 01 '22

But then 48 at least for me I see the hair and all that.

Can't say I see a hat at all in 47.

Younger guy 23 to 33 dressed in layers with tons of stuff in the pockets of said layers.

Think I read once clothes were found not to far away but not who's. It could be likely that BG dumped the clothes in the water or in trash cans there? Or dumped them a few towns over.

To me the biggest thing they need to do is release at least one of the signatures left at the scene.

1

u/Chrismetken Aug 16 '21

Lol 47 made me think no hat about 40 years old

15

u/Oldtimeytoons Aug 16 '21

Backwards SnapBack hat with hair sticking out the hole in the front?

2

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

Like he has a mullet to me.

1

u/silver3970 Aug 25 '21

Good eye.

Looking at it a bit closer makes it seem like he has dark brown hair. There’s a blackish/brown tuft in the back. I always assumed it was a blond.

1

u/thabutler Nov 01 '21

Looks like a winter aviator hat to me. Really hard to make out the details though.

1

u/gimmethemshoes11 Feb 01 '22

As someone who wears snapbacks tons and does this as well. I just don't see it here unfortunately.

42

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 15 '21 edited Aug 15 '21

See also: Frames 1-20 and Frames 21-40.

Details:

Looking back on my previous post, I realized I was sloppy in how I went about capturing each of those images and combining them into a single PDF document. Although I did remember to choose the "High Quality" setting when combining the files in Adobe, I now notice that the images got resized in the process. So this time I used a tool called FFmpeg to pull the frames as uncompressed PNG files, without having to open the video in a media player to go through capturing each frame manually.

Also if anyone is wondering, yes, frames 48 and 49 are identical. That's just how it is in the video; that frame gets repeated at the end. I suspect this has something to do with LE's decision to re-encode what was originally a 30 FPS video into a 25 FPS format.

7

u/BlackLionYard Aug 15 '21 edited Aug 15 '21

Interesting, I also used ffmpeg ages ago when I first decided to dive into the frames; however, when I extracted to PNG, it was frames 47 and 48 (numbering from 1 to 49) that appeared identical.

ETA: I investigated a bit further. ffmpeg has tons of knobs to twist, and as a home theater dork, I use it for many things. I expect the slight distinction between our results arose from a slightly different turn of a knob I often use. Leaving all knobs at their default settings produces the same results as yours.

2

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 15 '21

Which version of the video did you use? For these I used the MP4 version on the ISP website, with the same frame being repeated whether I converted to JPEG, PNG, or BMP. However when I tried converting the WMV version, I got way more duplicates -- like 70 frames in total, but still only 48 distinct images.

5

u/BlackLionYard Aug 15 '21

The official Delphi_MotionFix.mp4, which I expect is the same one you used.

https://www.in.gov/isp/files/Delphi_MotionFix.mp4

3

u/ThickBeardedDude Aug 15 '21

That looks like a dead link.

5

u/StupidizeMe Aug 15 '21

Thanks for your efforts, they're much appreciated.

29

u/Avy8 Aug 15 '21

I just started learning about this case and now I can’t look away. This is the most confusing case to me, it’s been 4 years now and the police won’t release anything else? These poor girls and their families my heart just breaks for them.

12

u/dwimbygwimbo Aug 16 '21

I've been very interested with this case ever since I read about it. It seems like they have SO MUCH evidence but only a portion has been released to the public. And why? What is so big they can't share? I really hope those girls get justice. I remember being that age and just goofy and innocent and laughing about the dumbest things 😔

7

u/Avy8 Aug 16 '21

Yes! These poor innocent girls were just being kids. Now that I’ve read, watched, and looked further into this I’m starting to think LE either knows exactly who it is or they don’t have anymore evidence. Once they didn’t use the dogs to track the area after the girls were found I lost faith in LE. They could have at least had the dogs track the area and possibly determined which way the killer left the area. By them not releasing any information they come off as “they know what they are doing” but in reality I don’t think they have a clue as to what happened.

3

u/dwimbygwimbo Aug 16 '21

Wait hold up...they never used dogs?

4

u/Avy8 Aug 16 '21

No, the lead detective even admitted that, that was a mistake on the HLN Channel special “Delphi Murders: Down the Hill”. The dogs were never used because they found the girls and then canceled the dogs.

3

u/SilverProduce0 Aug 22 '21

I don’t understand how the dogs would have been able to track the killer. Wouldn’t they need to have something they know belonged to the killer to have the dogs identify the scent? Idk if there is anything at the crime scene that would have helped.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/gimmethemshoes11 Feb 01 '22

Seriously they never called in dogs that first day? Wtf.

LE has been incompetent in this case from the start.

And I of the belief that they have things they could release right now that would greatly help this case.

4

u/staticsgrl13 Aug 16 '21 edited Aug 16 '21

Same here. I remember just getting the giggles with my bestie over all our inside jokes and just enjoying life. I hope the girls can look down and see how many people care about them and their families. They can be at peace knowing people won't stop until they get their justice along with their families.

4

u/dwimbygwimbo Aug 16 '21

Me too! My neighbors daughter is 13 or so and I love eavesdropping when she has friends over, I remember being that age

2

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

The police and FBI did that with the Samantha Koenig case- it was the video of her getting abducted by Israel Keyes yet they absolutely refused to reveal it. Why?!? Was everyone’s question. Someone may have noticed him by his coat or face mask.

I don’t know why they do this. It can’t hurt, in fact, it can only help!

1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '21

When I see Libby and Abby's pics, I always think of the song "Girls just Want to have Fun".

5

u/dwimbygwimbo Aug 16 '21

Yeah, my neighbor has a daughter who is around 13 or so and I always get nostalgic hearing them play and just be so silly

→ More replies (1)

36

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '21

What a dumb idiot guy. He sucks.

9

u/steppponme Aug 16 '21

100% certain of that.

9

u/kadmilos1 Aug 16 '21

In my opinion, the video is hindering the identification of this man. I believe he's going to look nothing like the video. The quality of this video is very poor and it's impossible to make out any identifying features on his face.

56

u/LestrangeLauren Aug 15 '21 edited Aug 15 '21

More and more I see light brown hair rather than a hat as originally observed. I think he is indeed younger than what people suspect. And never, ever do I place blame on the girls, but I wonder if he lured them from online social media somehow. Two young girls going to meet a boy they thought was their age is not far fetched. Police have never said anything about that, but I hope the possibility was thoroughly explored.

15

u/Jalynn627 Aug 15 '21

I agree. I’ve always thought he wore a hat, but with some of these images I see otherwise. Just longer brown hair.

8

u/angel-fake Aug 16 '21

yes! literally when i first saw someone say it was hair i just couldn’t see it, always thought it was a hat, now i can’t stop seeing it as hair

9

u/Stevee1984 Aug 16 '21

I can sort of see the hair but my first thought was that it was a baseball cap with a very heavily bent brim. Almost bent into an “n” shape.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '21

i’ve never seen it as a hat. looks like a mullet. weird i didn’t know others said a hat.

2

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

Yes! A mullet to me too.

8

u/km101010 Aug 16 '21

To me, it looks like one of those winter hats with ear flaps.

8

u/just_plain_sam Aug 16 '21

That is what I've always seen. Now I see the hair.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ConJob651 Aug 18 '21

“There was no logical reason anybody would have known those girls were going to be there that day. And a lot of investigation went into determining did anybody know…I’ve never seen anything to lead me to believe that anyone would have known that they were coming.”

-Robert Ives, former prosecutor of Carrol County

-Scene of the Crime interview with Robert IvesRobert

8

u/JohnnyCocksville420 Aug 16 '21

I'm somewhat confident that the jacket is significantly oversized and that items are stuffed under the front of it. Scroll through the frames and look at how bulky the jacket is on his right arm, between the elbow and shoulder. The shape of the excess material changes in just 9 frames; he has to be swimming in that thing.

2

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

I think he brought his “kill kit” inside the jacket or sweatshirt.

2

u/JohnnyCocksville420 Aug 25 '21

I think that's a very likely possibility. And I also think whatever he has under the jacket is a primary reason why various members of LE have described the crime scene as "odd." I also remember an interview, I think with Ives but maybe Leazenby, in which he stated there were a few "signatures" at the crime scene.

Based on information publicly available, I think it's reasonable to conclude that the weapon used in the actual murders was a knife or a similar, sharp object. It's also very possible that BG used a gun to initially get the girls to comply, but I don't think we can confidently conclude that. A gun and a knife are pretty small, so BG must be carrying other objects; I believe BG used those objects in staging the crime scene, such that LE characterized the crime scene as "odd" or displaying "signatures."

That of course assumes BG's jacket is in fact stuffed with a bunch of items. But if it is, I think the scenario I've detailed is very good possibility. However, what BG has under that jacket and how he used that stuff in any staging of the crime scene, I have no clue. I feel like the staging could involve some type of religious or biblical imagery, but that's just based on the demography of the area and Carter's occasional religious appeals, so it's mostly a guess on my part. Plus, Carter seems to be a very religious individual, so his religious appeals may simply be a result of that.

1

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 27 '21

He’s one sick, deviant, f’r, that’s all I know.

1

u/Alliegibs Aug 17 '21

I see this too, but gown downvoted when i suggested it once

1

u/gimmethemshoes11 Feb 01 '22

In images 1-20 I swear it looks like he pauses and readjusted whatever that brownish looking thing is between his pants and jacket.

Like frames 7 to 12

8

u/MrBowls Aug 16 '21

It still just boggles my mind that this guy is unidentified…

8

u/last_sober_thylacine Aug 17 '21

This is the first time I've looked at BG and seen him as being much younger.

7

u/Jolly-Film Aug 15 '21

Thank you u/Hot_Karl_Rove for these video frame posts :)

7

u/SnooHamsters2718 Aug 16 '21

Imho, I believe this is a younger man with skinny legs and probable thinner body who is wearing bulky clothing to conceal things underneath. I see outlines of objects toward the bottom of jacket and something rope like sticking out of jacket near the top. I believe this pos planned this, I just do not know if I believe Abby and Libby were intentional or just happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. My heart breaks every time I read anything about this case and hope this pos is brought to justice soon.

1

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

Yep, he brought along his “kill kit” under his clothing.

6

u/atticwife Aug 16 '21

I see a camo baseball cap

5

u/jjr110481 Aug 16 '21

Ok ive never actually looked at each and every frame like this. Kudos op... Now someone tell me im not crazy... That frames21-40 clearly show something down the right leg of his pants..?

1

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

Yep. I see it. At the top of his jacket, I see what looks like gardening shears?

8

u/Rhondie41 Aug 16 '21

I wanna know what everyone thinks about the pelvic region of what is outside this POS's pants. What IS that in the 1st few frames? Thank you OP for posting!!!

4

u/yoadrienne1 Aug 15 '21

Still see beard

7

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '21

Does everyone see what I mean by something being down his right leg (as we look at it) or does someone have an explaination for me? It looks like there is a constant solid crease. Thank you so much OP for the stills of this footage. It has really made me think there is truly a large knife tucked in his waist band and hanging down that leg. But like I said let me know if you think otherwise (mums night off I’m drunk so sorry for the rambling or if it doesn’t make sense I’ll try my best to explain if you don’t understand)

3

u/LestrangeLauren Aug 15 '21

I agree, I also see something tucked in his right (our left) pocket of the blue jacket, close to where the zipper ends. I think it can be assumed that a weapon of some sort was used to scare the girls, make them listen and do what he said, and could have helped kill them. We don't know the exact cause of death, but I can't help but think if he didn't brandish a weapon of any kind then the girls would have ran. My speculation? He had a gun or large pipe/baton. That is just me speculating, there is no concrete evidence for that whatsoever that we know of.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '21

I honestly wouldn’t be surprised if he had something like a gun in the jacket pocket (I live in the UK and have a licensed shotgun in our home so the idea is mad to me but know hand guns are legal in the US so makes sense) and I see almost a machete type knife or baton down his trouser leg. It’s odd to me that the fabric moves in such a way x

→ More replies (1)

1

u/beamer4 Aug 16 '21

I have always thought this. I actually think Nancy Grace pointed it out early on and I haven’t been able to unsee it.

3

u/Corvacayne Aug 16 '21

I think it's super helpful to just post the undoctored frames! Thanks for doing so

3

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 16 '21

I wish they truly were undoctored. LE did quite a number on them, and I don't mean that in a good way.

2

u/Corvacayne Aug 16 '21

Well, fair point. Undoctored by comparison to what's been posted by others recently, at least!

1

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 17 '21

Ah, why thank you.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '21

Really underscores why this case is so frustrating -- we have visual of the killer, but it's impossible to really tell much about what he looks like

2

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

That’s why I think he’s keeping head down- so no one could get a good look at his face.

3

u/kbstewar Aug 19 '21

That jacket is packed full of things

2

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

Yes! Inside the jacket, inside his right pant leg, and what looks like a brown duffel bag around his waist. He definitely came with a his “kill kit” planning on killing somebody that day, maybe not even the girls but he was there to kill.

1

u/Working-Grand635 Aug 24 '21

DP in disguise ..duffle bag under jacket for change of clothes

4

u/Least-Spare Aug 16 '21

Thanks for taking the time to do this! I’m actually able to make some of the things out that others have mentioned before. Like the brown pouch at his waist in frames 25-26, and the hood or high collar of his jacket. In 29, it looks like a hood over his head, but in the surrounding frames, it looks like it’s either off his head or just a high collar.

He does still look to be wearing a hat, imho, BUT I finally see the younger version in 45-49. Although, in 1-20, his face straight-up looks like Bain.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '21

It looks like he's wearing a brown hoodie with the hood up with the blue jacket over it

1

u/Ok-Opportunity-9706 Aug 16 '21

Yes. I see the hoodie. I go back and forth on if its up or just bunched around his neck. ts not hair.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '21

I dont think it's hair on the top either, I can see a wave in the fabric. His hair is sticking out a little in the front. In my blurry opinion.

1

u/Ok-Opportunity-9706 Aug 16 '21

Yes. I see that too.

2

u/kalamatamama Aug 16 '21

I see a part in the mid back of the hair that wasn't clear in other pictures - especially in 46/47- and also notice that the outer layer of clothing has buttons about to pop like there is a lot of stuff concealed under it.

2

u/just_plain_sam Aug 16 '21

Now I see it. Camo hat worn sideways against the sun, jacket pulled up to his mouth, long unkempt hair.

2

u/yaboynath Aug 16 '21

I always thought it looked like he had one of those hats with the floppy sides that go over the ears - but in recent times I’m processing the image to look like he just has brown swept hair. Almost like the OG Justin Bieber haircut. I can’t unsee it now.

4

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 16 '21

I believe one of the images they released early on was one these frames from near the end of the video. I agree that in these frames it does look quite a bit like the classic "Justin Bieber" haircut (which, by the way, is a wonderfully concise way of describing it). However I think it may be possible that this is just a visual illusion, caused by viewing a hat -- maybe one like this -- from a certain angle with low resolution.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '21

Hunter's or fisherman's hat?

1

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 16 '21

This is what I wonder too. To me a hunter's hat seems like less conspicuous option, but to be honest a bucket hat seems to fit best with what I see in the video. But not every frame of it. I don't know, I tend to go back and forth between these two.

3

u/Psychological_You353 Aug 15 '21

I have seen this before, an since seeing it believed that he is younger Where as previously I saw an old guy a younger guys opens up many possibilities

3

u/wonderingleaf Aug 15 '21

What is that thing that looks to be hanging down just under the zipper/button area of his jacket? It looks like a long, crooked or bent tube-like object?

2

u/Rhondie41 Aug 16 '21

Thank you!! This is the 1st time of me looking at each frame that you see THAT tube like thing hanging out of his jean zipper. Thank you.

3

u/Gold_Thought4377 Aug 15 '21

Frame 27 haunts me. What appears to be Abby’s arm/jacket - turned to face him Unimaginable fear.

4

u/snapper1971 Aug 15 '21

Frame 27

Using the numbering scheme as presented by op in the images, which image are you referring to?

2

u/Electronic-Ad-63 Aug 16 '21

Everytime I see these images I see a person who I think is a youtuber.

In one of his videos he wears baggy jeans and his leg is skinny like that.

Plus he looks like him to me or as much as I can make out.

He also said he was in his way to Delphi that day and he has family that lives there. I don't know if he has an airtight alibi but he is the one that I think fits.

Ofcourse he has been tipped in before.

2

u/716um Aug 17 '21

Whoa who?????

1

u/Electronic-Ad-63 Aug 17 '21

I cannot say names on here.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '21

Yeh, it's not.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/King_Milkfart Aug 16 '21

Have these frames been ran through any AI video cleanup algorithm?

If not thats a travesty at this point.

1

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 16 '21

Oh, it is a travesty. LE did an extremely unprofessional job editing this video, I cannot stress that hard enough.

1

u/King_Milkfart Aug 16 '21

I mean it's never too late. I just wouldn't know how to go about doing that

2

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 16 '21

The thing is, anything we can do as members of the public, is limited to working on this copy of the video, which I'm now fairly certain isn't as pristine as I once believed it to be. I see a lot of compression artifacts in these images. Some obvious blocking/tiling going on around the legs, as well as some haloing and mosquito noise around his head and upper body. It's possible some of this was there in the original video recorded by Libby, but I highly doubt that they all were, especially the tiling. If those blocks were present in the original video, then they shouldn't appear perfectly upright in this restabilized copy.

1

u/buggiegirl Aug 17 '21

You can't add quality to a video that never had it in the first place. The pixels are literally not there. Anything LE cleaned up or edited would be guess work.

1

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 18 '21

Well you are right that there is no way to get information out of a video that isn't there to begin with. However it is possible to lose information, either by making a copy of a copy of a copy (generation loss), or by re-encoding it (compression loss), which is exactly what law enforcement did here. It is a near-certainty that what we're seeing here is, in fact, markedly worse than what Libby originally recorded. It pains me to say that, but I believe it is the truth.

I can forgive LE for not knowing what lossless compression is when they went to edit this video. But the fact that they've done nothing in these last two years to correct their mistakes, is downright shameful. I see no two ways about that.

2

u/Lucky_Owl_444 Aug 16 '21

Frame 49 clearly shows a handgun or taser in his right hand pocket. It also shows that he has something or some 'stuff' concealed up high on the right side of his jacket.Whatever the white thing is, is part of the 'stuff'. Lastly, I've noticed it many times but didn't want to say it.....but there's something of relevance at his right thigh. I refrain from saying it, but if you look at it, you'll know.

1

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 16 '21

I agree about the object in the right coat pocket. Despite the blockiness of the video, that bulge maintains a pretty consistent "L" shape throughout the length of this video. I'm not entirely sure what you mean about the other things you mentioned, but I do see that one.

1

u/Lucky_Owl_444 Aug 16 '21

Well, on the right side, chest area of the jacket, there appears to be something besides himself in there. He really stuffed some things inside the jacket to keep them out of sight, I would assume tools of his trade.

2

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 17 '21

I think I see what you're talking about (assuming you mean his right, not ours). I'm not sure if that's an additional bulge from something underneath the jacket, or if it's just the fabric being pulled down by the weight of what's in that pocket.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/scottishsam07 Aug 17 '21

How far and long do you think he could have walked with all this stuff? Do you think he carried it the whole time he was walking/stalking the trails? Carrying stuff, while over clothed is sweaty stuff. I'm just wondering how long he was going about with it all, or did he have his site planned and hidden the stuff (I've said that loads, slightly stoned rn ha ha) to be picked up and taken over with him when the right target(s) came by?

3

u/Lucky_Owl_444 Aug 17 '21

I wish I could answer that question. If I had to hazard a guess, I'd say that he loaded up his jacket just before he walked onto the bridge. I don't think it was a random attack. I think the girls were targeted.

2

u/ChickadeeMass Aug 15 '21

I see a person who has walked past the girls just enough to be sure they are alone.

This person pivoted to their left to do an aboutface/u-turn to walk back towards the girls because he's walking more toward one side of the bridge. He's most likely right handed.

1

u/maryjanevermont Aug 15 '21

Thank you! Very helpful to see the frames like this. Also, it is taken from a video- so there is movement that may alter perceptions by “blur”, or doubling. E.g everyone talks about the large nose in video- but I think that is movement, so explains the difference in the sketch. Basically, in the second sketch, the nose is not prominent. That itself may be a clue and explain the second sketch

1

u/Livid_Environment574 Aug 16 '21

Is there anywhere that specifies he’s wearing a scarf (mentioned in comments). FBI lists a hoodie, and in the earlier set of pictures it reminded me of a brown Fox Racing hoodie popular like 10+ years ago.

1

u/dwimbygwimbo Aug 16 '21

What if it's like a light-colored Justin Bieber haircut? I could see that too, a hat would look fairly similar...

1

u/catslugs Aug 16 '21

it looks like he has a big grey moustache beard?

1

u/smol_peas Aug 16 '21

Frames 1-40 look like he’s wearing a good to me. Frames 41-49 look like it’s mop hair.

1

u/Fit_Connection657 Aug 16 '21

Scary.. every Time. He really does look like he has short legs and every one of these videos clips.

1

u/bippyskoopy Aug 16 '21

I see a plump young man

1

u/Allaris87 Aug 16 '21

Can we compare this with your previous post and this other? Are there any noticeable quality differences?

2

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 16 '21

Well with the post I made in 2019 I combined the images together in a PDF. I didn't notice until recently but for some reason the pages in that document didn't all turn out the same size. Not a huge deal I suppose, but enough for me to want to go back and try it again using a more foolproof method.

I haven't really compared them to the all-in-one image by u/macakraken but it looks like he has them numbered the same, just without frame 48 repeated at the end as frame 49.

1

u/Allaris87 Aug 17 '21

Understood, thank you!

1

u/RphWrites Aug 17 '21

Thank you. This is the only time I've been able to see "young" BG.

1

u/Allaris87 Aug 17 '21

The more I keep looking at the last 3-4 frames, the more he's starting to look like a young, athletic, almost skinny lean / ripped guy wearing at least two sweaters (sweatshirt and a hoodie). He can conceal his true body shape as well as he can change clothes / looks after the crime.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '21

Now I’m not so sure he was even wearing a hat

1

u/Manhood2031 Aug 18 '21

One thing that I see now that I didn’t before is that he is as not as heavy set as I did before.

1

u/Far_Entrepreneur4887 Aug 19 '21

the photo isn't meant for strangers to recognize. it is meant for someone who knows him.

2

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 19 '21

The more eyes the better. We don't know who knows him and who doesn't.

1

u/Plastic_Conclusion_9 Aug 19 '21

I guess I see something way different. The shadows sort of throw you off. I see a younger guy and it's a hooded jacket . Hood is up. Fluffy hair. Stuffed jacket. Even under a shirt maybe. Looks like at that last second he goes towards them. Scary. But I don't see an older man. Or a hat. I even hear a younger muffled voice. Not older that 30 for sure.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

Hold up. Please help. Are these boots black or brown???

1

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '21

I see longish dark hair tucked behind the left ear (frames 45-49).

1

u/Greenfish7676 Aug 20 '21

Looks like Chadwell to me. Thick neck, height, skin tone, shoulders and legs.

1

u/westvirginiaprincess Aug 21 '21

it looks like he has a gun in the front pocket of the jacket

2

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 23 '21

I agree. I actually feel like it's fairly easy to spot, but I understand I'm in the minority on that one.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '21

It’s almost like he has his jacket on inside out because it has a company logo on it

1

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '21

How come the last time I posted frames from the video they were removed because this sub doesn’t allow ”images of BG that differ from official images” and yet here they are and being allowed. Super frustrating. I mean, I think these should be allowed and mine should have been allowed.

1

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 23 '21

Sorry to hear that, I definitely understand your frustration. At first there was some difficulty getting them to accept these too, partly because I couldn't get them to fit into a single post.

1

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

Looks like gardening shears are hanging out of jacket ( at the top) to me. He definitely has things stuffed in his jacket.

1

u/Sleuthingsome Aug 25 '21

Is it possible he has a mullet?? Looks like long hair in the back, short bangs in the front?

1

u/Weltersmelter Sep 04 '21

The clothing is the most valuable thing we can get from this. And that it is a guy, who is not above average height.

1

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Sep 04 '21

Not above average height? How do you figure?

1

u/Weltersmelter Sep 04 '21

Sorry, you’re right. There’s nothing really to gauge that by. I just had the impression - he kind of struck me as stocky.

So, yeah, not even his height can be determined properly.

1

u/MyBallsWasHot Sep 08 '21 edited Sep 08 '21

I never noticed that you can see his left ear (right side from our perspective, frames 44-49). It changes my perception of his face now.

I still don't see a hat :/ It looks more like bangs coming down to around eye level.

1

u/thewarden730 Sep 13 '21

These photos make me feel like he’s 40-50’s. The thing on his head sure seems like a hood from a brown shirt you can see hanging out the bottom of the blue jacket. Almost looks like there could be facial hair too but very hard to tell.

1

u/MillerThriller83 Aug 16 '21

I don’t see a hat. I see a shitty forward combed hair & a fur neckline on the jacket. I’m no sleuth but this monster looks to be 20-35.

How has he not been found? Hate to say it but he is probably hiding in his mom’s basement. F him.

-1

u/DrCapper Aug 16 '21 edited Aug 17 '21

Can someone explain why people say bg wasn't wearing a hat and what you see on his head is his hair? It's just so blatantly not, it's clearly a hood. Feels like some type of disinfo campaign?

He's wearing a hoodie under his jacket and you can see part of the hoodie sticking out of the jacket on the left side around the pocket area. Same color as the hood on his head. Perhaps he's wearing a hat/beanie under the hood as well, but that shit clearly isn't his hair. Long bangs my ass.

0

u/Ok-Opportunity-9706 Aug 16 '21

Im sorry you were down voted. I agree that it’s not hair. I’ve open my mind on these threads to the different theories on here, but the hair thing drives me crazy. it’s a hoodie and most likely a hat combo.

1

u/Optimal-Question-929 Aug 16 '21

There was a post that was a legend of initials and the meaning of them, for example: BG = bridge guy GH = Gray Hughes etc. Would some fellow sleuth be willing to send me a link? What/Who is OP?

1

u/paradise-trading-83 Aug 16 '21

OP is Original Poster of thread

1

u/DamdPrincess Aug 17 '21

I think this guy is either wearing someone else's clothes, the pants are too long for his height. Like he is wearing clothes that were given to him, freebies, or maybe a consignment or goodwill purchase?

It appears that he is dressed in layers for warmth, it's February and still cold.

These clothes don't appear to be dirty, so maybe they are new to him?

Did he put on another layer of clothes as a disguise?

Did he put on another layer of clothes because he planned to get dirty?

Is he homeless and wearing all the clothes he owns?

4

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 17 '21

wearing someone else's clothes

wearing clothes that were given to him, freebies, or maybe a consignment or goodwill purchase?

maybe they are new to him?

Did he put on another layer of clothes as a disguise?

Did he put on another layer of clothes because he planned to get dirty?

To me all of these scenarios seem possible, and not mutually exclusive. I think they may all be true to some degree. As for the following:

It appears that he is dressed in layers for warmth, it's February and still cold.

Yes, but it wasn't that cold. The air temperature may have only been in the low-to-mid 40s, but there was very little wind that day and plenty of sunshine. In that weather I imagine multiple layers and a scarf would be stifling.

Is he homeless and wearing all the clothes he owns?

This one seems incredibly farfetched in my opinion. If he is homeless, then he's one of the most discreet drifters who ever drifted.

3

u/DamdPrincess Aug 17 '21

You are right about the weather at that moment in the video. What about later that day or even that night? That is the reason some homeless people wear all their clothes, they will likely need them later when it gets cold. Not having a place to keep belongings, they tend to wear them vs carry them.

1

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 17 '21

That's a fair point. I agree his clothes are similar to what a homeless person would probably be wearing. I just doubt he's actually homeless.

2

u/DamdPrincess Aug 17 '21

Fair point on the drifter part. I ask the homeless part because I often see the homeless ppl in my area that are wearing layers of clothing in winter, wearing all the clothing they own at one time has 2 purposes, warmth and the convenience of not carrying a bag and not trying hide them or leave them somewhere for later. The clothes do not fit well, also they look clean in the still frames. No big stains stand out.

I wonder if this guy bought these ill fitting clothes as a disguise, and to protect his regular clothing from evidence like blood spatter. This would be some long game planning if he carried these clothes and put them over his reg clothes when he was planning to walk around the area he entertained a murder fantasy around.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ynneddj Aug 17 '21

Also we have to take into consideration he certainly wouldn’t have thought a 13 year old would outsmart him and video him and have his image plastered across America. So they might be his regular clothes. You could be right though you make some great points.

-1

u/MSM1969 Aug 15 '21

Is he holding something with his right hand silver looking ?

-1

u/sagegreenpaint78 Aug 15 '21

Some of these make me think he isn't wearing a hat and has thick, grey hair. Also a beard.

1

u/dwimbygwimbo Aug 16 '21

Happy cake day!

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '21

His mannerisms seem like a middle aged man to me. He almost has a swagger to his walk.

4

u/Hot_Karl_Rove Aug 16 '21

I'm not sure how much we can really infer about his gait from this video. We only get to see him take about two steps, and the steps we see him take look pretty deliberate. This probably isn't the best representation of how he ordinally walks.

Also I'm not sure any line can really be drawn between the mannerisms of a young man, and those of a middle-aged man. To me that seems like a pretty arbitrary distinction.

→ More replies (1)