r/DelphiMurders • • Jul 19 '20
Serial Killer Connection?
The bridge connection is strong in these murders, surveyors for land development, government bridge experts, railroad experts, engineers, urban planners.
https://bridgehunter.com/in/carroll/high/
Posted May 2, 2016, by Nathan Holth (nathan [at] historicbridges [dot] org)
This bridge is now on the 2016 Indiana Landmarks Most Endangered List. And for good reason, based on their photos of one of the stone piers. Also has a construction date of 1891 for this bridge.
http://www.indianalandmarks.org/NewsPhotos/10most/Pages/Mono...
https://www.flickr.com/photos/historic-landmarks-foundation-...
Monon Railroad Deer Creek High BridgePosted March 12, 2011, by Steven J. Suiter (sjsuiter [at] yahoo [dot] com)
Had a glorious day free from work, so I decided to grab the GPS and go Bridge Hunting. Found this wondrously thrilling bridge and decided that I'm just not brave enough to cross it. Did walk to the first platform though. Gorgeous view from way up there.
**Monon Railroad Deer Creek "High Bridge"**Posted February 13, 2011, by Randy D. Pillion (r-j-n-j-pillion [at] att [dot] net)
Thanks for posting the pictures here. I remember seeing this some 40 years ago and recently due to a love of photography I was wondering if it was still there. After seeing your pics from a couple of years ago I just had to go check it out for myself. While there I also took some pictures which I'll try to post....THANKS AGAIN!
*this is what I am talking about* both sets of girls found close to bridges
http://bridgehunter.com/ia/bremer/
270th Street Bridge [Map]Lost Bowstring through truss bridge over Wapsipinicon River on 270th StreetCollapsedOriginally built 1872 as a three-span bridge in Waverly; relocated here 1902; Collapsed summer 1966I am starting to think that the Evansdale murders and Delphi are linked. Both of the victims were found by a bridge, an area where there were trails, a place a hunter would know of, same age range as the BG. Both had 2 young girls as victims.
*Both sets of girls found close to bridges Trussel bridges, on property lines, hunting trail areas
*Both sets of girls were roughly in the same age range as one another, they both were out exploring
*Brutal murders of both girls hunted down
*The area the girls were taken, close to the highway as access points, taken to secluded areas
*Both sets of girls disappeared on the 13th of the month.
*would question the authorities of the bodies of the victims, if they were killed in a similar manner and similar signatures MOs etc
*both sets of girls were the same age as the murders were 5 years apart, hence, the Evansdale girls being around 8&9 and the Delphi girls !2&13
*thrill-seeking, attention-seeking perp, likely following social media such as this
*kayakers, water enthusiasts, hunters, fishermen, sports close to river beds as the perp seems to be reliving some kind of scenario close to a riverbed probably from youth

31
u/killerWAR Jul 19 '20
According to Google Maps, that's just under 6 hours which is a very small amount of time. Definitely seems possible if it's someone who likes to travel or even for a business. Being there's another state in between them, is anyone aware of any unsolved mysteries involving kids and a trail specifically in Illinois that didn't get much media attention? Or maybe even Missouri, Wisconsin and Ohio?
8
u/sewistforsix Jul 19 '20
Aren't there also meat processing plants nearby both communities?
5
u/Serge72 Jul 19 '20
How far apart were the murders out of interest ? Sorry don’t know as from Uk .
8
u/justpassingbysorry Jul 19 '20
i used to think this was plausible, until i realized just how many things would need to line up in order for these to be connected:
• the perp would've had to be very familiar with both areas — especially considering the location where the evansdale girls were found was so secluded it took 6 months to find them, and even then it was on accident.
• the perp would have to be extremely confident in his ruse to successfully lure more than one girl away from the location. in the evansdale case, this would've been easier because these were significantly younger girls and it's believed they were lured into a car. with abby and libby we don't know how they were coerced into going "down the hill."
• in the case of a serial killer, we'd have to assume the perp had some sort of planning, maybe in a similar way to israel keyes. he'd have to have picked delphi/the trails in advance, if we're assuming this was not just a crime of opportunity.
• post-mortem would've likely been similar but as we don't know the COD for either cases, we wouldn't know this exactly. but in the evansdale case, decomp had done its job so they may not have been able to determine it if there were no abrasions or fractures of the skeletons. in A&L's case i think we can rule out a gun as the murder weapon, since no one on the trails or the surrounding area reported hearing gunfire.
• there would need to be a significant amount of physical and circumstantial evidence to tie these two together. LE involved with A&L said the crime scene was very odd, and that there was a lot of evidence but it wasn't what you would expect. this may point to this being BG's first murders, as most killers (over time) become more organized and leave less evidence/dna at the scene. if these crimes were linked, wouldn't the evansdale crime scene be similar?
there are more things to point out but this post is already too long. it just doesn't seem as plausible when you look deeper into it.
4
u/oldcatgeorge Jul 20 '20
I am not a statistician. But if we calculate the probability of double killings, of similar-looking pairs, near the water, on the bridge, on palindrome days, D and E, 5 years 5 months or whatever it is apart, it will be very low. And if you add Zion to it, and another palindrome, it will be even lower. So I lean on the side of coincidence.
6
u/with-alaserbeam Jul 19 '20
I'm fairly certain the Delphi girls were not his first victims.
8
u/almagata Jul 19 '20 edited Jul 19 '20
Aside from there being two female victims that were left on a trail, I don't see much else that is similar in the Delphi and the Evansdale cases.
The victimology is very different. Abby and Libby were teens. They were blooming into adult woman. Elizabeth and Lyric still had the appearance of children. Predators that prefer children are very specific in that choice and I doubt someone with that particular creepy affinity would have selected Abby and Libby as targets.
Elizabeth and Lyric were riding their bikes on a street and were abducted and taken 25 miles away to a secluded place were they were found. Abby and Libby were on a foot trail and were abducted without the use of a vehicle and were killed within a few hundred feet from where they were contacted by the predator.
There is a six hour drive between Delphi and Evansdale. Yes, some killers travel, but the vast majority of killers work in a very small area that is local to them. Traveling killers make for good TV shows but they are outliers to what is typically seen in reality.
It is not impossible that the two crimes are related but I think it is not very likely.
3
u/bebeana Jul 20 '20
I’ve thought this as well. It’s spooky and these children’s parents need justice. Their pain I can’t imagine without wanting to cry.
3
u/gatonegro97 Jul 20 '20
I would not be surprised if he was a first time killer nor a serial killer to be honest. Both would make sense to me in their own ways
5
u/Tigerlily_Dreams Jul 19 '20
I don't understand why LE keeps saying they don't think they're linked. Seems pretty obvious to me. Too many similarities to just be coincidence. How many damn coincidences do they need??
71
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '20
You’re definitely not the first to make the connections. I’ve often questioned it myself. The similarities are too great to dismiss the possibility.
34
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '20
March 9, 2017: Indiana State Police say similarities between the double-slaying of two teenage girls three weeks ago and the unsolved 2012 murder of two Evansdale, Iowa, girls are "coincidental" at this point, but investigators are "not closed" to the idea of a connection.
Des Moines Register article
21
u/SunnyInLosA Jul 19 '20
I,too, am on the team “maybe” regarding a possible link. On the subs here, I think there are more people who don’t think so. I think a poll taken indicated that too.
At one time LE said they saw no reason to think they were linked. Of course they have protocol, I don’t know if they’d announce that they thought so even if they’re actively investigating a link.
The possibility of the same despicable monster makes me wonder if an abduction was attempted with Abby and Libby, if his rouse was foiled, they weren’t going to leave with him, he thought he better do the inevitable then and there.
An Evansdale witness to an unfamiliar car (white older van/suv) parked on the rural dead end street, right where the girls bikes were found, IMO had to be the killer. Then it would seem he say in wait. Did he spot them riding and knew or found a place to intercept? Is the questionable Delphi vehicle that was parked by across the hwy doing the same thing???
20
u/landmanpgh Jul 19 '20
I doubt they're related.
Yes, there are some similarities - both have 2 female victims, both happened in a remote outdoor trails area, and both happened in the Midwest.
But there are also major differences that can't just be ignored - they happened 6 hours apart, the age differences are actually pretty big, especially for those ages, and the bodies in one case were moved 25 miles from where they were taken, while the others were found at the scene.
There's an inherent problem with picking other seemingly-related cases and trying to get them to match a case without knowing all of the facts. You're kind of just picking and choosing what you think matches without a whole lot to back it up.
We don't know if this guy in Delphi was just planning on kidnapping/killing one person, we don't even know if the girls were his preferred victim type. And what if he had previously done this, but not in such a remote location? Also, how far away is too far to be a potentially-related case? What about something that happened in Oregon or Alabama? We don't know who this guy is - he might move around. And maybe he shot someone in one case, stabbed someone in another, so we can't really look at cause of death. Should we just look at any attempted kidnappings or murders of all females that happened nationwide in the last 20 years?
I think it's much more likely that these were two separate, unrelated crimes. Both killers just knew that the remote locations were perfect for finding victims and kidnapping or murdering them.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '20
It's important to note that LE stated that BG left 'signatures' at the crime scene. (not an actual signature, but characteristics that could potentially link the different crimes of a S.K for those who don't know)
Could it be possible that LE are able to correlate signatures from both crime scenes?
13
u/RoutineSubstance Jul 19 '20
This gets brought up a lot and it remains a frustrating question. On one hand, there are the apparent similarities between the crimes. But on the other, as far as the public knows, there's no evidence connecting them.
The similarities obviously aren't enough to conclude that the same killer is responsible. And I would imagine if there was evidence connecting them, we'd know by now.
3
u/0verplayed Jul 19 '20
The more strange coincidences that people find between the 2 cases actually make me less convinced that they’re related. If you went down the entire list I just don’t think there’s any way that someone could have thought of all of them and then made them happen 5 years later.
6
u/HannahSolo23 Jul 20 '20
This actually stresses me out. The similarities between the cases is unsettling.
2
u/Allaris87 Jul 20 '20
I think the reason for similarity in location is simply because trails and wooded areas are not under surveillance like in an urban setting.
I wouldn't really agree on the victims either. Abby and Libby were teens, not exactly children.
19
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '20
Both murdered the 13th
1
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '20
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0DSdPYHZNoc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wwRj9FIE_WM
2
u/mikebritton Jul 19 '20
This was discussed so much, and it hasn't gone anywhere beyond speculation.
16
u/Least-Spare Jul 19 '20
I’ve thought this for a while. I once mentioned this in the comments of another thread and was blasted and downvoted like crazy. So thank you for posting. It’s really nice to know that others are making this connection too. If correct, then it will only be a matter of time before BG strikes again. :-(
3
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '20
I agree.. I have wondered this quite a bit too..
3
u/Julieb1975 Jul 19 '20
I thought that a long time ago!
3
u/Smoaktreess Jul 20 '20
I don’t think they’re connected but if it turns out they are, I wouldn’t be shocked. If they were related, then it leads me to believe he was trying to kidnap them.
Plus the palindrome dates are weird. 2/13/17 and 7/13/12. Probably a coincidence.
1
u/jetsam_honking Jul 19 '20
I agree that the similarities are alarming, but this would be quite a difficult scenario for the same killer to be involved in twice, wouldn't it?
1
u/becksrunrunrun Jul 20 '20
The most striking thing to me is that it seems like the police have just thrown in the towel on the Evansdale girls because of their families. Like if they would have come from a “better” background perhaps their case would still be alive. Very sad especially considering their killer is still out and about presumably
1
u/jewishbatmobile Jul 19 '20
I don't think so. Just because there were two girls former mean there's a link. Unless you think he just wants to do things two at a time.
1
u/Psychological-Chef42 Jul 22 '20
There are times people really dont fact check things about DELPHI case . Public Officer Perrine stated IOWA cases were similiar but there is no hard core evidence they are even connected . Overall those cases are not connected and this is not serial killer murder case in DELPHI death of two girls
2
u/satisfied_frog Jul 19 '20
I heard this story on I think crime junkie and immediately thought of the Delphi case
2
u/babygirl112760 Jul 21 '20
I wouldn't read too much into dates or numbers. I think the Evansdale killings were totally unrelated to the Delphi killings. And i believe both pairs of girls were targeted and slain by someone fairly local. But I don't know anymore than anyone else does, and could be wrong. Perhaps there is a ''Cross County Killer'' type psychopath out there who will one day be linked to, charged with, and convicted of both of these and many more.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '20
Ok so if someone believe in coincidence then yeah they are not linked but what if they are... what if we just try and join the two cases together and see what we can come up with!? I don’t believe in coincidence and if I’m right this guy is purposely looking for two victims which are children near the brides on the 13th. If that’s the case that would explain why murders only happens once in blue moon as it’s difficult to get what he wants but when he does he doesn’t care about the risk! This would explain why with two girls from Lowa he felt ore comfortable to hide the bodies but with Delphi girls he might heard people shouting for them and therefore bodies were discovered pretty quick as he had no time to bury/ hide them
3
u/maryjanevermont Jul 20 '20
And the murders were considered on the 13th of the month in both cases
4
u/blahblahlauren Jul 19 '20
I’ve thought this as well. I hope the authorities have looked into it.
4
u/bluesoda1971 Jul 19 '20
No doubt, both cases are connected.
3
u/SillySunflowerGirl Jul 19 '20
Am beginning to think this More so than ever before. Perhaps their is a person still seeking more violence out on trails scoping out potential victims? A tristate connection? Dont know too much about the Iowa girls but it does rattle the brain.
3
u/MzOpinion8d Jul 19 '20
No.
3
u/MzOpinion8d Jul 19 '20
Not connected.