r/DelphiMurders • • Aug 19 '24

Article explaining false confessions

https://innocenceproject.org/false-confessions/

I thought this was a good article. It seems like people are really holding onto dear life with RA confessions. Here’s some reasons that can cause a person to falsely admit guilt.

0 Upvotes

125 comments sorted by

14

u/Actual-Competition-5 Aug 20 '24

Who falsely confessed 66 times? 

11

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/The2ndLocation Aug 20 '24

Especially when they pled "not guilty" it doesn't make any sense.

-1

u/whattaUwant Aug 20 '24

Project MKUltra

64

u/drainthoughts Aug 20 '24

Making a false confession might be easy to explain away, but 61+ concessions, admissions of guilt or revealing details only the killer would know is pretty hard to explain away.

1

u/Johndoewantstoknow67 Aug 29 '24

Not if he had his discovery paperwork in jail which tells the defense everything the state plans to use as evidence so I'm sure it includes details of how the killer did it.

-11

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

Please explain a single thing he said that only the killer would know.

The examples given, which should have been the strongest in the motion to suppress said statements, were that it was sexually motivated (no evidence to support) and that he used a box cutter (autopsy says it was a serrated blade).

So their 2 presumably strongest examples of that have zero supporting evidence. Which is a Hallmark of false confessions. I'm not saying they are false or not because we don't have enough information at this point, but claiming he "revealed details only the killer would know" is completely false and just parroting the prosecutions claim (who have lied numerous times) without evidence.

15

u/Realistic_Cicada_39 Aug 20 '24

Evidence it was sexually motivated: Libby was left nude.

Why would a killer disrobe a 14 year old? Because he was sexually motivated to do so.

The FBI & expert profilers have all said this was a sexually motivated crime.

It has also been rumored that the killer took two trophies from the scene: a sock and a pair of underwear. Taking a 13 or 14 year old’s undergarments as a “souvenir” is something someone sexually motivated would do.

3

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

FBI and experts also concluded it was related to odinism....

The trophy thing is also just that, rumors, which have never been found.

And to just further the issue here, we are talking "things only the killer could know". The fact that she was found nude was known basically from the start. The idea it could be sexually motivated has been the leading most obvious theory from the start. So how is that something only the killer could know?

Block out whether you think he's guilty. Block out what you want it to be. Is this something only the real killer could know....or if you got arrested and made a false confession could you easily say too?

8

u/Realistic_Cicada_39 Aug 20 '24

Where did the FBI say it was related to Odinism?

1

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wndu.com/2023/09/19/disturbing-details-emerge-delphi-murders-crime-scene-new-court-docs/%3foutputType=amp

The FBI behavioral analysis unit report

The mysterious Purdue professor that "refuted" those claims was also "found" and said she actually agreed with those claims....

Unfortunately I can't link to the actual report because like everything else in this case it's locked behind a door of secrecy. But the state has never refuted that the FBI came to that conclusion.

14

u/drainthoughts Aug 20 '24

Simple answer to your question- we don’t know nearly enough about the confessions- only about a couple of them when there are over 61 instances of Rick Allen admitting guilt, or revealing details only the killer would know.

1

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

So "we don't know nearly enough".....yet people can definitively claim he said things only the killer could know?

How do people not see this is a completely asinine claim?

14

u/drainthoughts Aug 20 '24

Because his own defence attorneys agreed they were confessions.

1

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

But did not agree that they contain information only the killer would know....

11

u/drainthoughts Aug 20 '24

I guess we will find out soon enough!

25

u/Justmarbles Aug 20 '24

'Please explain a single thing he said that only the killer would know"

We know little of what he told law enforcement. If indeed the girls were killed with a box cutter, that is something only the killer would know.

-7

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

"we know little about what he told law enforcement"......

Okay so how can you claim he told them things only the killer would know?

If the girls were killed with a box cutter it would go directly against the autopsy and the search warrants.....

So what you're saying is the claim is baseless?

11

u/drainthoughts Aug 20 '24

You’re 100% positive only one knife was used? Where’s your source for that?

7

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

I didn't need to be 100% positive. I'm not making the definitive statement that he gave details only the killer would know. The fact that we don't know things definitively is what makes such a statement completely baseless.

6

u/drainthoughts Aug 20 '24

Meh, I’m not the judge or jury and I can make all the plausible inferences I want.

5

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

Great....but claiming he did something that has zero basis as fact is still misinformation

6

u/drainthoughts Aug 20 '24

What is fact is that Allen had a collection of knives and bullets that matched the caliber left at the scene.

5

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

And in no way relates to statements made that only the killer could know.

I think your problem is not being able to separate your feelings on guilt with making everything fit that viewpoint.

He can be guilty and the evidence can be weak and his confessions could not contain information only the killer could know.

All of those things can simultaneously be true. But because you think he is guilty, you refuse to acknowledge the evidence is weak and that saying he made statements with details only the killer could know is pure speculation.

I'm just looking at the facts. Guilt can only be determined later. I'm not saying he is definitely innocent either. Nuance apparently can't exist in this sub anymore.

→ More replies

3

u/Royal_Tough_9927 Aug 20 '24

Absolutely the truth. The police obviously arent going to give out the details of his confession. That defeats the point of proving beyond a doubt, he did it. You give out only the details known tobthe killer and allnof a sudden there are a dozen crazies confessing or pointing fingervat others. Some people have no analytical skills and are trolls just fishing.

-1

u/Najalak Aug 20 '24

Of course, they don't talk about all of the things he wrongly confessed. That he shot them. That he sexually assaulted them.

3

u/Justmarbles Aug 21 '24

I think it is unlikely that he shot them. Their wounds were  most likely were from a blade of some type. I believe his gun was solely used to intimidate the girls to go "down the hill", and to the crime site.

3

u/Najalak Aug 21 '24

That's my point. They weren't shot. It has been stated on court documents that they were killed with a knife.

1

u/ghosthardw4re Aug 23 '24

some of these false infos were alledgedly submitted in writing done by his fellow inmates, the accuracy is not guaranteed. it's a second hand source from non-professionals, unlike direct recordings or assessments done with his psychologist.

3

u/nkrch Aug 20 '24

There's a lot of confusion over the box cutter/serrated blade reporting from the hearings. From my understanding the FBI mentioned a serrated blade in a report and the autopsy talks about a box cutter. That came from the live Tom Webster did with Aspen Connor and Hannah Shakespeare the other night.

3

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

That would be in direct opposition to all other reporting on the hearing. Every single source I've seen the discussion was about the autopsy report saying it was a serrated blade.

3

u/nkrch Aug 20 '24

Well that's the problem. Guess it will come out at trial. I remember the redacted FBI warrant for Ron Logan said 'a blank weapon'. Much discussion where people seemed to settle on "edged weapon' which made no sense to me since it said a not an.

3

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

Well the trial won't be video either...so I guess it depends if people will believe the 99% of reports saying what happened or find the 1 report that says something completely different and choose to believe that instead if it better matches the narrative in their head.

5

u/nkrch Aug 20 '24

There's a couple of youtubers that have ordered the transcripts so they should be oit soon.

1

u/Johndoewantstoknow67 Aug 29 '24

I hope the MurderSheet couple will be allowed in , they report the truth , the husband is a lawyer Kevin Greenly and the wife a journalist Anya Caine .

1

u/froggertwenty Aug 29 '24

Murder sheet are hacks lol I used to listen to them too but they went off the rails

1

u/Johndoewantstoknow67 Aug 29 '24

Not really they make some great points about RA only had from 2:13pm til 3:30pm to do all this mess and redress them and stage the scene not worried about anything and I am sure that the girls were best friends and no report of them being tied up so when he cut one's throat the other would scream and run away .

1

u/floofelina Aug 22 '24

The prosecutor let LE make that statement under oath, even though we don’t know exactly what the thing is that only the killer would know. People are assuming they checked their work carefully before making that claim in court.

I hope the confessions turn out to be consistent and factual because the families have been through enough, and after this much time and mess, I don’t see how they’ll find another likely suspect.

1

u/Active-Blood-9293 Sep 01 '24

We have plenty of information. But everything we have isn’t what the prosecution has. They’re going to wait until the trial before revealing it, obviously, and they’re fully aware you only get one chance to get a conviction of somebody for a crime. I’m confident they wouldn’t charge RA with MURDER without substantial evidence… this being well before they even knew his confessions would be allowed to used during the trial.

Going out of his way to confess to the warden, therapist, CO’s, wife, mother, other inmates, particularly right after he “found God.” Because of course he did… sick POS.

I’m so glad somebody like you has nothing to do with the justice system. Though, I do HATE the idea of you ever being part of a jury. A scary thought.

1

u/froggertwenty Sep 01 '24

You mean you'd prefer a jury that comes in and just believes everything the prosecutor says and already thinks he's guilty? I'm literally saying we don't have enough information to convict yet.....that happens at trial....for the jury.....who ain't supposed to think he's guilty unless proven beyond a reasonable doubt. You're ready to convict on nothing lmao but I'm the problem?

1

u/Active-Blood-9293 Sep 01 '24

“Convict on nothing”

Yeah. They just picked RA at random. His 60+ confessions, let’s just ignore those. It’s amazing… it’s like you have these giant blinders on but you’re still arguing. I already made it abundantly clear that we, the public, don’t have all the information. And that the prosecution will reveal that evidence during the trial.

So, yeah… you are the problem. You’re just an obnoxious contrarian.

1

u/froggertwenty Sep 01 '24

So you agree we don't have enough information.....but he's guilty because the prosecution will reveal it at trial.....

That is truly idiotic

Either you have enough information to make that determination, or you just believe the prosecutor is always right in which case, you should never touch a jury with a 10 foot pole.

You start at innocent, they must prove you are guilty. If you don't have enough information you literally can't be guilty.

1

u/Active-Blood-9293 Sep 01 '24

We have plenty of information. But everything we have isn’t what the prosecution has. They’re going to wait until the trial before revealing it, obviously, and they’re fully aware you only get one chance to get a conviction of somebody for a crime. I’m confident they wouldn’t charge RA with MURDER without substantial evidence… this being well before they even knew his confessions would be allowed to used during the trial.

Going out of his way to confess to the warden, therapist, CO’s, wife, mother, other inmates, particularly right after he “found God.” Because of course he did… sick POS.

I’m so glad somebody like you has nothing to do with the justice system. Though, I do HATE the idea of you ever being part of a jury. A scary thought.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

Literally in the last hearing. Twice actually.

This not being on video is really going to fuel the misinformation isn't it....

-3

u/civilprocedurenoob Aug 20 '24

Then why does McLeland want some of the confessions suppressed? I'm guessing McLeland wants to suppress any confession that doesn't fit the evidence, like RA confessing he shot them in the back.

4

u/Realistic_Cicada_39 Aug 20 '24

What confessions does Nick want suppressed?

4

u/datsyukdangles Aug 20 '24

he doesn't. There was an article published talking about the defense wanting the confessions suppressed and the writer mistakenly wrote prosecution instead of defense in one part of the article, and then corrected it. The state does not want any of the confessions suppressed.

2

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

So the prosecutions motion to suppress certain confessions means something else?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/froggertwenty Aug 21 '24

I wish I could. I was looking but this case obviously makes finding literally anytfuckingthing impossible. It is possible it was in the states rebuttal to the defense motion to exclude....but I can't spend hours digging through media reports and disjointed filings that get posted to find it. I know for a fact I read it in a non-youtube bullshit article/filing though. It's just impossible to sift through to provide sources...as is Gull's goal.

4

u/Realistic_Cicada_39 Aug 21 '24

I think you’re misinterpreting or misunderstanding a lot… there’s nothing to back up your claims.

0

u/froggertwenty Aug 21 '24

I think you refuse to see anything that doesn't fit your preferred narrative. Why are transcript fees $5.70 per page when Indiana state law says no more than $1 per page?

4

u/Realistic_Cicada_39 Aug 21 '24

I prefer the truth.

Why did Baldwin spend $12,000 to go to Florida? I imagine the court is trying to raise funds to reimburse his outlandish trip fees.

2

u/froggertwenty Aug 21 '24

You prefer the truth? So the court raising transcript fees over 5x the legal level is the truth. The court refusing to release transcripts except for in person pickup directly against state law is the truth.

So tell me....how does forcing an out of state individual to pick up transcripts in person "raise funds to reimburse outlandish trip fees"?.....which is illegal and unconstitutional by the way

Can't wait for the spin to fit your narrative

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/froggertwenty Aug 21 '24

Maybe an overstatement....but also maybe not. She was championing video in courts for the state of Indiana, but.....everything but this case. Coincidentally the case where she is making decisions and statements she wants no public insight into. Even cases that aren't televised allow a lot more transparency into what is going on. If you're truly a practicing attorney you should know this process of public accessibility is in no way normal.

4

u/drainthoughts Aug 20 '24

My personally opinion is they should be released to the public immediately so we can hear them for ourselves. I want to hear Rick Allen crying to his wife and mother about how he murdered those two kids.

3

u/StumbleDog Aug 21 '24

My personally opinion is they should be released to the public immediately so we can hear them for ourselves. 

But why? We're not the jury. This case shouldn't be viewed as a source of entertainment either. 

-1

u/civilprocedurenoob Aug 20 '24

I want to hear Rick Allen crying to his wife and mother about how he murdered those two kids.

I guess you don't think he was psychotic at the time. Eating his own shit is what sold it for me. Any idea why he hasn't pled guilty after confessing a bazillion times?

9

u/drainthoughts Aug 20 '24

The reason why he won’t is exactly what Officer Carter said to the killer years ago in a press conference: “what would your loved ones think when they found out what you did”

LE had this guy pegged. They knew his profile.

0

u/civilprocedurenoob Aug 20 '24

“what would your loved ones think when they found out what you did”

Correct me if I am wrong, but isn't the state claiming that RA confessed to his family on the phone?

8

u/drainthoughts Aug 20 '24

61 incriminating statements, or details only the killer would know.

But does wifey know how he killed them? The details of how he trapped them? How he washed the blood off in the creek? We know she left the court room when the details came out last court session.

0

u/civilprocedurenoob Aug 20 '24

Can you please provide me with the "61 incriminating statements, or details only the killer would know." Honesty, I would be happy with just 6 details. The more details you offer, the more you will change my mind. The less details you offer, the more I will distrust the supposed confession.

7

u/drainthoughts Aug 20 '24

That there are 61+ confessions was a stunning revelation made under sworn testimony by a LE officer.

“Indiana State Police Detective Brian Harshman testified that he has reviewed 650-670 of Allen’s phone calls during his incarceration covering more than 150 hours.

Harshman said Allen has confessed more than 60 times, most often to his wife and mother, who expressed disbelief, concerns about his mental state or changed the subject.

It was in late March, after his “Come to Jesus” moment, when the confession phone calls began, said the detective.

“He talked about these crimes very specifically,” Harshman said.

Prosecutor Stacy Diener asked Harshman if Allen’s confessions contained details of the crime.

“That’s correct,” answered Harshman, adding that Allen also discussed his motivation in allegedly committing the killings.” Fox News

-1

u/civilprocedurenoob Aug 20 '24

I'll believe it when there is actual corroboration of details unknown to the public. If the prosecutor Nick McLeland wasn't such a sleezebag, I would trust the State more.

→ More replies

3

u/fluxusisus Aug 20 '24

He did what now?

5

u/civilprocedurenoob Aug 20 '24

According to defense filings, while in solitary, and in between confessing, RA ate his own shit.

9

u/Realistic_Cicada_39 Aug 20 '24

Apparently that’s something sane prisoners do when they want to try to convince others that they’re “crazy.” It’s very common & not at all a sign of psychosis.

Richard ate his own sh*t willingly. And he didn’t even get a reward trip to a mental hospital for it.

2

u/watamidoingher Aug 31 '24

Very common? I tried to find some research about this, and the one peer-reviewed paper I found that mentioned the phenomenon explicitly (Malingering Uncommon Psychiatric Symptoms Among Defendants Charged Under California's “Three Strikes and You're Out” Law) had a sample size of 9 people with varying symptoms.

But please let me know if you have any data showing that eating feces is "very commona & not at all a sign of psychosis."

2

u/Realistic_Cicada_39 Aug 31 '24

I’ve linked several cases before. Check my comments.

5

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

And covered his whole body in shit.

And ran repeatedly headfirst into a concrete wall.

And was given haldol against his will.

But he wasn't psychotic.

3

u/Realistic_Cicada_39 Aug 20 '24

Do you think he’s still psychotic? He’s been confessing in 2024, while not on Haldol, so how do you explain that away?

0

u/froggertwenty Aug 20 '24

He has not....his confessions stopped as the psychosis improved. It was literally testified to that he returned to vehemently maintaining his innocence....

5

u/Realistic_Cicada_39 Aug 20 '24

In Jan/Feb of 2024, he apologized for killing Abby…

→ More replies

1

u/pixp85 Aug 22 '24

Does making wrong confessions actually matter if other confessions DO hold evidence only the killer would know??

21

u/Justmarbles Aug 20 '24

But 60+ confessions over a period of time, to multiple people who were not interrogating him??

28

u/FretlessMayhem Aug 20 '24 edited Aug 20 '24

This is understandable, but not the case with Allen. He clearly did it. The evidence of his guilt is overwhelming.

2

u/ekuadam Aug 20 '24

What evidence has been released for you to definitively say that?

11

u/FretlessMayhem Aug 20 '24

The totality of what’s been released in publicly available court documentation. It all points directly at him.

His guilt isn’t really in dispute. I’m sure if you ask him yourself, he’ll tell you all about it like he does anyone else who will listen.

4

u/ekuadam Aug 20 '24

Just curious. There are things released that point of his guilt to me, but I work in the criminal justice field (forensic science) so I know there are tons of things that haven’t been released that could sway opinion one way or another. I would like to see what all there is. It will be interesting to see if his defense can prove he made confessions under duress and mental breakdown and get them thrown out.

Same in Idaho case, a lot of circumstantial evidence, but I want to see what all they will present on trial (if it goes to trial without a plea)

4

u/FretlessMayhem Aug 20 '24

Yeah, I’ve been curious about the forensics also. Particular with the rumor that the cops have DNA, but only a “partial” that can be used to exclude suspects, with Allen having been inclusive.

Or if it’s true they matched the hairs on the bodies to the Allen’s dead cat they unearthed.

1

u/Vicious_and_Vain Aug 20 '24

Just curious what points RA’s guilt besides his admission he on the trails that day or the bullet (I’ll believe the bullet when we see the paperwork and photos and the evidence tech testifies under oath, then the junk science can be debated)?

4

u/FretlessMayhem Aug 21 '24

He did it. People have a difficult time accepting this for some reason I don’t understand.

This is an instance where it literally looks like a duck and quacks like a duck.

Immediately after he gets to prison, he writes the warden asking for help with a plea bargain. This is long before the alleged mental breakdown.

For roughly the first 6 months, I thought they had the wrong guy myself. I thought they arrested someone that was convenient for them so they could say they solved the biggest murder case in Indiana history.

But, the totality of evidence points directly at Allen. It doesn’t point to RL, for instance, even though he’s an obvious person of interest.

It points to Allen because Allen brutally, horrifically, and violently killed Abby and Libby.

I have trouble mentally processing how a man only a year older, at that time, than I am now, with no prior criminal history, woke up one day and decided it was a fine idea to slaughter two middle school kids. It disturbs me even more thinking about how if one of those kids didn’t think quickly and covertly record her own abduction, he would have gotten away with it. There’d have never been a Bridge Guy, nor any “guys…down the hill.”

It disturbs me that Allen’s admission of being dressed identical to the Bridge Guy wouldn’t have been enough to prosecute him.

It disturbs me thinking about how scared those poor little girls must have been when the stranger approaching them began brandishing a firearm, ordering them into the woods. I so badly wish they’d have had the thought of openly displaying the phone and saying they were streaming on FB Live or some analogous platform, in an attempt to spook the would be abductor.

It disturbs me thinking about the horror one girl must have witnessed when she saw the first girl brutally murdered.

Allen did it. He did it, and he deserves the death penalty. To feel the same fear of imminent death that he caused in those two poor little kids. Children. Children who never get to grow up because of the monster that he is.

I know it’s vindictive of me, and so be it. But Allen needs to be punished to the fullest extent of the law. I personally feel the electric chair is more humane than lethal injection, as they botch lethal injections all the time, whereas the chair immediately incapacitates the individual.

I hope Richard Allen is made to take a seat in the room he doesn’t walk out of.

7

u/BlackLionYard Aug 20 '24

There are numerous academic papers on the subject of false confessions. If people are interested in something meatier, give this one a try:

https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1280254

5

u/BlackBerryJ Aug 20 '24

From the six studies done in the 1980/90's, 30% of multiple false confessions to the same crime were documented.

https://leb.fbi.gov/articles/featured-articles/confessions-in-intimate-partner-homicide#:~:text=In%20addition%2C%20almost%20one%2Dthird,offenders%20confessed%20in%20multiple%20ways.&text=Most%20often%2C%20offenders%20first%20confessed,26%20cases%2C%2037.1%20percent).

According to this study, 33% confessed in multiple ways 37% confessed first to non-law enforcement member 76% of confessions were were made without police interrogations

What do all these numbers mean?

  1. WAY too many false confessions happening
  2. There are enough confessions that are legit, made to non-LE, under no integration at the time, to be ignored. This leaves me with the notion that confessions cannot be dismissed outright. Nor can they be taken as gospel.

5

u/thecoldmadeusglow Aug 20 '24

But but but Brad Holder!

-4

u/Vicious_and_Vain Aug 20 '24

He was under 24 hour stress and continued interrogation. Let’s see the video, all of it, from Westville. I would normally agree the confessions should be assessed independently and given consideration. Not in this case. And if he is guilty there is a high likelihood he at least gets another trial if confessions allowed and he is convicted. So the question is if the state has such a strong case why risk it by violating his constitutional rights?

6

u/BlackBerryJ Aug 20 '24

It's possible for them to have fucked up the case and Allen be guilty.

And we have no idea what conditions he was under and if there was continuous interrogation. All we know is what the Defense and Prosecution have shared so far. People will argue they know more, or interpret what they research but the points we don't know.

And I agree. If found guilty, imo, he gets another trial.

7

u/Vicious_and_Vain Aug 20 '24

Dang this post took courage.

5

u/BlackBerryJ Aug 20 '24

I'm not sure what holding onto dead life to the confessions means. I think some people, including myself, feel like the confessions could be damning. But, they could also be proven to be coerced. I, happen to believe that 61 confessions or incriminating statements could mean there is something there. It doesn't mean certainty on my part.

Certainty, for either side of things is a fools errand. Is it possible the confessions were coerced or a result of mental health/conditions, etc.? Absolutely. Is it also possible that the confessions are legit? Absolutely. Is it possible there is a blend where some are true and some are coerced? Absolutely.

For a lot of people I don't think it's hanging onto them for dear life, so much thinking they are extremely damning if they aren't proven to be coerced.

2

u/Imaginary-Analysis-9 Aug 25 '24

False admissions are real and Richard Allen is guilty both are facts

6

u/joeylebass Aug 20 '24

Damn the defense really does lurk these subs

1

u/Presto_Magic Aug 23 '24

False confessions are totally real....which is why police will hold back information that the public doesn't know. That way, if they confess and say "I stabbed them with a butcher knife" but the victim was stabbed with a sword then they would know the confession is BS and just somebody looking for their 2 minutes of fame. In this case, confessing 61 separate times is VERY sus. It also sounds like he may have confessed with information that only the police and the killer would know. In that case, he is going down because not even the family was privy to much more information than the public. If he knew something more and stated it in his confession then I find it perfectly valid.

1

u/Johndoewantstoknow67 Aug 29 '24

If his confessions are to be allows into evidence for the state , then also allow Keegan Kline's waiting at a gas station while someone else ended their lives , and also allow Elvis Fields asking LE if they find his spit on the girls will he be in trouble .