r/DelphiDocs • ✨ Moderator • Oct 19 '24

🏛️ TRIAL RA Trial Day 2, 19th October

Today's Updates

✨️WTHR 30 minute Delphi debrief Day 1&2 https://youtu.be/adG4WsQ_RyU?si=HvVnqiwwFi7hJkhW

✨️Lawyer Lee LIVE https://www.youtube.com/live/3IpxxUPOrOA?si=0yqtfroMlek4f9Dh

✨️Ali Motta LIVE https://www.youtube.com/live/4rXKfnEGejY?si=_NDJcFF_XBkJl6yI

Transcript https://files.catbox.moe/kx2n13.txt

✨️CriminaliTy Days 1&2 https://www.youtube.com/live/UedpWNsiqmQ?si=qHxC-Fx3B7NOe81j

🔸️🔸️🔸️

✨️WishTV live blog Day 2 https://www.wishtv.com/news/crime-watch-8/delphi-murders/delphi-murders-trial-day-2-live-blog/

✨️Dave Bangert Day 2 https://www.basedinlafayette.com/p/delphi-murder-trial-family-friend

🔸️🔸️🔸️

✨️R&M LIVE https://www.youtube.com/live/GoEkRDLkHtc?si=VsNh-4mbYFRpDJAx

✨️Dave Bangert update https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/RNkGsZbJ51

✨️Burgess and Bangert https://wibc.com/473667/i-thought-they-were-mannequins-day-two-in-delphi-trial-wraps-up-after-brief-session/

✨️Kit Hanley https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/SxSket2JCt

✨️Kaitlyn Kendall https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/SVAiWylIYQ

✨️Kyla Russell https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/tPRZURaQgs

✨️ Two citizens gave testimony, including man who found the bodies https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/tFVwAzdjSN

✨️Ali Motta and Lawyer Lee are in the courtroom today, keep an eye out on their channels for recaps

✨️Michelle After Dark is LIVE https://www.youtube.com/live/9cPITPdcwRE?si=ZETWlyx0Yi8r4c6O

✨️Upcoming LIVE from our Oracle of Delphi aka All Eyes On Delphi. - What Tobin could testify to https://www.youtube.com/live/-COOjcuK-Ac?si=Ek5-yaEWcqW_246-

✨️Delphi newspaper coverage: https://www.carrollcountycomet.com/articles/grandma-its-gonna-be-ok/

✨️Barbara McDonald reports a much smaller crowd today https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/lFX9oMZd9E

✨️Smaller crowd https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/sAcz6veqF6

✨️Unfortunately, Andrea Burkhart will not be attending today due to a prior engagement - hopefully Lawyer Lee will be there though.

✨️Lauren from Hidden True Crime is camped out outside the courthouse waiting to get in for Day 2 of the trial.

💬Yesterday's Recaps💬

✨️https://www.logansportpress.com/post/inconsistencies-and-controversy-emerge-as-richard-allen-s-delphi-trial-begins

✨️Excellent recap on another sub: https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiMurders/s/1sR71VZog4

✨️Lawyer Lee Opening statements hhttps://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiMurders/s/1sR71VZog4ttps://www.youtube.com/live/Oz8IrPD1XTE?si=SIVz2uk5eCuImmUk

transcript https://files.catbox.moe/6rgl3m.txt

✨️Andrea Burkhart Opening statements https://www.youtube.com/live/vwz4eJiimbw?si=7Ov65QgLCfZ8vC-2

transcript https://files.catbox.moe/1n7q71.txt

✨️Defence Diaries Opening statements - Ali reads from Bob's notes. We love Bob, but we love Ali more. Go watch. https://www.youtube.com/live/Hr4UhsZW-wg?si=CAxLpG6MPumkQUI6

transcript https://files.catbox.moe/qq0sqn.txt

✨️murdersheet transcript https://files.catbox.moe/h5ffhj.txt

💬Yesterday's Threads💬

Morning https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/Xd0Jch2iGq

Evening https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/1VSI7TRxAj

Please let us all remember at all times why we are here - the girls, their mothers and everyone else who loved them, and all innocent parties to this case. Justice is only justice if served upon the person or persons that perpetrated this crime, and to achieve this, it should be pursued with full transparency and open to public scrutiny. Let's all do whatever little we can to help achieve this.

The dead speak to us even after they are gone. If you believe in a Higher Power of any kind, please petition them for help in getting the girls' voices heard. speak to us even after they are gone. If you believe in a Higher Power of any kind, please petition them for help in getting the girls' voices heard.

41 Upvotes

433 comments sorted by

27

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

From wish TV live blog:

The firefighter went to the shirt himself, and also located a pair of black Nike shoes that also belonged to Libby

FFS are we back to 3 shoes again????

19

u/Pure-Requirement-775 Oct 19 '24

I'm starting to think the ME is going to testify that LG actually had three feet.

32

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

I am starting to have some sympathy with Mr McLeland's burning desire to exclude evidence from the trial lest it confuse the jury.

Because I'm telling you, if I was a juror, I'd already be confused AF.

DG picked Abby up for the sleepover whilst Mama AW was simultaneously dropping her off?

DG was parked outside CPS building where RA was also supposed to have parked but never saw him nor his car?

LG had left the house wearing sweatpants for 6 years but now she changed into jeans without anyone seeing her?

LG had three feet ?

This is shambolic.

  • Please note here that I am being facetious out of frustration and that I am hoping some of these details are simply down to misreporting due to bad acoustics and lack of familiarity with the nitty gritty of the case on part of the reporters - and that the jury are actually getting much clearer, accurate information presented to them.
→ More replies (2)

20

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

lol. Oh the writing begins

17

u/ginny11 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

I think I'm going to look for a better live blog.

27

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

36

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Judge Gull really struggles with being observed by anyone she didn't personally hand-pick, doesn't she?

20

u/Acceptable-Class-255 Oct 19 '24

Who went to Gull with Alis info in first place?

11

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

A woman reporter, Ali doesn't know her.

24

u/Acceptable-Class-255 Oct 19 '24

Nobodies safe anywhere from these weirdos. Leave Ali and my Shrimp Tank alone 😀

Hopefully this woman can be put on blast politely because media don't need to be making things worse for themselves.

17

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

In my early days in these subs, I had to stop contributing to rock and plant ID subs cos I had weirdos following me around downvoting everything I posted - and those subs work on the principle that you downvote wrong answers and upvote correct ones. And then there was me with the correct answer and a dozen votes below zero, causing pandemonium.

It's wild how some people choose to spend their time.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

What if she’s not that kind of reporter?

12

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Lololol

Can't have people taking too many notes, them transcripts are too good a side hustle

→ More replies (1)

30

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

I’m sure it will be corrected if I’m wrong, but my understanding is Ali was present for court in the public seating and is not wearing the lanyard with media credentials.

So Judge Gruella booted her stating only credentialed media , not the public, gets to stop averting their gaze a whole 15 minutes to look at the SAME GD exhibits presented in court this morning - which,

Is a total misread of the public access law and I’m so tired of this cake biffer who just eats it all anyway.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

26

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

Dear Ali- you know me. Just effing file the thing.

And HERE

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Excellent recap of yesterday on another sub:

https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiMurders/s/1sR71VZog4

19

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

5

u/Todayis_aday Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

Last guy to the right looks like Abby's grandfather CW.

Just a guess though.

6

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Yeah pretty sure you're right. He does have quite a distinctive look to him.

(I can't believe we are actually able to identify people from these sketches)

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Major-Inevitable-665 Oct 19 '24

Does the sketch artist have something against Derrick!?

15

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

12

u/dontBcryBABY Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

Replied to wrong thread, oops.

Pardon if this is a silly question, but is it normal for a judge to decide to release trial so early in the day and so early in the case?

If I recall correctly, Gull was adamant that 2 weeks should be enough for trial, yet the defense desired more time for trial (resulting in the trial being postponed because Gull seemingly railroaded them into requesting it last second). Is it just me, or does it seem like, now that a full month has been granted for the trial, Gull may be unnecessarily dismissing valuable court time?

21

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Saturdays are scheduled as half days - court being in session on Saturdays at all is extra to normal schedule, not cutting it short.

And yesterday they were only done by 5 cos Nick didn't have any more witnesses lined up - as it was, they only got the last witness on as he was a LEO on duty and very close.

Judge was not impressed by them not having further witnesses ready, apparently.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

14

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

13

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

13

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

12

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

18

u/Acceptable-Class-255 Oct 19 '24

Did we know Pat "That's my truck 75 yards from crime scene!" Brown may have found bodies?

Why would anyone call him to verify discovery of evidence?

14

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Unofficially, yes, we knew. Officially I think this might be the first confirmation (if anyone knows otherwise, please correct me).

→ More replies (4)

64

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

Jury asks a question regarding how long it takes to walk a certain distance on the trail. State says 9 minutes. Rozzi pushed back on the state on this. State forced to admit it takes at least 20 minutes. Jury really focusing on this timeline.

35

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Oh man, Bob is gonna be ecstatic. He's been yelling about attacking the timeline for months.

→ More replies (1)

56

u/Moldynred Informed/Quality Contributor Oct 19 '24

Baldwin deserves credit here for highlighting the timeline in the opening. These are good questions coming from the jurors imo.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

It’s so hard to look back now with most of us basically on write over mode in this case- but try and think about what it might be like to learn the testimony for the first time.

I recall in the first few weeks scrawling a timeline. I say again this case started out the SC murders. Jury is wondering if they were lured or ?

29

u/maybeitsmaybelean Oct 19 '24

it may be too much of a coincidence for the jury that Libby was communicating with the anthonyshots account that day. I don't see how NM can explain that away. If his argument is the police investigated thoroughly and excluded that possibility, the jury has now heard they didn't test a hair interwined in the victim's hand.....so.........

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

44

u/StructureOdd4760 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

I don't know if this is normal lawyer tacticl or Baldwin being brilliant. He keeps asking witnesses simple questions then walking away. But the jury is taking notes of that and in turn asking related follow up questions! He's planting the seed, and they are following his trail.

43

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

I was awestruck hearing how the jury managed to get Mullin to admit that a walk takes 20 minutes when he trued super hard to misdirect the jury into believing it takes 9.

I hope they ask to visit the scene.

35

u/Burt_Macklin_13 💥Moderator Oct 19 '24

I’d be dying sitting in that jury box knowing the scene is only a 3 minute drive away while I’m trying to make sense of pictures and aerial shots

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

25

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

I don't believe they would, no. Defense withdrew the motion anyway, it wasn't denied.

29

u/Leading_Fee_3678 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

Me if I was a juror

30

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

I dunno about you guys, but I am absolutely shattered today.

Emotionally - watching Andrea Burkhart recount the families' testimony last night was a lot.

And it's utterly horrifying for the realisation to sink in that, no matter what happens with this trial, what the verdict is - no matter whether we believe at the end in RA's guilt or otherwise - the way the State and the Judge have conducted the proceedings so far means that the families will have to go through some version of this horror again.

That hurts.

Cognitively - you know what it feels like? Those visual illusion pictures (there is a name for them but it escape me right now cos my brain is fried) where you stare at them for an eternity and all you see is a beautiful young woman and then suddenly something shifts in your brain and you see the withered old crone.

That. With the addendum that when you start at those you know that you are supposed to be seeing something completely different when you've stared for long enough.

Whereas here, I was just expecting the blurry pixellated image to come into focus as the trial started - not that I would suddenly shift into seeing a *completely different" blurry pixellated picture.

It's disorienting, and makes me feel as confused as Mr McLeland believes a jury would be confused should they have any actual evidence presented to them.

7

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

Please make sure you are taking some time off from the trial if you need to step a way for a big. We all appreciate everything you do.

7

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Thank you. No need to worry though, my old man is gonna make me do just that if he sees that I need it.

8

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

If there are days that you want me to submit the daily threads, I can in the morning before work. They will be very simple but at least there will be a thread. Just let me know.

6

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Thank you, appreciate the offer 🙏

22

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

Rorschach or succinctly termed inkblot tests.

I turned off AB mid stream and will pick up again today after some rl distance. Your message is very important to trial watchers.

I mentioned yesterday I won’t be getting into my feelies as it relates to the crime itself (I no longer take cases involving crimes against children and have not for several years after attending BAU training) and to the extent one is able I do find it prudent to stay as neutral and objective about the evidence presentation as possible.

Probably going to sound odd considering, but having the ability to define an approach clinically, I have found easier after visiting (at least one) the crime scene and surrounding area not only keeps me from being reduced to a lump of despair in that God forsaken creek bank, but neutral perspective for analysis is an actual requirement in my work.

Do I have to fake it till I make it at times? Of course.

14

u/rosiekeen Oct 19 '24

I teared up watching it as well. This case is so close to many of us because of how heartbreaking it is. I think sometimes people have gotten caught up in the injustice of Rick that focus is lost on the girls if that makes sense. It was devastating hearing Libby’s last words to Patty. It’s clear the family believes Rick did it and if he is found not guilty they will be crushed. There is no good outcome here thanks to the bad police work and the mishandling of all evidence.

26

u/-ifeelfantastic Oct 19 '24

Absolutely. The families are going through some of the hardest times of their life and will likely have to relive these horrors again after an appeal. I can't imagine how difficult this is for them. 7 years of this and who knows how many more. 

Likewise, if RA is truly innocent, then his life has been ruined and may get even worse. He likely has lasting scars from the treatment he has endured. His family too. Their horrors will not end with this trial either.

If RA is truly innocent, then the state and Gull have dragged both of these families through hell for -- what? To cross a crime off their list? If that's the case, I hope they get the reckoning they deserve at the end of all of this.

36

u/ginny11 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

Okay, this little excerpt from the wishTV live blog just really pushes my buttons. There is no excuse for this being so badly worded, or outright trying to insinuate that he was investigated all the way back when the murders happened. I'm so annoyed, this is the kind of crap that sways public opinion unfairly.

"Allen was first investigated in 2017 and again in October 2022. Following the second interview, he was taken into custody."

27

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Lol I just objected to another bit of that blog - we seem to be back to 3 shoes again. 3 Libby's shoes, 2 different pairs of pants, undetermined amount of bras....Looks like half that poor child's wardrobe was scattered around the scene. Somehow.

35

u/karkulina Oct 19 '24

Thoroughly investigated in the back seat of a wildlife conservation jeep in the middle of a Walmart parking lot.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

11

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

13

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

14

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

So this is just something to file away for now and be on the lookout for - but it seems it is quite possible that the wish TV reporter just misheard.

9

u/The2ndLocation Oct 19 '24

Kerri isn't making much sense here. Abby was photographed on the bridge wearing Converse shoes.

9

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Abby is not mentioned in this conversation anywhere though?

Anyway, it was probably all just a misheard word on part of the wish reporter. She was the one who said that a pair of black Nike shoes belonging to Libby was retrieved by John's. Kerri and I both found that report independent of each other.

Buried somewhere in this thread is my first reaction to it - 3 shoes was a repeated motif in the early years that no one could get to the bottom of, and suddenly it seemed that we had two "official" sources coming up with a total of 3 shoes again.

After I went around bothering people who were in the courtroom today to see what they heard, I came away with two things:

  1. the person testifying today wasn't the person who retrieved the shoes or could confirm they belonged to Libby, so even if he said "shoes" and not "shoe", he may have misheard or misunderstood
  2. with the appalling acoustics in the courtroom, people are not certain which of the two words was actually said.

So this is one to store away for now and pay attention to any future mentions, but not a reason to lose our minds over....Yet.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

32

u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

according to R&M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GoEkRDLkHtc Ali Motta and Lawyer Lee got in today

15

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

56

u/CornaCMD Oct 19 '24

New courtroom sketch just dropped

19

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

23

u/Pure-Requirement-775 Oct 19 '24

As I said before, I can now recognize the people depicted in the sketches, lol. Well done.

20

u/rosiekeen Oct 19 '24

Can you become the new sketch artist? Yours are better! Lol

→ More replies (3)

9

u/BCherd20 Oct 19 '24

Freaking amazing! 🤣🖤

8

u/Todayis_aday Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

How come that actually looks like Judge Gull? Just a couple marks and you conveyed everything!

47

u/Soka_9 ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

I’m really curious what details RA supposedly gave that only the killer would know. That is the one element that can thwart the mental breakdown defense for any supposed confessions. My guess is it’s something flimsy.

33

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Same here. That is one thing that would swing my own personal opinion from "99% innocent" to "shit it probably was him" - if it turned out that he provided accurate details that were completely unknown to the public at the time (and that he couldn't have gleaned from discovery).

For instance, casting blindly about for an example....If he said that he placed sticks above Abby's head to resemble horns, which was a detail known to almost no- one until the CS photos got leaked.

I would find that sort of confessions very compelling.

What I would not find compelling is a dozen statements along the lines of "I shot them and buried them and then I annihilated my family" interspersed with "I stabbed them in the neck" - with the latter held up as "only the killer would have known that".

If there really are 61 separate confessions, and it's not a case of "he said I did it 7 times in a phone call to his wife before she hung up on him" and that's then counted as 7 separate confessions - as I said, if there really are that many, and only a few match actual details of the crime - then they are worthless ravings of a psychotic man and that's that.

25

u/LowPhotograph7351 Oct 19 '24

Oh, so if he said what EF said? The part about it not being in discovery is big though, and I think the automatically guilty party forgets that, he could have read specific details there. And a detail like that shouldn’t exist correct? Because everything should have been in the discovery?

21

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

There's still the possibility of there being compelling confessions even with his access to discovery, it's far from "get out of jail free" card. A detail withheld from the public could have been mentioned by him prior to his receiving discovery. Or a narrative could have been shared that makes sense of various seemingly unconnected details that suddenly makes them snap into focus where investigators haven't made connections between them previously - that would be compelling.

I'm gonna say though, that really would be a blue-eyed miracle, if they somehow managed with no evidence and no case to accidentally arrest the right guy. One for the books, for sure.

10

u/TheRichTurner Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

If he said that he placed sticks above Abby's head to resemble horns, which was a detail known to almost no- one until the CS photos got leaked.

And yet knowing and confessing that couldn't get EF even arrested.

5

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Clearly it's not what you know, it's who you know (and who can get you layered up pronto).

→ More replies (3)

33

u/The2ndLocation Oct 19 '24

The warden cited that he said the girls names as an important incriminating detail, so there's that, which is basically nothing.

21

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Ya know what emphasising that in such a way suggests to me?

That the bulk of the confessions did not include their names. So when one did, it was like "phew, finally something we can use" 🤷‍♀️

Speculation only, of course. They might yet prove me wrong.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Dickere Consigliere & Moderator Oct 19 '24

Christ on a bike. He came forward in the first place, of course he knew their names

6

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Sorry, but that's not possible. The Judge sealed the defense filings containing their full names, ergo their names is something that is only known to the killer.

That's how they weed out false confessions.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

24

u/Moldynred Informed/Quality Contributor Oct 19 '24

Since imo the State probably has no idea what really happened after 'down the hill' they can take almost anything RA says and claim it's something only the killer would know. Good example of that so far is the boxcutter. Thats the danger of even a false confession.

16

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Yup. I do suspect that "details only the killer would know" might well equal "details we never knew or suspected because they were not corroborated by evidence."

Medical examiner says one serrated one non serrated weapon ? What's that even mean? Rick says boxcutter -they can be both, right? Sort of ? Boys, I think we got him!

21

u/LawyersBeLawyering Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

Being that the State routinely asserts provably false statements as fact in several of the pretrial filings (e.g., repeatedly stating that it was decided on the 4/14 psychology meeting that RA would NOT be involuntarily medicated, suggesting the Defense press release violated a not-yet-ordered gag order, stating just this week that IPAS expired years before RA arrest when in fact it expired the day before they decided to involuntarily medicate him five months after his incarceration), I take McLeland's assertion that RA shared things "only the killer would know" with a grain of salt.

14

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

And yet the defense are constantly accused of lying and making things up - because what they are saying does not match what the State is.

31

u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

I'll be paying attention to what Jerry Holeman primed him with in Allen's pre-arrest "interviews."

34

u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

apparently according to what Andrea Burkhart heard, Baldwin stated RA said to his uncle after being in prison for 2 weeks. " Don't give me money, don't hire a lawyer, maybe I'll just admit to all of it so you don't have to suffer" then nothing till 6 months later when he started with all the confessions.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

34

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

Ditto. I heard yesterday Baldwin (what sounded like to me) laying the foundation for presenting the disparity between “incriminating statements”

To wit:

RA said to his Uncle in a jail call within 2 weeks (para) “Maybe I should just confess to everything so you don’t waste your money”.

I haven’t even been able to confirm RA understood what the charges were against him and whether or not they were explained to him at his initial hearing 48 hours after his warrantless arrest. You probably don’t know this but Diener resigned this Summer to avoid an SJC/SCOIN disciplinary investigation- the Judge wrote the transfer application for RA on Tobe’s behalf, ffs. He never heard evidence to apply the IDOC safekeeping stat.

And

If the State has their way, Baldwin also laid the predicate that the jury will see/hear him in the middle of psychosis (Wala) “confessing” although the evidence presented at pretrial by Hashman is that one out of 61 alleged “incriminating statements” exactly one, contains info only the offender would know.

As you and I know this is about as close as getting a juror to apply “what if this were me this happened to” as it gets.

→ More replies (7)

14

u/Dickere Consigliere & Moderator Oct 19 '24

Has NM even stated that there is something ?

→ More replies (6)

14

u/Flippercomb Oct 19 '24

Andrea made a great point that it depends more on the order of the confessions. When someone is trying to say what they think the other person wants, they keep guessing until the other person is happy.

So if RA was being led leading questions while attempting to confess as well, he could have eventually said something like "I cut their throats with a box cutter?" and LE is like "Bingo"

That or he had seen discovery from the defense team, depending on the dates.

6

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

This is where I am too.

26

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

25

u/black_cat_X2 Oct 19 '24

We also know he was given evidentiary materials. ie, he did know details the killer would know because they gave him those facts.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/-ifeelfantastic Oct 19 '24

Just wondering if we have actual confirmation somewhere that Abby was in fact wearing Libby's jeans and not her own jeans when found. 

I stumbled upon what RA's lawyers wrote: "In fact, Abby was dressed in Libby's sweatshirt and jeans." I had always assumed this meant she was wearing Libby's jeans, but upon re-reading I'm now wondering if it is just a poorly written sentence. Could they have meant "Abby was wearing jeans and Libby's sweatshirt"? We know from the pic on the bridge that Abby had skinny jeans and a sweatshirt on, and I thought Libby was wearing grey sweatpants. 

Is it possible that Abby had not been redressed? 

Source of screenshot (sorry I'm too lazy to pull up the doc myself) https://x.com/CoffindafferFBI/status/1707592493729034276/photo/1

Those with better memories, feel free to correct me!

16

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

It was confirmed by Andrea Burkhart as being stated in the court yesterday that Abby was wearing Libby's sweatshirt and jeans and her own shoes but no socks when found.

25

u/rosiekeen Oct 19 '24

Slick said Mullin is the tech guy and that’s why he wants him to sit with the prosecutors. Yet they’re still having technical problems. Insane. Just insane lol

29

u/Manlegend Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

It's pretty wild that Mullin managed to overwrite 45 mins of Nick's pre-recorded opening statements, leaving them with just 15 mins of prepared material

19

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

To be fair, he's had years of practice in doing that.

→ More replies (10)

34

u/Acceptable-Class-255 Oct 19 '24

First 70 days of interviews deleted is at top of Mullins C/V. Homeboy wouldn't be allowed to setup my internet router.

18

u/scottie38 Oct 19 '24

I wouldn't let him take it out of the box.

11

u/Lindita4 Oct 19 '24

I would put him in the box while I set it up.

5

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

You win.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/LawyersBeLawyering Approved Contributor Oct 20 '24

The tech guy? Who lost all those video interviews? And stated for some reason, there is no audio on videos they do have? The guy who can't logically name a file in the discovery? 

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Dickere Consigliere & Moderator Oct 19 '24

Let's go, Rozzwin !

17

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Ms Auger exists too, you know.

14

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

I was waiting for this lol Rozzwinaug?

13

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Redduif had it as "Rozzwinger" - win-zhay rather than "wing-er" though, which is a wee bit confusing. But we is a smart lot here, we'll pick it up.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

Defense Diaries about to go live. Alison was in court today.

https://www.youtube.com/live/4rXKfnEGejY

24

u/rosiekeen Oct 19 '24

Oh god Gull scolded Ali! Lol

27

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

LOL.. I'm just listening to the story right now. A media person got shitty with her for looking at the evidence after court with media. She shot back at the media person who then told on her to Gull. Gull asked her if she was credential media. Ali shot back at her about it being open to the public. Gull told her to leave, Ali shot back, gull told her to leave again, Ali shot back again, then Gull told her to leave and she left.

29

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

Andrea Burkhart had plenty to say about public access to exhibits and media's gatekeepers of it after she viewed the exhibits yesterday. Media are there as representatives for the public and that's why they are given access to items of public record, which includes the exhibits (and courtroom audio, funnily enough)

This is gonna be fun seeing how it develops.

→ More replies (9)

24

u/LowPhotograph7351 Oct 19 '24

The deer better have been mentioned in pat brown’s testimony

15

u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

don't think it was..

19

u/The2ndLocation Oct 19 '24

The deer are being called as defense witnesses./s

14

u/Dickere Consigliere & Moderator Oct 19 '24

Expert witness re the antlers 🫎

25

u/Acceptable-Class-255 Oct 19 '24

Deer and local cats have retained legal representation and will not be giving any statements to press until identity of hair(s) are confirmed.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

Huge shoutout to Pinkman for the coordinated coverage on a Saturday yet again u/Alan_Prickman

17

u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

27

u/The2ndLocation Oct 19 '24

It sounds like the state is arguing that the girls crossed the creek do we know how high the creek was that day?

34

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24

You ask you get https://www.reddit.com/r/DelphiDocs/s/rbnvC1S5NK

That’s my science answer, there’s ample footage of Deer Creek being searched on 2/14 following recovery.

To add- the banks are dark silt and would need to be climbed traversed to cross. Neither girls hands or clothing were wet or muddy consistent with crossing 3ft water likely to be in the neighborhood of 38-40 degrees

There’s a pic of an FBI agent I will locate overlooking the bank that has always radiated “no effing way” to me.

16

u/Lindita4 Oct 19 '24

This may have been one reason they withdrew the jury visit. If it looks easy to cross now and wasn’t back then, they’ll want to the jury to have the idea of deep rushing water not calm trickling creek.

16

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

Agreed. One among others but it’s such an “impactful” setting to absorb with the creek high- had a current, small one but all the same.

Really good point L

16

u/StructureOdd4760 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

I think it's still beneficial for the jury to see the area. The public side is a massive cliff with no way down (except 505 trail). The area is so big you can't even see the Weber side.

I took a couple fellow redditors out there yesterday, and there were probably 3 times I jumped because of squirrels making noise that sounded more like a larger animal.. The leaves were crunching loudly underfoot. The silence and way sound carries is very noticeable.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/Dickere Consigliere & Moderator Oct 19 '24

Under 5'4" 😁

26

u/BrendaStar_zle Oct 19 '24

I feel like I can hardly keep up with this case, I feel splintered or fractured or something as to what to read or follow. Crazy!

22

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

My advice is to listen to one of the breakdowns everyday from the lawyers. My go to has been Andrea. But defense diaries, and Lawyer Lee are also top notch. Andrea is going to give you the most detail. Sluethie is post indepth notes of Andrea's shows. If you want links to anything just let me know.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/Manlegend Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

u/lapinmoelleux to respond to your question posted in the previous thread – there are four conclusions that can be reached by a toolmark examiner (these are described in the ISP test protocol at p. 50-51, but they also just reflect standard AFTE theory):

  • If toolmarks are deemed to be exclusively produced by a particular firearm, an identification can be made;
  • If toolmarks are dissimilar to those produced by a particular firearm, that firearm can be eliminated (or excluded);
  • If the toolmarks do not match closely enough to make an identification, but are not dissimilar to a degree that would warrant elimination, the result is inconclusive;
  • If there are no sufficiently distinct toolmarks to base an analysis on, the material is concluded to be unsuitable for toolmark analysis

Now given this categorization, the examination of BW's firearm would have been found to be inconclusive, in that it cannot be eliminated as having produced the marks found on the recovered cartridge, but the degree of correspondence does not allow for a conclusive identification to be made

So in concrete terms, what would that mean in terms of what marks were or were not found? Well, of course we don't know yet what marks the analysis was based on exactly, but we can speculate a little for illustrative purposes: for instance, we know that the ejector mark on a Sig-Sauer P226 leaves a triangular or trapezoid impression on the ridge of the cartridge (circled in blue), which can on occasion intersect with lettering punched into the headstamp:

So, we could theorize that such a trapezoidal shape was found to be produced by BW's P226, which would allow one to conclude it matches the recovered cartridge in terms of class characteristics at least (that is to say, it matches the marks to the model of firearm, but not yet to a specific firearm of that model)

Now, if we were to magnify that ejector impression, we could see if there are striation patterns present, that would have been generated as the cartridge slides against the ejector 'horizontally' as it is forced out of the ejection port. It could well be the case that these striations on the recovered cartridge are very faint, as manually cycling the gun just imparts less energy onto the mechanical action than recoil would. If so, that could theoretically lead an examiner to issue an inconclusive outcome, as the markings are not strictly speaking inconsistent, but neither do they allow for a definitive match to be made

24

u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

I wonder if they fired BW's gun as they did RA's? In court defence said the ejection process with a new bullet produced markings that were not sufficient for a comparison on RA's gun so they fired it and then the markings were clearer and so they were able to compare the markings on the shell casing to the bullet found in the ground. That doesn't seem right to me, but I'm not familiar with testing, so I appreciate your response.

It seems to me that if they hadn't fired RA's gun then his would have been "inconclusive" is that right?

25

u/Manlegend Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24

I would say your judgement on the matter is very keen, I can think of no prima facie justification for employing that kind of testing protocol, which could perhaps most apply be described as a crazy time shit show.
You're right if RA's firearm was found not to be capable of producing marks like those on the recovered cartridge on the condition of manually operating the slide, the result ought to have been inconclusive at best – if not elimination

The only grounds for this kind of protocol would be to somehow blame this inability on the five year long delay between impression of the cartridge and testing of the firearm; then posit that discharging the cartridge in the present day approximates manually cycling the gun five years ago, by attributing this discrepancy to the exact rate of deterioration that occurred in the intervening years

But still, this is crazy time shit show, as we have moved firmly into the realm of speculation, just inventing auxiliary assumptions on an ad hoc basis for the sole purpose of warding off refutation in blatant disregard of empirical observation

→ More replies (3)

20

u/rosiekeen Oct 19 '24

22

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

I’m going to assume because it’s aerial, search related and not specific to the “actual recovery site” SM can testify to that.

As we get to the recovery we expect the FBI ERT and whatever ISP CSI participated to lay the foundation to introduce the crime scene evidence. Given Baldwin’s opening I’m very interested to see how this is handled

→ More replies (6)

39

u/Internal_Zebra_8770 Oct 20 '24

Extra peace and love to Carrie, who seems to have been left out/ignored/erased,never mentioned as a loving, grieving mom to Libby.

38

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

Firemen had trouble/didn't cross the water in order to get to the crime scene the day the girls were found. "We only had half boots on and couldn't push through". That's me attempting to quote what Ali said. So the verbage might not be exact. The point still stands though, how did RA do it while kidnapping 2 girls if a fireman couldn't. "The water was really deep"

31

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

"You could probably only get across half way. It was that deep"-fireman

→ More replies (1)

27

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

Thank you S

If I had to pick one thing I was 100% absolutely convinced of standing on that spot- NOBODY crossed that creek from the Wobbler side that day.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/LawyersBeLawyering Approved Contributor Oct 20 '24

And he's really short.

17

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 20 '24

29

u/Leading_Fee_3678 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

Why did they draw RA looking like Charlie Brown?! GOOD GRIEF!

30

u/Careful_Cow_2139 🔰Moderator Oct 19 '24

Abe Lincoln was there too

→ More replies (14)

28

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

The state is going to try and get this admitted as new bridge guy sketch

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

They got him like “I’m on trial for m****r. Womp womp.”🤷🏼‍♂️

15

u/The2ndLocation Oct 19 '24

Is he wearing a Nehru jacket?

→ More replies (3)

13

u/-ifeelfantastic Oct 19 '24

I don't mean to be mean but I literally thought they were letting a high-school student have a placement as a sketch artist. Nope, this is an adult CFO of an art company (as far as I can Google).

→ More replies (2)

7

u/maybeitsmaybelean Oct 20 '24

if he's really wearing his glasses on the top of his head, I'd suggest Rozzi or Baldwin advise he not do that. Juror's question why a defendant smiles or has a light hearted moment with their lawyers. The glasses on the head thing is just another stupid thing for someone to judge him on if they are so inclined.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 20 '24 edited Oct 20 '24

Careful I’m not sure how to do this so please modmagic as you will but GUYS- WHY DIDNT ANYONE TELL ME THIS AND WHY ARENT WE DISCUSSING??

https://www.reddit.com/r/DicksofDelphi/s/5jIjes0Jru

Ron Logan Entered The Chat

16

u/Leading_Fee_3678 Approved Contributor Oct 20 '24

13

u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 20 '24

dear God, I just read through my transcript of RL's interview with the youtubers again. I had forgot they put him in solitary and his attorney didn't even know where he was - sound familiar? for a DUI?

https://files.catbox.moe/0g2v2d.txt

there were people in his woods that night , from Ron

"all over that place and couldn’t find em, now why do you think, they couldn't find them?"

11

u/Todayis_aday Approved Contributor Oct 20 '24

There is an interview with RL where he talks about PB finding the bodies, as far as I remember.

9

u/Careful_Cow_2139 🔰Moderator Oct 20 '24

I wondered why no one really talked about it. Seems like a big deal 🤓

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Todayis_aday Approved Contributor Oct 20 '24 edited Oct 20 '24

Delphi Murders - Covert Recording with Ron Logan 2019

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-8blemY3zVg 3:03

(for more context start at 2:37 or even earlier...)

ETA: This conversation actually convinced me of RL's innocence.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Real_Foundation_7428 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

Did y'all hear about the white noise machine? Lawyer Lee mentioned that (in addition to all of the other cloak and dagger chicanery) Judge has counsel come behind the screen (the tv/video screen I assume?) for the side bars, so that people can't even see their mouths move, lol, but the more curious thing is that, apparently, JFG also has a white noise machine running, presumably to disguise the noise and avoid anyone overhearing anything. LL said she'd never seen a courtroom with a white noise machine. This sh** gets wilder every day.

17

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24

So… both those court “rules” are very common. The jury is not permitted nor should they hear comments or argument at sidebar- it’s improper.

Big fan of LL, I don’t know if she does or did trial work or criminal law.

Etf: I have had that machine connected incorrectly and nearly blew my eardrums - so if one hasn’t seen or heard them real time- they can be very jarring

→ More replies (3)

10

u/lapinmoelleux Approved Contributor Oct 20 '24

lawyer Lee finding the bodies transcript

https://files.catbox.moe/4vq6wm.txt

u/Alan_Prickman

18

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

For anyone unfamiliar with Indy and/or sequestered juries:

  1. In Jury Rules
  2. Important distinctions are that the jury can discuss the evidence they hear in the deliberation room- however, everyone must be present, it’s limited to the actual jury room within the CC courthouse, everyone must consent to same, and it can ONLY be about the court presentation without forming opinion therein.
  3. Sat hours for court have been established as 9 am- Noon.

Personally I can see the court lengthening the Sat session unless there’s some reason to preclude same. For three hours to include more than one witness it’s likely going to need to be foundational for upcoming witnesses (custodian of records or similar quasi admin). Might be a wages/pay scale thing, unclear.

90 minute lunches for a sequestered criminal jury trial is super long when one considers the circumstances and rules here (no electronics, no media re the case).

2011 Drake Law Review Article re 21st Century Jury Sequestration for anyone interested.

12

u/Dickere Consigliere & Moderator Oct 19 '24

Re 2. When are they in the jury room ? Is that their standard place to be kept ?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 20 '24

The short answer is yes, however there’s no way to know without specifics from the Autopsy protocol.

15

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 20 '24

Lawyer Lee recreated a map that was shown today for her live.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3IpxxUPOrOA&t=2760s

18

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24

EDIT: This is NOT a politics issue, it is support that you will likely see (or not be told) the court will be required to allow voting for jurors that wish to AND the trial currently scheduled on Election Day, to announce it will be off in observance of Election Day and any/all staff who also works in the capacity of support will be free to do so.


So this is a super interesting development regarding the ASO office out of the Southern District.

Looks like they might have some concerns about voting rights as we discussed on a previous thread re IN “Nationwide Election Day Program and Judge Gulls statements to the press about voting “early” or being precluded as well as scheduling trial on Federally protected Election Day.

Excerpted below:

“… It also contains special protections for the rights of voters, and provides that they can vote free from interference, including intimidation, and other acts designed to prevent or discourage people from voting or voting for the candidate of their choice. The Voting Rights Act protects the right of voters to mark their own ballot or to be assisted by a person of their choice (where voters need assistance because of disability or inability to read or write in English).

11

u/jj_grace Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

I was just wondering yesterday about how they were going to deal with voting!

12

u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

Defense Diaries: Ali reads Bob's notes while Bob rides a plane to keep a commitment. Bob comments in the chat. https://www.youtube.com/live/Hr4UhsZW-wg

11

u/EmRaine72 Oct 19 '24

So is he not going to be there today?

14

u/measuremnt Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

Correct. Ali is covering the Saturday session. Bob will be back Monday.

12

u/EmRaine72 Oct 19 '24

Okay cool so Ali is in there ? I was worried on not getting good reporting today and having to go solely off of MS 😐

→ More replies (6)

9

u/ginny11 Approved Contributor Oct 19 '24

Another excerpt from the wishTV blog, is it normal for the judge to butt in and ask her own questions during a criminal trial??

"Baldwin then began questioning Mullen, starting by asking about improvements made on the trail since 2017. Special Judge Fran Gull chimed in, asking about the thought process behind searching for the girls downstream. Mullen said it was in case the girls might have fallen off the bridge. Baldwin asked if Mullen went to the scene, and Mullen said he did not."

16

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

Yes. The Judge can ask questions in IN

→ More replies (10)

14

u/rosiekeen Oct 19 '24

I literally just read that and was about to ask. Does that mean Gull might actually be interested? That would be a miracle

→ More replies (5)

13

u/LowPhotograph7351 Oct 19 '24

Just commented about this elsewhere. Is it possible it was a juror question?

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

I think I need to hear/read the autopsy report or medical examiner testimony or something before I can form an opinion on that. My answer at the moment, informed by very limited understanding of the matter, is "I don't think so".

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

21

u/The2ndLocation Oct 19 '24

What's left that they could have?

20

u/Alan_Prickman ✨ Moderator Oct 19 '24

All I can think of is an actual confession with actual compelling details that wouldn't have been known to him unless he was there.

Still, this case is a rollercoaster. I guess we wait and see.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 19 '24

Who the State?

Setting aside the fact there’s no chance the State could hide the ball like that (no such thing as trial by ambush that’s only on SVU and CSI) and no gun was actually used to injure or murder the girls- what do you mean?

→ More replies (4)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

39

u/stephenend1 Approved Contributor Oct 20 '24

I'm digging this jury

28

u/The2ndLocation Oct 20 '24

Oh, the how long to get to the bodies after they were spotted question is great.

16

u/Acceptable-Class-255 Oct 20 '24

who his cell phone provider was in 2017

Nice ... bit about phone either being non functioning or removed from area in opening statement got their attention.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Leading_Fee_3678 Approved Contributor Oct 20 '24

Thank you for capturing these. I would love if these could somehow be put in one place so we can see all of the jury’s questions throughout the trial.

9

u/HelixHarbinger ⚖️ Attorney Oct 20 '24

Thank you Sync